Minnesota Twins: All-Time Greatest Lineup

Matt Busch@immortalspcastCorrespondent IIINovember 7, 2010

Minnesota Twins: All-Time Greatest Lineup

0 of 16

    NEW YORK - OCTOBER 09:  Joe Mauer #7 of the Minnesota Twins looks on during batting practice against the New York Yankees during Game Three of the ALDS part of the 2010 MLB Playoffs at Yankee Stadium on October 9, 2010 in the Bronx borough of New York Cit
    Chris McGrath/Getty Images

    The Minnesota Twins start their 50th season in Minnesota next season.

    I thought it might be fun to choose the best starting lineup possible from the last 50 years. I also included the top five pitchers for a starting rotation and a closer.

    There were a few rules to make the list. They must have either been a Twins player for at least five years, or done something extraordinary on the field (such as a World Series victory, MVP award, batting title, etc.).

    They also must have spent most of their time at the position they played at, so I wasn't allowed to DH someone who wasn't a designated hitter during their time in Minnesota.

    So who made the cut? Read on to find out.

1. Rod Carew, 2B

1 of 16

    MINNEAPOLIS, MN - APRIL 12: Hall of Famer Rod Carew #29 of the Minnesota Twins speaks at the Kirby Puckett statue unveiling prior to a game between the Boston Red Sox and Minnesota Twins during the Twins home opener at Target Field on April 12, 2010 in Mi
    Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

    Leading off and playing second base for your All-Time Twins team is none other then Rod Carew.

    This was one of the easiest choices on the whole team.

    Carew debuted for the Twins in his rookie season of 1967. He continued to play for the Twins until 1978 when he departed for the Angels.

    Carew has a laundry list of accomplishments for the Twins:

    • 12-time All-Star (every year as a Twin)
    • 1967 AL Rookie of the Year
    • 1977 AL MVP
    • Seven-time batting champ as a Twin

    Carew's number, 29, has been retired for the Twins, and was inducted into the Twins Hall of Fame and also at Cooperstown.

    Honorable Mention: Chuck Knoblauch

2. Joe Mauer, C

2 of 16

    SEATTLE - AUGUST 27:  Joe Mauer #7 of the Minnesota Twins bats against the Seattle Mariners at Safeco Field on August 27, 2010 in Seattle, Washington. The Twins won 6-3. (Photo by Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images)
    Otto Greule Jr/Getty Images

    Batting second and catching for your All-Time Twins team is homegrown Joe Mauer.

    Another "no duh" selection.

    Mauer is the face of the current Twins team and a native to the Twin Cities. He has spent his entire career, since 2004, as a Twin. After signing an eight-year, $183 million contract extension, he may be a Twin for the remaining years of his career.

    Even at age 27, Mauer already has accomplished a lot in his career:

    • Four-time All-Star selection
    • Three-time batting champion
    • Two-time Gold Glove Winner
    • Three-time Silver Slugger
    • 2009 AL MVP

    It would be hard to find a player who means more to the Twins in their history than Joe Mauer.

    Honorable Mention: Brian Harper

3. Kirby Puckett, CF

3 of 16

    MINNEAPOLIS - OCTOBER 19:  Kirby Puckett #34 of the Minnesota Twins swings at a pitch during Game one of the 1991 World Series against the Atlanta Braves at the Metrodome on October 19, 1991 in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The Twins defeated the Braves 5-2.  (
    Rick Stewart/Getty Images

    Batting third and roaming center field for the All-Time Twins is Kirby Puckett.

    Puckett's accomplishments are tough to define just by numbers. He was the spirit of the franchise and helped deliver two World Series to the Twins in 1987 and 1991.

    His heroics in Game 6 of the 1991 World Series alone make him a Minnesota legend. But he is so much more than that to Minnesota.

    When ESPN conducted a poll of fans to determine the greatest player in franchise history for every team, Kirby Puckett won the vote in a landslide. This was a testament to Puckett's popularity in Minnesota. The vote was even more telling in who he beat in the voting: Walter Johnson. Walter Johnson, to many, is the greatest pitcher of all time. Yet Kirby Puckett was the overwhelming choice.

    Puckett's popularity was due to his charisma and smile, but he also was able to produce Hall of Fame numbers in his 12 years in Minnesota, despite his 5'8", 230-pound frame.

    • 10-time All-Star
    • Six-time Gold Glove Winner
    • 1993 All Star MVP
    • 1989 AL Batting Champion

    Puckett was forced into early retirement, but was still a first ballot selection for the Hall of Fame.

    Puckett was inducted into the Twins Hall of Fame, and his number 34 is retired.

    Honorable Mention: Torii Hunter

4. Harmon Killebrew, LF

4 of 16

    MINNEAPOLIS - OCTOBER 8:  Former Twin great Harmon Killebrew waves to the crowd prior to throwing out the first pitch before a game between the Minnesota Twins and the New York Yankees during game three of the American League Divisional Series on October
    Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

    Batting clean up and playing left field for the All-Time Twins team is Harmon Killebrew.

    The Hall-of-Fame slugger came to Minnesota when the team was moved from Washington. He remained with the Twins until 1974.

    In his 20 years with the Nationals/Twins, he put up amazing numbers:

    • 13-time All-Star Selection
    • 1969 AL MVP
    • 573 Career home runs (Which at the time was most all-time for a right-handed batter)

    Killebrew helped push the Twins to the 1965 World Series. Sandy Koufax shut down the Twins in Game 7 that season, but still is remembered as one of the great seasons in franchise history.

    Killebrew was inducted into the Hall of Fame in 1984.

    Killebrew is a member of the Twins Hall of Fame, and his No. 3 is retired.

    Honorable Mention: Shane Mack

5. Tony Oliva, RF

5 of 16

    Tony Oliva makes an easy decision for the right field position on the All-Time Twins team and will bat fifth.

    He spent his entire career as a Twin from 1962-1978. He was on the 1965 World Series team, which barely lost to the Dodgers.

    Over his career, Oliva had many great seasons:

    • Three-time batting champion
    • Eight-time All-Star
    • 1966 Gold Glove Winner
    • 1964 AL Rookie of the Year

    Tony Oliva is a member of the Twins Hall of Fame, and his No. 6 has been retired.

    Honorable Mention: Michael Cuddyer

6. Kent Hrbek, 1B

6 of 16

    1 JUL 1992:  MINNESOTA FIRST BASEMAN KENT HRBEK HITS A PITCH TOWARDS LEFT FIELD DURING THE TWINS GAME VERSUS CALIFORNIA ANGELS AT ANAHEIM STADIUM IN ANAHEIM, CALIFORNIA. Mandatory Credit: Stephen Dunn/ALLSPORT
    Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

    Kent Hrbek takes the spot at first base for the All-Time Twins and bats sixth.

    This was perhaps the most difficult selection to make. Hrbek doesn't have gaudy numbers, was never an MVP, never won a batting title, never won a gold glove and only has one All-Star appearance, but his value goes beyond numbers.

    Hrbek is a Minneapolis native and was a crucial part of both of the franchise's World Series titles. He spent his entire career with the Twins from 1981-1994.

    Hrbek gets the nod over Justin Morneau due to the titles, the local hero status and his continued involvement in the Twins, despite his playing days being over.

    Hrbek was no slouch on the diamond, however.:

    • .282 Career Batting Average
    • 293 Career Home Runs
    • 1982 AL All-Star

    Hrbek seemed to come through in the clutch. In 1987, he hit a Grand Slam in Game 6 of the World Series. Also in 1991, he made a controversial out against Ron Gant in Game 2 of the World Series. This play has gone down in folklore in Twins territory.

    Hrbek is a Twins Hall of Famer, and his No. 14 has been retired.

    Honorable Mention: Justin Morneau

7. Gary Gaetti, 3B

7 of 16

    1989:  Gary Gaetti #8 of the Minnesota Twins runs the base after his home run during a game in the 1989 season.  (Photo by: Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)
    Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

    Gary Gaetti is the All-Time Minnesota Twins third baseman and will bat seventh.

    He played for the Twins from 1981-1990. Gaetti helped anchor the left side of the infield for a decade, and was a key part of the 1987 World Series winners. 

    Gaetti had a very solid career:

    • Two-time All-Star
    • Four-time Gold Glove Winner
    • 1987 ALCS MVP

    In 1987, Gaetti became the first player in history to homer in his first two plate appearances in the postseason.

    Gaetti is a member of the Twins Hall of Fame.

    Honorable Mention: Corey Koskie

8. Jason Kubel, DH

8 of 16

    OAKLAND, CA - JUNE 06:  Jason Kubel #16 of the Minnesota Twins bats against the Oakland Athletics during an MLB game at the Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum on June 6, 2010 in Oakland, California.  (Photo by Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images)
    Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    Jason Kubel is the designated hitter on your All-Time Twins team and bats eighth. Kubel has spent his entire career as a Twin, dating back to 2004.

    Despite his struggles in the postseason, Kubel has had some of the most clutch hits for the Twins in the last half decade.

    Kubel also has the distinction of hitting the first (regular season) home run at newly opened Target Field.

    • On April 17, 2009, Kubel hits for cycle including Grand Slam in 11-9 victory over Los Angeles Angels.
    • 92 career home runs
    • Lifetime .271 Average

    Kubel wins out the position with very little competition.

    Honorable Mention: Chili Davis

9. Zoilo Versalles, SS

9 of 16

    Zoilo Versalles makes the cut as the All-Time Twins shortstop and will bat ninth. 

    Versalles came over from Washington and played for the Twins from 1961-1967. He was one of the most important players in the 1965 pennant-winning Twins.

    Versalles's career could have possibly been more impressive but he still had some great accomplishments:

    • Two-time All-Star
    • Two-time Gold Glove Winner
    • 1965 AL MVP

    Versalles has been inducted into the Twins Hall of Fame.

    Honorable Mention: Christian Guzman

Johan Santana, SP 1

10 of 16

    NEW YORK - JUNE 19:  Johan Santana #57 of the Minnesota Twins celebrates his 92 pitch complete game shutout against the New York Mets during their interleague game on June 19, 2007 at Shea Stadium in the Flushing neighborhood of the Queens borough of New
    Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

    Johan Santana pitches his way to the ace position on the Twins' All-Time team.

    During his career in Minnesota, Johan Santana became known as the best pitcher in the American League with a mid-90's fastball and the best change-up in baseball.

    He dominated during his time in Minnesota from 2000-2007.

    • Two-time Cy Young Winner
    • Three-time All-Star selection with Twins
    • Won Triple Crown of Pitching in 2006 (ERA, strikeouts, wins)

    Minnesota has been looking for another ace like Santana since he departed for New York after the 2007 season.

Jim Kaat, SP 2

11 of 16

    Jim Kaat solidifies the second spot in the rotation for the All-Time Twins.

    Kaat was a great pitcher during the 60's and 70's, but he might be more known for his defensive abilities. He currently ranks second all-time for Gold Glove awards won by a pitcher with 16.

    Kaat was the best pitcher on the Pennant-winning 1965 Twins squad. He matched up three times in the World Series against Sandy Koufax. Losing Game 7, but pitched a complete game 5-1 win in Game 2.

    Kaat's career numbers are gaudy:

    • Three-time All-Star (twice as a Twin)
    • 16 Gold Glove Awards (12 with Twins)
    • 283 career victories
    • Pitched for 25 seasons, third most all-time

Jack Morris, SP 3

12 of 16

    MINNEAPOLIS - OCTOBER 27:  Pitcher Jack Morris #47 of the Minnesota Twins delivers a pitch against the Atlanta Braves at the Metrodome in Minneapolis, Minneapolis, on October 27, 1991. The Twins defeated the Braves 1-0 in game 6, the final game of the 199
    Rick Stewart/Getty Images

    Jack Morris, a St. Paul native, enters third in the rotation.

    "Black" Jack Morris only spent one season in Minnesota, but it was memorable. Game 7 of the 1991 World Series goes down as perhaps the greatest postseason pitching performance of all time. Ten innings of shutout baseball to win the game and the series.

    This would be the last game for Morris as a Twin, but that game alone lands him on the All-Time Twins team.

    • 254 career wins
    • 14 consecutive opening-day starts (MLB Record)
    • Five-time All-Star (one with Twins)
    • Four-time World Series winner (one with Twins)
    • 1991 World Series MVP

Frank Viola, SP 4

13 of 16

    1989:  Frank Viola of the Minnesota Twins looks on during a game in the 1989 season.  (Photo by: Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
    Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

    Frank "Sweet Music" Viola comes out at the fourth spot in the rotation for All-Time Twins team.

    Viola's career in Minnesota was defined by 1987 and 1988. In 1987, he pitched the Twins to a World Series victory, and a year later had the best season of his career. He was then traded to the Mets, which helped the Twins bring in players who would eventually win the 1991 World Series.

    Viola's accomplishments:

    • 1987 World Series MVP
    • 1988 AL Cy Young Award Winner
    • Three-time All-Star (One with Twins)
    • 176 career wins

    Viola was also credited with inventing the circle change-up, which would pay off years later when Johan Santana perfected the pitch.

Bert Blyleven, SP 5

14 of 16

    1989:  Bert Blyleven of the Minnesota Twins stands in the dugout during a game in the 1989 season.  (Photo by: Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images)
    Jonathan Daniel/Getty Images

    Bert Blyleven rounds out the rotation as the fifth starter.

    Blyleven had two tours of duty with the Twins: 1970-1976 and 1985-1988. He has another tour still in progress as the Twins' color commentator, which started in 1996.

    Blyleven was the No. 2 starter on the 1987 World Series winning  team. He was just shy of making it into the Hall of Fame on the last round of voting, and it may be just a matter of time before he is inducted.

    Blyleven's career numbers are amazing:

    • 287 wins
    • 3,701 strikeouts
    • Two-time All-Star
    • Two-time World Series champ (one with Twins)
    • 1989 Comeback Player of the Year

    Blyleven was known as a prankster in the dugout, perfecting the "hot foot" where he would light teammates shoelaces on fire.

    Honorable Mention: Brad Radke, Jim Perry, Mudcat Grant

Joe Nathan, CL

15 of 16

    MINNEAPOLIS, MN - MAY 26: Joe Nathan #36 of the Minnesota Twins in the dugout in the eighth inning against the New York Yankees during the game on May 26, 2010 at Target Field in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The game was suspended due to rain after the fifth i
    Hannah Foslien/Getty Images

    Joe Nathan anchors the pen for the All-Time Twins team.

    Nathan was just shy of the franchise record for saves when he was injured last spring training, and it's almost inevitable that he will pass Rick Aguliera for the lead next season.

    Nathan hasn't been a postseason star, but his numbers in the regular season are too great to ignore.

    • Four-time All-Star
    • AL Rolaids Relief Man of 2009
    • Single season saves record for Twins with 47 in 2009
    • Career 46-22 record
    • 247 saves

    Honorable Mentions: Rick Aguliera, Jeff Reardon

Tom Kelly, Manager

16 of 16

    Manager Tom Kelly of the Minnesota Twins celebrates with the trophy after game seven of the World Series against the Atlanta Braves.
    Rick Stewart/Getty Images

    Tom Kelly is the skipper on your All-Time Twins team.

    He took over the reins of the Twins in 1986, and only a year later would bring home a World Championship. He would win another in 1991. He was the longest tenured manager in Twins' history, managing until 2001 when Ron Gardenhire would take over.

    The years after the 1991 World Series weren't kind to Tom Kelly's Twins. Departing superstars led to a run of disappointing seasons.

    Tom Kelly became one of the men in charge of rebuilding the Twins into contenders. He and general manager Terry Ryan laid the ground work for the current model of Twins baseball, which continues to this day.

    In Kelly's final season, the Twins won 85 games and were set for a decade of excellence.

    Honorable Mention: Ron Gardenhire