Finding the Best Consumer-Value Baseball Experience

Joel Reuter@JoelReuterBRFeatured ColumnistFebruary 3, 2014

Getty Images

Nothing says summer like a day at the ballpark, and with football season officially over and spring training just around the corner, the sports world will soon be turning its attention back to our national pastime.

Last season, 74,026,895 total fans made their way out to stadiums around the league, per an press release. It was the sixth-highest attendance total in MLB history.

No two trips to a baseball stadium are created equally, especially from a financial standpoint, and a day at the ballpark is by no means a cheap outing these days.

What follows is my attempt to nail down the three best consumer values among all 30 MLB teams, as there are still bargains out there when it comes to taking in an MLB game in person.

Let's start by taking a look at ticket prices around the league, as that is the biggest single expense among everything that goes into attending a game. The average ticket price last season for a non-premium seat was $27.48, which represented a 1.8 percent increase over 2012, per

Average MLB Ticket Prices in 2013
TeamAverage Ticket Price
1. Boston Red Sox$53.38
2. New York Yankees$51.55
3. Chicago Cubs$44.55
4. Philadelphia Phillies$37.42
5. Washington Nationals$35.24
6. St. Louis Cardinals$33.11
7. Minnesota Twins$32.59
8. Houston Astros$30.09
8. San Francisco Giants$30.09
10. Miami Marlins$29.27
11. Seattle Mariners$28.45
12. Los Angeles Angels$27.54
13. Detroit Tigers$26.36
14. Chicago White Sox$26.05
15. Toronto Blue Jays$25.38
16. New York Mets$25.30
17. Milwaukee Brewers$24.95
18. Baltimore Orioles$23.89
19. Colorado Rockies$23.65
20. Texas Rangers$22.54
21. Los Angeles Dodgers$22.37
22. Oakland Athletics$22.12
23. Cincinnati Reds$21.35
24. Tampa Bay Rays$20.39
25. Kansas City Royals$19.83
26. Cleveland Indians$19.59
27. Atlanta Braves$17.32
28. Pittsburgh Pirates$17.21
29. Arizona Diamondbacks$16.89
30. San Diego Padres$15.99

The top three teams are clearly outliers, as the rest of the MLB is within roughly $10 of the league-average price in either direction.

The Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees and Chicago Cubs are three of the most iconic teams in baseball, but given their inflated ticket prices, it's hard to call any of them a bargain. For that, they'll be removed from the conversation moving forward.

The other significant factor in determining whether a team can be considered a bargain is its on-field product. There has to be at least a decent chance that all of your root, root, rooting for the home team won't be in vain.

To properly gauge the on-field product, we'll take a look at how teams have performed over the past three seasons combined. To move on and continue being considered for the title of best consumer value, a team must have a record of .500 or better over the past three seasons or have made at least one trip to the postseason.

MLB Cumulative Records (2011-2013) and Postseason Trips
Team2011-2013 RecordPlayoff Trips
Arizona Diamondbacks256-2301
Atlanta Braves279-2072
Baltimore Orioles247-2391
Chicago White Sox227-2590
Cincinnati Reds266-2202
Cleveland Indians240-2461
Colorado Rockies211-2750
Detroit Tigers276-2103
Houston Astros162-3240
Kansas City Royals229-2570
Los Angeles Angels253-2330
Los Angeles Dodgers260-2261
Miami Marlins203-2830
Milwaukee Brewers253-2331
Minnesota Twins195-2910
New York Mets225-2610
Oakland Athletics264-2222
Philadelphia Phillies256-2301
Pittsburgh Pirates245-2411
San Diego Padres223-2630
San Francisco Giants256-2301
Seattle Mariners213-2730
St. Louis Cardinals275-2113
Tampa Bay Rays273-2142
Texas Rangers280-2072
Toronto Blue Jays228-2580
Washington Nationals264-2211

With that, 10 more teams are eliminated from the running as the Chicago White Sox, Colorado Rockies, Houston Astros, Kansas City Royals, Miami Marlins, Minnesota Twins, New York Mets, San Diego Padres, Seattle Mariners and Toronto Blue Jays all fall short of the aforementioned stipulations.

That leaves us with 17 still eligible for consideration moving forward, but where do we turn our attention to next?

The stadium itself certainly plays a big part in the overall experience of attending a baseball game. Saying that one stadium is better than another is largely subjective, but we can at least get an overall sense of how a stadium is regarded by combining a few different lists from around the Web.

Included in the following table are rankings by Joe Parks of, Brian Merzbach of and the Yelp! reviews from each MLB stadiums as compiled by The New York Times.

Stadium Rankings
Team (Stadium)ParksMerzbachYelpAverage
Arizona Diamondbacks (Chase Field)28202424
Atlanta Braves (Turner Field)22262323.7
Baltimore Orioles (Camden Yards)9857.3
Cincinnati Reds (Great American Ballpark)26181820.7
Cleveland Indians (Progressive Field)21241620.3
Detroit Tigers (Comerica Park)19251419.3
Los Angeles Angels (Angel Stadium)24221921.7
Los Angeles Dodgers (Dodger Stadium)12132516.7
Milwaukee Brewers (Miller Park)20271119.3
Oakland Athletics ( Coliseum)29282928.7
Philadelphia Phillies (Citizens Bank Park)1810611.3
Pittsburgh Pirates (PNC Park)2211.7
San Francisco Giants (AT&T Park)3333
St. Louis Cardinals (Busch Stadium)1316712
Tampa Bay Rays (Tropicana Field)30302829.3
Texas Rangers (Ballpark in Arlington)14211316
Washington Nationals (Nationals Park)16232621.7

Dropping the teams with stadiums that are rated in the bottom third league-wide leaves us with just nine teams remaining.

So you have your ticket, you're set to watch an above-average team take the field and you're sitting in one of the 20 best ballparks in the league. What's a baseball game without a hot dog and your favorite carbonated beverage?

Concession Prices
TeamHot DogSodaBeerTotal
Baltimore Orioles$1.50$1.50$6.75$9.75
Detroit Tigers$4.25$4.00$5.00$13.25
Los Angeles Dodgers$5.00$5.25$6.25$16.50
Milwaukee Brewers$3.50$2.50$6.00$12.00
Philadelphia Phillies$3.75$4.00$7.75$15.50
Pittsburgh Pirates$3.25$3.25$5.50$12.00
San Francisco Giants$5.00$4.50$6.75$16.25
St. Louis Cardinals$4.25$5.25$6.75$16.25
Texas Rangers$5.00$4.50$5.00$14.50

There are certainly other costs that go into attending a baseball game. Whether you take public transportation or park at the stadium is a big one, and any souvenir purchases and further concessions can add up quickly as well.

Overall, though, the above charts paint a pretty good picture of the top bargains around the league from a numbers standpoint. Based on ticket prices, team quality and concession prices, here are the three best consumer values in baseball: 

3. St. Louis Cardinals (Busch Stadium)

ST LOUIS, MO - OCTOBER 20:  The St. Louis Cardinals practice on the field prior to Game Two of the MLB World Series against the Texas Rangers at Busch Stadium on October 20, 2011 in St Louis, Missouri.  (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)
Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

The Cardinals rank sixth in the league with an average ticket cost of $33.11, but all things considered, that remains one of the best bargains in the MLB. St. Louis may have the best fanbase in all of baseball, and they have been as successful as any team in the league over the past decade-plus.

Their stadium is still relatively new, having opened in 2006, and while it is never going to be in the running for best ballpark in the league, it is a nice place to take in a game with a great view of the Gateway Arch.

A perennially successful team with a nice new ballpark and a ticket price less than $10 above the league average makes the Cards the third-best consumer value in the league heading into 2014.

2. San Francisco Giants (AT&T Park)

SAN FRANCISCO, CA - JULY 23:  Sergio Romo #54 of the San Francisco Giants pitches in the eighth inning against the Cincinnati Reds at AT&T Park on July 23, 2013 in San Francisco, California.  (Photo by Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images)
Thearon W. Henderson/Getty Images

The Giants' average ticket price is tied for eighth in the league at $30.09, but it's worth every penny to take in a game at AT&T Park. A disappointing 2013 season aside, the team has played very well in recent years. (They did win the 2010 and 2012 World Series, after all.)

Opened in 2000 as Pac Bell Park, there are few stadiums that rival AT&T Park. It's certainly in the argument of best stadium in the league today, as it ranked third in all three of the rankings compiled above. With the huge brick wall protecting McCovey Cove in right field and the oversized Coke bottle and baseball glove in left field, it's a great backdrop for a baseball game.

The team has never ranked lower than 11th in the league in total attendance since the park opened and ranked third last season with an average attendance of 41,584, per The Giants earn the No. 2 spot here for their two World Series titles over the past four years and for having a beautiful stadium that is typically packed to capacity.

1. Pittsburgh Pirates (PNC Park)

PITTSBURGH, PA - OCTOBER 07:  Pittsburgh Pirates fans cheer during Game Four of the National League Division Series against the St. Louis Cardinals at PNC Park on October 7, 2013 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.  (Photo by Justin K. Aller/Getty Images)
Justin K. Aller/Getty Images

There's little question that the Pirates are the best consumer value in the MLB today. Their average ticket price of $17.21 puts them 28th in the league, which is an absolute steal to experience PNC Park.

Even when the Pirates were piling up losing seasons and were an afterthought as far as the postseason was concerned, just seeing PNC Park justified the price of admission.

From the 21-foot-high scoreboard wall in right field that protects a short porch to the view of the Roberto Clemente Bridge in center field, it's truly a must-see ballpark.

The Pirates also have one of the most exciting young teams in baseball, fresh off their first postseason trip since 1992. Baseball fans would be wise to make their way to PNC Park sooner rather than later, as it may not remain the terrific value it is right now for long.


    LeBron Rips Astros for Cheating 😳

    Lakers tweets he would be 'F*^king irate' if someone cheated him out of a title

    MLB logo

    LeBron Rips Astros for Cheating 😳

    Joseph Zucker
    via Bleacher Report

    @ScottMillerBbl Spring Training Notebook

    Red Sox's damage control, what the Astros face and more 📝

    MLB logo

    @ScottMillerBbl Spring Training Notebook

    Scott Miller
    via Bleacher Report

    MLBPA Responds to Manfred's Claim Regarding Astros' Part in Investigation

    MLB logo

    MLBPA Responds to Manfred's Claim Regarding Astros' Part in Investigation

    Paul Kasabian
    via Bleacher Report

    Manfred Apologizes for Calling WS Trophy 'A Piece of Metal'

    MLB logo

    Manfred Apologizes for Calling WS Trophy 'A Piece of Metal'

    Adam Wells
    via Bleacher Report