Major League Baseball Midterms: Grading Every All-Star Selection

P Clay Buchholz, Boston

P Trevor Cahill, Oakland

P Fausto Carmona, Cleveland

P Neftali Feliz, Texas

P Cliff Lee, Seattle

P Jon Lester, Boston

P David Price, Tampa Bay

P Mariano Rivera, New York Yankees

P CC Sabathia/Phil Hughes, New York Yankees

P Joakim Soria, Kansas City

P Matt Thornton, Chicago White Sox

P Jose Valverde, Detroit

C John Buck, Toronto

C Victor Martinez, Boston

1B Miguel Cabrera, Detroit

2B Ian Kinsler, Texas

2B Dustin Pedroia, Boston

2B Ty Wigginton, Baltimore

SS Elvis Andrus, Texas

3B Alex Rodriguez, New York Yankees

3B: Adrian Beltre, Boston

OF Jose Bautista, Toronto

OF Torii Hunter, Los Angeles Angels

OF Vernon Wells, Toronto

DH David Ortiz, Boston

P Jonathan Broxton, Los Angeles Dodgers

P Matt Capps, Washington

P Chris Carpenter, St. Louis

P Yovani Gallardo, Milwaukee

P Roy Halladay, Philadelphia

P Tim Hudson, Atlanta

P Ubaldo Jimenez, Colorado

P Josh Johnson, Florida

P Tim Lincecum, San Francisco

P Evan Meek, Pittsburgh

P Arthur Rhodes, Cincinnati

P Adam Wainwright, St. Louis

P Brian Wilson, San Francisco

C Brian McCann, Atlanta

1B Adrian Gonzalez, San Diego

1B Ryan Howard, Philadelphia

2B Brandon Phillips, Cincinnati

2B Martin Prado, Atlanta

SS Jose Reyes, New York Mets

SS Troy Tulowitzki, Colorado

3B Omar Infante, Atlanta

3B Scott Rolen, Cincinnati

OF Michael Bourn/Marlon Byrd/Chris Young, Houston/Chicago Cubs/Arizona

OF Corey Hart, Milwaukee

OF Matt Holliday, St. Louis