Featured Video
🚨 Hacksaw Jim Duggan Returns
WWE: Crown Jewel
Roman Reigns returned to the top of the totem pole in WWE in 2026.WWE/WWE via Getty Images

Is WWE or AEW Having a Better 2026?

With 2026 having been nothing short of newsworthy for both WWE and AEW, it hasn't been uncommon for the pendulum of momentum to swing back and forth between the two promotions throughout the year.

The quality of the creative direction has been a primary point of contention among fans, especially in regards to WWE. They haven't had John Cena's farewell tour or nearly as many notable names to fall back on this year, forcing management to make new stars and elevate certain competitors to greater success.

The same can be said for AEW, as a handful of fresh faces have risen up over the last year and are well on their way to winning world titles. AEW has always prided itself on being where the best wrestle, but some of the stories they've told this year with their top talent put their product at a level above WWE's more often than not.

AEW hasn't been without its flaws, however, as depth in the women's division outside of the top title picture has been a recurring issue in the absence of Toni Storm. WWE has experienced similar struggles with Rhea Ripley, Bianca Belair and Asuka missing most of the year for various reasons.

There has been a lot to like about both WWE and AEW as well as much that's been criticized, but which company has had the better 2026 on the whole?

The Highs and Lows of the Men's Main Event Scenes

1 of 7
SiriusXM at Super Bowl LX – Feb 5

The men's world title scenes have largely carried WWE and AEW at different points in 2026 and arguably have been the most must-see aspects of both products.

CM Punk was a fighting World Heavyweight champion up until he lost the title to Roman Reigns in an instant classic on Night 2 of WrestleMania 42. Although Reigns hasn't been around remotely as much, he has delivered big time whenever the gold has been up for grabs and might be in the midst of his best in-ring year ever.

The Undisputed WWE Championship picture wasn't quite as consistent for the first half of the year, but Punk taking the title from Zayn in July followed by Zayn getting the belt back in September injected excitement into the top of the card on SmackDown and has made for an unpredictable period where almost anyone has been able to challenge for the championship at any time.

The scene surrounding the AEW World Championship has been slightly stronger in 2026, if only because of how many people were vying for the prestigious prize between January and August. MJF did an outstanding job of holding down the fort as the champ as well as Darby Allin during the thrilling one month that he held it for.

Ospreay is approaching the three-month mark with the AEW World title and is still finding his footing in the role, but at least he has no shortage of credible contenders waiting in the wings with MJF next up for an opportunity.

An Overall Lack of Standout Stories

2 of 7
WrestleMania 42

Despite the three men's world championships across WWE and AEW feeling more important than they have in some time in 2026, there has been an overall lack of long-term stories that have stood out in both companies, including outside of the main event scene.

Only a few feuds have spawned multiple months, and they haven't necessarily been riveting. Cody Rhodes vs. Randy Orton started out extremely disappointing and did improve once Pat McAfee was removed from the equation, but it felt like the damage had been done, and Rhodes' waning crowd support hasn't helped matters.

WWE's sole overarching story this year has been with The Bloodline, an angle that has been done to death since it started in 2020. Their ongoing war with The 946 has been a recurring highlight on Raw since SummerSlam and justifies the WarGames stipulation at Survivor Series, but there's been very little long-term direction otherwise.

Similar to WWE, AEW has excelled with making moments in 2026 and sending the message that anything can happen on the weekly television shows, but virtually none of their feuds will go down as being their best ever once this year is over.

Will Ospreay, MJF, Darby Allin and Kenny Omega all made magic on and off throughout the year, and the AEW World Championship scene in general was brilliantly booked from the beginning of 2026 through August's All In event, but the product hasn't been nearly as hot in the months due to most matches coming together on the fly instead of telling stories that extend beyond one event.

If anything, The Bloodline have been more of a sure thing this year than anything else in wrestling and that storyline has somehow exceeded expectations, but even that required WWE to bring back a group that was well past its peak in order to get viewers invested again.

The Next Generation Is Gradually Taking Over

3 of 7
WWE Royal Rumble

Of course, WWE can't rely on The Bloodline forever, and already it's evident that they aren't generating the same success they once did. That's why it's important to use something as established as that faction to elevate the talent of tomorrow, most notably Oba Femi.

Although his absence from either world championship picture has been inexcusable, Femi has been the best call-up from NXT in years. He beat Brock Lesnar in his retirement match at SummerSlam and is the obvious choice to dethrone Roman Reigns for the World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania 43.

Trick Williams and Je'Von Evans, who were also called up to the main roster this year, have gotten over with the audience and have done extremely well for themselves. WWE hasn't put that same amount of effort into the women they've brought up from NXT (more on that later), but at least there's more variety than there's been before.

Likewise, AEW won't always have Will Ospreay, Kenny Omega, MJF and others in prominent positions due to age, injuries and the very real possibility of any of them (specifically MJF) making the jump to WWE. Thus, they've taken the necessary steps to spotlighting the up-and-coming likes of Kevin Knight, Thekla, Maya World, Kyle Fletcher and others.

Even Andrade El Idolo, Tommaso Ciampa, The New Level, Royce Keys and Danhausen have benefited from swapping promotions in 2026. WWE and AEW's rosters are stacked with stars, but it's up to the respective creative teams to do right by them and utilize them to their full potential.

AEW's Pay-Per-View Quality Has Been Unmatched

4 of 7

AEW has been producing pay-per-views of an exceptional quality since the inception of the promotion, but the run they've been on in 2026 alone has been almost untouchable.

There hasn't been a bad one in the bunch, as even when the pay-per-view builds have been lacking, AEW has shown out with all of their events by maximizing every minute they have available to them.

Revolution, Dynasty and Double or Nothing improved upon each other, followed by a fun Forbidden Door and a rock-solid (albeit unnecessary) Redemption show. Meanwhile, All In 2026 was the greatest installment of the event yet, and the three shows since then (All Out, WrestleDream and Full Gear) have been loaded with stellar wrestling.

WWE has had the exact opposite trend with their premium live events this year in that none of them have truly felt special or worth rewatching after the fact. Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber were both dull, WrestleMania 42 was infamously a mixed bag, and Clash in Italy and Night of Champions were fine yet forgettable.

SummerSlam was an enjoyable event and both Backlash and Money in the Bank had their fair share of highlights, but WWE's subpar creative in 2026 has prevented them from going all out with their events and emphasizing the action as much as they do the sponsorships, celebrity cameos and commercialization of the product.

This Is The Least Interesting WWE's Women's Division Has Been in Years

5 of 7
SmackDown

As previously noted, WWE has a stronger women's division now than at any other point in the promotion's history, yet the booking of the divisions on Raw and SmackDown hasn't been this abysmal and uninspired in a decade or longer.

Jade Cargill barely defended her WWE Women's Championship in the first few months of the year, and although it looked like Rhea Ripley might turn things around on SmackDown after WrestleMania 42, an injury has kept her out of action since May.

WWE then wisely capitalized on Chelsea Green's popularity and gave her a run with the title but never fully booked her as the face of the division. Having the belt back on Tiffany Stratton is a return to the norm as opposed to attempting to push Tatum Paxley, Jordynne Grace, Blake Monroe or anyone from Fatal Influence.

Raw's women's division has hardly been better. Liv Morgan has dominated the Women's World Championship picture but hasn't done anything out of the ordinary with the title, nor has there been a meaningful effort to give any of the other women a shot in that spot.

AEW hasn't told a ton of stories with its women in 2026, but at least the great work from Kris Statlander, Thekla, Willow Nightingale and now Mercedes Moné has made the AEW Women's World Championship picture interesting all year long.

Tag Team Wrestling Has Reached New Heights in AEW

6 of 7
WRESTLING-FRANCE-SPORT

Tag team wrestling is alive and well in AEW.

AEW prioritized tag teams out of the gate in 2019 but got away from featuring the division in a compelling way in recent years. In 2026, the division is deeper than it's ever been, including the vast amount of trios teams they have at their disposal.

Cage and Cage set the standard for the year with a superb string of matches, culminating in their terrific three-way TLC war at All Out. Along with The Young Bucks and FTR, the tag title mix has since been bolstered by the additions of The New Level, The Motor City Machine Guns, The Rascalz, The Kasper Brothers and more.

WWE, on the other hand, threw in the towel on tag team wrestling this year. They've cycled the same three or four teams in and out of the WWE Tag Team Championship picture on SmackDown with a majority of the matches blending together, while the World Tag Team Championship went four months without being defended on Raw until recently.

WWE doesn't see tag teams as a draw and that's understandable to an extent, but there have been glimmers of greatness when they have taken it seriously here and there over the years. It's been refreshing to see tag teams become a focal point again in AEW, and as a result, they've played a pivotal role in enhancing the overall product.

Final Assessment

7 of 7

From a business standpoint, WWE has cooled off considerably compared to where they were in the wake of WrestleMania 40 and during John Cena's retirement tour, but attendance numbers and viewership have held steady throughout the year.

In other words, there isn't enough of an incentive for the company to change creatively. There have been brief periods where Raw and SmackDown seem to be firing on all cylinders, but maintaining that momentum has been a constant struggle.

AEW has seen their own uptick in attendance and viewership in 2026, indicating that the product they've presented has panned out and has captured the attention of their audience. There has definitely been a different vibe about AEW this year which has brought about higher fan satisfaction.

AEW has been at its worst in the past when they've worried too much about competing with WWE instead of being the best alternative they can be. Their shows could be more well rounded and certain criticisms aren't unfounded, but they've finally figured out what they've wanted to be and have established an actual identity for themselves without letting the wrestlers' creative freedom go unchecked.

That isn't to say WWE is "cooked" creatively by any means. It's been a rebuilding year for them, and once they take more risks toward the top of the card as opposed to playing it safe so frequently, they should start to see more fans gravitating back toward their shows.

AEW having such a critically-acclaimed 2026 should motivate WWE to put forth their best product possible next year and get back to what worked so well for them in the first few years of the Triple H regime.

Graham Mirmina, aka Graham "GSM" Matthews, has specialized in sports and entertainment writing since 2010. Visit his website, WrestleRant, and subscribe to his YouTube channel for more wrestling-related content.