MLB Scout Talks Devin Williams' Struggles With Yankees, 'Not Built for New York'

New York Yankees reliever Devin Williams has been one of the biggest disappointments of the 2025 season, but some around MLB aren't surprised by his struggles.

Randy Miller of NJ Advanced Media spoke to an American League scout who predicted over the offseason that Williams wouldn't be a good fit with the Yankees after they acquired him from the Milwaukee Brewers, and the scout feels their prediction came to fruition.

"I knew it," the scout said. "This guy is not built for New York."

Williams struggled mightily to start the 2025 campaign but briefly returned to his usual form before struggling once again. Earlier this week, he was demoted from his closer role for the second time this year after recording two blown saves and a loss in his last three appearances. His ERA currently sits at 5.54, by far the worst mark of his six-year career.

The Yankees rightfully thought they found a gem when they landed Williams from the Brewers. The two-time NL Reliever of the Year was coming off three straight seasons with an ERA under 2.00, and he dazzled on the mound with his trademark changeup that made him look unhittable at times.

However, playing in New York carries a significant amount of pressure. Williams is far from the first player to struggle after arriving to the Big Apple, but his disappointing year could be what holds the Yankees back from reaching a second straight World Series.

"Devin was great in Milwaukee, but the expectancy of winning there is totally different from New York. If you come in second in Milwaukee, fans will put up with it. If you don’t win in New York, get the hell out," the scout said. "The Yankees aren’t winning and Devin Williams is one of the reasons. It’s too bad because everyone loves his arm. His changeup, the Airbender, is one of the best pitches in the game. But I never thought he was the kind of guy who could thrive in New York and he’s proving me right."