2011 NFL Rule Changes: How Do the New Rules Impact the League?

Ryan CookFeatured ColumnistMarch 23, 2011

2011 NFL Rule Changes: How Do the New Rules Impact the League?

0 of 7

    NEW ORLEANS, LA - MARCH 21: NFL commissioner Roger Goodell addresses the media during the NFL Annual Meetings at the Roosevelt Hotel on March 21, 2011 in New Orleans, Louisiana. Despite a NFL owners imposed lockout in effect since March 12 the league is c
    Sean Gardner/Getty Images

    NFL commissioner Roger Goodell took to the stands once again on Tuesday, lecturing fans, players and coaches alike on a new shift in the rulebook ahead of next season.

    Goodell's face in front of a blue backdrop has become a sore sight as of late, particularly since the lockout has proven to be the true victor in the well-publicized debacle this past month. Fortunately, however, these newest rule changes could make things particularly interesting should football be played in 2011.

    Fans hope so, at least.

    All of this comes nearly a year after the NFL implemented new overtime rules, which failed to be taken advantage of last season. Tuesday's announcement should make a very direct and immediate impact on one position in particular.

Kickoffs Will Now Take Place on the 35 Yard Line

1 of 7

    ARLINGTON, TX - FEBRUARY 06:  Mason Crosby #2 of the Green Bay Packers kicks off to start Super Bowl XLV against the Pittsburgh Steelers at Cowboys Stadium on February 6, 2011 in Arlington, Texas.  (Photo by Doug Pensinger/Getty Images)
    Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

    It was more of a shock than a surprise to see a rule change this early in the offseason. Nevertheless, Roger Goodell decided to address an idea which had been toyed with for several years: changing the field position on kickoffs.

    On Tuesday, owners grouped together and voted 26-6 in favor of moving kickoffs to the 35-yard line.

    In years previous, kickoffs were taken from the 30-yard line, an area which often limited some kickers in terms of distance.

    There will be positive and negative aspects within this rule change, of course. 

    Here's a look at both the good and the bad...

The Good: Touchbacks

2 of 7

    DENVER - OCTOBER 09:  Cornerback Champ Bailey #24 of the Denver Broncos is congratulated by teammate Ian Gold #52 after Bailey intercepted a pass intended for Clarence Moore of the Baltimore Ravens in the endzone for a touchback with 36 seconds remaining
    Brian Bahr/Getty Images

    Kick returners will feel the heat thanks to the recent rule change—that's a given.

    For once, however, the kickers themselves will have an equal chance at slotting a touchback to limit the opposing team to the 20-yard line.

    Coincidentally, this is also an area owners discussed on Tuesday.

    Fans have proposed the idea of moving touchbacks to the 25-yard line several times in the past, yet this is an area the NFL feels is irrelevant at least for the time being.

    Kickers will love the extra cushion—lethal returners like DeSean Jackson and Devin Hester, on the other hand, might not.

    It should add an extra touch of excitement to future games, especially for teams that have a distinct problem with kick-return coverage.

The Bad: Injuries

3 of 7

    PHILADELPHIA - NOVEMBER 21:  Ellis Hobbs #31 of the Philadelphia Eagles is taken off the field on a stretcher after getting injured on a kickoff returns against the New York Giants at Lincoln Financial Field on November 21, 2010 in Philadelphia, Pennsylva
    Nick Laham/Getty Images

    Remember the case of Ellis Hobbs last season? Brutal.

    The Philadelphia Eagles kick-return man now has a disc injury to nurse over the course of the offseason, while his health and career hangs in the balance as time quickly progresses.

    Welcome to the problem.

    Gifting kickers with an extra five yards is great, but it doesn't do much for eager returners who are looking to "milk" yards the best they can. 

    Is that not enough to convince you?

    The other factor is simple—returners who are looking to force their way out of their own end zone will also be met with a pile of defenders, who happen to have a five-yard head start from the referee's whistle.

    Roger Goodell's helmet-to-helmet rule will help contain these injuries, but the can of worms can't be kept shut entirely. A five-yard jump for defenders more or less means many hard knocks and a ton of fumbled possessions.

All Scoring Plays Will Now Be Reviewed by Replay Officials

4 of 7

    DENVER - NOVEMBER 14:  Head coach Todd Haley of the Kansas City Chiefs questions a video replay call with referee Mike Carey on a touchdown by Brandon Lloyd of the Denver Broncos at INVESCO Field at Mile High on November 14, 2010 in Denver, Colorado. The
    Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

    Moving the kickoffss were not the only idea placed on the drawing board on Tuesday.

    The owners also voted in favor of a new replay system—one that should make many Detroit Lions fans happy in the future.

    After a 30-2 vote in favor of the new system, all scoring plays will now be reviewed by the replay official—at least until the correct decision can be made.

    Clear-cut touchdowns will obviously remain the same. However, plays such as Calvin Johnson's disallowed touchdown catch early last season will be sent to the tape.

    Again, there is legitimate concern for this recent rule change. But the positives far outweigh the negatives in this instance.

The Good: Coaches No Longer Have to Waste Challenges

5 of 7

    CHICAGO, IL - DECEMBER 12: Head coach Lovie Smith of the Chicago Bears throws his red flag to challenge an official's call against the New England Patriots at Soldier Field on December 12, 2010 in Chicago, Illinois.  The Patriots beat the Bears 36-7.  (Ph
    Dilip Vishwanat/Getty Images

    Ask any head coach: "What grinds your gears?"

    They'll automatically tell you about wasted challenge calls.

    It's infuriating for the team and it has become a huge problem for the NFL, with many blown calls on the field.

    Not any more.

    Coaches will no longer have to reach into their pockets and seek out ole' red.

    Instead, referees will be left with the reviewing decision—one that automatically introduces a whole new set of problems.

    Perhaps it's a discussion for another day, but coaches will still be awarded a third challenge if they win their first two.

    Blown calls, therefore, will decrease, but don't expect every coach to now be calm and collected on the sideline.

The Bad: The Game Slows Down

6 of 7

    DENVER - SEPTEMBER 26:  Quarterback Peyton Manning #18 of the Indianapolis Colts and linebacker Mario Haggan #57 of the Denver Broncos talk during a video replay ruling at INVESCO Field at Mile High on September 26, 2010 in Denver, Colorado. The Colts def
    Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

    Coaches may be pleased to know that the challenge flags are safe, but the game itself becomes vulnerable with this new rule change.

    Is the NFL slow enough already? Yes. Do replay calls tend to drag on? Of course.

    Yet, with this rule change, the normal three-hour span may be stretched out even further.

    Having said that, fans will still watch on a weekly basis, especially if referees can guarantee the correct call will be made.

    Still, expect to see a few bored players on the field and a handful of unnecessary commercial breaks.

Other Negotiations

7 of 7

    JACKSONVILLE, FL - NOVEMBER 21:  David Garrard #9  of the Jacksonville Jaguars is chased down by Marcus Bernard #58 during a game agaisnt the Cleveland Browns at EverBank Field on November 21, 2010 in Jacksonville, Florida.  (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty I
    Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

    Roger Goodell also touched on the following issues during Tuesday's owners meeting.

    No Replacement Players

    The league seems to have learned from the past, as Goodell stressed to fans that players will not be replaced during the lockout.

    "We have not had any discussions or consideration given to replacement players," Goodell told the New York Daily News. "That hasn't been discussed, it hasn't been considered and it's not in our plans."

    In 1987, owners found a solution to the labor strike by implementing replacement players to keep fans moderately happy.

    The football was far from pleasing, but in the end, the league came to terms and big-name players such as Joe Montana returned, allowing the NFL to pick up where it left off.

    Apparently, though, Goodell wants none of this.

    Teams Have Been Fined

    Five undisclosed teams have been fined for breaking a crucial offseason rule. The sum of money is also unknown.

    All the same, the NFL has slapped five total franchises on the wrist for breaking the player workout policy.

    There's no question that teams have become uneasy during the lockout, taking to the practice field early to condition their players.

    Unfortunately, March 15 is the NFL's workout commencement date—a time several teams disregarded.


The latest in the sports world, emailed daily.