B/R NFL 1,000: Ranking the Top 35 3-4 Outside Linebackers from 2014
Who is the best player in theย NFL? Not based on the last 10 years or one game, but over the last year: Who was the best? Good luck answering that one without starting a fight, right? ย ย
Well, that's what the NFL 1000 aims to do by scouting, grading and then ranking the best players at each position before putting them in order and breaking ties to come up with the top 1,000 players. No narratives, no fantasy football points, no quarterback rating: This is cold, hard scouting.
You can find rankings for all other positions on ourย B/R NFL 1000 main page.
The B/R 1000 metric is based heavily on scouting each player and grading the key criteria for each position. The criteria are weighed according to importance for a possible best score of 100.
Potential is not taken into consideration, nor are career accomplishments.
Outside linebackers have many responsibilities, but in a 3-4 defense we're looking largely at pass rushers. With that in mind, linebackers are judged on pass rush (30 points), run defense (20), coverage (10) and tackling (35), plus five points for their value as starters or backups. In that category, we're looking at whether the player is a consistent starter, a spot starter, a top-level backup or simply a backup-only player.
In the case of ties, our team asked, "Which player would I rather have on my team?" and set the rankings accordingly.
Subjective? Yes. But ties are no fun.
Each player was scouted by me and a team of experienced evaluators (Dan Bazal, Cian Fahey, Dan Hope, Marshal Miller, Justis Mosqueda) with these key criteria in mind. The following scouting reports and grades are the work of months of film study from our team.
All statistics fromย Pro Football Focus. Players' heights, weights and seasons played fromย NFL.com.
35. Nick Perry, Green Bay Packers
1 of 35
Pass Rush
After completing his third season in the NFL, Nick Perry (6โ3โ, 265 lbs, fourth season) has yet to live up to the expectations of a first-round pick.ย He has the size and speed to be an effective edge-rusher, but he hasnโt shown that he can consistently get to the quarterback. While Perry finished this past season with only three regular-season sacks, he showed a glimpse of his potential in the playoff game against the Dallas Cowboys, recording 1.5 sacks on Tony Romo.
Coverage
Perry lacks the agility and awareness to compete against quality tight ends when asked to drop back in coverage. He isnโt able to stick his foot in the ground and break on the ball, and too often, he falls for head fakes, allowing the offensive player to get separation.
Run Defense
He's solid but not exceptional against the run. Unlike a lot of 3-4 outside linebackers, Perry isnโt a liability against the run, and he can hold his own against most offensive rushing attacks.
Tackling
Perry doesnโt tackle with great leverage, and he allows too many runners to escape his grasp. He finished the year (playoffs included) with only 21 tackles and six misses.
Starter
The Green Bay Packers have been patient with Perry, but at some point, he will need to start being more productive. Nine career sacks for a player of his potential is simply not enough.
Overall
34. Brian Orakpo, Tennessee Titans
2 of 35
Pass Rush
Injuries have plagued Brian Orakpo (6โ4โ, 257 lbs, seventh season) over the past three seasons. When he is healthy, he has the ability to dominate the edge and put a ton of pressure on the quarterback. Orakpo finished 2014 with only a half-sackย in seven games played.
Coverage
Rarely asked to drop back in coverage, Orakpo looked stiff and ineffective against the pass. He is better off rushing the quarterback on every play because he is a real liability when asked to cover an offensive player one-on-one.
Run Defense
Orakpo has the power to set the edge against the run and the quickness to run down the line and tackle running backs from behind. His focus on getting sacks can take him out of running plays at times, though.
Tackling
Usually an excellent tackler, Orakpo struggled at times this past season to bring down ball-carriers. He tries to go for the highlight-reel hit too often. Orakpo finished his shortened season with six missed tackles to go along with only 17 solo tackles.
Starter
When healthy, Orakpo can be one of the most dangerous outside linebackers in the game. The Tennessee Titans are hoping he can stay on the field and return to his elite edge-rusher days from earlier in his career.
Overall
33. Calvin Pace, New York Jets
3 of 35
Pass Rush
After having a career year in 2013, Calvin Pace (6โ4โ, 265 lbs, 13th season) followed it up by having one of his patented mediocre seasons. Pace finished the year with only five sacks. Nearing the end of his career, Pace lacks the speed and quickness to be a constant force on the field.
Coverage
Awareness and experience allow the 34-year-old Pace to be one of the better 3-4 coverage linebackers in the league. He reads and reacts to plays as well as anyone, and shows great timing in disrupting passes thrown his way.
Run Defense
Pace isnโt able to sink his hips and hold his ground in most running situations. He allows offensive linemen to push him around, and he struggles to disengage from blocks. He isnโt able to track runners down in the open field because of his lack of speed and agility.
Tackling
Earlier in his career, Pace was a tackling machine, but those days are far behind him. While he still plays with aggression, he gets a little out of control when aiming at ball-carriers and often comes into his target too high.
Starter
Pace is on the downhill side of his career and might only have one or two more years left in him. He can still be effective in the correct situation, but he is no longer an every-down player.
Overall
.jpg?w=256 "Eagles Sirianni Football")
.jpg?w=256 "Titans Football")
32. Quinton Coples, New York Jets
4 of 35
Pass Rush
Quinton Coples (6โ6โ, 290 lbs, fourth season) finished 2014 with 6.5 sacks, but when you are an outside linebacker in a Rex Ryan defense, that just isnโt good enough. He lacks the ability to react quickly to the snap of the ball, and he hasnโt developed a go-to pass-rush move that allows him to consistently put pressure on the quarterback.
Coverage
Coples only had two passes thrown his direction this past season, and both of them were completions. His size allows him to cover up for some of his mistakes and his slow footwork when dropping into coverage. When you are 6โ6โ, it is hard for an offensive player to create enough separation in a short and quick passing game.
Run Defense
While his height might help him in pass coverage, it hurts him when defending the run. He isnโt able to get low, anchor down and hold his ground. He gets driven back by offensive linemen because he allows them to get into his body.
Tackling
Coples lacks the athletic ability to chase runners down in space, but if they happen to make their way into his tackle radius, he will bring them down. He is more effective against bruising tailbacks than he is against quick and elusive backs.
Starter
It will be interesting to see how Coples fits into the New York Jets' new defensive scheme now that Rex Ryan is coaching in Buffalo.
Overall
31. Bjoern Werner, Indianapolis Colts
5 of 35
Pass Rush
Bjoern Werner (6โ3โ, 257 lbs, third season) hasnโt quite lived up to expectations thus far in his young career after being selected in the first round of the 2013 draft.ย Werner has a lot of the physical tools needed to be an excellent 3-4 outside linebacker, but he will need put it all together to take that next step. Right now, he relies solely on effort and determination, but if he could develop a few counter moves for when his original pass-rush move fails, he could become a double-digit sack artist in this league.
Coverage
As Werner develops, so will his ability to drop back in coverage. At this stage in his career, he lacks the ability to keep his man from catching the ball, but he is usually able to quickly pull him down for yards after the catch. Once he is able to read and diagnose the play faster, he will become a much better coverage linebacker.
Run Defense
One of the strongest areas in Wernerโs game is his ability to shut down the run. When he is engaged with defenders he is able to use his hands well, shed blocks and make plays on the runner. He also does a nice job of keeping linemen away from his body, allowing him to react to the play.
Tackling
Missing just six tackles in over 800 snaps this past season, Werner proved that he can be an efficient and reliable tackler. He is able to drive through ball-carriers and finish plays with some physicality.
Starter
The addition of Trent Cole this offseason should help take pressure off Werner and allow him to become much more effective as a pass-rusher.
Overall
30. Courtney Upshaw, Baltimore Ravens
6 of 35
Pass Rush
Courtney Upshaw (6'2", 272 lbs, fourth season) is a run-stopping outside linebacker with minimal ability to get to the quarterback. In his first three seasons in the NFL, he has only managed to record three sacks, with none of those occurring this past season. He lacks the quick twitch to blow past offensive linemen with a speed rush, and he hasn't quite developed an adequate enough bull rush.
Coverage
Upshaw might be the only linebacker on this list who dropped back into coverage more times than he rushed the quarterback. On 339 pass plays where he was on the field, Upshaw fell into coverage on 186 of them. His ability to use his hands and jam receivers at the line of scrimmage is one of the strengths of his game.
Run Defense
Being 272 pounds and playing on the edge allows Upshaw to easily break through tight ends who dare to line up across from him. Opposing offenses make it a point to attack Upshaw with a bigger offensive lineman or a double-team. He is one of the best at his position when it comes to setting the edge.
Tackling
Upshaw is a gifted tackler with an occasional lapse in concentration. When focused, he attacks ball-carriers and drives his legs to force them to the ground. His aggressive nature gets him in trouble as he tries to go for knockout blows instead of relying on technique and form.
Starter
Upshaw is the perfect fit to play opposite Terrell Suggs. He excels at stopping the run and dropping into coverage, which allows Suggs to put pressure on the quarterback as often as possible.
Overall
29. Trent Murphy, Washington
7 of 35
Pass Rush
Trent Murphy (6'5", 258 lbs, second season) had a respectable, but not outstanding, rookie campaign. Midway through the season, he took over the starting outside linebacker role, and his production took off. Murphy doesn't have elite speed, and he isn't going to consistently bend around the edge to get sacks.
Coverage
As the season went on and Murphy became more confident in Washington's passing scheme, he was allowed to drop back in coverage more often. Early in the year, he appeared lost, but the more he dropped back, the better he got at reading the offense and breaking on the ball.
Run Defense
A valuable run defender, Murphy excelled against the run and was impressive all year long. He showed excellent technique with his hands, knowing when to to shed the block and when to stay engaged to eat up a blocker.
Tackling
Murphy is a physical player who drives through the ball-carrier when making a tackle. But in space and on the move, he can be exposed because of his lack of fluidity in changing direction.
Starter
By the end of his rookie season, everything was starting to click for Murphy. If he is able to build off that this offseason, he should make strides moving forward.
Overall
28. Trent Cole, Indianapolis Colts
8 of 35
Pass Rush
An explosive edge-rusher, Trent Cole (6โ3โ, 270 lbs, 11th season) combines a quick first step with a plethora of pass-rush moves. Cole also relies heavily on his experience and technique to not only sack the quarterback, but also make it difficult for a quarterback to get into a groove by constantly being in the backfield.ย His production has been declining over the past few seasons because of age, but he is still a threat to get to the quarterback on every play.
Coverage
At this stage of his career, Cole is limited in pass coverage and is rarely asked to drop back and match up with opposing tight ends or running backs coming out of the backfield. His mobility takes a sharp decline when he is moving backward instead of forward, not allowing him to stay in the hip pocket of the offensive player.
Run Defense
Since Cole played most of his career as a defensive end, he is a step ahead of most 3-4 outside linebackers when it comes to defending the run.ย He is able to diagnose what play the offense is running and use his hands to shed blocks and break away from offensive linemen. He isnโt able to consistently make plays down the line or catch running backs from behind, but he is solid when a play comes his direction.
Tackling
Cole has never been the most reliable tackler, and he misses on a lot of opportunities. He finished the season allowingย nine ball-carriers to escape his grasp. That's too many for someone who finished the year with only 45 total tackles.
Starter
Cole, who is now with the Indianapolis Colts, will look to revive his career next season. He is still a valuable asset because of his ability to get to the quarterback and should return to totaling double-digit sacks this upcoming season.
Overall
27. Whitney Mercilus, Houston Texans
9 of 35
Pass Rush
An athletic speed rusher, Whitney Mercilus (6'4", 258 lbs, fourth season) has the ability to fly past offensive linemen around the outside. His inability to develop an effective counter move has slowed his development, but he is still young and has the opportunity to flourish in the Houston Texans system.
Coverage
Although Mercilus is an excellent athlete, he isn't fluid when dropping into coverage. He lacks the awareness and instincts to be effective on passing downs when he isn't rushing the quarterback.
Run Defense
Mercilus does a good job of working in space against the run. He is able to handle blockers and use his hands to disengage from blockers. His vision has improved each year he has been in the league, and he is getting better at diagnosing plays.
Tackling
An impact hitter, Mercilus excels at breaking down and tackling in space. He has the size and speed to outmatch most offensive linemen, and once he gets his mitts on a ball-carrier, he will take him to the ground. He only missed three tackles in 822 snaps this past season.
Starter
Mercilus has all the physical tools to be a top-flight outside linebacker. He just has to refine his technique.
Overall
26. Matt Shaughnessy, Arizona Cardinals
10 of 35
Pass Rush
Two years into the experiment that moved Matt Shaughnessy (6โ5โ, 285 lbs, seventh season) from defensive end to outside linebacker, it appears it might not have been the correct move.ย Shaughnessy lacks the top-tier quickness needed to be a successful edge-rusher. He doesnโt have any counter moves and lacks an elite go-to pass-rush move. He doesnโt have the leg drive to generate an effective bull rush, which would open up moves to the inside and outside.
Coverage
Shaughnessy shows good instincts in pass coverage and the ability to move laterally while keeping his eyes on the quarterback. Since he lacks the speed needed to keep up with offensive players on intermediate to deep passes, he is relegated to staying close to the line of scrimmage or sliding out to the flat.
Run Defense
The best part of Shaughnessyโs game is probably his ability to stop the run. He is powerful enough to match up with offensive linemen and has the hand strength to break away from their grip. Shaughnessy can stand up running backs and stop them in their tracks, preventing them from pushing forward for extra yards.
Tackling
A surefire tackler, Shaughnessy has the size and strength to bring down even the most powerful runners in the league. He only missed one tackle during the regular season in 2014.
Starter
Shaughnessy is not your typical 3-4 outside linebacker, as he is more effective at stopping the run than he is at creating pressure on the quarterback. He was at his best early in his career when playing defensive end in a 4-3 scheme.
Overall
25. Sam Acho, Chicago Bears
11 of 35
Pass Rush
Sam Acho (6'3", 257 lbs, fifth season) lacks the explosion off the snap to dominate with a speed rush around the outside. His best pass-rush move is his bull rush, which allows him to get under the offensive tackle's pads and drive him back into the quarterback.
Coverage
A little stiff in the hips, Acho has issues flipping around and trailing tight ends on deep routes and up the seam. He is able to move laterally to get to the flat and has above-average hands for his position.
Run Defense
Acho has really developed into an excellent run-stuffer. His vision and play recognition have improved dramatically over the past few years. He lacks the speed to be great in pursuit along the backside, though.
Tackling
Acho is a striking tackler who hits with a ton of force. Heย has the ideal size and strength to be one of the best tacklers on the edge and uses his powerful frame to drive ball-carriers to the ground.
Starter
Acho signed with the Chicago Bears this offseason, and he should be a main piece of the puzzle in their new defensive system.
Overall
24. Jarret Johnson, Retired
12 of 35
Pass Rush
A limited pass-rusher, Jarret Johnson (6โ3โ, 260 lbs, 12 seasons) produces most of his pressure through aggressive play and determination. He lacks speed off the edge and has to rely on his awareness to be in the right place at the right time. Johnson is a team player and his willingness to take on blockers allows others on his defense to standout.
Coverage
Once again, Johnson relies more on his football IQ than his physical abilities. He is exceptional at reading quarterbacks' eyes and reacting to the play. His lack of speed makes him a liability when asked to turn and run to cover the seam route.
Run Defense
Johnson has made his career out of being a run-stopper. He shows supreme lower-body stability and power. This allows him to maneuver around offensive linemen and make plays on the running back. His physicality makes him one of the best in the league against the run.
Tackling
Although his tackle radius isnโt what it used to be, Johnson will make the play if a ball-carrier gets within his grasp. He isnโt a big hitter, but his technique and ability to wrap guys up are what set him apart.
Starter
The hard-nosed, run-stuffing outside linebacker retired this offseason. He then signed a one-day contract with the Baltimore Ravens to retire as a member of the team that originally drafted him out of Alabama.
Overall
23. Connor Barwin, Philadelphia Eagles
13 of 35
Pass Rush
Connor Barwin (6โ4โ, 264 lbs, seventh season) was a fairly one-dimensional player in 2014. The good news for Eagles fans is that his one dimension was getting pressure on the quarterback. Barwin finished with a career-high 14.5 sacksย and was constantly in the backfield. He has been known throughout his career for his powerful bull rush, but this past season, he added a few speed moves to his repertoire.
Coverage
Barwin was asked to drop back in coverage quite a bit in Chip Kellyโs defense, and most of the time, he was ineffective. He allowed 15 catches to opposing receivers, which was near the top of the league. Barwin also conceded the most yards after catch (154) and the most touchdowns (three).
Run Defense
In 2013, Barwin was one of the best against the run, but in 2014, whether it was a result of the scheme or flat-out poor play, he ranked as one of the worst run defenders at the position. He lacks the speed and agility to track down runners, and he wasnโt nearly as effective at shaking off blockers to make plays on the running back.
Tackling
One of the positional leaders in tackles, Barwinโs form is spot on, and he rarely allows ball-carriers to break away. In over 1,000 snaps this past season,ย Barwin only missed three tackles.
Starter
Barwinโs game changed completely from 2013 to 2014. He was much more dynamic as a pass-rusher but struggled against the run. It will be intriguing to see what Barwinโs game looks like this upcoming season.
Overall
22. Aldon Smith, San Francisco 49ers
14 of 35
Pass Rush
After being suspended for the first nine games of this past season, Aldon Smith (6โ4โ, 265 lbs, fifth season) struggled to find his way when he returned to the 49ers defense. He only recorded two sacks, and both of them came during the Week 12 matchup with the Washington Redskins.ย Smith has all of the physical tools to be the best edge-rusher in the league, but his off-field issues have finally started interfering with his play on the field.
Coverage
One of the more athletic and fluid 3-4 outside linebackers in the NFL, Smith is one of the few players at his position who can drop into coverage and still be effective. But with his elite pass-rushing skill set, it is hard to not have him rush the quarterback on every throwing down.
Run Defense
Smithโs long, lean frame makes it difficult for him to stand his ground and effectively set the edge. But he is able to put some of his pass-rushing skills to work to beat offensive linemen and make a play on the running back.
Tackling
Most people think Smithโs slender build can be a burden, but it actually works to his advantage. His long reach allows him to make tackles that most defenders wouldnโt.
Starter
When he is on the field, Smith is one of the most electrifying pass-rushers in the game. This offseason has been a relatively quiet one from Smith, which means that he should see the field quite a bit next season and return to his All-Pro form.
Overall
21. Jason Worilds, Retired
15 of 35
Pass Rush
Jason Worilds (6โ2, 262 lbs, five seasons) had 7.5 sacks this past season, nearly matching a career high, and his 16 quarterback hits ranked him second among all 3-4 outside linebackers.ย Worilds plays with a good motor and gets the most out of his quarterback pressures from pure determination. He lacks the assortment of pass-rushing moves that most of the elite edge-rushers possess, but he can still cause chaos in the backfield thanks to his persistence.
Coverage
Although Worilds collected his first career interception in Week 9 against the Baltimore Ravens, he routinely gets taken advantage of in the passing game. His thick build makes it difficult for him to quickly change direction and make plays on the ball.
Run Defense
Worilds has the top-flight strength to hold his own against the run. He is able to anchor down and set the edge but lacks the top-notch quickness to chase down running backs from behind.
Tackling
An exceptional tackler, Worilds doesnโt let many runners escape his grasp. He isnโt going to wow anyone with highlight-reel tackles, but he consistently takes ball-carriers to the ground.
Starter
Worilds had arguably his best season as a professional in 2014, but at age 27, he shocked the world this offseason by announcing his retirement.
Overall
20. Brooks Reed, Atlanta Falcons
16 of 35
Pass Rush
After an excellent rookie season in 2011, Brooks Reed (6โ3โ, 254 lbs, fifth season) has failed to live up to expectations ever since. He has only recorded 8.5 sacks over the past three seasons but has shown glimpses of excellence. When you are racing J.J. Watt to the quarterback, it can take away from some of your overall statistics.
Coverage
Reed has superb hands and the awareness to read the quarterback's eyes. He can get lost in space and struggles to keep up with top-tier tight ends. He is most effective releasing to the flat or breaking up a screen pass.
Run Defense
His attacking style allows him to blow up running plays before they start and make stops in the backfield. He has the lower-body strength to hold his ground against most offensive linemen but struggles at times when he is trying to disengage from blocks.
Tackling
An outstanding tackler, Reed is one of the best outside linebackers in the game when it comes to wrapping up the ball-carrier. His skill set is something his new team, the Atlanta Falcons, desperately need. He should compete for the team lead in tackles with middle linebacker Paul Worrilow.
Starter
Reed will be playing a new position next season after signing with the Falcons this offseason. He will be playing the โOttoโ 'backer in Dan Quinnโs system, which will allow him to rush the quarterback and make plays in the backfield.
Overall
19. Barkevious Mingo, Cleveland Browns
17 of 35
Pass Rush
Virtually ineffective as a pass-rusher during his first two seasons in the league, Barkevious Mingo (6โ4โ, 240 lbs, third season) will need to have a breakout season in 2015 to avoid talks of him being a bust. He hasnโt developed as quickly as the Browns would have liked, and because of that, he spends a lot of time getting dropped back into coverage on passing plays.
Coverage
Mingo being dropped into coverage says more about his inability to get pressure on the quarterback than it does about his efficiency as a cover linebacker. He has the speed and quickness to keep up with most offensive players he is asked to cover, but he lacks the overall technique and awareness to be effective on a consistent basis.
Run Defense
Playing defensive line in college helpedย Mingo become an above-average run-stuffer. He is able to get into the pads of offensive linemen and stand them up, as well as cut loose from blocks to make plays on running backs. He sees the field well and is able to quickly diagnose the play, and then he uses his quickness to track down the runner.
Tackling
Mingoย allowed nine would-be-tackles to slip through his hand, and that is too many for someone who only played 681 snaps. He too often goes for a big hit rather than using good form to wrap up the opposing player.
Starter
Mingo still has a high amount of potential, and if the Browns can somehow tap into it, he can become a special player.
Overall
18. Paul Kruger, Cleveland Browns
18 of 35
Pass Rush
After a disappointing first season in Cleveland, Paul Kruger (6โ4โ, 270 lbs, seventh season) showed why the Browns paid top dollar to bring him into town. Kruger finished the year with a career-high 11 sacks, which led the Browns in that category. His ability to bull rush and shed blocks led to most of the quarterback pressures he produced.
Coverage
Since Kruger was one of the few Browns that could generate pressure in the backfield, he was rarely asked to drop back into pass coverage. When he did fall back, he was one of the more effective coverage linebackers for the Browns as well. He proved that he could knock tight ends off their routes and managed to keep up with them on most short to intermediate routes.
Run Defense
Kruger has the upper-body strength to hold his position and set the edge in the running game. His long frame allows him to make plays that most outside linebackers wouldnโt be able to make. He isnโt the most athletically gifted player at his position, which leads to scat backs being able to escape him.
Tackling
Once again, Kruger struggled with consistency as a tackler. He had 13 failed opportunities this past season in 919 snaps. He doesnโt have the lateral quickness to get from sideline to sideline and has to rely on teams running plays at him.
Starter
The Browns breathed a sigh of relief afterย Krugerโs bounce-back season. If he can build on this past season and get some help rushing the passer, the Browns might field a much-improved defense in 2015.
Overall
17. Aaron Lynch, San Francisco 49ers
19 of 35
Pass Rush
Aaron Lynch (6โ5โ, 270 lbs) was an impressive college player dating back to his freshman season at Notre Dame, but a transfer to South Florida and off-field issues pushed him to the fifth round of the 2014 draft. The San Francisco 49ers rolled the dice and got a big payout.ย A natural pass-rusher, Lynch exploded off the ball and rushed the passer with a mean streak and tenacity rarely seen in first-year players. His length, power and burst allowed him to post six sacks and 27 hurries in just 521 snaps.
Coverage
Lynch played defensive end in college and was often lost in coverage during his rookie season. Like Aldon Smith in the 49ers defense, Lynchโs goal is to hit the quarterback, not cover targets. And while heโll do fine putting hands on a tight end at the line of scrimmage, Lynch isnโt comfortable in space.
Run Defense
Playing the run from his most common spot at left outside linebacker means taking on a lot of pulling guards and fullbacks. Lynch held up, but he needs to improve when asked to take on a blocker head-on. He has the size and strength to be a real asset here if he can improve his leverage and work on reading the play faster.
Tackling
With just three missed tackles on the year, Lynch impressed with his range, reach and power. Heโs not afraid to take on a ball-carrier head-up and gives good chase in pursuit.
Starter
Lynch was expected to ride the bench and learn the ropes for a year by our scouting staff, but he impressed in his first season and looks like another mid-round steal for general manager Trent Baalke.
Overall
16. Jabaal Sheard, New England Patriots
20 of 35
Pass Rush
Jabaal Sheard (6โ3โ, 254 lbs, fifth season) does everything well as an outside linebacker, but he doesnโt excel at any of the skills needed to be a dominant pass-rusher.ย He has a quick first step and adequate enough strength to disrupt the backfield. He always seems to be a split second late getting to the quarterback, which shows in his sack numbers, but he can get there fast enough to cause the quarterback to release the ball before the play develops.
Coverage
One of the areas in which Sheard showed improvement over the past year was dropping back into coverage, albeit in a limited role. When passes were completed against him, he was quick to react and bring down the ball-carrier, not allowing them to produce yards after the catch.
Run Defense
Because of his awareness and ability to sniff out rushing plays,ย Sheard is an asset against the run. He lacks the top-end speed to chase down running backs from behind, but his solid, compressed frame allows him to set the edge and force runs back to the inside.
Tackling
Tackling is by far the most improved portion of Sheardโs game. He missed only two tackles in 690 snapsย compared to 10 missed tackles in 663 snaps in 2013. He did a much better job of using his hands, breaking away from offensive linemen and pulling down opposing ball-carriers.
Starter
If Sheard can combine his effectiveness as a pass-rusher from 2013 with the all-around talent he showed this past season, then we should expect great things from him in years to come.
Overall
15. Akeem Ayers, St. Louis Rams
21 of 35
Pass Rush
Scouting Akeem Ayers (6โ3โ, 255 lbs, fifth season) was a tale of two playersโone for the Tennessee Titans and one for the New England Patriots. The grade then comes somewhere in the middle, as Ayers was a star in the Patriots sub-packages but invisible for the Titans.ย Coming off the edge, Ayers has the quickness and agility to counter offensive tackles and get into their space in a hurry. Heโs not an overly powerful rusher, though, and he has to increase his hand use to beat quicker tackles.
Coverage
No matter where he was playing last year, Ayers really didnโt do much in coverage. He was asked to pin his ears back and get the quarterback in New England, and that allowed him to fire off the ball and not worry about coverage responsibilities.
Run Defense
Ayers was a blur in the backfield at times and seemed to make the big play any time one was needed. Heโs capable of spotting the ball and taking the right angle to get in position to make the play, and with his speed, he can beat blockers to their spot. Ayers will struggle when met head-on by a blocker, but he has good awareness on the go.
Tackling
Missed tackles were pretty rare for Ayers in New Englandโhe missed just threeโbut he also had fewer chances to make a play on the ball. His strong hands showed up often as he brought down runners in the backfield and on the edge, but he has to improve his impact at first touch.
Starter
Is Ayers the star we saw in New England for nine games, or the dud we saw in Tennessee for the first two weeks of the year? Weโre betting on him as a starter in St. Louis, but he could be a system-based talent.
Overall
14. Arthur Moats, Pittsburgh Steelers
22 of 35
Pass Rush
When Arthur Moats (6โ2โ, 250 lbs) was picked in the sixth round by the Buffalo Bills back in 2010, itโs fair to say not much was expected of him. Five years later, heโs still in the league, and in 2014, he posted his best season to date. Moats had four sacks, three quarterback hits and 15 hurries in 16 appearances (and nine starts) as the Steelers rotated him in with James Harrison and Jarvis Jones.
Coverage
Moats is a pure pass-rusher, and his experience and expertise are not in coverage. When asked to defend a tight end, heโll hold his own in short drops and zone coverage, but he can get overwhelmed quickly in man coverage. Moats simply lacks experience here, and it shows when he is asked to play in coverage.
Run Defense
When he was on the field, Moats did a good job of standing up on the edge and keeping the run inside. He doesnโt have great size to force the run back to the middle with his bulk, though, so heโs forced to use his athleticism to beat outside blockers to the corner. When that fails, Moats is easily moved at the point of attack.
Tackling
Moats was credited with 20 tackles on the yearโnot a lotโbut what counted more for us was how many tackles he made when presented with the opportunity. In those situations, Moats did well and showed good pop and toughness in taking down backs who often rivaled his size.
Starter
Moats started to move into a more active role in the Steelers defense in 2014, but heโs still not considered an every-down player and starter. That may be coming as James Harrison ages, but for now, Moats is a high-snap backup.
Overall
13. Derrick Morgan, Tennessee Titans
23 of 35
Pass Rush
Derrick Morgan (6โ3โ, 261 lbs, sixth season) was the No. 16 pick in the first round of the 2010 draft and was thought to be an ideal 4-3 defensive end with the athleticism to play outside linebacker.ย In the Tennessee Titansโ scheme, he was asked to rush the passer from both an up and down position, and he produced 6.5 sacks in that position. On top of those sacks, Morgan added pressure that opened the door for teammates to finish the play with a sack.
Coverage
Morgan was only targeted 16 times on the year, and when he was in space against the pass, he showed good instincts and athleticism to find the ball and get his hands in place to deflect it. Morgan knocked down five passes on the season and has the size to redirect tight ends at the line of scrimmage.
Run Defense
Morganโs production as a pass-rusher and cover man are well documented, but against the run, heโll struggle to set the edge consistently. Morganโs size and length are enough for him to be able to stack up blockers and get to the ball, but he shows up weak against the push.
Tackling
On the year, Morgan was credited with 41 solo tackles and impressed with his power at the point of impact. The same stat sheet shows he missed six tackles, something that kept his score down.
Starter
Morgan hasnโt blown up to become a double-digit sack guy, but heโs a consistent presence on the edge and is proving to be a talented three-down player.
Overall
12. Chandler Jones, New England Patriots
24 of 35
Pass Rush
A part-time defensive end and part-time linebacker, Chandler Jones (6โ5โ, 265 lbs, fourth season) gets into the backfield and causes problems for quarterbacks. With excellent length and quickness off the ball, Jones turns blockers and then uses his speed to finish the job. On the year, he posted six sacks, six hits and 19 hurries in just eight starts (10 games) because of injury.
Coverage
Jones is a true pass-rusher, so his experience and ability in coverage are limited compared to his peers. Jones does well to jam and redirect players at the line of scrimmage, but heโs not the type of player you want matching up with a tight end up the seam or sliding out to the slot to cover up a receiver.
Run Defense
Jonesโ ability against the run was hit-or-miss at times, but he came out ahead on the year. In Week 1, the Miami Dolphins pushed him around all game, but Jones learned to use his length when playing outside linebacker to keep blockers off his legs and off his chest. He showed a remarkable ability in pursuit and is a valuable weak-side run defender.
Tackling
With eight missed tackles on the year, Jones did have a higher number of misses than youโd like from a 10-game season, but heโs a capable and reliable tackler in space. The issues came in traffic, where Jones struggled to hold on for a ride and pull down ball-carriers.
Starter
The Patriots love to mix things up on defense, and Jones allows them to be versatile with his skills as a pass-rusher from either a stand-up or hand-down position.
Overall
11. Tamba Hali, Kansas City Chiefs
25 of 35
Pass Rush
The second half of the Kansas City Chiefs' dynamic outside pass rush, Tamba Hali (6โ3โ, 275 lbs, 10th season) picks up where Justin Houston leaves off. While Haliโs sack totals may have been down this past season, it was in part because of the dominant play of Houston. There were many plays where Hali was beaten to the sack by Houston, and he could have finished the year with double-digit sacks.
Coverage
Hali is also one of the more well-rounded 3-4 outside linebackers in the league. He is almost as effective dropping into coverage as he is rushing the quarterback, allowing only one catch this past season.
Run Defense
Hali is excellent at setting the edge and sticking to his assignment. He sacrifices his personal stats to make the correct play and allow his teammates to produce the numbers. He can struggle at times to release from blocks and will allow runners to get past him.
Tackling
Tackling is one of the weaker aspects of Haliโs game. He has moments of inconsistency and struggles when matched up one-on-one with a dynamic runner in space.
Starter
Hali might not be the best player on the Chiefs defense, but he might be the most valuable. Without him, teams would be able to focus more on Houston.
Overall
10. Elvis Dumervil, Baltimore Ravens
26 of 35
Pass Rush
Elvis Dumervilโs second season in Baltimore was a great one. The 5โ11โ, 255-pound edge-rusher dominated with 17 sacks, nine quarterback hits and 28 hurries in just two starts (16 games).ย Given the Ravensโ hybrid scheme, Dumervil was able to pin his ears back and attack the passer from his left outside linebacker position. And with his speed and low center of gravity, itโs rare for a blocker to win against Dumervil.
Coverage
Coverageย isnโt whatย Dumervil does, and it never hasย been in his career. If he's asked to take on a tight end at the line of scrimmage, youโll see a good initial pop, but the muscle-memory isnโt there for Dumervil to turn and run with receivers.
Run Defense
Because of his smaller size, Dumervil is never going to stand up well against pulling guards or fullbacks on play-side runs. Where he does excel is in pursuit on weak-side plays. His ability to quickly get into the backfield is a major boost on rushing downs.
Tackling
Dumervil doesnโt post great tackling numbers because of his role as a situational pass-rusher, but we didnโt hold that against him. Instead weโre looking at the tackles he made (or didnโt make) when presented with a chance. With five missed tackles and 25 stops on the yearย (playoffs included), Dumervil comes in as a slightly above-average tackler.
Starter
Dumervil was as productive as most starters in 2014, but heโs a rotational or sub-package rusher the majority of the time. Thatโs good, too, as it allows him to stay fresh and healthy as he hits the latter part of his career.
Overall
9. Brandon Graham, Philadelphia Eagles
27 of 35
Pass Rush
Brandon Graham has long been a favorite of the NFL 1000 team, even if heโs primarily used as a third-down pass-rusher in the Eaglesโ 3-4 scheme.ย Graham wins with quickness and great leverage, as offensive tackles have a hard time getting under the pads of a 6โ2โ, 265-pound rusher with speed. Grahamโs ability to use his hands to keep blockers off his frame also aids in his production. The Eagles, in our humble opinion, would be wise to increase his role in 2015.
Coverage
Graham is often on the field on third down, but heโs rarely in coverage. When asked to take a running back or fullback out into the flats, he can run with speed and balance, but his awareness in coverage isnโt up to par with the better three-down linebackers we see.
Run Defense
For a smaller edge-defender, Graham does a great job of taking on running backs and setting the edge. Heโs fearless, and his ability to burst off blocks at the snap and square himself to the line of scrimmage is top-tier. Graham isnโt the huge, hulking presence you normally see dominating the run, but heโs among the best producers in a snap-to-snap setting.
Tackling
Given his limited snaps (524), Grahamโs 10 missed tackles in 16 games were an issue for us. Of course, numbers arenโt everything, but his limited reach and tendency to let runners press through his grasp appear to be a weakness in his game.
Starter
Graham isnโt an every-down player in Philadelphia, but he has the ability to be a three-down edge-defender in a 4-3 or 3-4 scheme. With Trent Cole now in Indianapolis, Graham could see reps as a starter in 2015.
Overall
8. Jason Babin, New York Jets
28 of 35
Pass Rush
Jason Babin started just four games for the New York Jets in 2014, but he saw action in all 16 as a third-down pass-rusher.ย He impressed in that role, tallying two sacks, seven quarterback hits and an impressive 27 hurries. Babin didnโt produce the gaudy pass-rushing numbers of other linebackers, but his ability to flush the pocket, disturb the quarterback and generate pressure was consistent when he was on the field.
Coverage
Babinโs experience in Houston, Seattle, Kansas City, Tennessee, Philadelphia and Jacksonville have built up his ability to play in any scheme and take on any role. The Jets asked him to play in coverageโmostly zone dropsโand he held his own and limited catches. Heโll never be great in matchup coverage, and you donโt put him on the field for that, but Babin isnโt a weakness in small coverage roles.
Run Defense
Babin has the size (6โ3โ, 267 lbs) to be a stout run defender on the edge. Whether he has his hand in the dirt as a defensive end or is standing up as an edge linebacker, Babin is able to crash the edge and either stand up blockers or attack the ball-carrier. He was one of the better run-defending outside linebackers scouted this yearโeven taking into consideration his limited use on rushing downs.
Tackling
Babinโs 23 tackles in 2014 may not impress on the surface, but in limited snaps because of the nature of the defense, he produced at a high rate. And when it comes to securing ball-carriers and getting into position to make a play, he was good enough to turn heads. Limiting missed tackles will help increase his score, as will better situational awareness, like on misdirections.
Starter
Babin was more of a situational pass-rusher in 2014, keeping his point total here below perfect. But donโt be surprised to see him in a bigger role in Todd Bowlesโ defense this year.
Overall
7. James Harrison, Pittsburgh Steelers
29 of 35
Pass Rush
Age is just a number to James Harrison, and in 2014, he defied the odds in his return to Pittsburgh after a year in Cincinnati. At 36 years old during the 2014 campaign, Harrison posted 5.5 sacks,ย 13 hits and 15 hurries while playing as a sub-package edge-rusher.ย His quickness, leverage and strength are all still there, and perhaps most importantly, his motor still runs at 100 percent on every play. Harrison is built like a tank, and he uses the natural leverage on his 6โ0โ, 275-pound frame to get under the blockerโs hands and push the pocket.
Coverage
Harrison isnโt a player youโre going to send into coverage often, but he can handle himself against running backs or fullbacks in the flats and has good awareness to jump up and knock down passes while rushing the passer.
Run Defense
Harrisonโs stout build and low center of gravity help him attack the run. When the play comes to his side, Harrison knows how to use his length to keep blockers off his frame, and in pursuit, heโs a dog to deal with. He had 26 solo tackles in limited reps in 2014.
Tackling
Harrison is a top-tier tackler most seasons, but in 2014, he did miss a few opportunities that we hadnโt seen him miss in the past. It may seem way too picky, but Harrisonโs ability to position himself to make the tackle seemed off early in the season.
Starter
Harrison doesnโt get a full five points here because of his status as a rotational pass-rusher, but you canโt ignore his production in limited time in his return to Pittsburgh.
Overall
6. Ryan Kerrigan, Washington
30 of 35
Pass Rush
For the fourth straight season, Ryan Kerrigan played all 16 games. He also recorded his first double-digit sack season, notching 13.5 along with nine quarterback hits and a wild 51 hurries.ย Kerrigan (6โ4โ, 260 lbs) has the first step to beat offensive linemen off their blocks, but he has underrated power to bull rush offensive tackles when heโs met head-up. With his agility and hip flexibility, Kerrigan is able to beat blockers with multiple moves.
Coverage
Kerriganโs first job is rushing the passer, but he does a good job dropping into coverage and knocking down passes at the line of scrimmage. His reps here are limited, but when asked to cover,ย Kerrigan will win more often than not.
Run Defense
Kerrigan, as mentioned above, has excellent size for an athletic edge-defender, and he can get under blockers and win with leverage at the point of attack. We did note his tendency to lose his feet, though, which limited Kerrigan on play-side actionโespecially with a pulling guard finding him.
Tackling
Kerrigan notched 39 solo tackles in 2014 and did a great job hitting consistently, and by missing just four tackles all year, he was among the most reliable tacklers we scouted.
Starter
New general manager Scot McCloughan has a player to build around in Kerrigan. With his ability, production and youth (26), Kerrigan figures to be the nucleus of Washington for a long time.
Overall
5. Julius Peppers, Green Bay Packers
31 of 35
Pass Rush
A true technician as a pass-rusher, Julius Peppers wins with size (6โ7โ, 287 lbs) and experience (14th season).ย Unlike most big men, Peppers has great quickness off the snap and the agility to counter offensive tackles and beat them with finesse moves and power. And despite his listed size, Peppers looked much leaner in 2014, as he took on a stand-up pass-rushing roleโsomething that definitely boosted his agility and quickness.
Coverage
Peppers doesnโt have much coverage experience from his stints in Carolina or Chicago, but in Green Bay, he showed impressive instincts, awareness and agility. Working primarily in zone drops, Peppers has shown he can explode to the ball, and with his reach and size, heโs able to redirect tight ends or running backs crossing his face.
Run Defense
On the hoof, Peppers has the size and length to be an effective run defender. Ideally, heโd be stronger at the point of attack, though, and would not allow himself to be pushed off the point.
Tackling
With 23 solo tackles in 2014, Peppers ranks on the lower end of the top 10 players this year, but some of that is a result of his move to outside linebacker. Heโs still a massive presence when pursuing a ball-carrier, but weโd like to see more consistency when he's making contact and securing the runner. Our scouts counted 10 plays in the regular season where Peppers missed chances.
Starter
Peppers looked like his younger self in Green Bay, and as a healthy and happy player, he dominated the NFC North with his size and strength. Even as he gets into the latter part of his career, Peppers can still take over games.
Overall
4. Clay Matthews, Green Bay Packers
32 of 35
Pass Rush
In 2014, Clay Matthews proved he is one of the most versatile linebackers in the NFL. And while he's listed as an outside linebacker hereโsince thatโs where he lined up the majority of the timeโMatthews excelled as an attacking inside linebacker in the second half of the season.ย His first-step quickness is unreal, and he follows it up with the strength to stun and shed blockers and a nonstop motor for pursuit. Matthews totaled 11 sacks,ย 10 quarterback hits and 28 hurriesย in a year in which his primary responsibilities split between rushing the quarterback and coverage.
Coverage
Playing inside linebacker means stepping up in coverage, and Matthews did just that. He took that quickness we see in pass-rushing situations and used it to drop into zones to take away crossing routes, and when asked to match up against tight ends, he did a great job limiting targets.
Run Defense
Matthews isnโt the biggest linebacker (6โ3โ, 255 lbs), and that affects his ability to shut down rushing lanes. Heโs much better on the outside, where he can win with leverage, rather than the inside, where he truly has to own a gap. Outside runs where he can give chase are where Matthews excels.
Tackling
With 40 solo tackles on the year, Matthews ranks on the high end for our outside linebackersโand some of that is credited to his time at inside linebacker. And with justย four missed tacklesย on the season, Matthews is one of the most reliable producers when taking down ball-carriers.
Starter
Whether heโs lined up at inside or outside linebackerโand we saw him do both plenty last yearโMatthews remains a force to be reckoned with. His value only increased with the versatility he showed in 2014.
Overall
3. Terrell Suggs, Baltimore Ravens
33 of 35
Pass Rush
Terrell Suggs continues to prove heโs one of the best in the game, and in 2014, he added 12 sacks to a resume thatโs starting to look Hall of Fame-worthy. Suggs didnโt just get sacks, though. He created panic by hitting opposing quarterbacks 11 times and adding 32 hurriesย as a pass-rusher. With ideal burst, strength, length and leverage, Suggs is able to beat blockers of all skill and experience levels.
Coverage
You wonโt see Suggs in coverage often, as he usually lines up as more of a defensive end in passing situations, but when asked to drop into the flats or take away the hook-to-curl zone, he does so with fluid movements, awareness and nice closing speed.
Run Defense
We all know how good Suggs is against the pass, but his play as a run defender is often underrated. Suggsโ length gives him the room to stack up blockers and find the ball, and his instincts and football IQ are good enough that heโs rarely out of position.
Tackling
A big, strong tackler when meeting the ball-carrier or getting after the quarterback, Suggs rarely misses a chance to put the runner on the ground. Heโs a wrap-up tackler who only missed four tackles in 2014.
Starter
Age canโt slow down Suggs, who continues to be the model hybrid edge-defender. His ability to play up or down allows the Ravens to be the flexible, attacking unit they are.
Overall
2. Pernell McPhee, Chicago Bears
34 of 35
Pass Rush
Pernell McPheeโs 2014 was productive and opened eyes to what a power rusher can do in a hybrid defense. Coming off the edge, McPhee has the length and strength to get push, and offensive tackles have a hard time when faced with his leverage and ability to sink his hips and drive. McPheeโs 7.5 sacks werenโt a lot, but he affected the game consistently with 21 quarterback hits and 35 hurries.
Coverage
McPhee is a hybrid edge-rusher, meaning heโs part defensive end and part linebacker. Unlike some 3-4 outside linebackers, heโs not much of an asset in coverage. McPhee can execute a zone drop or jam a tight end on the line of scrimmage, but he doesnโt have the awareness or fluid hips to run in coverage.
Run Defense
McPheeโs size, strength and ability to lock out blockers make him one of the better run defenders youโll see in this group. His 17 solo tackles may not seem like much, but McPhee did a great job setting the edge, limiting outside runs and shedding blockers to make stops.
Tackling
Turn on the game film and you wonโt see many missed tackles or missed opportunities from McPhee. Heโs a wrap-up tackler with great explosion as he closes on the ball-carrier. McPhee missed just eight tackle attempts all year.
Starter
McPhee was an underrated star for the Ravens in 2014, and now heโll look to solidify the defense in Chicago as the newest member of John Foxโs Bears.
Overall
1. Justin Houston, Kansas City Chiefs
35 of 35
Pass Rush
Good luck having a season better than the one Justin Houston turned in last year. The fourth-year pro logged 22 sacks (0.5 short of tying the single-season record), and per Pro Football Focus, he added another eight quarterback hits and an amazing 56 hurries to that total.ย The great thing about Houston is that if he gets close to the quarterback, heโs putting him downโand a low number like eight quarterback hits shows that when Houston is in striking distance, heโs finishing the play.
Coverage
If youโre dropping Houston into coverage often, youโre doing something wrong, but weโre looking at times he was asked to cover and how he performed. With his great size (6โ3โ, 258 lbs), heโs able to get physical with tight ends, and he has the hips to turn and drop into zone coverage without any issues.
Run Defense
Like most great edge-defenders, Houston is geared to explode off the snap and get into the backfield, but he shows remarkable discipline to throttle down and set the edge on defense. His awareness and instincts are as developed here as they are in his pass rush.
Tackling
Looking at Houston as a tackler means weighing his ability to tackle the quarterbackโwhich is eliteโand his ability to stop the run. He logged 40 solo tackles last year and did a good job securing the ball-carrier and using his strength to wrestle him down.
Starter
Houston continues to dominate from the edge-rusher position, and his attempt at the single-season sack record in 2014 shows just how much offenses must respect his skills.
.jpg?w=480 "Eagles Sirianni Football")
.jpg?w=480 "Titans Football")
.jpg?w=480 "Bears Ravens Football")
.jpg?w=480 "Texans Patriots Football")
.png?w=600 "New NBA Mock Draft ๐")
