New York Yankees Manager Joe Girardi in Favor of Instant Replay

Bronx Baseball DailySenior Analyst IOctober 8, 2010

MINNEAPOLIS - OCTOBER 06:  Manager Joe Girardi of the New York Yankees argues with one of the umpires that Greg Golson made the catch for theout in the ninth inning against the Minnesota Twins the during game one of the ALDS on October 6, 2010 at Target Field in Minneapolis, Minnesota. The Twins runner was ruled safe.The Yankees defeated the Twins 6-4.  (Photo by Elsa/Getty Images)
Elsa/Getty Images

The play Yankees manager Joe Girardi is discussing is Greg Golson‘s catch in the ninth inning of Game One of the ALDS that should have ended the game, but instead was ruled a trap.


“As long as it doesn’t slow the games down,” Girardi said in the visiting manager’s office before Thursday night’s Game Two.

“I couldn’t really see it but I go by the reaction of the players and they usually tell you a lot,” Girardi said. “[Golson] said he caught it, so I asked the umpires to convene. After they come back with that decision there’s really not much I can do, but I appreciate them getting together because it might be a call that’s overturned.”

“If Thome hits a home run there and the Twins go on to win, it could change the complexion of the series,” Girardi said.

“Could they have reviewed that play as quick as they talked about it? Probably,” Girardi said. “It takes the same amount of time. To me, that’s the great thing about technology. They can slow everything down. And there’s different things you can do. You could have an umpire right in front of a TV. They could do that. So it could actually speed up the game.”

I initially didn’t make too much of a big deal about this replay issue because ultimately the Golson play wasn’t that big of a deal because it did not effect the outcome of the game. There will be another play that has a larger effect than the Golson play (the Berkman non-strikeout being different because replay wouldn’t cover balls and strikes).

This is a big deal though, instant replay in baseball, because there is no good reason against having it. Instant replay is technically part of the sport in a small way, and it has become a prevalent part of all sports today.

There is no reason it has to slow down the pace of the game. Every time there is an incorrect call, the managers usually are out there arguing for 5-10 minutes anyway, slowing down the pace of the game. If replay is instituted, they could just make a rule that managers aren’t allowed to argue a call.

It’s pathetic, and it needs to end. Preferably baseball could even institute something before the ALCS.

Related Stories


The latest in the sports world, emailed daily.