
Buy or Sell Latest on Tarik Skubal, Randy Arozarena and Offseason MLB Free Agency, Trade Rumors
With MLB's collective bargaining agreement expiring December 1 and a lockout expected to follow, the offseason is picking up steam anyway. There have been a few signings and the rumors aren't stopping.
So, who's up for a round of "Buy or Sell?" on the latest rumors?
We've picked out eight rumors from the last few days that we think deserve scrutiny, though it's worth clarifying that this is not about putting the sources under the microscope. Rather, this is about the implied outcome.
For instance, if a rumor claims that Team A is interested in Player B, is it believable that a deal between the two will actually get done?
Let's get to it, starting with a certain West Coast ace who is purportedly not available in trade talks.
Is Logan Webb Totally Unavailable in San Francisco?
1 of 8
Source: Bob Nightengale of USA Today
Nightengale is pretty unequivocal in his reporting on where the San Francisco Giants stand with Logan Webb. He writes that they will not trade him, "no matter how many teams continue to ask for the ace."
Look, you can't fault teams for asking. The 29-year-old righty has mostly been a mainstay among the best pitchers in baseball for much of this decade. He's also on a team-friendly contract that will pay out $47 million across 2027 and 2028, which is a steal for a three-time All-Star who also has three top-10 finishes in the NL Cy Young Award voting.
Right now, though, the Giants would risk selling low if they were to deal Webb. The 2026 season was not his finest hour, as injuries limited him to 27 starts and his ERA ballooned to 4.31. He especially struggled in the latter half of the year, posting a 5.89 ERA over his last 13 starts.
That the Giants should be looking to rebuild after a 97-loss season is the argument in favor of trading Webb, but every indication is that they'd rather not. Indeed, Nightengale says they're looking to add starting pitching.
Besides which, it's not like the Giants are hurting for prospects. Per B/R's Joel Reuter, they have six top-100 talents in their system.
Verdict: Buy
Have the Yankees Already Nixed a Jonathan Loáisiga Reunion?
2 of 8
Source: Jon Heyman of the New York Post
It was Heyman who reported last week that the New York Yankees were in on Loáisiga, which made for a fun little story on account of his history with the team. Now he says they "seem focused elsewhere at moment."
Loáisiga was a top-100 prospect when he came up with the Yankees in 2018, as part of a sort of second wave of Baby Bombers that also featured Miguel Andujar. His Yankees tenure peaked in 2021, when he produced 3.3 rWAR out of the bullpen. He then experienced a whirlwind between 2022 and 2025, with Tommy John surgery in 2024 in the middle of the vortex.
After reestablishing himself with a 2.42 ERA in 67 appearances for the Arizona Diamondbacks, Loáisiga would seem to be an ideal fit for a Yankees bullpen that is currently missing David Bednar and Paul Blackburn. Moreover, general manager Brian Cashman has spotlighted the pen as "our main priority."
The Yankees always have a bunch of irons in the fire, however, and it's possible that they're not focused on Loáisiga solely because of that. Even if he's on their radar, it's a big radar.
More likely, they're focused on also bringing back Bednar and Blackburn after already re-upping with Tim Hill. And why not? For all the flak the Yankees rightfully get for their tendency to "run it back," keeping the 2026 pen together is a good idea. It had the second-lowest ERA in the league at 3.13.
Verdict: Buy
Are the Orioles a Fit for Randy Arozarena and Ketel Marte?
3 of 8
Sources: Andy Kostka of The Baltimore Banner and Jake Rill of MLB.com
The Baltimore Orioles have been known to be on the hunt for upgrades to their outfield, and Kostka reports that Randy Arozarena is of interest to them. If so, they'd better be ready to pay up.
He is a Scott Boras client, after all, and Adam Jude and Ryan Divish of The Seattle Times heard during the GM Meetings that Boras is pushing for a six-year deal in the $150 million range. The Orioles have only gone that far for a free agent twice in their history, including for Pete Alonso just last year.
Of course, Boras wouldn't be good at his job if he didn't aim high at the outset. It's doubtful that any team will go as far as five years for Arozarena, much less six. As such, this initial demand comes off as a prelude to settling for $100 million.
With a $36 million gap between what they spent in 2026 and what they project to spend in 2027, the Orioles could do something like four years, $100 million for Arozarena and still have money left for other needs. It also may not hurt that the Orioles hold spring training in Sarasota, Florida, which is about an hour's drive from Arozarena's home in Tampa.
As for Rill's report that the Orioles are in on Marte, that largely depends on whether he wants to go to Baltimore. His 10-and-5 rights allow him to block any trade. And per Nick Piecoro of The Arizona Republic, the D-backs still may not have a clear idea of where Marte would go even after meeting with his agent.
Even so, a Diamondbacks insider described the relationship between Marte, the team and manager Torey Lovullo as "completely broken" to John Perrotto of FanSided. A trade would be best for everyone, and the O's are a good fit on account of their plethora of left-handed bats. For instance, a Marte-for-Jackson Holliday trade would be fun.
Verdict: Buy
Is Trevor Rogers Radioactive for Certain Clubs?
4 of 8
Source: Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic
Even if none of them are on Tarik Skubal's level, Trevor Rogers is part of a solid selection of free agent starters that also includes Freddy Peralta, Michael King and Sonny Gray.
Rogers has a problem, though: Out of all the starters on the market, he's the only one with a qualifying offer.
Unless the new CBA completely does away with the system, the lefty will be tied to penalties if he rejects the offer (as expected) and signs with another team. Those are especially severe for luxury tax payors, who have to give up $1 million in international bonus money and two draft picks if they sign Rogers.
To this end, Rosenthal posits that the New York Mets, Chicago Cubs, San Diego Padres and Atlanta Braves are "expected to be interested" in Rogers, but that they could prefer to sign other starters who aren't tied to a qualifying offer. He's pretty plugged-in, so this may not be idle speculation.
All four of those clubs badly need starting pitching, so this could end up being a "beggars can't be choosers" scenario for any one of them if Rogers is still there after other options come off the board. For now, though, it is plausible that they would prefer not to sign him. It's not as if he's a can't-miss talent, after all.
Verdict: Buy
Should Teams Stop Asking the Rays About Drew Rasmussen?
5 of 8
Sources: Bob Nightengale of USA Today and Robert Murray of FanSided
In the aftermath of the World Series, Drew Rasmussen instantly became a popular speculative subject for offseason trades. Heck, MLB Trade Rumors even had him at No. 2 on their list before the Rays triggered his $20 million option.
Tampa Bay Rays president of baseball operations Erik Neander moved quickly to quiet such talk, saying that the team has "every intention" of keeping its ace for the 2027 season. Nightengale's and Murray's reporting indicates that nothing has changed in the weeks since.
Granted, you can still look back at the Rays' history and feel skeptical. They do tend to cash in on trade value once it's there, and especially if it also means saving some money. In this case, the time they ducked a $25 million salary by trading Tyler Glasnow to the Los Angeles Dodgers comes to mind.
However, the Rays weren't coming off a World Series run when they did that. Even if they're already projected to spend $16 million more in 2027 than they did in 2026, they should be able to afford that.
There also wasn't a lockout looming when the Rays traded Glasnow. There is this time around, and it's complicating the trade value of all players who are slated for free agency after 2027. Rasmussen is one of those, and the size of his salary surely only complicates things further.
Verdict: Buy
Is Now the Time for a Junior Caminero Extension?
6 of 8
Sources: Robert Murray of FanSided and Ken Rosenthal of The Athletic
According to Murray, extensions for young players in general are "something heard as possibilities" right now. Junior Caminero is among the candidates, and Rosenthal's reporting breaks the situation down in full.
Some of the intrigue comes down to timing. For players, the looming lockout is effectively a threat of future constraints on earning power. As such, the time for Caminero to maximize his future earnings may be now.
There's also the matter of the cost. Caminero has hit 87 home runs over the last two seasons, including 42 in a 2026 campaign that saw him finish second in the AL MVP voting. And he's just 23 years old.
Thus, Rosenthal's ballpark estimate for extending Caminero: "It would certainly be $200 million plus, maybe even $300 million plus."
The Rays have never signed a deal that big, but that may not be relevant in this context. They're finally due to get a new ballpark in (they hope) 2029, and owner Patrick Zalupski has teased a corresponding payroll leap into the top 15 or even the top 10 of MLB.
An extension for Caminero would essentially be a down payment on that project, and he has every reason to listen if the Rays make a good offer. There are still four years standing between him and free agency, so there's sense in striking now while the iron is hot rather than risking it going cold.
Verdict: Buy
Could Freddy Peralta's Contract Blow Away Expectations?
7 of 8
Source: Jim Bowden of The Athletic
Sticking with the Rays for one more, we turn to Bowden's rather surprising comp for Freddy Peralta's next contract: Carlos Rodón.
"Peralta is expected to get five or six years in the Carlos Rodón range (six years, $162 million)," he wrote.
For reference, B/R's Tim Kelly projects only a three-year, $73 million contract with a post-2028 opt-out for Peralta. Even a more aggressive projection from MLB Trade Rumors stops at five years and $110 million.
Granted, Evan Phillips and Jake Bauers have already beaten expectations for their contracts, which could bode well for Peralta. And while the rest of us can fret about how he only had a 4.42 ERA this year, it's an outlier relative to his career 3.71 ERA.
Teams also care about what players project to do, and Peralta showed at the end of 2026 that he deserves optimistic projections. He was terrific for the Rays in September and October, posting a 1.82 ERA over 49.1 innings.
That said, teams will also recognize that Peralta is a seasonal age older than Rodón was as a free agent after the 2022 season. Even if he matches Rodón's AAV, a five-year deal worth $135 million should be his ceiling.
Verdict: Sell
Could Tarik Skubal Actually Score a $500 Million Contract?
8 of 8
Source: Jim Bowden of The Athletic
There have been $500 million projections for Tarik Skubal before, but it's the way that Bowden framed the possibility that stands out as being slightly different:
"Teams meeting with Skubal know going in that the price will end up between $350 and $500 million depending on years, and that the final contract will ultimately break the record for starting pitchers by both AAV and total amount."
You see that? "Know." Not "expect." Not "anticipate." Know.
OK, fine. Maybe we are reading too much into that. And it's fair to have doubts whether Skubal has that much earning power. The current high-water mark for a pitcher contract is $325 million. Is he really going to reset the bar by $175 million?
Actually, it might not be that far of a reach. MLB Trade Rumors has Skubal getting to $425 million in their predictions, and they have a history of underestimating contracts for ace pitchers. In recent years, Dylan Cease, Corbin Burnes, Blake Snell, Yoshinobu Yamamoto and Carlos Rodón have all beaten their MLBTR predictions.
Besides, this could be the last chance MLB's big spenders get to make it rain without any limitations. Why leave anything to chance?
Verdict: Buy
Stats courtesy of Baseball Reference, FanGraphs and Baseball Savant.


.jpg?w=2560)



.jpg?w=2560)





.jpg?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)