Home Run Derby 2012: Why Contest Should Only Allow True Power Hitters

The 2012 Home Run Derby was rather predictable, with big bombers Prince Fielder and Jose Bautista advancing to the final round.

It was also predictable that hitters such as Andrew McCutchen and Carlos Gonzalez would get knocked out early.

That's because McCutchen and Gonzalez may have big power numbers this season, but they aren't necessarily definitive power hitters.

For example, Bautista came into the contest averaging a home run every 11.7 at-bats in 2012, per CBSSports.com. Fielder, the eventual champion, came into the Derby averaging a homer every 15.7 at-bats.

On the other hand, McCutchen has averaged a home run every 17.2 at-bats this season, while Gonzalez has averaged a long ball every 18.5 at-bats.

The truth is, McCutchen and Gonzalez—while great players—aren't necessarily guys who are going to jack up the most dingers in a home run contest. They are mostly line-drive hitters. The 2012 Home Run Derby was over before it even started.

And, be honest, even if McCutchen or Gonzalez had won the contest, would you rather see mere 400-footers or incredible, towering shots (SI.com had Fielder hitting a ball 476 feet)?

Players like Fielder, Bautista and Los Angeles Angels outfielder Mark Trumbo should be the models for the Home Run Derby. 

Even though Fielder came into the contest with 15 jacks on the season (minuscule compared to the leaders), you got the sense that he would put on a show in Kansas City.

That's just what Fielder did.

Let's do ourselves a favor and forget about the mere line-drive hitters next year.

Follow me on Twitter. We can talk about baseball together.