Ranking the Top 10 Prospects in the Detroit Tigers Farm System
For the last five years, the Detroit Tigers farm system has ranked in the bottom third among all teams. It’s not that they’ve struggled to develop prospects; they’ve traditionally opted to trade them for big league talent, which has worked out well for the most part.
While the Tigers system will, once again, lack overall depth, they do boast a trio of prospects that should be big league ready at some point during the 2013 season. Their consensus top prospect, Nick Castellanos, is fresh off a breakout season in which he batted .405 for High-A Lakeland as a 20-year-old, and played the second half of the season at Double-A Erie. Outfielder Avisail Garcia, 21, began last season at Lakeland with Castellanos, but finished the year on the Tigers postseason roster. Not to be forgotten, hard-throwing Bruce Rondon, who sits in the triple-digits, may break camp as the team’s closer.
The Tigers have relied heavily on their international scouting department, which is responsible for half of their top 10 prospects. And although they didn’t draft until the second round last year after signing Prince Fielder during the offseason, they did net two top-10 prospects in Jake Thompson and Austin Schotts.
But as you’ll see, after their top three prospects, the drop-off in quality of their overall system is significant.
10. RHP Brenny Paulino
DOB: 2/21/1993 (Age: 19)
Height/Weight: 6’4”, 170
Drafted/Signed: Sept. 2009 (Dominican Republic)
Scouting Notes: 6’4”, 170-pound right-hander has a highly projectable frame and power arm; big velocity jump over last two years; missed entire 2012 season after injuring his right shoulder and undergoing surgery; he’s going to fall behind the developmental curve, but still has exceptional upside.
Before the injury, Paulino’s fastball was sitting in the low to mid 90s and occasionally scraping 96-97 mph; threw from three-quarters angle before hurting his shoulder, so it’ll be interesting to see what adjustments he makes; long limbs and wiry frame makes him susceptible to control issues; both his secondary offerings, curveball and changeup, are raw offerings given his lack of experience; both should improve steadily once he’s healthy.
2013 Opening Day Level: Low-A West Michigan (when healthy)
9. LHP Casey Crosby
DOB: 9/17/1988 (Age: 24)
Height/Weight: 6’5”, 225
Drafted/Signed: Fifth round, 2007 (Kaneland HS, Ill.)
Scouting Notes: Has been a highly regarded prospect in Tigers’ system since they drafted him in 2007; injury history with left elbow including Tommy John surgery; reached the major leagues for the first time last season and registered a 9.49 ERA with 11 walks in 12 innings spanning three starts.
Crosby has always had good stuff but struggled to harness it throughout his career; fastball sits in the low 90s and will reach 94-95 early in games; he’s made nice progress on the curveball, though he still seemingly lacks a consistent feel; changeup is deceptive relative to his fastball, but he needs to locate both pitches; generates plenty of swings and misses and weak contact, just needs to become more efficient.
2013 Opening Day Level: Triple-A Toledo
8. OF Tyler Collins
DOB: 6/6/1990 (Age: 22)
Height/Weight: 5’11”, 205
Drafted/Signed: Sixth round, 2011 (Howard JuCo, Texas)
Scouting Notes: 22-year-old outfielder batted .290/371/.429 with 20 stolen bases for High-A Lakeland in full-season debut; 5’11”, 205-pound frame doesn’t involve projection; advanced hit tool; laces balls from line to line and collects tons of doubles; excellent plate discipline should allow him to hit for a high average; left-handed hitter with some bat speed and a strong top hand.
Has all the tools to be a big league corner outfielder—except power; unless he starts jumping the yard with more frequency, it’s hard to see him as anything more than a solid fourth outfielder, but his bat could have him moving quickly.
2013 Opening Day Level: Double-A Erie
7. SS/2B Eugenio Suarez
DOB: 7/18/1991 (Age: 21)
Height/Weight: 6’, 180
Drafted/Signed: Oct. 2008 (Venezuela)
Scouting Notes: Finally graduated to Low-A West Michigan this past season after three seasons in the complex leagues; turned in solid full-season debut, batting .288/.380/.409 with 34 doubles, 21 stolen bases and 116/65 K/BB in 135 games; showed vastly improved on-base skills and cleaned up his defense.
6’, 180-pound middle infielder showed improvements across the board; right-handed hitter with a consistent, level swing; comfortable working counts and making pitchers work; doesn’t show much power, but could show more as he adjusts swings; strikes out more than desired; approach and on-base skills continue to improve.
Average speed that impedes his range at shortstop; aggressive basestealer who picks his spots; will need to be more explosive and improve efficiency; started seeing playing time at second base; slick defender with fluid actions; above-average glove with a plus arm; will get lazy and sit back on balls.
2013 Opening Day Level: High-A Lakeland
6. OF Danry Vasquez
DOB: 1/8/1994 (Age: 18)
Height/Weight: 6’3”, 169
Drafted/Signed: July 2010 (Venezuela)
Scouting Notes: Signed a monster $1.2 million bonus as a 16-year-old out of Venezuela; opened 2012 season as 18-year-old at Low-A West Michigan, but was demoted to Short-Season Connecticut after batting .162/.218/.222 through 29 games; rebounded in New York-Penn League with .742 OPS in 72 games.
At 6’3”, 169 pounds, Vasquez should add considerable strength to his naturally strong frame when he fills out; pretty left-handed swing with lots of potential; is comfortable using the whole field as an 18-year-old; makes lots of contact but will also have to learn how to take his walks; not a lot of present power, but his plus bat speed and the natural loft in his swing suggest it will come.
Average speed; suitable for either corner outfield position; inconsistent reads and poor routes magnify his inexperience; arm strength is solid-average but may not be good enough for right; should receive another crack at the Midwest League in 2013.
2013 Opening Day Level: Low-A West Michigan
5. RHP Jake Thompson
DOB: 1/31/1994 (Age: 18)
Height/Weight: 6’4”, 235
Drafted/Signed: Second round, 2012 (Rockwall-Heath HS, Texas)
Scouting Notes: 6’4” right-hander was a two-way standout in high school who also received draft consideration as a hitter; physically mature but still involves some projection; possesses more athleticism than his size suggests; made impressive debut at the rookie level with a 1.91 ERA and .141 BAA, as well as 31/10 K/BB in 28 innings.
Large physical frame makes him both durable and projectable as he continues to gain experience; pounds lower half of strike zone with heavy fastballs in the high 80s, low 90s; should be a consistent low-to-mid-90s arm as he continues to develop and becomes more mechanically efficient; slider is an inconsistent pitch but flashes plus potential with occasional two-plane break and hard bite; changeup is present, as well, but is undeveloped and therefore inconsistent; could move quickly as he develops secondary weapons.
2013 Opening Day Level: Short-Season Connecticut
4. OF Austin Schotts
DOB: 9/16/1993 (Age: 19)
Height/Weight: 5’11”, 180
Drafted/Signed: Third round, 2012 (Centennial HS, Texas)
Scouting Notes: Outstanding athlete who was a standout two-sport star at his Texas high school; batted .310/360/.452 with Tigers’ rookie-level affiliate before late-season promotion to High-A Lakeland for one game; showcased surprisingly advanced baseball skills to go along with top-of-the-line athleticism.
5’11”, 180-pounder has above-average bat speed with the potential to be a well-rounded hitter; swing is fluid and balanced and he’s able to drive the ball to all fields; not a physical player but possesses tons of forearm strength with quick-twitch wrist muscles; has more power than his size suggests and should always pose as an extra-base threat; biggest asset is his plus speed, which led to a 16-of-20 success rate on the basepaths.
Tigers shifted Schotts to center field after spending his amateur career at shortstop; average arm strength wouldn’t have sufficed at previous position; speed is ideal and a clean fit in center; has already been lauded for his all-out approach and ability to make adjustments.
2013 Opening Day Level: Low-A West Michigan
3. RHP Bruce Rondon
DOB: 12/9/1990 (Age: 22)
Height/Weight: 6’3”, 265
Drafted/Signed: Sept. 2007 (Venezuela)
Scouting Notes: Imposing presence on the mound at 6’3”, 265 pounds; Rondon has all the makings of a future closer in the major leagues and nearly assumed the rule late in 2012 after a meteoric rise through the Tigers system; lack of athleticism hurts his longterm projection and he’ll need to keep his weight under control in future seasons.
Rondon boasts one of the best fastballs in the game, sitting at 99-100 mph and routinely touching 102-103 mph; didn’t throw a pitch below 100 mph in the XM Futures Game; heavy pitch that’s thrown on a consistent downward plane; pitch explodes with late life to his arm side; slider is decent when he throws it correctly with tight spin; also features a fading changeup, though he understandably lacks a feel for it; command was vastly improved this past season but can still fall into funks where he’s missing the strike zone; Tigers offered the right-hander a vote of confidence by not re-signing Jose Valverde; it looks like he’ll be closing games for the Tigers, at least part-time, to open the 2013 season.
2013 Opening Day Level: MLB
2. OF Avisail Garcia
DOB: 6/12/1991 (Age: 21)
Height/Weight: 6’4”, 240
Drafted/Signed: July 2007 (Venezuela)
Scouting Notes: Highly impressive athlete given his 6’4”, 240-pound frame; was eased along until breakout 2012 campaign in which he began at High-A Lakeland and finished in the major leagues; made a strong impression with the Tigers during the 2012 postseason.
Toolsy outfielder with a football build; natural approach allows him to drive the ball the other way with ease; quiet setup at the plate with quick hands that allow him to make a lot of contact; more likely he’ll hit for average than power; level, line-drive swing doesn’t result in much power at the present; should start to show more power in coming seasons by adding slight loft to his swing and learning how to turn on the ball.
Profiles as an everyday right fielder in the major leagues; slightly above-average speed gives him range in right field; plus arm is ideal for the position; big league experience as a 21-year-old should prove to be invaluable experience as he continues to develop; could open the season as the team’s fourth outfielder, or even a solid platoon option against left-handed pitching, but more likely he’ll start at Triple-A.
2013 Opening Day Level: Triple-A Toledo
1. OF/3B Nick Castellanos
DOB: 3/4/1992 (Age: 20)
Height/Weight: 6’4”, 210
Drafted/Signed: First round, 2010 (Archbishop McCarthy HS, Fla.)
Scouting Notes: Supplemental first-round pick in 2010 impressed in his full-season debut in 2011 with a league-leading 158 hits for Low-A West Michigan; batted .405 through 55 games to open 2012 season at High-A Lakeland; received promotion to Double-A Erie where his plate discipline was challenged and he batted .264/.296/.382 in 79 games; named the MVP of the XM Futures Game after going 3-for-4 with a home run and three RBI.
Castellanos is a pure hitter with highly advanced bat-to-ball skills and the ability to consistently barrel the ball; natural inside-out swing with lots of power to right-center field; quick hands and bat speed thanks to loose wrists and a fluid swing; not physically strong for his size but possesses plenty of wiry strength; power should continue to develop as he gains more experience at higher levels; will likely always be an extra-base machine; biggest weakness is propensity to chase sliders off the plate and low; has the barrel control to be a plus hitter in the major leagues but will need to refine his approach and pitch recognition.
Was developed as a third baseman until mid-2012; has the arm strength and hands for the position, though his footwork and reads remain raw; moved to the outfield halfway through 2012 season seemingly as a way to expedite his arrival in the big leagues; has received playing time at both corner outfield positions; still needs to learn how to make consistent reads and needs to make his actions more fluid; no reason to believe he won’t be able to handle the outfield; not a particularly strong runner but moves well once he hits full stride.
2013 Opening Day Level: Double-A Erie
Top 10 Archive
Los Angeles Angels Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 16)
Washington Nationals Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 13)
Chicago White Sox Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 13)
Cincinnati Reds Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 11)
Tampa Bay Rays Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 10)
Baltimore Orioles Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 7)
St. Louis Cardinals Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 7)
Seattle Mariners Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 6)
Texas Rangers Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 5)
Toronto Blue Jays Top 10 Prospects (Dec. 3)
Los Angeles Dodgers Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 30)
Chicago Cubs Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 29)
Boston Red Sox Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 28)
Philadelphia Phillies Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 27)
San Francisco Giants Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 26)
Atlanta Braves Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 26)
New York Mets Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 21)
New York Yankees Top 10 Prospects (Nov. 20)