If you are going to be uptight, nervous, and over-manage in the postseason, you better win.
Time and time again, New York Yankees manager has overmanaged in this postseason and the Yankees’ talent has bailed him out.
Today, there was nobody to bail Girardi out.
In the bottom of the 11th this afternoon in Anaheim, with the score tied at four, Girardi took RHP David Robertson out of the game with two outs and nobody on base.
Why Girardi took Robertson out is anyone’s guess.
Robertson, who led all American League pitchers in K/9 with 12.98 was cruising along. He had thrown only 11 pitches and six of them were for strikes. There was absolutely no reason to take him out– especially since a right-handed batter was coming up in Howie Kendrick.
Girardi took Robertson out to bring in Alfredo Aceves. Aceves proceeds to give up a single to Kendrick and then a double to Jeff Mathis– game over.
The Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim win 5-4 and now they are back in the ALCS.
I guess we can stop calling Aceves “Ace.” That might be the worst nickname in sports.
Aceves as “Ace?” Come on.
Does CC Sabathia say “Hey Ace what’s up?" I suppose he starts laughing after that.
Here is what has to kill you if you are a Yankee fan.
Robertson is just better than Aceves. He is better and its not even close. There is no way Girardi could possibly think that Aceves gave the Yankees a better chance to win the game than Robertson does.
I can’t wait to hear Girardi get ripped in the newspaper and on the radio tomorrow in New York. If I was Girardi, I would block out all forms of media tomorrow. It’s going to get ugly.
Here are some other observations from today’s game:
Why did Girardi pinch-hit for Mariano Rivera in the 10th with Francisco Cervelli? There were two outs and nobody on. Let Rivera hit and use him for another inning. Just stupid managing on Girardi’s part.
How great has Jeff Mathis been for the Angels? He is a lifetime .200 hitter and he's been hitting the ball all over the ballpark in the ALCS.
Did Bobby Abreu go to the Nick Punto school of baserunning? It was such an awful baserunning play, that I thought that it would have taken all the wind out of the Angels sails.
Girardi just made another pitching change. He just summoned Eric Plunk out of the pen.
On that play, it wasn’t a great play by Derek Jeter. It was a great play by Mark Teixeira backing up second base. Being the cutoff man and turning around and throwing to Teixeira isn’t a great play.
Let’s give other people credit when it’s due.
Why do pitchers continue to challenge Alex Rodriguez when they are behind in the count? Just walk him at that point. Hideki Matsui hasn’t done a thing this postseason.
I loved how Jered Weaver begged Mike Scioscia to stay in the game. I thought that was awesome. I wish more pitchers were like Weaver.
Did Jeter's HR remind anyone else of Game 4 of the 2000 World Series?
Didn’t you just know that the Angels weren’t going to score with first and third with nobody out in the 10th. It was almost inevitable.
If Torii Hunter is up in a big spot– don’t throw him a strike. Hunter is so anxious to be the hero, he will just swing at anything.
Remember, this is the same organization that hyped up Russ Davis as the next Mike Schmidt.
Vladimir Guerrero’s sixth inning, two-run HR saved the series for the Angels. The Angels were 10 outs away from their season essentially being over and Guerrero tied the game and gave the Angels new life.
Girardi just made another pitching change.
Besides Girardi, the other concern you have if you are a Yankee fan is that they are having a hard time scoring if they don’t hit a HR. Something to watch for in the remainder of the series.
Somebody should tell Kendry Morales and Juan Rivera the ALCS started. These two were a combined 0-for-10 today and have a combined .077 average for the ALCS.
Hero for Game 3 - Jeff Mathis
Goat for Game 3 - Alfredo Aceves
Series MVP - Alex Rodriguez
Game 4 is Tuesday at 7:57 ET.