2009 NFL Running Back Battles To Watch: Part 2

Andrew Garda@andrew_gardaFeatured ColumnistJune 14, 2009

JACKSONVILLE, FL - DECEMBER 14:  Maurice Jones-Drew #32 of the Jacksonville Jaguars runs for yardage against the Green Bay Packers during the game at Jacksonville Municipal stadium on December 14, 2008 in Jacksonville, Florida.  (Photo by Sam Greenwood/Getty Images)

Welcome to part two of the 2009 NFL Running Back Battles To Watch. Yesterday we looked at a bunch of great backs including—but not limited to—the Denver Broncos, Indianapolis Colts, and the Carolina Panthers.

Today we'll be looking at some more interesting backfield situations and seeing what they might mean for their respective teams.

We'll start off with a team that has a clear-cut No. 1 running back but also some questions as to what to do if he cannot carry the full load over the course of the 2009 season.


We all think Maurice Jones-Drew aka "The Human Bowling Ball' or "The Bad Little Man" will be the bell cow here and get most of, if not all, the work. The man can do it all and despite his size, he usually stays healthy. With no Fred Taylor, he should get every carry Freddy used to get, right?

Well, yes and no. While MJD is a stud and the offensive line is much healthier and better than 2008's version, the Jaguars will by no means risk burning out Jones-Drew before the playoffs. I expect one of the backs behind him to get a fair share of carries as well.

Note that I am not saying they will cut significantly into his totes—but that it will factor in and probably in a good way.

Former USC tailback Chauncey Washington patiently waited for his shot, but now has to hold off former Liberty stud Rashad Jennings, a guy who improbably fell to the Jags in the seventh round—something I still can't figure out.

Both players have the ability to fill in for MJD but despite being a USC Homer, I like Jennings better. Not only can he catch and slide into holes but he has decent size too. Matt Waldman of the Rookie Scouting Portfolio and footballguys.com said it best when he stated, "What you should know about Jennings is that he's a bigger back with finesse."

That size combined with the skills Waldman alludes to make him a very attractive compliment to Jones-Drew and a guy to watch for long term on his own as well.

Jennings has some issues finishing a run and will need to improve that if he wants to catch Washington.

And let's not forget, Greg Jones has been occasionally stud-like when he has had a shot in the past and is a great third down back. Jones has never quite been the same since a knee injury and is often hurt.

Who ends up spelling MJD could have some real value for fantasy owners and Jags fans. It should be a horse race between these three.

New Orleans

Will Reggie Bush stay healthy? What about Pierre Thomas? Big questions for an offense which needs to improve its run game to take some pressure off the pass game. It looks like Thomas has the between-the-tackles work locked down while Bush will continue to play scat-back.

But both have some injury questions (Bush's legs and Thomas' wrist) so the Saints have journeymen Mike Bell, second year player Lynell Hamilton, and undrafted free agents P.J. Hill and Herb Donaldson.

Mike Bell has played well in camp so far but don't discount the rookies just yet. The Saints went hard into the free agent market post-draft so they clearly have some concerns with the tailback position.

Bell has played well before and then faltered. Hill has some serious character concerns but seems to realize he screwed up and is motivated to prove he has the ability and maturity to make an impact. All three are big backs, something the Saints lost when they let Deuce McAllister go.

It will be interesting to see if any can make ground on Thomas and given the injury issues (for both Thomas and Bush) and Thomas' size, one of these guys could see action this season.


With Brian Westbrook banged up again (What? Stop lying Garda! NEVER!) every Eagles fan—and many, MANY fantasy football owners—want to know who to grab for this year's version of "Westbrook Insurance."

Aside: Should Westbrook and/or the Iggles talk to Geico about a sponsorship? I mean, in these troubled economic times, shouldn't a club be looking for cash wherever they can?

I'm not saying, but I am just saying is all.

But all shenanigans aside, whoever backs Westy up resonates hard an long amongst the NFL community of fans and it goes beyond fantasy football folks. As much as I like the receivers and the passing offense this year, they need the run game hitting on all cylinders.

With the very real possibility that the last two years of 15 games might have been an illusion in terms Westy's health, the Eagles need to know they can throw another guy in there and crank out the yards effectively.

Which leaves you with this question: LeSean McCoy or Lorenzo Booker?

Booker was a guy who I had high hopes for coming to Philadelphia last season after being virtually ignored by Miami previously. With his ability to catch the ball and his general shifty running style, I thought Lo-Book was going to get some traction finally but sadly that didn't happen.

Booker barely saw the field and then the team went and drafted LeSean "Shady" McCoy who plays very similarly to Westbrook's game. And while a tad undersized, McCoy plays tough and isn't afraid of contact.

It will be a battle in the most literal sense and no other fracas may impact the whole offense of a team like this one. If they cannot move the ball on the ground—and lack a player at the RB spot who can catch the ball as effectively as Westy—defenses could key heavily on the pass game.

San Francisco

I spent a lot of time the past few months looking over the 49ers and there are a ton of questions surrounding the run game and what it could be.

New offensive coordinator Jimmy Raye keeps saying this will not be a run-heavy playbook, but if you look at his resume, he's definitely developed some very strong rushing attacks. So does that mean Raye is tossing some disinformation out there?

Maybe not.

The 49ers often run a game where a strong rushing attack sets up a vertical passing attack. It hasn't worked well for many reasons—not the least of which is the lack of a permanent solution at quarterback.

So it isn't farfetched that Raye is being truthful—a rarity in today's NFL it seems. With the weapons at both running back and wide receiver, the Niners are setup to have an effective attack from either direction.

We know Frank Gore is the stud-bell, cow-big, dawg-whatever you call it in the backfield. But he cannot do it alone as we saw when he wore down last season. 

So who is the backup who could share in his carries? This is a great discussion as the backs behind him all have questions.

Michael Robinson has functioned more as a fullback and special-teamer and while Thomas Clayton tends to shine in preseason games, he hasn't played worth a tinker's damn during the season. Neither of them has quite been able to give the team a consistent and safe backup to Gore in the past few years.

Two rookies—third round pick Glenn Coffee and street free agent Kory Sheets—have a shot at spelling Gore. Coffee is a solid one cut runner with great vision, who can aggressively attack the hole. He’s a powerful runner who could help the short-yardage game, something that occasionally struggled in 2008.

Sheets has great acceleration and burst and is a very good receiver out of the backfield. He can be very elusive and shows patience behind the line with good vision and instincts. I think he could emerge as a nice compliment to Gore in the vein of a Leon Washington or Reggie Bush.

Adding Sheets as an extra weapon is nice, but ultimately the 49ers need to get someone to consistently and reliably spell Gore to save him for a potential run at a playoff spot this year.


Somehow the Seahawks ended the draft without a replacement for the long departed Shaun Alexander, instead relying on Julius Jones and T.J. Duckett for a solution at the running back position.

I can't say I am enthusiastic about that. However, I am cautiously optimistic.

With a healthy pass game—which they lacked from the get-go last season—the Hawks could find themselves in possession of a consistent though not spectacular rushing attack.

Julius Jones has shown some skills in the past and will probably make a good two-down runner for the team, getting a lift from a new zone-blocking scheme which he fits into well. However, even though he was the top running back for Seattle last season, he was pretty inconsistent and has to correct that if the team is to depend upon him.

People keep talking each season about how this is TJ Duckett's time to shine, but I haven't heard a lot of that yet this off-season. Maybe that bodes well for the former Falcon/Redskin/Lion. He has always possessed a nose for the end zone and he'll get most of the red zone/end zone looks in my opinion—at least when the team isn't throwing the ball to Houshmandzadeh or second year tight end John Carlson.

The question—aside from will Edgerrin James or Duece McAllister sign prior to the season—I am asking is where do guys like Justin Forsett end up? If Duckett is more suited to the short yardage/goal line role, will Forsett a second year man out of California, end up as Jones' backup? Or will he be relegated to special teams?

I want to watch this battle closely as teams all know the Seahawks are gearing up to throw the ball a lot. So who ends up running the ball is of paramount importance. If they cannot move the ball on the ground, the wide receivers may find it very tough to get room to work in the secondary.

That's it for now - if you don't hear from me in a few days, have someone here at BleacherReport send a cop to check on me. I might be buried under an avalanche of moving boxes.


The latest in the sports world, emailed daily.