Fantasy Football: Mock Draft Results When Holding the 4th Pick in 12-Team League

Jay Clemons@ATL_JayClemonsFantasy Sports Lead WriterJune 26, 2012

Eagles tailback LeSean McCoy, a consensus top-5 selection for fantasy drafts, rolled for 1,624 total yards and 20 touchdowns last season.
Eagles tailback LeSean McCoy, a consensus top-5 selection for fantasy drafts, rolled for 1,624 total yards and 20 touchdowns last season.Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

On Tuesday, I participated in my second live mock draft of the summer ( teams/standard-scoring rules)—drawing the No. 4 slot.

For most standard-scoring leagues, I adhere to the time-tested principle of four running backs, two receivers and either a high-end quarterback or top-notch tight end in the first seven rounds. But at No. 4, it's sometimes wiser to skip the games of pre-draft chicken and take the best player each time.

Here's my squad and first alternate with each pick. To see the first 48 selections, click here:

Round 1, Pick 4 overall: RB LeSean McCoy, Eagles
Backup Plan: RB Maurice Jones-Drew, Jaguars

Round 2, Pick 21 overall: QB Cam Newton, Panthers
Backup Plan: RB Jamaal Charles, Chiefs

Round 3, Pick 28 overall: RB Fred Jackson, Bills
Backup Plan: WR Mike Wallace, Steelers

Round 4, Pick 45 overall: RB Roy Helu, Redskins
Backup Plan: WR Miles Austin, Cowboys

Round 5, Pick 52 overall: WR Miles Austin, Cowboys
Backup Plan: WR Dwayne Bowe, Chiefs

Round 6, Pick 69 overall: WR Malcom Floyd, Chargers
Backup Plan: RB Jahvid Best, Lions

Round 7, Pick 76 overall: WR Pierre Garcon, Redskins
Backup Plan: TE Jermichael Finley, Packers

Round 8, Pick 93 overall: RB Toby Gerhart, Vikings
Backup Plan: WR Titus Young, Lions

Round 9, Pick 100 overall: WR Darrius Heyward-Bey, Raiders
Backup Plan: RB Daniel Thomas, Dolphins

Round 10, Pick 117 overall: WR Laurent Robinson, Jaguars
2nd option: WR Nate Washington, Titans

Round 11, Pick 124 overall: TE Dustin Keller, Jets
Backup Plan: TE Brent Celek, Eagles

Round 12, Pick 141 overall: QB Ryan Fitzpatrick, Bills
Backup Plan: QB Andrew Luck, Colts

Round 13, Pick 148 overall: RB Evan Royster, Redskins
Backup Plan: RB Rashard Mendenhall, Steelers

Round 14, Pick 165 overall: D/ST Green Bay Packers
Backup Plan: D/ST Pittsburgh Steelers

Round 15, Pick 172 overall: TE Coby Fleener, Colts
Backup Plan: TE Ed Dickson, Ravens

Round 16, Pick 189 overall: PK Mike Nugent, Bengals
Backup Plan: PK Shaun Suisham, Steelers


  • LeSean McCoy (my No. 1 overall player) fell into my lap at the 4-spot. McCoy is not likely to replicate his 20 total touchdowns (17 rushing) from last year, but he is a great candidate to eclipse 1,624 total yards—which included 11 games of 100-plus total yards. In fact, I'll be shocked if McCoy comes in under the 1,750-yard threshold, a testament to his expanding role in the Eagles offense.
  • There were springtime suggestions that Philly coach Andy Reid wanted to restrict McCoy's touches, a supposed random act of kindness even though Foster (331 touches), Rice (367) and Maurice Jones-Drew (386) crushed McCoy (321) in that category last season. For 2012, I'll buy McCoy for 313 touches...and hopefully 1,600 total yards.

  • None of the top-five quarterbacks (Aaron Rodgers, Drew Brees, Tom Brady, Matthew Stafford, Cam Newton) should slide past the first 25 picks. As a result, it made sense to abandon plans of taking Jamaal Charles, Fred Jackson, Michael Turner, Trent Richardson and siding with Newton—even if he's hardly a lock to repeat his 4,700-plus total yards and 35 TDs from last season.
  • Fred Jackson averaged 137.6 total yards per game last season; and yet, he's being largely ignored by a sizable chunk of fantasy owners who believe he's either on his last legs...or that C.J. Spiller will become the Bills' next 1,200-yard rusher. The first notion is a baseless concern, and the second one would have merit if Jackson were to sustain another serious injury. In the meantime, though, Jackson is a healthy lock for 1,600 total yards and seven TDs over a 16-game season.
  • For a second straight mock, I was burned by the specter of waiting too long for Detroit's Jahvid Best, my No. 22 tailback. Last week, I had budgeted for getting Best sometime in the low-90s; for Tuesday's mock, he had been scooped up at No. 75—the highest of any mock simulation or Average Draft Position ranking this offseason.
  • My five receivers—Miles Austin, Malcom Floyd, Pierre Garcon, Darrius Heyward-Bey, Laurent Robinson—are all viable candidates for 80 catches and/or seven touchdowns. Floyd ascends to the role of San Diego's WR1 (replacing Vincent Jackson), while catching passes from a QB (Philip Rivers) who's a lock for 4,500 yards passing and 26 touchdowns. Regarding Heyward-Bey (64 catches, 975 yards, 4 TDs in 2011), he amassed 60 targets (and three TDs) in his final six games last year.
  • What's my motivation for drafting tight ends Rob Gronkowski or Jimmy Graham high in Round 2 if I can consistently land Brandon Pettigrew or Dustin Keller somewhere in the 120s? Keller (65 catches, 815 yards, 5 TDs last year) is one of the few premium tight ends to incur double-digit bumps in receptions the last two seasons.
  • Buffalo's Ryan Fitzpatrick deserves some props for attaining career marks in yards passing (3,832) and TDs (24) last season. But here's the killjoy fact of the day: Fitz tallied zero or one TD in eight of the 16 starts...meaning he single-handedly contributed to at least four or five fantasy losses in 2011. That aside, I'll gladly accept the backup-QB value of the 141st pick.

Jay Clemons can be reached on Twitter, day or night, at @ATL_JayClemons.


    Browns Stay in Playoff Hunt with Win

    NFL logo

    Browns Stay in Playoff Hunt with Win

    Kyle Newport
    via Bleacher Report

    Baker Finds Callaway for the Lead 🎥

    NFL logo

    Baker Finds Callaway for the Lead 🎥

    via Twitter

    Limited Edition B/R Bomber Is Here — Grab Yours 🛒

    NFL logo

    Limited Edition B/R Bomber Is Here — Grab Yours 🛒

    B/R SHOP
    via B/R SHOP

    Is Hopkins the Most Underrated NFL Star?

    NFL logo

    Is Hopkins the Most Underrated NFL Star?

    Brad Gagnon
    via Bleacher Report