Week 5 Start 'Em, Sit 'Em: Play or Bench Tips for Fantasy Football Owners

Chris Roling@@Chris_RolingFeatured ColumnistOctober 8, 2015

Justin Forsett of the Baltimore Ravens is a top play in Week 5.
Justin Forsett of the Baltimore Ravens is a top play in Week 5.Nick Wass/Associated Press

Fantasy football owners have some tough calls when it comes to Week 5 start 'em, sit 'em decisions, like whether Andrew Luck should suit up on Thursday Night Football against the Houston Texans.

The riddle that the Indianapolis coaching staff faces, as tough as it is, gets dwarfed in comparison to what owners face. It sounds silly, but on a scale, making the decisions on players from 32 teams weighs quite a lot more.

With injury reports, news and matchup analysis still rolling out ahead of Thursday's action, let's take another look at some value verdicts between top names and break down some of the tougher start-sit decisions.


Tom Brady (at DAL) vs. Andy Dalton (vs. SEA)Tom Brady
Aaron Rodgers (vs. STL) vs. Tyrod Taylor (at TEN)Aaron Rodgers
Matt Ryan (vs. WAS) vs. Russell Wilson (at CIN)Matt Ryan
Peyton Manning (at OAK) vs. Philip Rivers (vs. PIT)Peyton Manning
Carson Palmer (at DET) vs. Derek Carr (vs. DEN)Carson Palmer
Author's opinion.

Start: Carson Palmer, Arizona Cardinals (at DET)

Video Play Button
Videos you might like

Carson Palmer remains one of fantasy's most consistent quarterbacks.
Carson Palmer remains one of fantasy's most consistent quarterbacks.Rick Scuteri/Associated Press

Fantasy's fourth-highest scorer at quarterback deserves love against the Detroit Lions. 

There's sure to be some pause from owners considering the Arizona Cardinals are on the road this week and Palmer makes the trip coming off his worst fantasy performance of the season.

Still, he's scored 25, 21, 18 and 16 points, respectively, with 10 touchdowns. The Lions aren't exactly world-beaters against quarterbacks, either, having allowed six touchdowns and an average of 18 points per game to the position.

This seems like more of a defensive matchup, but Palmer's elite form will see him score among the top 10.

Sit: Derek Carr, Oakland Raiders (vs. DEN)

Oakland Raiders quarterback Derek Carr deserves to tout a higher ownership rate than his 47.6 percent thanks to 20- and 26-point outings after returning from a Week 1 injury. 

Regardless, he's a sit this week against the Denver Broncos. Carr lost an interception and a fumble to finish with 11 points against the iffy Chicago Bears last week. It's an anomaly, but this matchup reeks.

The Broncos rank first among defenses against quarterbacks on average this year. The unit has allowed just two touchdowns and one team to sneak into double digits, with impressive performances against Joe Flacco, Alex Smith and Matthew Stafford.

Carr will have incredible days this year based on matchups. Just not this week.


Jamaal Charles (vs. CHI) vs. Devonta Freeman (vs. WAS)Jamaal Charles
Joseph Randle (vs. NE) vs. Latavius Murray (vs. DEN)Latavius Murray
Dion Lewis (at DAL) vs. Matt Forte (at KC)Matt Forte
Le'Veon Bell (at SD) vs. Jeremy Hill (vs. SD)Le'Veon Bell
Mark Ingram (at PHI) vs. Karlos Williams (at TEN)Mark Ingram
Author's opinion.

Start: Justin Forsett, Baltimore Ravens (vs. CLE)

Baltimore Ravens back Justin Forsett stumbled out of the gates and looked like one of fantasy's bigger disappointments early this season. Last week in Pittsburgh, though, he posted his first double-digit outing with 27 carries for 150 yards and 15 points, his first time over the 15-attempt mark on the year.

Don't expect it to stop now. Forsett gets the Cleveland Browns next, owners of a defense that has allowed 16 or more points to backs in three of four contests, including allowances of 27 and 28 points.

At home, Baltimore won't want to air it out with Flacco often, especially if the ground game works well. It should, with Forsett finally appearing back to 2014 form.

Sit: Joseph Randle, Dallas Cowboys (vs. NE)

Joseph Randle faces a dire situation in Dallas this weekend.
Joseph Randle faces a dire situation in Dallas this weekend.Brynn Anderson/Associated Press

It's never easy to sit a guy like Joseph Randle, whom owners probably took pretty high in drafts based on the situation.

Randle has one big performance on the season, the 27-point outburst in Week 3 after three touchdowns on 14 attempts. The problem was how fluky it looked, as all the scores came in the first half.

In fact, that head coach Jason Garrett even has to field questions about Randle's status says it all, per Clarence Hill of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram:

It's clear there are questions about the usage in Dallas, nothing but a terrible sign for Randle as he heads into an encounter with the New England Patriots. The defense has allowed an average of just 13.7 points to backs over three games, so Randle needs to sit on the bench this week.


Julio Jones (vs. WAS) vs. DeAndre Hopkins (vs. IND)Julio Jones
Larry Fitzgerald (at DET) vs. Julian Edelman (at DAL)Larry Fitzgerald
Antonio Brown (at SD) vs. Randall Cobb (vs. STL)Randall Cobb
A.J. Green (vs. SEA) vs. Keenan Allen (vs. PIT)Keenan Allen
Odell Beckham Jr. (vs. SF) vs. Demaryius Thomas (at OAK)Odell Beckham Jr.
Author's opinion.

Start: Rueben Randle, New York Giants (vs. SF)

Rueben Randle remains a top target in New York.
Rueben Randle remains a top target in New York.Kathy Willens/Associated Press

There is another Randle worth a start, though. 

This would be Rueben Randle of the New York Giants, who has nine points or more in each of his last two outings along with a touchdown in each contest.

Randle sees more action as the season wears on because defenses get so absorbed in stopping Odell Beckham Jr. With Victor Cruz still not practicing, it looks like he has a clear-cut path to acting as the No. 2 wideout again.

The situation peaks just when Randle gets his easiest matchup, too. The San Francisco 49ers are a mess, but especially when it comes to defending wideouts—they have allowed 32- and 46-point outings to the position this year, so Randle should make noise as the No. 2.

Sit: Golden Tate, Detroit Lions (vs. ARI)

With the offense struggling, Golden Tate has become a nonfactor.
With the offense struggling, Golden Tate has become a nonfactor.Scott Eklund/Associated Press/Associated Press

It seems fantasy owners continue to hold out hope on Lions wideout Golden Tate, he of an 87.9 ownership percentage. 

It's time to look elsewhere.

Tate has a pair of two-point performances this year, with a high of eight in Week 2. Stafford has not only been banged up, but he's playing behind one of the league's most porous lines and the attention goes to Calvin Johnson first and foremost.

The situation has left Tate out to dry, and it will again in a matchup with the Cardinals, who have allowed just two sets of wideout corps to score more than 20 points this season, an impressive number considering most teams have to throw against the unit in an effort to keep up with Palmer and Co.

Tate won't see significant production against the battle-tested unit.


Rob Gronkowski (at DAL) vs. Travis Kelce (vs. CHI)Rob Gronkowski
Tyler Eifert (vs. SEA) vs. Jason Witten (vs. NE)Jason Witten
Gary Barnidge (at BAL) vs. Jimmy Graham (at CIN)Jimmy Graham
Charles Clay (at TEN) vs. Eric Ebron (vs. ARI)Charles Clay
Delanie Walker (vs. BUF) vs. Martellus Bennett (at KC)Delanie Walker
Author's opinion.

Start: Antonio Gates, San Diego Chargers (vs. PIT)

Antonio Gates returns from suspension in Week 5.
Antonio Gates returns from suspension in Week 5.Ben Margot/Associated Press

Owners have been waiting for this moment: San Diego Chargers tight end Antonio Gates returns from suspension this week and features an 85 ownership percentage.

Gates shouldn't have any issues making an impact right out of the, well, gates. His first opponent of the season is the Pittsburgh Steelers. The defense has allowed a high of eight points to tight ends in the three weeks after New England managed 33 in Week 1.

Gates isn't Rob Gronkowski, but he might be one of the closest things to him. He's fresh, with plenty of film on how to exploit the Steelers under his belt, so look for him to post a major day.

Sit: Jared Cook, St. Louis Rams (at GB)

Jared Cook continues to lose targets with the emergence of Tavon Austin.
Jared Cook continues to lose targets with the emergence of Tavon Austin.Alex Brandon/Associated Press

It was right to expect big things from St. Louis Rams tight end Jared Cook this season.

He's one of the league's most physically gifted tight ends and got a new quarterback this year, but it just hasn't turned into production, as he's tallied 14 total points in four games.

Don't expect a turnaround this week against the Green Bay Packers, regardless of whether the Rams will pass a lot while playing from behind. The Packers have allowed just two sets of tight ends to reach double digits this year, and Cook isn't Martellus Bennett or Travis Kelce.

To make matters worse, Tavon Austin continues to emerge for the offense, placing Cook even further down the target totem pole.

All scoring info courtesy of ESPN standard leagues, as is points-against info and ownership stats as of October 8. Statistics courtesy of ESPN. Miami, Minnesota, Carolina, New York Jets on bye.

Follow Chris_Roling on Twitter