2023 NFL Free-Agent Signings, Trade Grades: Day 2 Tampering Period Deals
The following sentiment supposedly floated around Indianapolis during the NFL combine: "This free agent class sucks," per Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer.
Yet the money flowed freely at the start of the league's tampering period, with over $600 million in total contractual worth agreed upon just among Monday's top-10 deals.
The action doesn't stop there, as there are hundreds of players still available to sign once the new league year begins, including some of Bleacher Report's highest-rated options.
Day 2 of the unofficial start to free agency begins with us still firmly entrenched within the first wave of talent, featuring plenty of individuals who are capable of making a significant impact. Not all acquisitions will be considered quality gets, though.
B/R is here to decipher the good from the bad among the latest free-agent agreements, with grades handed out for each significant move.
Colts Trade CB Stephon Gilmore to Dallas Cowboys
1 of 21
Colts Get: 2023 fifth-round draft pick
Cowboys Get: CB Stephon Gilmore
When Stephon Gilmore joined the Indianapolis Colts, expectations were far different than they are today.
Many projected the Colts as a potential playoff team and possible division winner. After all, the organization traded for quarterback Matt Ryan, Yannick Ngakoue came over from the Las Vegas Raiders and running back Jonathan Taylor was the reigning rushing yardage leader.
Last year's squad turned into the NFL's version of Murphy's Law. Ryan was benched for poor play. The once-vaunted offensive line suddenly couldn't block. Taylor suffered injuries. Owner Jim Irsay fired Frank Reich midseason, then hired the unproven Jeff Saturday to serve as interim coach.
Obviously, Gilmore wanted to be part of a contender. The former NFL Defensive Player of the Year could be now after the Colts traded him to the Dallas Cowboys for a 2023 fifth-round drat pick, per ESPNs Tom Pelissero.
For the Colts, the organization understands it not the right situation for Gilmore, who turns 33 later this year. The team adds a draft pick and saves $9.9 million toward the salary cap. Though cornerback went from a need to a glaring hole in an instant.
The Cowboys, meanwhile, are never afraid to make a big splash. With Anthony Brown testing free agency, Jerry Jones and Co. decided to go in a different direction and land a short-term upgrade.
"Pro bowl level corner that fits scheme. Can play all coverages we like," a team source told NFL Network's Jane Slater after the trade had been agreed upon in principle.
Gilmore playing opposite Trevon Diggs gives Dallas an opportunistic set of cornerbacks who can change a game in an instant.
Grades: D (Colts), B (Cowboys)
Eagles Re-Sign CB James Bradberry
2 of 21
Contract Terms: Three years, $38 million ($20 million guaranteed)
Both the Philadelphia Eagles and James Bradberry were fortunate that the New York Giants couldn't find a trade partner and chose to release the cornerback during the latter portions of last year's free agency when the majority of teams had already spent their budget.
The Eagles were desperate to find a starting outside corner opposite Darius Slay and managed to bring in Bradberry on a one-year, $7.5 million deal. The organization didn't get off as lightly this time around, but the result stayed the same.
Bradberry and the Eagles agreed to a three-year, $38 million deal, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter. The 29-year-old defensive back could have gone elsewhere, but he understands the value of being in a good locker room and the right situation.
"I went back because of the familiarity with the coaching staff, because I love the city and playing for the Eagles," Bradberry told CBS Sports' Josina Anderson. "They also gave me a deal around what I was looking for. Yes, there were other teams that offered me more, but I feel like Philly is the best fit for me."
Bradberry's retention became even more important upon the report from ESPN's Dianna Russini about the Eagles allowing Darius Slay's agent to seek a trade.
Grade: A
Panthers Sign QB Any Dalton
3 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years, $10 million ($8 million guaranteed)
The Carolina Panthers already made the biggest offseason move to date by trading up to acquire the No. 1 overall pick in April's draft. The organization did so with the intention of drafting a quarterback since it was unlikely to procure a top prospect with its original slot (ninth overall).
In any instance of a team investing in a first-round quarterback, it's always smart to also bring along a veteran backup who helps ease the transition.
The Panthers seemingly understand the process and the best way to set up their new franchise signal-caller. The team and Andy Dalton agreed to a two-year, $10 million deal, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter.
Dalton's experience can't be matched among the current backup quarterback market.
The 35-year-old is entering his 13th season with 162 starts under his belt. Even in situations where he was signed to serve as the backup, he ended up starting because of extenuating circumstances.
With this particular setup, Dalton enters knowing full well he's there to help bring along this year's No. 1 overall pick. If an injury or something unforeseen occurs, the Panthers will then have a proven starter leading the way.
Grade: C+
.jpg?w=256 "Bills Texans Football")
Browns Sign DL Dalvin Tomlinson
4 of 21
Contract Terms: Four years, $57 million ($27.5 million guaranteed)
The Cleveland Browns' defensive interior has been counted among the league's worst units over the past two seasons. On a philosophical level, general manager Andrew Berry didn't seem to believe in making legitimate investments at that particular spot. Instead, he splurged on edge-defenders to pair with Myles Garrett, who also signed a massive extensive prior to the 2020 campaign.
But the retreads and inferior draft picks the Browns placed in the middle of their defense simply couldn't hold the point of attack, thus disrupting the entire scheme. While Garrett shined as a Defensive Player of the Year candidate, he didn't receive the help he needed from the rest of the front.
Dalvin Tomlinson is the ideal addition after agreeing to a four-year, $57 million deal, according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
Tomlinson didn't demand the same attention or annual yearly salary as Javon Hargrave or Dre'Mont Jones, who agreed to terms with the San Francisco 49ers and Seattle Seahawks, respectively. Yet this pairing is all about fit.
The 29-year-old Tomlinson is a superior run defender, who's powerful at the point of attack and provides a little bit of pass-rush juice. He's not nearly as explosive off the snap as the other two mentioned, yet he's going to demand blockers and allow others around him to make plays.
The Browns still aren't completely set along their defensive line, even after the additions of Tomlinson and Ogbonnia Okoronkwo. Quality depth remains a must. But the unit is better today than it was at any point last season.
Grade: A
Falcons Sign QB Taylor Heinicke
5 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years, $20 million
Another domino falls in the quarterback market. Granted, everyone continues to wait for Aaron Rodgers' decision, but the Atlanta Falcons' acquisition of Taylor Heinicke is a fascinating approach.
Heinicke agreed to a two-year, $20 million deal, according to NFL Network's Tom Pelissero. His addition sends multiple signals as to how the Falcons plan to proceed this fall.
For starters, Desmond Ridder is currently slated to go into the season as QB1. Heinicke's deal places him in the upper echelon of the backup wage scale. It simultaneously is a big enough number to signal he can be the starter if Ridder doesn't develop as expected.
Draft plans should also be significantly altered.
"We're going to add to the position, whether it's free agency, the draft, or both," general manager Terry Fontenot told reporters at the NFL combine. "We've talked about the quarterback position, we want to make sure we continue to add to that position, we want to keep bringing players in. (But still) really excited about Desmond."
True to his word, Fontenot is bringing in Heinicke. Will he add another quarterback via the draft?
Currently, the Falcons own this year's eighth overall draft pick and sit behind the likes of the Carolina Panthers, Houston Texans and Indianapolis Colts. The Seattle Seahawks, Detroit Lions and Las Vegas Raiders could still be in the QB market as well, even after previous commitments to veterans.
Thus, Atlanta isn't positioned particularly well to add a top prospect without trading up to this year's third overall pick, where the Arizona Cardinals currently reside.
No matter which way the Falcons decide to go in the draft, Heinicke is a quality addition. He can be a top-end backup and mentor to Ridder or [insert rookie quarterback]. If the young signal-caller doesn't pan out, Heinicke is also a proven starter, albeit on the lower end.
Grade: B
Colts Sign K Matt Gay
6 of 21
Contract Terms: Four years, $22.5 million
Surprisingly, the Indianapolis Colts agreed to a splash signing during the wee hours of Tuesday morning...with a kicker.
Yes, a kicker. But the importance of such a move shouldn't be completely overlooked for two reasons.
First, the Colts' kicking game struggled greatly upon Adam Vinatieri losing his swing then retiring after the 2010 campaign. Since that point, Indianapolis has cycled through Rodrigo Blankenship, Michael Badgley and Chase McLaughlin.
To be fair, McLaughlin fared rather well last season, though the Colts front office clearly saw an opportunity to upgrade with a Pro Bowl-level performer, who happens to be the fifth-most accurate kicker in NFL history, per CBS4 Sports' Mike Chappell.
Second, general manager Chris Ballard and new special teams coach Brian Mason obviously perceive this acquisition as an opportunity to create some stability, and the team paid handsomely to do so.
Once officially signed, Gay 's four-year, $22.5 million deal is the largest free-agent contract ever for the position, per NFL Network's Tom Pelissero.
Grade: C+
Chargers Sign LB Eric Kendricks
7 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years, $13.25 million
Drue Tranquill left a massive void in the middle of the Los Angeles Chargers defense as he considers his options at the onset of free agency's legal tampering period.
Tranquill led the Chargers last season with 146 total tackles and added 10 tackles for loss.
While the 27-year-old defender weighs his options, the Chargers chose to go in a different direction by agreeing to terms with eight-year veteran Eric Kendricks on a two-year, $13.25 million deal, per NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
Kendricks brings reliability and familiarity to a defense that finished 20th overall last season.
The veteran linebacker led the Minnesota Vikings in total tackles in seven of the last eight seasons and piled up his second-most in a season in 2022 with 137. Also, Chargers linebackers coach Jeff Howard served as a defensive assistant with the Vikings during the first five years of Kendricks' career.
The 31-year-old defender can serve as a defensive captain, call the plays and provide the unit with some stability since the group has been disappointing since Brandon Staley became head coach.
Grade: B
Buccaneers Trade OG Shaq Mason to Texans
8 of 21
Buccaneers Get: 2023 sixth-round draft pick
Texans Get: Shaq Mason, 2023 seventh-round draft pick
The Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Houston Texans are heading in opposite directions.
Tampa Bay had its fun with an excellent run led by quarterback Tom Brady, who retired this offseason (really, he did). The Buccaneers are entering the rebuilding phase and attempting to get younger at multiple spots. The team has moved on from the likes of Leonard Fournette and Donovan Smith. More will likely depart in free agency.
The Texans, meanwhile, endured a strip-it-to-the-studs rebuild, and they're finally ready to build a strong foundation and improve the roster.
As such, the two parties came to terms on a deal for 29-year-old right guard Shaq Mason.
The teams flipped late-round picks, according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport. In doing so, the Buccaneers continue to shed salary ($5.3 million), while the Texans fortify an offensive front for whichever rookie quarterback the team inevitably selects with this year's second overall draft pick.
Houston is building a strong line, presumably for Alabama's Bryce Young, who's an undersized prospect at 5'10" and 204 pounds. But a starting five of Laremy Tunsil, a developing Kenyon Green, Scott Quessenberry, Mason and Tytus Howard provides the aforementioned foundation for the rest of the lineup.
Grade: B+ (Texans), D (Buccaneers)
Raiders Sign WR Jakobi Meyers
9 of 21
Contract Terms: Three years, $33 million ($21 million guaranteed)
Josh McDaniels didn't like how his first season as head coach of the Las Vegas Raiders went, so he's going back to his roots.
The franchise's two biggest acquisitions at the onset of the legal tampering period both have ties to McDaniels' time with the New England Patriots.
Jimmy Garoppolo's agreement to become the Raiders' new starting quarterback was the first domino to fall. From there, the organization can build around its latest signal-caller. They chose to do so by agreeing to terms with wide receiver Jakobi Meyers on a three-year, $33 million contract, according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
Meyers spent his first four seasons with the Patriots, where he led the team in receiving yardage each of the last three years, although he never eclipsed 1,000 yards in a campaign.
Three of those seasons were under the supervision of McDaniels, who previously served as New England's offensive coordinator.
The Raiders' plan appears quite simple: Place the best possible supporting cast around Garoppolo, who is a solid starter but can't carry an offense.
Davante Adams and Hunter Renfrow are under contract. The Raiders front office placed the franchise tag on Josh Jacobs. Meyers will enter the fray and do so after signing a contract under perceived market value.
If Las Vegas adds more line help via the draft, the offense should be potent in McDaniels' second season.
Grade: A
Steelers Sign IOL Nate Herbig, Re-Sign Damontae Kazee and DL Larry Ogunjobi
10 of 21
Nate Herbig Contract Terms: Two years, $8 million ($4 million guaranteed)
Damontae Kazee Contract Terms: Two years
Larry Ogunjobi Contract Terms: Three years, $28.5 million
The Pittsburgh Steelers rarely make a big splash by bringing in high-profile free agents. However, they tend to do a good job of signing those who fit their culture for a reasonable price.
Case in point, the organization reportedly agreed to terms Tuesday with offensive lineman Nate Herbig, safety Damontae Kazee and defensive lineman Larry Ogunjobi.
Herbig is set to sign a two-year, $8 million deal at the start of the new league year, according to NFL Network's Mike Garafolo. The 24-year-old Herbig came into the league as an undrafted free agent but worked his way into a roster spot for the Philadelphia Eagles, where he started 17 games in three seasons.
After being waived by the Eagles, Herbig landed with the New York Jets and started 11 games thanks to all the injuries their offensive front endured last season.
While primarily a guard, the four-year veteran does present some flexibility at all three interior spots. His addition could push incumbent left guard Kevin Dotson out of the starting lineup.
As for Kazee, he agreed to re-sign on a two-year deal, per The Score's Jordan Schultz.
The veteran defensive back joined the Steelers last offseason and started four games at free safety. Considering Terrell Edmunds remains a free agent, Kazee's retention gives the Steelers another back-line option alongside Minkah Fitzpatrick.
Much like Kazee, Larry Ogunjobi joined the Steelers last year with something to prove. After a failed physical with the Chicago Bears that cost the defensive lineman a major free-agent deal, Ogunjobi signed a one-year deal to play in the Steel City and proved himself as a vital contributor to a thin front.
After spending five seasons with the Cleveland Browns and then the Cincinnati Bengals, Ogunjobi joined a different defensive scheme in Pittsburgh and still thrived. He made the necessary adjustments to earn a new three-year, $28.75 million deal, per ESPN's Adam Schefter.
Pittsburgh's starting defensive front is set with Ogunjobi, Montravius Adams and Cameron Heyward, though the Steelers must replace the potential departures of Tyson Alualu and Chris Wormley.
Grades: B+ (Herbig), C+ (Kazee), A (Ogunjobi)
Vikings Re-Sign C Garrett Bradbury
11 of 21
Contract Terms: Three years, $15.75 million
Continuity along the offensive line is usually a good thing. Five men must work in cohesion on a down-by-down basis to make the offense function properly. One weak link can ruin numerous plays.
Depending on which part of Garrett Bradbury's career is being discussed, his inclusion on the Minnesota Vikings offensive line can be viewed as good for continuity or the weak link.
The 2019 first-round draft pick didn't have his fifth-year option picked up last year because he struggled during his first three seasons. While Bradbury is extremely athletic with excellent lateral agility, he's struggled with setting the point of attack since he's not the strongest or most physical blocker.
However, the 27-year-old lineman showed marked improvement last season, and the Vikings rewarded him with a new three-year, $15.75 million contract, per NFL Network's Mike Garafolo and Ian Rapoport.
The center is vital to calling protections and being on the same page with his quarterback. Bradbury will remain Kirk Cousins' snapper and the two should be simpatico as they enter another year together, while keeping the starting five intact from last season.
Grade: B
Raiders Trade TE Darren Waller to Giants
12 of 21
Raiders Get: 2023 third-round draft pick
Giants Get: TE Darren Walker
Head coach Josh McDaniels and general manager Dave Ziegler are reshaping the Las Vegas Raiders in their image.
On Monday, the team agreed to terms with quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo. A day later, the organization brought in wide receiver Jakobi Meyers. McDaniels and Ziegler then moved on from former Pro Bowl tight end Darren Waller after trying to trade him for some time.
The Raiders settled for a 2023 third-round draft pick (100th overall), per Tom Pelissero. In doing so, Las Vegas continues to build as it deems fit and saves $11.9 million—which it essentially gave Meyers on a yearly basis—while the Giants get a legitimate threat in the passing game.
Waller's acquisition isn't a slam dunk for the Giants, though.
Yes, he's a dynamic receiving threat and the type of tight end who can help open up Brian Daboll's offense. At the same time, Waller turns 31 in September. He also missed 14 games the last two seasons with injuries and brings a hefty base salary.
Still, the Giants basically upgraded from Kadarius Toney to Waller by using the same draft capital in both deals. More talent is needed for the Giants pass game, but this trade serves as a good start.
Grades: A- (Giants), Raiders (C)
Lions Sign CB Emmanuel Moseley, Re-Sign DL John Cominsky
13 of 21
Emmanuel Moseley Contract Terms: One year, $6 million
John Cominsky Contract Terms: Two years, $8.5 million ($4 million guaranteed)
No one had to tell the Detroit Lions their defense stunk against the pass last season. They already knew after finishing 30th overall against opposing aerial attacks.
To change their approach, the Lions quickly agreed to terms with Cameron Sutton near the onset of the league tampering period. A day later, the team is bringing in Emmanuel Moseley to join him.
Moseley plans to sign a one-year, $6 million contract, according to ESPN's Adam Schefter.
Interestingly, the Lions still don't exactly know what they have in 2020 third overall draft pick Jeff Okudah. However, the inclusion of Sutton and Moseley should take pressure off the young defensive back since both played extensively over the last few seasons. Though Moseley's 2022 campaign was cut short because of a torn ACL, hence the lower figures on his new deal.
The flexibility now found within the Lions secondary is fascinating, considering both Sutton and Moseley have experience playing some safety and over the slot. It's an important factor in both of these acquisitions since Okudah played almost exclusively as an outside corner beyond a handful snaps over the slot.
All three should be on the field to start the season and provide a significant overall upgrade to what was a porous secondary.
John Cominsky, meanwhile, proved to be a pleasant surprise after being acquired last spring on waivers. Cominsky finished third on the team last season with four sacks and provided multiple pressures when working along the defensive interior. As such, the Lions will re-sign him to a two-year deal, $8.5 million contract, per NFL Network's Mike Garafolo.
Grade: B+ (Moseley), B (Cominsky)
Patriots Sign OT Calvin Anderson
14 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years (per NFL Network's Mike Garafolo)
Offensive lineman Calvin Anderson is going back to where it all began.
The New England Patriots originally signed Anderson as an undrafted free agent out of the Texas Longhorns program. He lasted less than a month before being released.
After a short stint on the New York Jets practice squad, the Denver Broncos claimed Anderson, and he turned into a valuable swing tackle for the team and even started 12 games over the last three seasons (11 at left tackle, one at right tackle).
Upon his return to New England, he'll be in the mix to start opposite Trent Brown, considering Isaiah Wynn, Marcus Cannon and Yodny Cajuste are all currently free agents. Conor McDermott is another option.
Or the Patriots can use this as an opportunity to rebuild depth after seeing their offensive line start to crumble last season.
New England does own this year's 14th overall pick. While Anderson can start, the team should still strongly consider drafting Northwestern's Peter Skoronski, Ohio State's Paris Johnson Jr. or Georgia's Broderick Jones if one of the top offensive line prospects remains available.
Grade: C+
Cardinals Sign LB Kyzir White
15 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years, $11 million
The Arizona Cardinals are finally on the board with their first free-agent acquisition from another team, and it should come as no surprise that it's a defensive player from the Philadelphia Eagles to join head coach Jonathan Gannon in the desert.
According to The Score's Jordan Schultz, the Cardinals and linebacker Kyzir White agreed to a two-year, $11 million deal.
White finished second on the Eagles last season 110 total tackles. Now, he can serve as the voice for Gannon on the Cardinals defense.
Arizona already invested first-round picks in Isaiah Simmons and Zaven Collins. Neither has quite lived up to expectations, though both managed 99 or more tackles last season. Collins is a big, physical middle linebacker, while Simmons converted back to his more natural position of strong safety last season.
White brings a different skill set as a true Will backer with the speed to chase down ball-carriers and a comfort level working in space.
Arizona's defensive front seven still needs reinforcements with J.J. Watt's retirement and Zach Allen's free-agent department, but the unit should be set along the second line.
Grade: B
Jets Sign WR Allen Lazard
16 of 21
Contract Terms: Four years, $44 million ($22 million guaranteed)
The New York Jets are one step closer to the inevitable: the acquisition of quarterback Aaron Rodgers from the Green Bay Packers.
But certain parameters must be met before that point is officially reached. According to ESPN's Dianna Russini, the four-time league MVP provided the Jets "with a wish list of free agents he would like them to target and acquire."
Allen Lazard was on the list after being one of Rodgers' favorite targets over the last few seasons. In accordance to the reported request, the Jets and Lazard reached a four-year, $44 million agreement, per The Score's Jordan Schultz.
Even without Rodgers being part of this equation, Lazard is a quality addition. He's a 27-year-old target with extremely strong hands, as evidenced by 100 receptions and 14 touchdown grabs over the last two seasons, and acts an ideal power slot in today's game.
Obviously, Lazard's deal and the possibility of future additions in Randall Cobb and/or Odell Beckham Jr. will dramatically reshape the Jets' wide receiver corps. Garrett Wilson isn't going anywhere after being named the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year. But New York can save $10.5 million by releasing Corey Davis, and Elijah Moore will be an intriguing option on the trade market if he becomes available.
Whatever the case, these moves are being made with one end goal in mind. As long as this gets the Jets closer to Rodgers as their starting quarterback, the move had to be made.
Grade: A
Cowboys Re-Sign LB Leighton Vander Esch
17 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years, $11 million
Leighton Vander Esch's career with the Dallas Cowboys has been a roller coaster of a ride. Despite the ups and downs, it'll continue after the two sides agreed to a two-year, $11 million deal, per NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
The 2018 first-round draft pick came into the league like a ball of fire and became a Pro Bowler and second-team All-Pro as as rookie. Unfortunately, a nerve issue in his neck derailed his second season. A broken collarbone shortened his third campaign. The Cowboys didn't pick up his rookie fifth-year option the following offseason. He signed a one-year contract once his rookie deal expired.
Here we are in Year 6, and he's still with the Dallas Cowboys. All things considered, it's an amazing turnaround after how Vander Esch's career went off track.
The linebacker's retention is important to the overall performance of the Cowboys defense. He mans the middle of the unit. When coupled with Donovan Wilson's eventual re-signing at strong safety, defensive coordinator Dan Quinn won't be forced to modify his scheme based on new talent.
If anything, the Cowboys should be able to expand their defensive playbook by retaining those familiar with the system while also upgrading at cornerback thanks to the Stephon Gilmore trade.
Grade: B
Seahawks Sign DT Jarran Reed
18 of 21
Contract Terms: Two years, up to $10.8 million (per NFL Network's Tom Pelissero and Ian Rapoport)
A reunion will be forthcoming after the Seattle Seahawks agreed to a deal with defensive tackle Jarran Reed.
Seattle originally drafted Reed with the 49th overall pick in the 2016 NFL draft, and he played five seasons with the franchise.
The last two seasons were spent with the Kansas City Chiefs and then the Green Bay Packers. Reed started as part of both defensive line rotations, though he never quite reached the heights he did in Seattle.
Logically, a return to the same city and team in which he thrived makes the most sense.
Furthermore, Reed is an excellent fit with how the Seahawks' defensive front is built. On Monday, the franchise splurged by agreeing to terms with Dre'Mont Jones. Jones will receive a massive $51.5 million deal once he finally puts pen to paper. But the fellow interior defender's value is derived from his ability to rush the passer.
Jones can line up at 3-technique with Reed manning 1-technique to provide a rock-steady defensive tackle duo.
Clearly, the Seahawks weren't happy with their previous setup since Poona Ford remains available in free agency and the team released veterans Shelby Harris and Quinton Jefferson.
With the interior reset and upgraded, Seattle's edge-defenders should excel as well.
Grade: B+
Falcons Re-sign OT Kaleb McGary
19 of 21
Contract Terms: Three years, $34.5 million
The right side of the Atlanta Falcons offensive line remains intact after agreeing to a five-year, $105 million contract extension with guard Chris Lindstrom and then keeping right tackle Kaleb McGary on a three-year, $34.5 million deal, per NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
The duo came into the league together as first-round picks by the Falcons during the 2019 NFL draft, and they've performed well.
McGary blossomed in his fourth season, after the Falcons didn't exercise the fifth-year option on his rookie contract. He received the second-highest run-blocking grade among offensive tackles last season (only behind the San Francisco 49ers' Trent Williams), according to Pro Football Focus' Jeff Deeney.
With McGary's average annual salary falling well below that of Jawaan Taylor ($20 million) and Mike McGlinchey ($17.5 million) despite his recent level of play, his re-signing should be viewed as a massive win for the Falcons organization.
Atlanta is clearly building a roster with Arthur Smith's vision in mind. Whoever is behind center will benefit because the offense will remain a run-first scheme with the best run-blocking right side the game has to offer.
Grade: A
Colts Sign Edge Samson Ebukam
20 of 21
Contract Terms: Three years, $27 million
Last offseason, Indianapolis Colts general manager Chris Ballard traded for Yannick Ngakoue in hopes of finding the pass rush his defense lacked coming off the edge.
Ngakoue held up that end of the bargain by leading the downtrodden Colts with 9.5 sacks. However, the smallish edge-defender became a liability when defending the run.
While defensive coordinator Gus Bradley prefers rangier and more athletic options to play LEO (rush end) in his defensive scheme, those defenders must still be competent in both phases of the game.
Instead of trying to re-sign Ngakoue, the Colts agreed to terms on a three-year, $27 million deal with Samson Ebukam, per ESPN's Adam Schefter and Jeremy Fowler.
Ebukam isn't as polished of a pass-rusher. He had 9.5 sacks over the last two seasons. He's a superior run defender compared to Ngakoue, though. And his average annual salary is lower than what the Colts spent on their previous defensive end ($13 million).
With Ebukam's inclusion to the lineup alongside Kwity Paye, Dayo Odeyingbo and the re-signed Tyquan Lewis, another edge-defender isn't a priority. Quarterback and cornerback are the primary targets, particularly once the NFL draft begins.
Grade: B
Other Signings
21 of 21
Here's a rundown of Tuesday's other signings.
Giants Sign DL Rakeem Nunez-Roches
The New York Giants are beefy along their defensive interior with Dexter Lawrence and Leonard Williams as the focal points for the unit. Depth has been an issue behind the two standouts, though.
According to the Record's Art Stapleton, the Giants have agreed to a three-year deal with veteran defensive lineman Rakeem Nunez-Roches. Per Pro Football Focus' Brad Spielberger, the agreement is worth $12 million in total contractual value.
The ninth-year defender spent the last five seasons as a critical part of the Buccaneers' defensive line rotation. He'll provide the same vital component to the Giants lineup.
Grade: B
Cowboys Re-Sign S Donovan Wilson
Donovan Wilson experienced a breakout campaign last season. The 2019 sixth-round draft pick started a full season for the first time and rewarded the Dallas Cowboy with career highs in total tackles (101) and sacks (five).
The organization reciprocated by re-signing its strong safety to a three-year, $24 million contract extension with $13.5 million guaranteed, according to NFL Network's Mike Garafolo.
With this move, the Cowboys keep their safety rotation of Wilson, Jayron Kearse and Malik Hooker intact through the 2023 campaign. More importantly, Wilson is under contract through 2025, while both Kearse and Hooker are scheduled to be free agents next offseason.
Grade: A
Dolphins Re-Sign RB Raheem Mostert
Raheem Mostert is an ideal fit in Mike McDaniel's offense, hence why he's stuck around as long as he has. The soon-to-be 31-year-old running back has agreed to terms on a two-year, $7.6 million contract with the Miami Dolphins, per ESPN's Adam Schefter.
First, Mostert broke out in San Francisco in Kyle Shanahan's vaunted outside zone scheme. McDaniel served as the run game coordinator on that staff. When he became the head coach in Miami, he brought Mostert along with him. The back will stick around a little longer and add some juice to the run game.
Grade: B
Lions Re-Sign OT Matt Nelson
The Detroit Lions own one of the league's best offensive lines. It was a top-10 group last season, according to Pro Football Focus' yearly O-line rankings.
Matt Nelson isn't a full-time starter, but he's been a quality swing tackle over the last two seasons, including 11 starts during the 2021 campaign. As such, the Lions announced his re-signing Tuesday (terms not disclosed).
The defensive line convert didn't start a contest last year, though he provides quality depth along the front five. Most teams don't have the same luxury.
Grade: C+
Texans Sign WR Noah Brown
The Houston Texans are building a solid supporting cast for whichever quarterback the organization selects with this year's second overall draft pick.
Wide receiver Noah Brown is the latest addition after the two sides agreed to a one-year deal, per KPRC 2 Houston's Aaron Wilson. NFL Network's Tom Pelissero later reported that his contract is worth $2.6 million, with $2.25 million of that guaranteed. Brown posted career highs last season with 43 receptions for 555 yards and three touchdowns.
Brown joins Brandin Cooks and Nico Collins to give the Texans a solid trio. The team has added right guard Shaq Mason to solidify its offensive line. Running back Dameon Pierce is coming off a standout rookie campaign.
With the right triggerman, the Texans could see real gains next fall.
Grade: C+
Raiders Re-Sign OT Brandon Parker
Right tackle has been a sore spot for the Las Vegas Raiders since the organization whiffed on its evaluation of 2021 first-round draft pick Alex Leatherwood. Brandon Parker has been asked to hold down the fort, even though he was never the plan.
During the 2021 campaign, Parker started 13 games on the strong side and struggled. He then suffered a season-ending triceps injury during last year's preseason. Despite those issues, the Raiders are bringing Parker back on a one-year, $1.5 million deal, according to NFL Network's Tom Pelissero.
Last year's starter at right tackle, Jermaine Eluemunor, is a free agent. The Raiders could still bring him back, but Parker can provide depth and compete for a starting spot regardless.
Grade: C
Jaguars Re-Sign S Andrew Wingard
The Jaguars are keeping their trio of safeties intact as Andrew Wingard has agreed to a new three-year, $9.6 million contract ($6 million guaranteed), per NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
Since the Jaguars signed Wingard as an undrafted free agent, he's started 24 games in four seasons. He is experienced, contributes in the defensive backfield alongside Andre Cisco and Rayshawn Jenkins and serves as one of Jacksonville's primary special teams players.
Grade: B
49ers Re-Sign C Jake Brendel
A certain type of lineman is necessary to play in Kyle Shanahan's outside-zone scheme, and center Jake Brendel fits like a glove.
"Jake is definitely an athlete," left tackle Trent Williams told reporters last summer. "Definitely a quick-twitch. Definitely has short-area quickness, which makes him a great center."
Brendel, who bounced around the league since 2016, finally become a full-time starter last season, and the San Francisco 49ers realized he's ideal in the middle of their scheme. As a result, the two sides agreed on a new four-year deal worth $20 million ($8 million guaranteed), per NFL Network's Ian Rapoport.
Grade: B
Browns Re-Sign LB Sione Takitaki
The Cleveland Browns originally selected linebacker Sione Takitaki in the third round of the 2019 NFL draft. Early in his career, the young defender found his niche as a downhill Sam backer. But he continually improved to the point where he wasn't a liability when working in space and started eight games last season.
Unfortunately, Takitaki suffered a season-ending torn ACL before entering free agency for the first time. So the two sides decided a short-term, prove-it deal is in the linebacker's best interests and agreed to a one-year, $2.6 million contract, per ESPN's Jeremy Fowler.
Grade: C+
Chargers Re-Sign OT Trey Pipkins III
Offensive linemen tend to need time to develop. Very few are properly taught to enter the professional ranks and immediately play at a high level.
Trey Pipkins III is an excellent example after being a third-round pick out of Sioux Falls who had to be thrust into the starting lineup far too early in his career.
But he survived the experience to the point where the Chargers were happy with last year's performance with the right tackle, and the two sides agreed to a new three-year, $21.75 million deal, per SiriusXM NFL Radio's Adam Caplan.
Grade: C+
Buccaneers Re-Sign OG Aaron Stinnie
A year ago at this time, Aaron Stinnie prepared himself for a competition at left guard and looked to be Ali Marpet's successor after his surprise retirement. Unfortunately, Stinnie suffered a torn ACL during the 2022 preseason.
Fast forward 12 months and Stinnie finds himself in a similar position. According to ESPN's Jeremy Fowler, the 29-year-old guard plans to re-sign with the Buccaneers on a one-year, $2.5 million deal.
In doing so, he'll have an opportunity to became a starting guard, albeit on the right side this time. With the organization's decision to trade Shaq Mason, a competition will ensue to see who takes the spot.
Grade: C
Eagles Sign RB Rashaad Penny
The Philadelphia Eagles organization values running backs, although they don't seem too enamored with handing a big deal to Miles Sanders. Instead, general manager Howie Roseman chose to bring Rashaad Penny in on a one-year, $1.35 million deal ($600,000 in guarantees), according to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport and Tom Pelissero.
When healthy, Penny is a nightmare for opposing defenses to stop. The 2018 first-round pick is first in yards per carry (6.2), yards after contact per carry (4.6) and rushing yardage over expected (+317) since the start of the '21 campaign, per NFL Next Gen Stats. He ran for over 1,000 yards in his last 10 games.
Now place Penny behind the league's best offensive line. Scary. Though he's never played a full season because of injuries.
Grade: A
.jpg?w=480 "Bills Texans Football")
.jpg?w=480 "Browns Football")
.jpg?w=600 "Making Sense of 2026 NFL Draft's Worst Picks 😨")
.png?w=600 "2027 NFL Mock Draft 🔮")