Biggest Overreactions from 1st Week of 2026 NFL Free Agency

The first week of the NFL's new league year is officially in the books and it's been a doozy. From retracted trades to blockbuster contract extensions to marquee free-agent signings, there's been a slew of headline-grabbing news since the legal tampering period began on March 9.

While the dust hasn't come close to settling from these splashy transactions, there's been no shortage of hot takes surrounding them. Whether the sky is falling for one club after a key free agent departure or another has been anointed Super Bowl LXI champs for a shrewd signing, there are overreactions to be found related to every big news blast.

Some of these drastic takes may be warranted, but it's far too early to determine how most of these moves will pan out. With that in mind, let's highlight some of the biggest overreactions from the first week of 2026 NFL free agency.

J.J. McCarthy is Officially Cooked After Kyler Murray Signing

AP Photo

The Minnesota Vikings capitalized on a rare opportunity to land a potentially elite starting quarterback on the open market, pouncing on the availability of Kyler Murray following his surprise release from the Arizona Cardinals.

With Murray agreeing to a budget one-year, $1.3 million deal in Minnesota, some foresee the end of J.J. McCarthy's tenure as an NFL starter.

It's not a shock that the Vikings brought in a competent quarterback to challenge McCarthy this offseason. One of the team's biggest missteps last year was allowing both Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones to walk in free agency while failing to add any proven signal-callers who could provide depth or even push McCarthy for his starting role.

That proved to be an issue with McCarthy's well-publicized struggles and injury woes. The second-year passer out of Michigan only completed 57.6 percent of his throws for 1,632 yards and had more interceptions (12) than touchdowns (11) in the 10 games he was available for.

Although head coach Kevin O'Connell reportedly told Murray that he could envision the QB as a "potential longer-range answer", the Vikings aren't going to simply hand the job to the seven-year veteran.

Minnesota invested the No. 10 overall pick into McCarthy just two years ago and shouldn't be ready to give up on the 23-year-old just yet. He's flashed special talent—including during an epic fourth-quarter comeback in the 2025 opener—at times and should get every opportunity to rehabilitate his flailing career.

According to the Athletic's Dianna Russinni, O'Connell has consistently maintained that McCarthy would have to compete for the QB1 role this offseason, not get outright replaced for his lackluster sophomore efforts. Having a real competition for the first time in his career could do wonders for McCarthy, who missed his entire rookie campaign with an injury suffered in his first preseason contest.

It's also worth noting that Murray hasn't been great in recent years either. He's suffered with injuries and poor play of his own, culminating in what appeared to be a "soft benching" following a foot issue early in the 2025 campaign.

If Murray doesn't return to the Pro Bowl form his displayed during his early seasons in the NFL and McCarthy shows improvements with another offseason under his belt, there's no reason to believe the latter wouldn't open the 2026 campaign as Minnesota's starter.

Jaelan Phillips Is Worth the Cost For Carolina Panthers

AP Photo

Just over a year after it appeared he might be on his way out of the league following a pair of significantly injury-shortened seasons, Jaelan Phillips capitalized on a bounce-back campaign by signing an eye-popping four-year, $120 million contract with the Carolina Panthers.

It's a hefty amount for a player who tallied just five sacks in 2025, especially one who only appeared in 13 of a possible 34 games between the 2023-24 seasons. The demand for capable edge rushers vastly outpaced the supply this offseason, a shortage that led Carolina to back up the Brinks truck to get one of the few proven players at the position.

While Phillips has the potential to be a disruptive, game-breaking force on the edge, the 2021 first-round pick has been unable to consistently produce since his early years in the NFL.

Phillips opened his career by playing in all 34 games across his first two seasons—tallying 15.5 sacks in that span—but missed more than half of 2023 with an Achilles tear. He suffered a knee injury four games into the following season and missed the remainder of it.

Although he produced at a respectable level for both the Miami Dolphins and Philadelphia Eagles last year, the Panthers are gambling on the 26-year-old not only staying healthy, but also raising his game to a level he's yet to reach.

Phillips banked more cash on his deal than fellow edge rusher Trey Hendrickson, an All-Pro as recently as the 2024 season, while having less sacks in his career (28.5) than Hendrickson amassed during a recent two-season stretch between 2023-24 (35).

Even though Phillips is a half-decade younger and has more upside at this stage of their respective careers, it's not easy to become a player of Hendrickson's caliber. Phillips was good at creating pressure—he tied Myles Garrett with 50 last season—last year, but struggled to turn those opportunities into sacks, converting only 10 percent in 2025.

The odds don't seem good of Phillips realizing that potential on a less-talented Carolina squad. Whether it's injuries or a lack of support that ultimately cause the shortcoming, it's hard to picture him living up to his monster contract.

Seattle Seahawks Overpaid Rashid Shaheed

AP Photo

The Seattle Seahawks are suffering the same fate as many of their fellow Super Bowl champions. Many of their free agents skyrocketed up the offseason wish lists of other organizations, causing Seattle to pay a premium to retain them or make the tough decision to let them walk.

One player the Seahawks didn't let get away was Rashid Shaheed, the breakout wide receiver/return man who added an electrifying element to Seattle's special teams game after he arrived at last year's trade deadline.

Seattle had to pay a hefty cost to retain Shaheed, agreeing to a $51 million contract that will keep him in the Pacific Northwest through the 2028 campaign.

While there's been gripes that the Seahawks drastically overpaid for a special teamer, there's a great chance that Shaheed winds up providing fantastic return on investment.

Shaheed's most obvious impact last year was in the return game and it should remain as such going forward. He scored three touchdowns in the 12 games he suited up for the Seahawks in last year (including the playoffs), with each of those plays having had a massive impact on the momentum of the contests they occurred in.

With the NFL putting more emphasis on returns with a series of rule changes in recent years, teams with a dynamic weapons like Shaheed are gaining an edge over opponents lacking that type of playmaking. Shaheed is also blazing a trail that others will inevitably follow in a copycat league, helping increase the value of return men on the open market.

Outside of special teams, Shaheed figures to play a larger role in the passing game in 2026. His middling 266 receiving yards on 18 catches didn't move the needle last year, but he should be in the mix more as he gains comfort and understanding in Seattle's system with a full offseason to prepare. It's not unreasonable to expect him to cut into Cooper Kupp's workload as the veteran wideout continues to age and regress.

Even if Shaheed only chips in 500 receiving yards and a couple touchdowns on offense each season, he'll still be worth every penny if he continues to tilt the field in Seattle's favor with his unique special teams contributions.

Tua Tagovailoa Will Replace Michael Penix Jr. As Atlanta Falcons Starter

AP Photo

As they've done several times since the departure of franchise legend Matt Ryan after the 2021 campaign, the Atlanta Falcons once again shuffled the quarterback deck this offseason.

Although the team released Kirk Cousins after a largely underwhelming two-year tenure, it quickly added Tua Tagovailoa to a quarterbacks room that also includes incumbent starter Michael Penix Jr.

To many, the arrival of Tagovailoa spells the end of Penix's brief stint as Atlanta's QB1. This isn't likely to be the case, however, as the Falcons are still heavily invested in Penix's success and needed an insurance option with the two-year veteran coming off a concerning ACL tear that cut his 2025 season short.

While Penix's second NFL season didn't go as planned, the rumblings of his potential demise as a starter are being greatly exaggerated.

The Falcons, at least publicly, appear to have faith in the player they took No. 8 overall in 2024. Ryan, now working as the franchise's President of Football, said last month that the main priority is getting Penix healthy. Ryan also said, "we feel like we're on track and in a good space with Michael right now."

Despite a 4-8 record as a starter and a 59.6 percent career completion rate, he's tallied double the number of touchdown throws (12) as interceptions (6)—even leading the league with a 1.1 percent interception rate in 2025—and has only taken 17 sacks.

There's plenty of areas where Penix can improve, but there's little evidence that Tagovailoa would blow him out of the water in an open competition—or even remain healthy enough to put a stranglehold on a QB1 role.

Tagovailoa's game has fallen off significantly in recent seasons, a regression that ultimately led to his benching late in the 2025 season. He's posted a losing record across the last two seasons and is tied for the third-most interceptions since the start of 2023.

Given he's only played a full season once in his six-year NFL career, it wouldn't be wise for Atlanta to count on Tua to lead this squad back to the playoffs. Penix offers far more upside at this stage of the two quarterbacks' respective careers and has a real shot to reclaim his starting role once he's back in form.

Kenneth Walker III Will Carry Kansas City Chiefs' Offense

AP Photo

After being hamstrung by one of the NFL's most impotent rushing attacks in 2025, the Kansas City Chief made a drastic change this offseason by inking Kenneth Walker III to a blockbuster three-year, $43 million contract.

There are now massive expectations for Walker as he prepares to take over the backfield from the ineffective combo of Isiah Pacheco and Kareem Hunt.

Compounding that lofty outlook is the status of Patrick Mahomes after he suffered a Week 15 ACL tear. While Mahomes is reportedly progressing well in his recovery and targeting a return in time for the regular season opener, it remains to be seen if the superstar signal-caller will be able to reach that goal.

If Mahomes is unavailable or limited, Walker will take on even more pressure to produce while the two-time NFL MVP works his way back.

Walker's projections are further boosted by the lack of competition in Kansas City's backfield. After splitting time with Zach Charbonnet for the bulk of his tenure with the Seattle Seahawks—a timeshare that reportedly irked the starter—Walker is now a clear lead back with only Brashard Smith and Emari Demercado to push him for touches.

While this situation could lead to heavy usage and ample opportunity for Walker to win the league's rushing crown, it could also backfire for the Chiefs.

Walker may have had an impressive stretch that led to a Super Bowl MVP award, but he hasn't been that type of player consistently during his four-year career. After breaking out as a rookie with a 1,050-yard rushing season, Walker regressed in each of the next two seasons, culminating with a concerning 3.7 yards per carry average during the 2024 campaign.

Injuries were an issue during that stretch as well. While Walker did manage to appear in all 20 games (including the playoffs) for Seattle last year, he missed multiple games in each of his first three seasons.

Other issues such as notoriously poor pass protection efforts and middling advanced stats could come back to haunt Walker as he tries to establish himself as one of the modern era's rare high-volume backs.

There's certainly upside for Walker to take his game to new heights in Kansas City, but there's also enough red flags surrounding this signing that the contract could eventually become an albatross for the Chiefs.