Featured Video
Gretzky Hates Octopus Celly 🐙
New Jersey Devils v Toronto Maple Leafs
Auston MatthewsMark Blinch/National Hockey League via Getty Images

Panic Meter for Struggling NHL Teams During the 2026-27 Season

Sara CivianNov 19, 2026

We're two months into the NHL season, and we're quickly approaching American Thanksgiving.

As hockey fans know, Thanksgiving is the best measuring stick we have when it comes to which teams will make the playoffs. As we await the day, we can't help but notice some absences from teams that many thought would either be in playoff spots or, at the very least, be better off than they currently are.

As we take a look around the league, some of these teams are legitimately screwed, but some of these teams will persevere and get over their current struggles. Which of the struggling teams have a chance, and which need to hit the panic button?

Chicago Blackhawks

1 of 6
Buffalo Sabres v Chicago Blackhawks
Connor Bedard

The Blackhawks got back on track with a 6-3 win against the also panicking Maple Leafs Tuesday, but as is the story of Chicago's season, it didn't come without a devastating blow.

We don't know the severity yet, but Connor Bedard is currently being evaluated for a right shoulder injury sustained in the game. He had his left shoulder surgically repaired in the past, and he sat out last season with a right shoulder injury that didn't require surgery.

In layman's terms, this isn't good for the worst team in the Central.

This is Bedard's fourth season in the league. While there still wasn't immense pressure for the Blackhawks to make the playoffs headed into this season, there were some encouraging bouts of full-team play last season that made us feel like the team was at least going in the right direction.

We thought perhaps GM Kyle Davidson would've spent the offseason shopping for a high-end winger in his prime to complement Bedard, or at least some more viable center depth.

Wrong.

Davidson traded the No. 4 overall pick that could've been used to draft that player to acquire Bowen Byram. Byram is a solid, young defenseman with an intriguing ceiling, but Chicago paid a heavy price for him, which included the fourth pick overall at the 2026 NHL Draft.

Unfortunately, Byram got injured at the beginning of the season and has missed more than a month. On the bright side, his return could at least give the team a much-needed boost.

But it's clear the entire offense needs an overhaul and an upgrade. You expect the defense to be rockier on a more youthful team, but it's worth mentioning that the defense, too, has been brutal.

When it comes to Chicago, the panic isn't a concern about timing. It's the fact that they haven't quite used their rebuilding time to slowly but surely collect enough of the necessary pieces. Artyom Levshunov is showing some promise in a rare bright spot of this season, but the Blackhawks have tried three times at this point to use a top-10 pick to find a No. 1 defenseman.

At this point, you're starting to wonder if and when things are going to click, and if and when Davidson is capable of giving the young core an adequate supporting cast.

Panic meter: 7.5 Box-Office Flops (Sorry, Showtime)

Columbus Blue Jackets

2 of 6
Tampa Bay Lightning v Columbus Blue Jackets
Zach Werenski

These Blue Jackets could only flail around the mushy middle until they arrived where they currently are: The non-mushy last-place spot at the bottom of the Metropolitan Division.

Their current five-game losing streak and latest 5-1 loss to the Islanders have displayed the utter lack of offensive power that has been the problem for the Blue Jackets for years.

The alarm bells started ringing when Zach Werenski and Kirill Marchenko both hinted last season that they weren't sure if they were going to stick with the franchise long-term. Werenski's still in Columbus and vetoed a trade to the Stars; meanwhile, the team's best goalscorer, Marchenko, was shipped to the Leafs.

Columbus is dead last in the NHL, averaging just 2.32 goals per game. It's the same old story for this franchise, but this time around it's like they're just rolling over and accepting their fate.

Panic meter: 8.5 "We like our group" interviews from GM Don Waddell

Detroit Red Wings

3 of 6
Detroit Red Wings v Edmonton Oilers
Dylan Larkin

At this point, the Red Wings are less in "panic mode" and more sinking into "existential dread" territory. It's been 10 consecutive seasons without a playoff appearance, with the last seven of those featuring franchise legend Steve Yzerman failing to deliver on his "Yzerplan" as GM.

You thought that, at least once Red Wings ownership cut ties with Yzerman, the franchise would be able to go in a fresh direction with the rebuild and start rounding out the solid core he drafted. Instead, it took Dylan Larkin requesting a trade to force Yzerman out of the role way too late into the offseason, so the team was essentially in a holding pattern when it needed to make moves to improve the roster.

Now, Larkin still hasn't been traded; there's no new long-term GM, and the entire city of Detroit is essentially sitting on its hands while nothing gets done. It's infuriating.

Panic meter: 8 Octopus tentacles

San Jose Sharks

4 of 6
NHL: NOV 15 Predators vs Sharks
Macklin Celebrini

Perhaps no NHL team was hyped up in the preseason more than the Sharks, and perhaps that was premature for a team still clearly needing many pieces.

Still, at 10-12-2, they're just one point out of the playoff race in the Pacific Division. The proximity to the playoffs just doesn't feel too convincing right now if you're watching this team on a nightly basis, though.

The team-wide defense and chaotic semblance of a "system" are going to require much more work before this team becomes a true playoff threat. The aging and expensive blueline contracts they signed in the offseason continue to baffle as they search for the players who will stabilize their blue line and provide some traction in the neutral zone.

Beyond defense specifically, players look completely lost when Macklin Celebrini isn't on the ice. The Sharks need an identity beyond Celebrini, as great as he is. This will only happen once the blue line is stabilized and some of the younger core feel comfortable taking some offensive chances and risks.

Toronto Maple Leafs

5 of 6
Edmonton Oilers v Toronto Maple Leafs
William Nylander

Oh, Toronto. Our precious, precious center of the hockey world has once again found its way into the center of negative discourse.

The Leafs have dropped seven games in a row at this point, including their most recent 6-3 loss to the lowly Blackhawks.

What happened to the good vibes generated from the start of No. 1 overall draft pick Gavin McKenna's career and an awesome start to the season for Auston Matthews?

For one, the team is adjusting to major offseason overhauls and is coming off a non-playoff season. There shouldn't have been much panic about making the playoffs in the first place, but alas, this is the Leafs.

Sergei Bobrovsky has struggled to adjust to his new team. He owns rough stats all around, like a 3.65 goals-against average, an .874 save percentage, and 5.26 more goals allowed than expected.

This franchise shouldn't be panicking; it should be noting which big changes worked and which didn't. It should be back to the drawing board. But Auston Matthews and his contract aren't getting any younger, and there's obviously immense pressure to win a Cup with Matthews in the fold. Still, the pressure is unrealistic when the team is not even looking playoff-ready.

Time to face reality.

Panic meter: 9 chirps from Biz

Utah Mammoth

6 of 6
NHL: NOV 16 Canucks vs Mammoth
Logan Cooley

WEE-OOO, WEE-OOO, WEE-OOO. Do you hear that? That's the sound of the Mammoth, once at the top of the Central Division, now amidst a six-game losing streak.

The streak has them now tied with the Jets for fifth in the division and out of a playoff spot. Meanwhile, they've won just three of their last 10. What the heck is happening?

Injuries all over the lineup haven't helped. Dylan Guenther, who scored 40 goals last season, is expected to miss two to four weeks with an upper-body injury. Veteran defenseman Nate Schmidt is also sidelined.

Still, there's something else going on: The goaltending has been atrocious. Karel Vejmelka and Sebastian Cossa have been one of the worst goaltending combinations in the league. The Mammoth have a .873 team save percentage, ranking 30th in the NHL.

There's a reason GM Bill Armstrong lobbied hard to acquire Connor Hellebuyck. But the Mammoth clearly didn't win that sweepstakes. If they can move on and still manage to acquire a better goaltender, they'll probably bounce back.

Panic meter: 3.5 tusks