Hiring John Harbaugh Sets Up New York Giants to Follow Patriots' Worst-to-First Blueprint

The New York Giants are set to make a big splash in the hiring cycle, which could propel them into playoff contention, much like the New England Patriots did with head coach Mike Vrabel.

According to NFL Network's Ian Rapoport, the Giants are working on a five-year deal that will make John Harbaugh one of the league's highest-paid head coaches. 

Like Vrabel, Harbaugh would take on his second head-coaching job, inheriting a roster with a promising quarterback, Jaxson Dart, who showed flashes in his rookie year, and a team that will hold a top-five draft pick. 

Although the Giants won't have as much cap space as the Patriots had a year ago, they can free up resources through notable cuts and trades. Keep in mind that defensive lineman Dexter Lawrence II doesn't have any guaranteed money on the final two terms of his deal.

As the Baltimore Ravens' head coach for 18 seasons, Harbaugh won about 61 percent of his games, going 180-113, leading the club to six division titles and a Super Bowl on 12 playoff trips. He's had just two losing seasons (both 8-9) in the last 10 years.

In contrast, Big Blue has won one playoff game in two postseason trips since its Super Bowl run through the 2011 campaign. New York finished last in the NFC East for back-to-back years.

With a dynamic signal-caller, a Pro Bowl-caliber receiver in Malik Nabers and a couple of cornerstone roster pieces on both sides of the trenches in left tackle Andrew Thomas and edge-rusher Brian Burns, Harbaugh can take the Giants from worst to first in the division, and there are similarities to the Patriots' jump from 4-13 to 14-3.

Fresh Start with a Storied Franchise

AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster

Harbaugh isn't a stranger to high-pressure situations. He raised Baltimore's standards after leading the club to a Super Bowl XLVII victory in the 2012 campaign. The 63-year-old head coach can handle the bright lights and media in New York.

Much like Vrabel, Harbaugh could be rejuvenated with a second team after his firing and comes with a proven resume.

Unlike Vrabel, Harbaugh didn't take a year off. Yet he has something to prove after the Ravens missed the playoffs in a losing season.

The Giants need stability and someone who can establish a winning culture. Given Harbaugh's nearly two-decade run with the Ravens, he can check boxes on both fronts.

Jaxson Dart Set Up to Follow in Drake Maye's Footsteps

AP Photo/Adam Hunger

Drake Maye started in 12 games during his rookie campaign, throwing for 2,276 yards, 15 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions.

Ironically, Dart started in the same number of games and threw for 2,272 yards and 15 touchdowns, with just five interceptions, during the 2025 term. 

Coming out of Ole Miss, Dart drew comparisons to Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen, which is more reason to believe he can make a second-year leap comparable to Maye's development between 2024 and 2025.

Yes, Maye is an MVP candidate, a high bar for Dart, but it's not out of the realm of possibility for the 22-year-old signal-caller.

According to Rapoport, Harbaugh is expected to hire Todd Monken, who was his offensive coordinator in Baltimore. Under Monken, Lamar Jackson won his second league MVP and improved significantly as a passer, throwing for career highs in yards (4,172) and touchdowns (41), while leading the league in multiple categories in 2024.

Dart isn't as electric as Jackson running the ball, but Monken can use similar play designs to unlock the young signal-caller's dynamic playmaking ability. 

In December, ESPN's Jordan Raanan reported that the Giants want Dart to protect himself as a ball-carrier to avoid unnecessary wear and tear on his body. The rookie quarterback was in and out of the blue tent mostly because of head injuries and missed a couple of games while in concussion protocol.

Monken can help Dart develop as a passer, which may put the Giants' quarterback on the fast track to MVP consideration.

Harbaugh's Coaching Staff Can Bolster Roster Talent

AP Photo/Nick Wass

Vrabel didn't turn around the Patriots by himself. He built a quality coaching staff that optimized the use of upstart and veteran talent. He hired offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels, who elevated Maye and his supporting cast.

In McDaniels' system, rookie first-rounder Will Campbell has shown promising signs of a franchise left tackle, and running back TreVeyon Henderson racked up 1,132 scrimmage yards, tying Dart for most rushing touchdowns (nine) among rookies and finishing second among 2025 draftees in rushing yards (911).

In terms of contract value and guaranteed money, the Patriots spent the most in free agency last offseason. They incorporated key acquisitions like wideout Stefon Diggs and defensive tackle Milton Williams in a rise from the basement to the penthouse in the AFC East.

The Giants won't have a ton of cap space, even with cuts and trades, but like Vrabel, Harbaugh knows how to build a strong staff. Though his background is rooted in special teams, his Ravens squads ranked in the top nine in scoring for five of the previous nine years, and in the top 10 in defensive scoring for 13 of his 18 seasons with the team.

Among Harbaugh's most notable assistants from recent years, his former defensive coordinator Mike Macdonald led the Seattle Seahawks to a 14-3 record and the NFC's No. 1 seed this season. 

Given the defensive toughness of Harbaugh's Ravens teams and his possible reunion with Monken, the Giants will be a better-coached team going forward.

Top-5 Pick Can Be Key Piece to Quick Rebuild

AP Photo/Adam Hunger, File

The Giants hold the No. 5 overall pick in the 2026 draft. They don't need a quarterback, so this allows the front office to take the best available prospect as a potential roster-building block.

Last offseason, the Patriots selected Campbell with the No. 4 overall pick to protect Maye in the pocket.

Assuming Nabers and running back Cam Skattebo recover from season-ending injuries, the Giants can take a look at offensive tackle Spencer Fano or take the best defensive player available after finishing 26th in points allowed and 28th in yards allowed this past season.

General manager Joe Schoen has a shaky track record of first-round picks. Kayvon Thibodeaux isn't playing up to his draft status as a former top-five pick. Cornerback Deonte Banks lost his starting job in 2025. Abdul Carter had a disappointing rookie campaign.

Perhaps Schoen redeems himself with a selection that shows as much promise as Dart and Nabers. If so, Big Blue would add another long-term piece to a young roster nucleus.

In a division with two other teams that finished with records below .500 and a struggling Philadelphia Eagles squad that just fired its offensive coordinator, the Giants can be next year's biggest success story under Harbaugh.