.jpg?w=2560)
The excitement of landing a 5-star prospect is hard to forget.
For a coaching staff, the signature is the product of many phone calls, text messages, visits and other contacts. That top-ranked talent is the source of hope, optimism and dreams all over the fanbase.
Unfortunately, some recruits became hard to forget for a different reason: They just never panned out.
The following players had very little production at the Football Bowl Subdivision level. It's important to remember someone like Arch Manningโthough he's fallen short of championship expectations as of this writingโhas been a net-positive player at Texas. Disappointment is far different from a bust.
Additionally, there are several players at risk of joining this inglorious list still on rosters in 2026. The narrative isn't great for Bryce Underwood or Malachi Nelson, for example. But we won't say those stories are finished quite yet.
Five-stars are based on the final 247Sports Composite Rankings in each cycle.
Antonio Alfano, Alabama Edge
1 of 10
Considered the No. 5 overall prospect in the 2019 class, Antonio Alfano enrolled at Alabama as the next great pass-rusher for the powerhouse program.
He never played a game in the FBS.
Alfano left Alabama early as a freshman while struggling with family matters. After transferring to Colorado, he dealt with off-field issues along with health challengesโepilepsy, specificallyโthat further derailed his career.
Later, he returned to play at Lackawanna College (JUCO) and appeared in four games with the Edmonton Elks of the Canadian Football League.
Calvin Ashley, Auburn OL
2 of 10
Calvin Ashley is a prime example of why criteria matters.
From an overall football view, he wouldn't necessarily fit "bust" status. Even if only briefly, Ashley spent part of the summer of 2021 with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. He earned All-USFL honors with the New Jersey Generals in 2023.
But those highlights came beyond the FBS, the level at which Auburn anticipated an immense impact from the 2017 cycle's No. 26 player.
Over two seasons on the Plains, he made six appearances, including one start.
Ashley transferred to Florida Atlantic in early 2019 but soon joined the FCS program at Florida A&M to be closer to his newborn son. He played one season at FAMU.
Jurrion Dickey, Oregon WR
3 of 10
Speedy wide receiver Jurrion Dickey, the headliner of Oregon's 2023 recruiting class, arrived on campus as the nation's No. 22 overall prospect.
However, he hardly made an impact in his two-plus seasons with the Ducks. Dickey notched a seven-yard catch in the Fiesta Bowl as a true freshman and a seven-yard reception in a rout of Michigan State in 2024. That was the full extent of his production at Oregon.
Oregon suspended him indefinitely prior to the 2025 season for violating team rules. He left for a junior college shortly thereafter.
Dickey has since become a productive target for NAIA school Midland University.
John Emery Jr., LSU RB
4 of 10
Throughout six years at LSU, a long list of setbacks cost John Emery Jr. an opportunity to become a core contributor.
Ranked 13th in his class, Emery held a reserve role on the iconic 2019 championship team. Emery managed 451 scrimmage yards in 2020, but he missed the 2021 season due to academic ineligibility.
Emery returned in 2022 and shared the backfield with two others, managing 375 yards and six scores on the ground.
He remained buried on the depth chart in 2023. A torn right ACL ended his brutal season in November. Most cruelly, he earned the starting nod in 2024 but made a single appearance before a torn left ACL ended the year.
Emery transferred to UTSA in 2025 but handled just four carries in one game.
Sam Huard, Washington QB
5 of 10
It had to be Washington for Sam Huard. Where else could he go?
Damon Huard, his father, left the program in 1995 as its all-time leader in career passing yards. Brock Huard, Sam's uncle, replaced his brother and broke that record, along with many others.
So, when the nation's 12th-ranked prospect headed to Washington in 2021, expectations were a continuation of the family legacy.
Huard started one game as a true freshman, tossing four interceptions in a loss to rival Washington State. He spent 2022 as UW's third-stringer, transferred to FCS Cal Poly in 2023, returned to the FBS with Utah in 2024 but didn't play, and then watched from the sideline at USC in 2025.
The one exception during his time at USC? Throwing a fourth-down pass as part of a clever, controversial trick play that resulted in a Big Ten rule change.
Arik Gilbert, LSU TE
6 of 10
Particularly on the heels of Thaddeus Moss being so productive on the 2019 championship team, Arik Gilbert went to LSU with a tremendous outlook.
LSU needed to address Moss' void at tight end. Gilbert, an imposing 6'5", 253-pounder ranked fifth in his class, had a clear path to immediate playing time and took advantage. He reeled in 35 passes for 368 yards and two touchdowns as a true freshman in 2020 for the Tigers.
From there, though, off-field issues wrecked his college career.
Gilbert transferred to Georgia but didn't play in 2021 due to personal reasons. He mustered two catches for 16 yards and a touchdown, then bolted for Nebraska, where he never entered a game.
Mique Juarez, UCLA LB
7 of 10
In 2015, UCLA landed its QB of the future in 5-star Josh Rosen. One year later, the Bruins landed the cornerstone of their defense in Mique Juarez, the No. 11 recruit in the cycle.
That was the vision, at least.
Juarez immediately felt the weight of that pressure and stepped away from the team during fall practices. He returned for the 2017 season, contributing on special teams and making three tackles.
During the 2018 opener, a concussion stalled Juarez's progress. He missed the rest of the year, and he left UCLA after being told he shouldn't play football again.
Juarez chose Utah as a transfer destination but never appeared on the roster.
Lorenzo Lingard, Miami RB
8 of 10
In the moment, it seemed like Lorenzo Lingard appeared at the perfect time for Miami. The program had begun to ascend as Mark Richt put his alma mater back on the national radar and also snapped a long streak of losing bowl games.
Lingard, the No. 25 player in the 2018 class, would be the next great running back at a school known for producing them.
The vision never became reality at a prominent spot.
After logging 17 carries as a freshman before a knee injury ended his year, Lingard only played a couple of games on special teams in 2019. He transferred to Florida, where he managed 27 touches over three seasons.
Lingard at least salvaged one fine campaign at Akron in 2023, totaling 1,009 scrimmage yards for the 2-10 Zips.
Trey Sanders, Alabama RB
9 of 10
You might remember the quote.
"As a freshman at Alabama, I do plan on winning the Heisman, nothing less," Trey Sanders said on signing day in 2019.
Why wouldn't the No. 6 prospect of the cycle be confident? Between his physical stature and versatility as a pass-catcher, he'd been labeled college-ready. And he was headed to Alabama, a major NFL pipeline at the position.
However, both on- and off-field injuries halted Sanders' dream.
That first season, a foot injury shelved him. Sanders returned in 2020 before a car accident ended his campaign. Though he collected 314 yards in 2021, a majority of his carries happened in the second half of lopsided games.
Over three seasons with the Crimson Tide, he turned 125 offensive touches into 594 scrimmage yards. He then totaled 242 yards in two years at TCU.
Ricky Slade, Penn State RB
10 of 10
Saquon Barkley. Miles Sanders. Ricky Slade.
Upon his arrival in 2018, it was the dream backfield progression for a rising program. Slade, who ranked 27th overall in that cycle, had an opportunity to immediately impact the Nittany Lions.
Slade served as the backup in his freshman year, rushing for 257 yards and six touchdowns. He won the starting job in 2019, yet tumbled in a four-player rotation, managing 319 scrimmage yards before electing to transfer.
At the time, it made sense. Slade followed his offensive coordinator, Ricky Rahne, to Old Dominion with the potential to become the featured runner. However, the school canceled its 2020 season amidst the COVID-19 pandemic.
Slade was no longer part of the ODU roster by February 2021 and didn't play elsewhere.


.jpg?w=2560)




.png?w=2560)





.png?w=2560)
