NFLNBAMLBNHLWNBAWorld CupGolf
Featured Video
HR Derby History Loading for 23-Year-Old? 💣

MLB Free Agency 2012: Ryan Madson and 5 Relievers for St. Louis Cardinals

Adam SpencerDec 20, 2011

The St. Louis Cardinals didn’t just lose Albert Pujols this offseason. They also lost a key component to their bullpen in Octavio Dotel.

After coming over from the Toronto Blue Jays in the Colby Rasmus trade, Dotel was a workhorse in the bullpen.

In 29 games after the trade, Dotel had a 3.28 ERA and allowed only nine earned runs.

Now he’s moving on to the Detroit Tigers, leaving the Cardinals with a hole to fill in their bullpen.

Here are five current free agent relievers who could come in and fill that void.

5. Scott Linebrink

1 of 5

Linebrink is getting pretty old, but he’s still got a lot to offer a team.

He’s a crafty veteran who can still get people out and pitch a lot of innings.

He’s very similar to Dotel, so signing him would be a good replacement.

He won’t give you quite as many innings as Dotel, but his 3.51 career ERA is similar.

4. Damaso Marte

2 of 5

In addition to losing Octavio Dotel, Trever Miller is also a free agent who might not return to the Cardinals.

Therefore, the team should look at signing Marte, a lefty specialist who can replace Miller’s production.

He’s struggled with the Yankees the past two years, but if anyone can turn Marte’s career around, it’s St. Louis pitching coach Dave Duncan.

3. David Aardsma

3 of 5

Aardsma has been a closer in Seattle for the past two years, racking up 69 saves.

The Cardinals need a guy who can be relied on to close out a game if current closer Jason Motte goes through a slump (as he’s known to do).

Fernando Salas seems to be better off in middle relief, so adding Aardsma at the back end of the bullpen makes a lot of sense.

TOP NEWS

2026 All-Star player photoshoot

Predicting Buyer or Seller for All 30 MLB Teams

Kansas City Royals v Chicago White Sox

All-Stars Who Could Hit Trade Block 🔄

MLB Top 100 Prospects

Updated Prospect Rankings 📊

2. Ryan Madson

4 of 5

Like Aardsma, Madson is another guy who has been a closer in the past.

He has 52 career saves and 113 career holds. He’d be ideal as a closer partner for Motte.

The past two years, he’s posted ERAs of 2.55 and 2.37, so he’s a guy that will be solid at the ends of games.

1. Peter Moylan

5 of 5

Moylan is a sidearm hurler who won’t be returning to the Atlanta Braves.

He throws a powerful fastball and has been very effective in his brief career.

He’s currently recovering from a torn labrum and rotator cuff, but he should be ready for spring training.

His career 2.60 ERA would be a welcome addition to the St. Louis bullpen.

HR Derby History Loading for 23-Year-Old? 💣

TOP NEWS

2026 All-Star player photoshoot

Predicting Buyer or Seller for All 30 MLB Teams

Kansas City Royals v Chicago White Sox

All-Stars Who Could Hit Trade Block 🔄

MLB Top 100 Prospects

Updated Prospect Rankings 📊

MLB Draft

Ranking Farm Systems After Draft 📊

New York Yankees v Detroit Tigers

Latest Teams Linked to Skubal

Every City's 2000s Mt. Rushmore 🤩
Bleacher Report1d

Every City's 2000s Mt. Rushmore 🤩

Picking four reps for each pro sports hotbed since the turn of the century ➡️

TRENDING ON B/R