.png?w=1280)
9 Offseason Free-Agent Landing Spots for Mitch Marner After Maple Leafs Elimination
The Toronto Maple Leafs are eliminated from the playoffs and have fallen short of expectations. Stop me if you've heard that one before.
Mitch Marner would be front and center of NHL offseason discourse regardless of the Leafs' playoff outcome. The 28-year-old is an unrestricted free agent on July 1st. He will command a major paycheck, one that might be a tight squeeze for Toronto's top-heavy financial spreadsheets. Even if Toronto won the Stanley Cup, his future would have been uncertain
The second-round loss to Florida, in which Toronto was thoroughly outplayed and humiliated, will only make matters worse. GM Brad Treliving will feel immense pressure to change the team's dynamic. Maybe Marner himself will feel it's time for a fresh start.
What's next for the projected top unrestricted free agent this summer? Let's analyze nine teams that could look to sign Marner this summer.
Toronto Maple Leafs
1 of 9
Before anything else, let's not rule out a Marner extension in Toronto. Even if change is necessary in Toronto, he does not have to be on the departures list. John Tavares is also a UFA. Matthew Knies will need a big extension and could be at risk of signing an offer sheet.
Marner is going to receive a big payday for a reason; he's one of the best two-way wingers in the NHL. The Leafs' big problem in the playoffs the last few seasons has been an inability to generate offense, and moving a consistent 100-point player isn't exactly a step closer to fixing that problem.
For his part, Marner is a career Leaf who grew up in Ontario. He has reasons he may want to stay as well and perhaps even leave money on the table to do so.
There is significant danger in enacting change solely for the sake of change. The Leafs moved on from Phil Kessel in similar circumstances, believing change was needed and he wasn't capable of stepping up in big moments. Kessel got the last laugh with two Stanley Cups in Pittsburgh.
Philadelphia Flyers
2 of 9
The Philadelphia Flyers are looking to accelerate out of the rebuild stage. They played excellent two-way hockey the last couple of seasons but were hampered by two critical weaknesses: poor goaltending and a lack of star power.
Marner would address the latter problem. The Flyers do have some capable wingers in Travis Konecny, Owen Tippett, and Tyson Foerster, and Matvei Michkov is a future star. But Marner is on a different level and would push the Flyers' gluttony of second- and third-liner wingers down the depth chart. becoming the best player in a Flyers jersey since Claude Giroux left in 2022.
The Flyers made an interesting move ahead of the 2025 trade deadline when GM Daniel Briere sent center Morgan Frost and winger Joel Farabee to Calgary. While the return for two quality players was suspect, the bigger picture in Philadelphia was a desire to rid themselves of two long-term contracts.
Now strapped with significant cap space in the summer and a mission to reach the next level, Marner will be at the top of the Flyers' wishlist.
Detroit Red Wings
3 of 9
General Manager Steve Yzerman's appointment as the savior in Detroit has not quite gone to plan.
Eight straight seasons of missing the playoffs are taking their toll and tensions have reached a boiling point. Captain Dylan Larkin voiced frustrations in his end-of-season talk with the media, questioning the lack of his team's additions ahead of the trade deadline.
For his part, Yzerman indicated that the Red Wings are "ready to go big" for the right player this summer. There probably won't be anyone bigger than Marner available.
To make the math work, Detroit will have to find ways out of an ugly contract or two. Vladimir Tarasenko, in particular, did not live up to expectations last season. For many reasons, the Red Wings must improve dramatically next season. Yzerman's legacy as a GM is on the line and Larkin will only grow more frustrated if the team remains stagnant. A proper star right-winger to go on his line would immediately quell his worries.
Utah Mammoth
4 of 9
Utah's first NHL season was a success holistically, but it's time to take it to another level after missing the playoffs.
To be fair, injuries on defense held Utah back. It's a team that is a move or two away from becoming a playoff team and maybe even one capable of making noise. Winger Nick Schmaltz has one year left on his contract, while Lawson Crouse has two. Both are good players in different way,s but Marner is multiple tiers above both.
An upgrade could be in the cards. Who wouldn't want to see the type of magic Marner could create with players like Clayton Keller, Logan Cooley and Dylan Guenther?
For Marner's part, Utah could be an oasis away from the spotlight he's endured in Toronto. The environment would be low-key, the media more forgiving, and a fanbase still in the honeymoon phase that would be thrilled enough that he wanted to be there.
New York Rangers
5 of 9
Even with the hiring of new Head Coach Mike Sullivan, the Rangers have bigger problems than can be solved by Mitch Marner. Who is the shutdown center? Where can they find a first-pairing left-handed defenseman? To the extent the roster is in any sort of good shape, the wings are where the Rangers are best situated.
But still. It's New York. They love flashy moves and big changes are coming. Chris Kreider's departure is all but inevitable. Artemi Panarin is in the final year of his contract. Could the team and player decide to part ways this summer? The Rangers also signed Alexis Lafreniére to a seven-year contract last Fall, but his play this season did not live up to expectations.
The Rangers need a fresh start, and so does Marner. New York isn't the path of least resistance, but GM Chris Drury can make room for him if he identifies Marner as worth the effort.
Carolina Hurricanes
6 of 9
This may be hard to believe, as we watch the Hurricanes reach the Eastern Conference Final in a cakewalk of a series against the Washington Capitals, but the Hurricanes viewed the 2024-25 season as something of a reset. They lost a number of players over the summer, including Jake Guentzel, whom they were not able to convince to re-sign after moving a number of prospects to rent him from Pittsburgh.
Then came the infamous Mikko Rantanen trade. After 13 uninspired games, they flipped him to Dallas.
The Hurricanes are a well-built team the best depth in the NHL and an unshakeable structure. What has held them back in past postseasons was the lack of a difference-maker who could create goals during stalemates. They tried and failed to find that long-term solution in Guentzel and then Rantanen. Expect them to search for that gamebreaker again this offseason, regardless of how the rest of their season transpires.
Carolina could appeal to Marner for a few reasons. The pressure won't be what it is in Toronto but he'd join a bona fide contender. Whereas in Toronto he's getting heat for his finesse game, his style of play would be a breath of fresh air in a Carolina system that breeds discipline and physicality but needs more creative star power.
Chicago Blackhawks
7 of 9
The Blackhawks attempted to supplement young phenom Connor Bedard with actual talent this season, and it could not have gone much worse. Tyler Bertuzzi and Teuvo Teravainen were not exactly the saviors Chicago needed to rescue an otherwise brutal roster.
Bedard was on an island. He was forced to play against the best players in the world on a nightly basis without any help. His production dropped and his frustrations became visible. The team was embarrassed frequently throughout the season, including at the Winter Classic. To be the second-worst offensive team in the NHL despite having a generational center is a categorical failure on the part of Chicago's management. They cannot afford to demoralize Bedard further. It's bad for his development.
No doubt, Chicago has the financial means, both in terms of on-hand cash and salary cap space, to make Marner a big offer. The fit here is more a question for Marner to answer. Does he want to play in another big city environment? Is he willing to spend what's left of his prime in a rebuild?
Anaheim Ducks
8 of 9
The Ducks found some life at the end of the season. Having fired Head Coach Greg Cronin, Anaheim made the decision to add Joel Quenneville behind the bench. Quenneville's hiring raises ethical questions given his role in the Blackhawks' handling of the Kyle Beach situation, but that aside, the move indicates that the Ducks are ready to move out of the rebuilding phase and start competing.
GM Pat Verbeek had loads of cap space last offseason and hoped to start adding to the roster. He struggled to find high-end players willing to join the Ducks. With some of their young talent actualizing and ownership giving the green light to spend on "big-name free agents," Anaheim could be a fit for Marner.
Pittsburgh Penguins
9 of 9
In some ways, the dots here are easy to connect. Penguins GM Kyle Dubas knows Marner very well, having been in charge in Toronto for years. The team has a long-term vision in mind, but is looking to add NHL talent to stay competitive in the final years of Sidney Crosby's career.
For Marner's part, what winger wouldn't want to be centered by No. 87? It could be Phil Kessel all over again. Having lived through the media circus in Toronto, where the core of the team was questioned on national TV every week, a transition to Pittsburgh, where nobody would dare question the capacity of its leadership group, could alleviate all of the pressure on Marner.
The timelines for Pittsburgh and Marner are what make this hard to envision. The Penguins are looking at a long rebuilding effort, one that former coach Mike Sullivan himself did not wish to stick out. Does Marner want to sign on to that dynamic? Meanwhile, does Pittsburgh want to commit in the range of $90 million over many years for a player whose prime will be over by the time the team has an upward trajectory?
