MLB
HomeScoresRumorsHighlightsDraftPower Rankings
Featured Video
Chapman's Game-Saving Play 😱

Every MLB Team's Most Frustratingly Inconsistent Player This Season

Mark MillerJun 7, 2018

With a quarter of the 2012 season behind us, we're beginning to see teams' true colors as some organizations have vaulted themselves into the spotlight and other notable teams find themselves floundering towards the bottom of their divisions.

Just as much as individual contributors can tie their names to teams' successes, inconsistent performers need to step it up if they want to positively impact their team's chances.

Here are some inconsistent players thus far in 2012 who have more than 100 games left to right their ship—and will no doubt look to do whatever they can to turn things around.

Arizona Diamondbacks: J.J. Putz

1 of 30

Arizona Diamondbacks reliever J.J. Putz entered the 2012 season on the heels of a 2011 performance in which he turned in a 2.17 ERA in 60 appearances for the D-Backs and struck out better than a batter per inning.

He hasn't been himself so far this season, with a 0-3 record to his name and an ERA north of 7.00 in 16 relief appearances.

Atlanta Braves: Jair Jurrjens

2 of 30

During much of the offseason, it seemed like the Atlanta Braves could have had a deal done to move Jair Jurrjens in an effort to utilize the young arms they already had prepped for big things.

The team opted to keep Jurrjens around, and while they're probably not regretting the move, he hasn't performed as expected thus far in 2012, with an ERA around 10 and a 0-2 record in four starts.

Baltimore Orioles: Endy Chavez

3 of 30

There aren't very many things that are going wrong for the Baltimore Orioles in 2012, as the team's success continues to be one of the biggest stories in all of baseball.

Coming off a relatively strong season filling in for the Texas Rangers in 2011, in which he batted over .300, Endy Chavez made his way to Baltimore, where he's batting only .133 and has driven in only one run in 20 games.

TOP NEWS

Washington Nationals v Los Angeles Angels
New York Yankees v. Chicago Cubs

Boston Red Sox: Josh Beckett

4 of 30

Things clearly haven't gone as planned for Bobby Valentine and the Boston Red Sox in 2012, as the team sits at .500 but is still in the basement of the AL East.

Josh Beckett has notched four wins for the Sox this year and has been pitching well as of late, but hasn't exactly provided the best clubhouse experience for the team given the off-the -field conflicts surrounding his off-day routines.

Chicago Cubs: Geovany Soto

5 of 30

With a career .253 average, Chicago Cubs catcher Geovany Soto isn't always counted on for the soundest offense, but at just .161 so far in 2012, he hasn't been counted on for any at all.

Soto has gone deep 34 times over the past two seasons and driven in at least 50 runs each year, but in 2012, has only hit three home runs, good enough for a total of 6 RBI.

Chicago White Sox: John Danks

6 of 30

When the Chicago White Sox opted to extend John Danks rather than entertain the idea of trading him and rebuilding, they certainly thought he'd be the cornerstone of a rotation that would hopefully do big things in the AL Central.

Danks has gotten off to a relatively slow start in 2012, with a 3-4 record and ERA approaching six to his name.

His walk numbers are up on the year, while strikeouts have declined more than two per nine innings.

Cincinnati Reds: Scott Rolen

7 of 30

Currently tied with the St. Louis Cardinals atop the NL Central, the Cincinnati Reds are hoping to return to the postseason in 2012, something they'd love third baseman Scott Rolen to be a part of.

Rolen has played in 29 games with the Reds thus far but has struggled to a .174 batting average and has seen his power numbers decline right along with his average.

Cleveland Indians: Casey Kotchman

8 of 30

After seeing a surge in the AL Central in 2011, the Cleveland Indians are back on top of the division once again in 2012 and have plenty of tools to prove they can take it the distance this time around.

First baseman Casey Kotchman will be a big part of the team's divisional run, so the team is certainly hoping he can build on his slow start and produce better on the offensive side as he did with Tampa Bay last year.

Colorado Rockies: Jeremy Guthrie

9 of 30

When the Colorado Rockies traded for Jeremy Guthrie during the offseason, they brought in a veteran presence that should be able to help the team's young rotation back into position to contend in the NL West.

Guthrie has enough of a track record to let others think he'll return to form, but he's seen his strikeout-to-walk ratio head in the wrong direction while his ERA has headed north of five.

Detroit Tigers: Alex Avila

10 of 30

The Detroit Tigers headed into the AL Central with the highest of expectations in 2012, as Cy Young- and MVP-winner Justin Verlander led a team with newly acquired Prince Fielder into play.

Alex Avila emerged in 2011 for the Tigers, batting .295 and driving in 82 runs while making his first All-Star appearance in the process.

The Tigers no doubt counted on him to do much of the same this time around, though he's gotten off to a slow start with a .224 average while watching his walk numbers go down and on-base percentage decline with it.

Houston Astros: J.D. Martinez

11 of 30

After budding star Hunter Pence was traded to Philadelphia last summer, the Houston Astros found a gem in J.D. Martinez who they called up from Double-A Corpus Christi.

He batted .274 in 53 games with Houston in 2011, driving in 28 RBI during the month of July.

Martinez got off to a hot start in 2012 too, batting .313 with a strong on-base percentage before seeing his average drop to .235, and was at one point this month held out of the lineup for a period of time to give him some time to refocus.

Kansas City Royals: Eric Hosmer

12 of 30

With a number of young guns ready to turn things around in Kansas City, the Royals have plenty of reason for optimism in the long term. 

After finishing third in the Rookie of the Year voting in 2011 with a .293 average and 19 home runs, Eric Hosmer has been slow to get things going in 2012, batting just .177 in 40 games in 2012.

Los Angeles Angels: Albert Pujols

13 of 30

Nobody felt as much pressure heading into 2012 as Albert Pujols, as can be expected after signing a $250 million contract to take the Los Angeles Angels to the next level.

Pujols certainly hasn't been himself, however, as he's gone deep only three times in 2012 and is batting nearly 125 points below his career average.

Los Angeles Dodgers: Dee Gordon

14 of 30

After an impressive rookie campaign in 2011 in which he batted .304 and stole 24 bases, Los Angeles Dodgers infielder Dee Gordon has seen a sophomore slump bring him down a few pegs in the resurgent Dodgers.

He's swiped 12 bags already in 2012 but is only batting .208 and has already struck out more times than he did all of last year.

Miami Marlins: Jose Reyes

15 of 30

2011 batting champ Jose Reyes turned many heads this past offseason when he opted to leave the Mets in favor of the new-look Miami Marlins and their new stadium.

He came into the season with a lot of expectations but is currently batting only .253 with the Fins and isn't getting on base enough to make the impact on the base paths he needs to.

Milwaukee Brewers: Rickie Weeks

16 of 30

The Milwaukee Brewers lineup was dealt a blow this offseason when Prince Fielder left Miller Park for the confines of Comerica Park in Detroit.

They dodged a bit of a bullet when slugger Ryan Braun's pending suspension was overturned, but have struggled to get things going in the division this year as they look to upstage the world champion St. Louis Cardinals.

If they hope to contend later this summer, they'll need more contributions from Rickie Weeks, who is batting just .158 in 2012 and leads the league in strikeouts.

Minnesota Twins: Joe Mauer

17 of 30

The Minnesota Twins came into the 2012 season with relatively minimal expectations after finishing with the worst record in the AL in 2011.

If possible, they're actually underperforming this season, as the starting rotation currently has one pitcher remaining from the opening-day rotation, and the team once again has the second-worst record in the league.

Whenever they do turn things around, they'll need to have Joe Mauer behind the effort, and he's been relatively inconsistent since signing his massive contract, batting 30 points below his career average and showing basically no power.

New York Mets: Ike Davis

18 of 30

After a limited but productive 2011 season, Ike Davis hasn't gotten off to the best of starts this season, batting only .156 in 41 games with the Mets.

The team is hoping he can return to form sooner rather than later so they can avoid the prospect of a potential demotion.

New York Yankees: Russell Martin

19 of 30

When the New York Yankees sent catching prospect Jesus Montero to the Seattle Mariners in exchange for Michael Pineda this past offseason, they probably weren't counting on losing out on Pineda for 2012.

They also probably weren't counting on missing out on Russell Martin's productivity either—the catcher has batted just .179 so far in 2012 and has struggled to get his swing back to form.

Oakland Athletics: Cliff Pennington

20 of 30

The Oakland Athletics made many changes this past offseason, moving some pitching out of the organization, while bringing high-potential players like Yoenis Cespedes into the fold.

Cliff Pennington remained in Oakland for the season but has underperformed so far, batting only .217 as his numbers across the board have been on the decline.

Philadelphia Phillies: Jimmy Rollins

21 of 30

After the dust settled in Philadelphia, Jimmy Rollins wasn't going anywhere (as was probably expected), signing a three-year, $33 million deal to remain with the Phillies.

He hasn't shown up offensively as of yet, hitting only .229 in 42 games, and has only gone deep once and driven in seven runs.

Pittsburgh Pirates: Clint Barmes

22 of 30

The Pittsburgh Pirates were cautiously optimistic about their chances heading into the 2012 season, and with free-agent infielder Clint Barmes signed to a multi-year deal, that was one spot they thought they could count on.

Barmes has largely been a disappointment in a Pirates uniform so far, batting under .200 as his strikeout numbers have been on the rise, while his on-base percentage has gone in the other direction.

San Diego Padres: Cameron Maybin

23 of 30

Cameron Maybin saw his batting average dip a bit in 2011 after leaving the Marlins for San Diego; however, he was still getting on base at a good clip and showed some reason for the Padres to think they had something in the young outfielder.

His walk numbers are on the rise, which is a good sign, but Maybin's average has continued to go in the wrong direction in 2012, as he's batting only .212 while watching his power numbers take a hit.

San Francisco Giants: Tim Lincecum

24 of 30

Tim Lincecum had some of the best individual seasons we've seen from young pitchers when he entered the league, and while he struggled at times in 2011, there was no reason to think it would linger into this season.

Lincecum has certainly struggled, however, as his ERA is higher than it's ever been (6.04). And while he's striking out more batters per nine innings, he's also giving more free passes.

Seattle Mariners: Brendan Ryan

25 of 30

Brendan Ryan may not be the answer for Seattle's offense, but the team likely expected something better than a .178 batting average and eight-RBI performance through the quarter pole.

St. Louis Cardinals: David Freese

26 of 30

Last year's World Series hero, David Freese, was flying high during the offseason and had every reason to believe he'd play a huge role in the team's efforts to repeat.

The team is in first place in the NL Central, but while Freese has seen some more pop in his bat, he'll likely want to improve on his .265 average and build up his on-base percentage in the process.

Tampa Bay Rays: Matt Moore

27 of 30

After showing everyone in the league what he was made of last fall, there were lofty expectations for Tampa Bay Rays starting pitcher Matt Moore heading into the 2012 season.

As a Rookie of the Year favorite, Moore has been a disappointment, going 1-4 with an ERA north of five and inflated walk numbers over his 2011 output.

Texas Rangers: Mike Napoli

28 of 30

After playing a big role in the Texas Rangers' postseason last year, catcher Mike Napoli found himself having completed the best season of his career, batting over .300 for the first time and hitting a career-high 30 home runs.

He's come back to earth a bit early on in 2012, batting only .233 in 40 games with the Rangers after signing a one-year, $9.4 million deal.

Toronto Blue Jays: Jose Bautista

29 of 30

Jose Bautista made a strong case for MVP honors in 2011 after leading the league in slugging, OPS and home runs, while posting a career-high .302 batting average and drawing over 100 walks.

He's hit 12 home runs in 2012 but has seen his numbers dip across the board and is batting only .230 through 45 games with Toronto.

Washington Nationals: Ryan Zimmerman

30 of 30

Despite playing in only 101 games with the Washington Nationals in 2011, Ryan Zimmerman was still a catalyst on offense, driving in 49 runs while posting a .289/.355/.443 line.

The pressure was ratcheted up a few notches this season, as the Nationals have the looks of a true contender, but injuries and a substandard performance have gotten in Zimmerman's way, as he's batting 40 points below his career average and has only seen two balls leave the park.

Chapman's Game-Saving Play 😱

TOP NEWS

Washington Nationals v Los Angeles Angels
New York Yankees v. Chicago Cubs
New York Yankees v Tampa Bay Rays
New York Mets v San Diego Padres

TRENDING ON B/R