WWE Royal Rumble: Will Phoenix Make CM Punk/the Rock a Classic?
This was a topic discussed by myself on a VoicesofWrestling.comย 1,003 Holds podcastย and one that has me nervous about Sundayโs Royal Rumble pay-per-view. Can and will the Phoenix crowd make the CM Punk-The Rock WWE Championship Match a classic?
Weโre all anticipating a classic match and by all means, it should be.
From an in-ring standpoint, CM Punk always rises to theย occasion. While heโs a little far removed from a truly top-tier match, heโs been solidly consistent. When the light shines bright, CM Punk rises to theย occasion. Iโm not worried about him.
TOP NEWS
.jpg?w=2560)
Ranking WWE Survivor Series Moments ๐

Is WWE or AEW Having a Better 2026?

BS Meter on Latest Rumors ๐ก๏ธ
The RockโIโd be lying if I claimed Iโm not a little nervous about. Of course, The Rock was a beast in his hey-day, delivering a ton of stellar matches. But thatโs the old Rockโthatโs not actor Rockโthat wasnโt once-a-year wrestling Rock.
WrestleMania 28โฒs main event between The Rock and John Cena was great. It was awesome, but The Rock blew up in the match quickly. You canโt deny that. Within 5-10 minutes, you could tell The Rock was on tired, nearly dead legs. There were long bouts of holding the ropes and gasping for air. I was worried we were about to see a huge letdown.
Alas, he was able to recover, and due in large part to Cena controlling the remainder of the contest, the two still put together a very solid match.
I wouldnโt be doing the match or my role as a critical wrestling fan justice if I left it at that. Even after the match, I wondered if it would have been as highly regarded on a Capitol Punishment pay-per-view. Would Cena-Rock in a vacuum or an Extreme Rules pay-per-view be nearly as well-regarded? I think the obvious answer here is, no.
It simply would not have been that big of a deal or that great of a match if not surrounded by 78,000-plus fans. ย The atmosphere, hype and anticipation of the match played as big of a part in making that match a top-tier affair as anything in-ring did.
In-ring wise, Punk-Rock might be good, but it might be average. Asย The Classicalโs Nick Bond discussed in his recent piece โSomebodyโs Going to Emergency, Somebodyโs Going to Jailโ, this match is going to have difficulty even being the best Royal Rumble match of all time. Itโs nothing personal against Punk or The Rock; itโs just one of WWEโs biggest events and has produced stellar, epic and legendary matches.
Bond mentions Cactus Jack vs. Triple H from Royal Rumble 2000, the infamous โI Quitโ match from the 1999 Royal Rumble between The Rock and Mankind and even Kurt Angle vs. He Who Shall Not Be Named (โฆChris Benoit) from 2003 as matches already on the top of the mountain. Itโs hard to argue with any of those being top-tier title matches.
If you want to talk about classic Royal Rumble affairs, you can also add in the numerous stellar Royal Rumble matches (letโs all give a slow clap for Pat Pattersonโs genius). Iโm talking the well-booked 1990 affair, the legitimately five-star 1992 Royal Rumble and great 2007 Rumble won by No. 30 entrant The Undertaker.
Can The Rock vs. CM Punk top any of those matches? On a purely in-ring standpoint? I doubt itโI really do. Both guys are good performers, but Iโm just not confident they can put together an organic, in-ring four- or five-star match.
Whatโs going to make the match a classic is the crowd and the atmosphere surrounding it. There was much debate when Dave Meltzer of the Wrestling Observer gave CM Punk vs. John Cena at Money in the Bank 2011 a five-star rating. Some would argueโin-ringโthat was not a great match. There were many blown spots and it wasnโt particularly fluid. Nobody is arguing though, that the atmosphere surrounding the match made it spectacular.
The WrestleMania 28 rematch of Undertaker vs. Triple H was nothing special in-ring, but the crowd was hot the entire way through. Again, a match that I wouldnโt say was an organic/in-ring five star contest turned into the stuff of legends thanks to a hot crowd.
Sunday in Phoenix, itโs up to those in the crowd to make this match a big deal and make this epic. Punk and Rock are going to lay the groundwork for you and itโs your turn to let your voices be heard and make this special.
Not to offend any fans we have in Phoenix or the Arizona-area, but Iโm just not confident in it. They shouldnโt feel ashamed though, Iโve begun to notice that silent WWE crowds have become the norm outside of New York, Chicago, Toronto and a few other select cities.
I canโt really explain why. Itโs very much a chicken and egg riddle.
Does a hot WWE product make a good crowd? Crowds were rabid in the late '80s, early '90s and again in the late '90s-early 2000s, and that does coincide with great points in WWE creative history. The issue though, lies with these bit-shows with hot crowds where you watch and say, โWOW, THIS IS ONE OF THE BEST SHOWS EVER! WWE IS GOOD AGAIN.โ
Money in the Bank 2011โnot to bring it up againโwas regarded as the Best Major Show in the 2011 Wrestling Observer Awards. Thatโs high praise. Now it was a great event from top to bottom, but Iโve often wondered, does the event have the same impact if it was done in Oklahoma City?
More recently, โTables, Ladders and Chairsโ was a highly-regarded event capped off by an extremely hot Dolph Ziggler vs. John Cena match and a great Six-Man Tag featuring The Shield vs. Team Hell No and Ryback. Another top to bottom great show, hot crowd and well, it was done at the Barclays Center in Brooklyn, NY. Largely the same audience as your typical Madison Square Garden/New York show.
Looking at Cagematch.netโs pay-per-view database, WWE pay-per-view events since 2003 that received 8+ overall ratingsย were from the following cities: Chicago (Rosemont), Seattle, Las Vegas, New York, Los Angeles, Atlanta, Orlando, Chicago, San Antonio, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada, Buffalo, New York, San Diego, ย Toronto, Las Vegas, Brooklyn, Kansas City, Denver, Providence, Chicago (Rosemont) and New York.
There are some outliers for sure, but I canโt help but notice three Chicago shows and three New York proper (one Brooklyn) shows. The only other city to show up multiple times was Las Vegas (twice).
Itโs not an exact science at all, but itโs very telling that New York and Chicago somehow, someway, continue to have highly-regarded pay-per-views even in a less than stellar time creatively for the WWE.
Back to Phoenix, letโs look at how well their events have been received. Again, thanks to Cagematch.net for their awesome database tool, we can look atย all Phoenix-area pay-per-views since 2003. (Not fair to leave Glendale out of the running).
What we can tell off the bat, is they are not nearly as well-received. SummerSlam 2003 tops the list at 7.74, followed by Glendaleโs WrestleMania XXVI, highlighted by an all-time great bout between Shawn Michaels and The Undertaker, at 7.28. The last three, Money in the Bank 2012, Cyber Sunday 2008 and Judgment Day 2006 all found themselves under 7 (6.67, 6.35, 5.79). Again, not an exact science but somewhat telling that they had a less-than-stellar WrestleMania, a close, but not quite great SummerSlam and a letdown Money in the Bank (a traditionally well-rated show).
Really, I donโt know. Iโm nervous the fans will let us down and this match wonโt have the same "oh and ah" feel it deserves, but weโll see. I hate to badmouth an entire fanbase, but take this as a beg and a plea to clear your throats. Donโt talk the entire day and let it all out during the pay-per-view. Itโs up to you to make The Rock vs. CM Punk an epic, all-time great match.
Rich Kraetsch is the owner and regular contributor to VoicesofWrestling.com


.png?w=2560)
.png?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)



.jpg?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)
