Stratton and Green fended off Fallon Henley and Lainey Reid coming out of the break, leaving them reeling entering another timeout.
During the picture-in-picture presentation, however, the heels downed Green and worked over her, isolating her from her partner and seizing control of the bout.
A miscommunication spot created an opening for Green to find space and make a tag to Stratton.
The US champion exploded into the match and took Reid down with the cartwheel Alabama Slam. A Swanton Bomb followed, but Henley rocked her with a hard right hand from out of nowhere.
Green cleared here out of the ring and set up for the Unprettier on Reid. The heel escaped, but only long enough to be slammed from the top rope.
On the floor, Jacy Jayne rocked Green with a Rolling Encore, only to be sent into the guardrail by Stratton. Henley laid out Tiffy Time, then joined Reid for the Fatal Flaw on the women's champion as the heels retained their gold.
After the match, Nia Jax and Lash Legend attacked from out of nowhere, laying the babyfaces out. Jax stood over Green, raising the women's title overhead and seemingly setting up the babyface's first challenger.
An inoffensive match that never really got going because of the ad breaks, it at least put the babyfaces on the defensive while introducing rivalries for both, with Jayne vs. Stratton and Jax vs. Green looking to be on the horizon.
Backstage, a confrontation between Damian Priest, R-Truth, and The War Raiders ended with the revelation that the WWE Tag Team Champions will defend their gold against Erik and Ivar, as well as the MTFs, next week.