Can One Player Really Be Called 'The' GOAT?

(Photo by Clive Brunskill/Getty Images)

Tennis today is so technically advanced it cannot be compared to the games of even a mere 20 years ago. Tennis has traveled far from its humble beginnings. 

Gone are the casual forehands and volley’s of a gentle game played on grass by women wearing long skirts and hats, and men in long pants and white shirts.

The wood rackets of the past are a far cry from the super charged graphite rackets of today’s game.  Even the color of the ball has changed so that it’s easier to see. These advanced rackets are strung with highly engineered polyester strings;  strings that help make the impossible shots possible.

So with all the advancements in the game, how can we say which player is 'the' GOAT?  Each era produced amazing players for their time and the type of game tennis was then. 

You can’t say that big Bill Tilden’s game wasn’t as good as Rod Laver’s, it was simply different.  Roger Federer has had an unbelievable run but what if you put a wooden racket and a white tennis ball in his hand, would he have beat Borg or Connor on clay or grass?

What about Margaret Court's game versus Billie Jean King? How would you compare their achievements in tennis with Martina Navratilova or Chris Evert?  Steffi Graff had an fabulous record in tennis.  The Williams sisters are the strongest women's in the WTA now that Justine Heninhas retired after her fabulous run.  I dare anyone to say that these women's accomplishments aren't as important and GOAT worthy as their male counterparts.

The title Greatest Player Of All Time is to subjective to be given to just one player. Respecting all the tennis greats, both men and women, that have come and will eventually go, it would be impossible and unjust to rate them against each other. 

I believe that Henry Lacoste would be thrilled with the clay court game of Rafael Nadal.  Rafa’s game would not have been possible back in the early matches at Roland Garros.  How can you compare Nadal to Borg, the technology is so different. They are both champions on the terre battue.   

You're currently logged into Facebook

Do you want to share your Bleacher Report activity on Facebook?