2011 NFL Draft: Critiquing Mel Kiper's Top 25 Big Board

Wes ODonnell@wesodonnellFeatured ColumnistMarch 10, 2011

2011 NFL Draft: Critiquing Mel Kiper's Top 25 Big Board

0 of 25

    NEW YORK - APRIL 28:  Mel Kiper, Chris Mortensen and Keyshawn Johnson broadcast for ESPN during the 2007 NFL Draft on April 28, 2007 at Radio City Music Hall in New York, New York. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images)
    Chris McGrath/Getty Images

    We all know him, we all get tired of hearing him gush over certain players, but we have no choice but to respect Mel Kiper Jr.

    Without Mel the NFL Draft coverage would not be what it is today and I most certainly would not get the privilege to write NFL Draft articles all day (it is true, this is what I do) and without Kiper people would not care for an event that actually has no physical activity (unless of course you count a team representative sprinting to the podium because the prior team got skipped).

    He is the unquestioned leader of the NFL Draft world and while it may be because ESPN is seen by way too many people in way too many ways, he's still one of the best.

    Even so, he is not always right (he could argue against that) and the beauty of the NFL Draft is that we can debate players forever.

    His new mock draft is up as is his new big board and here is look at how things stack up between me and Mel.

1. Patrick Peterson: CB, LSU

1 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - MARCH 1: Defensive back Patrick Peterson of LSU warms up before running a drill during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 28, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    No argument from me here.

    Patrick Peterson is easily my favorite prospect in this Draft and I believe he is a true "can't miss" prospect.

    He runs like a sprinter, is the size of a safety, has ball skills like a receiver and brings added versatility as the nation's best return man.

    My only question to Mel, why did it take so long to move him to No. 1?

2. Nick Fairley: DT, Auburn

2 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 28:  Defensive lineman Nick Fairley of Auburn looks on during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 28, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    The Auburn defensive tackle is the most disruptive player in the nation. 

    He's a tremendous athlete for his size, plays with a mean streak and can change the momentum of a game in a single play.

    I love him as a player but I am not all there on considering him the No. 2 overall prospect.

    The character issues and work ethic questions bother me too much.

3. Marcell Dareus: DT, Alabama

3 of 25

    TUSCALOOSA, AL - OCTOBER 16:  Marcell Dareus #57 of the Alabama Crimson Tide against the Ole Miss Rebels at Bryant-Denny Stadium on October 16, 2010 in Tuscaloosa, Alabama.  (Photo by Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images)
    Kevin C. Cox/Getty Images

    Dareus is an awesome athlete and really wowed at the Combine.

    His lateral agility, top-end speed and overall athleticism are tremendous and he has the versatility to play inside or outside in certain schemes.

    Kiper's right on this one for sure.

    Dareus has the potential to be a star and he'll be a high selection on Draft day.

4. Von Miller: OLB, Texas A&M

4 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 28: Von Miller of Texas A&M works out during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 28, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    Von Miller is simply a solid all-around prospect that has been at the top of this class since the season ended.

    He is a dynamic sack artist off the edge but is also very capable in coverage and seems to be ready to begin his life as an outside linebacker in the NFL.

    Miller has blazing speed for the position and has the chance to be drafted very high; he is a top five prospect.

5. Da'Quan Bowers: DE, Clemson

5 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 28: Defensive lineman Da'Quan Bowers of Clemson looks on during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 28, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    The Clemson defensive end led the nation in sacks, has a good combination of size, speed and power and fits the best in a 4-3 in my mind.

    Still has to work out and teams will be interested to see how he moves after the injury.

    He is a top 10 prospect with the potential to go No. 1 overall so sitting at Kiper's No. 5 spot is a pretty solid grade.

6. A.J. Green: WR, Georgia

6 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 27: Wide receiver A.J. Green of Georgia runs through a drill during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 27, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    An average Combine workout has brought A.J. Green back down to earth a little bit (Julio Jones dominant performance did not help too much either) but he is still one of the top prospects in this Draft.

    His size and speed are good but his playmaking ability is incredible and he runs great routes for a younger player.

    He is a top-five prospect (on my board) that should last no longer that No. 6 overall on Draft day.

    Not too much to get after Mel for in these first six players.

7. Robert Quinn: DE/OLB, UNC

7 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 28:  Defensive lineman Robert Quinn of North Carolina runs through a drill during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 28, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    This is an interesting one.

    Robert Quinn has not played football in over a year; he's very young and has a lot of raw talent about his game.

    He can be a dynamic pass rusher off the edge and was a nightmare for opposing quarterbacks.

    Many expected him to blow up the Combine and he turned in good (but not great) numbers overall.

    He's got a ton of upside and I like him overall, but I think No. 7 is a bit high when there are quality, proven players below him.

8. Blaine Gabbert: QB, Missouri

8 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 25:  Missouri Tigers quarterback Blaine Gabbert answers questions during a media session at the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 25, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    The Missouri quarterback's final take from me (and pretty much everyone else) will not be made until he throws on the 17th of March.

    He's got a lot of positive things to his game, is above-average athlete and Kiper commended his choice on the Combine by saying he was "smart not to throw in Indy."

    He may be right about that but I have always loved to see a player that wants to compete, especially at quarterback.

    I do not see what makes Gabbert special and think he has the potential to be a good quarterback that could win games in the NFL but do not think he is elite; No. 8 is too high for me even if I think he will go in the top seven picks.

9. Prince Amukamara: CB, Nebraska

9 of 25

    LINCOLN, NE - OCTOBER 30: Cornerback Prince Amukamara #21 of the Nebraska Cornhuskers breaks up a pass intended for wide receiver T.J. Moe #28 of the Missouri Tigers during first half action of their game at Memorial Stadium on October 30, 2010 in Lincoln
    Eric Francis/Getty Images

    Solid all-around prospect with the potential to be a shutdown corner.

    Amukamara ran much faster than I expected to see him run in Indianapolis and that was the only question I had about his game.

    He covers with a veteran's savvy, is willing in the run game and can effectively take away a team's best receiver.

    Kiper's right about him and said he's "ready to start at corner" and that is true.

10. Cam Newton: QB, Auburn

10 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 27: Cam Newton passes the ball during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 27, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    I have Cam higher than this based on potential alone and am not willing to let Gabbert rank ahead of him.

    Cam's physical tools are unmatched, he is continuing to improve as this draft season goes along and his tape alone speaks volumes of his ability on the field.

    There are a lot of teams that use more shotgun sets than in years past and Cam will find a way to make a difference on the field.

    If he truly dedicates himself to the NFL game than he will be a star and right now I would have to rank him higher than Gabbert.

11. J.J. Watt: DE, Wisconsin

11 of 25

    PASADENA, CA - JANUARY 01:  Defensive lineman J.J. Watt #99 of the Wisconsin Badgers rushes the TCU Horned Frogs in the 97th Rose Bowl game on January 1, 2011 in Pasadena, California.  (Photo by Stephen Dunn/Getty Images)
    Stephen Dunn/Getty Images

    Watt is a tremendous player that burst onto the scene this year but Mel has been a lot higher on him than most.

    He's got a tremendous motor for his size, has great athleticism and provides teams with the versatility to play him on the inside or the outside.

    He's a smart player that has a lot going for him but I cannot rank him ahead of players like Cameron Jordan, Mark Ingram or Julio Jones.

    No. 11 is a bit too high Mel, but we know that you like to jump on certain players.

12. Mark Ingram: RB, Alabama

12 of 25

    INDIANAPOLIS, IN - FEBRUARY 27: Running back Mark Ingram of Alabama runs with the ball during the 2011 NFL Scouting Combine at Lucas Oil Stadium on February 27, 2011 in Indianapolis, Indiana. (Photo by Joe Robbins/Getty Images)
    Joe Robbins/Getty Images

    Ingram is simply a complete running back that will do everything asked of him.

    He is my early favorite for offensive rookie of the year regardless of where he goes because of his all-around production and I have him as my No. 10 player overall.

    Cannot blame Mel on this one, he's a consensus top 10-15 player and Mel grades him in that range.

    Mark Ingram is going to be a stud.

13. Julio Jones: WR, Alabama

13 of 25

    ORLANDO, FL - JANUARY 01: Julio Jones #8 of the Alabama Crimson Tide stiffarms Chris Rucker #29 of  the Michigan State Spartans during the Capitol One Bowl at the Florida Citrus Bowl on January 1, 2011 in Orlando, Florida.  (Photo by Mike Ehrmann/Getty Im
    Mike Ehrmann/Getty Images

    I certainly cannot argue with Julio's placement at this point but his durability is a bit of a concern and Mel noted that as well.

    When he is healthy he is a beast and can take over a game when he gets going.

    He put up a tremendous workout in Indianapolis (better than I anticipated and that is saying something) and I expect he grabbed the attention of any team thinking receiver in the slightest.

    Jones is without question a top 15 talent.

14. Cameron Jordan: DE, California

14 of 25

    BERKELEY, CA - OCTOBER 09:  Kevin Price #4 of the UCLA Bruins is tackled by Cameron Jordan #97 of the California Golden Bears at California Memorial Stadium on October 9, 2010 in Berkeley, California.  (Photo by Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images)
    Jed Jacobsohn/Getty Images

    This defensive end prospect just continues to impress teams every time they get a chance to look at him.

    He was virtually unblockable at the Senior Bowl, he showed impressive athleticism at the Combine and, even if it was just field drills at his Pro Day, he had teams and scouts drooling once again.

    He's long, athletic and can shift inside on passing downs in addition to coming off the edge.

    I do not think he will be an insanely dynamic sack artist and I think that is what is holding him out of the top 10; I would rate him higher than Watt though.

15. Muhammad Wilkerson: DT, Temple

15 of 25

    This one is a bit surprising to me.

    A lot of people are high on Muhammad Wilkerson but this is very, very high.

    Proven defensive standouts like Ryan Kerrigan and Adrian Clayborn sit on the board still and while Wilkerson is a very talented kid, I cannot put him in front of either player.

    Mel said, "thought he could be top-10 pick next year, getting close for 2011."

    He's an impressive, scheme-versatile prospect best suited as a 3-4 defensive end, but he's not a top 15 player on my board.

16. Corey Liuget: DT, Illinois

16 of 25

    Another lesser-known name that both Mel (and Todd McShay) are very, very high on.

    Liuget tested well every time we have gotten a chance to see him, has the ability to play both the run and the pass and is a disruptive force on the inside.

    He's a bit shorter than I'd like (6'2") but he does play with good leverage and he could find a home in the first round. I am not sold on him being a better player than a number of the guys ranked below him on Mel's board though.

17. Aldon Smith: DE/OLB, Missouri

17 of 25

    COLUMBIA, MO - OCTOBER 23: Aldon Smith #85 of the Missouri Tigers in action against the Oklahoma Sooners at Faurot Field/Memorial Stadium on October 23, 2010 in Columbia, Missouri.  The Tigers beat the Sooners 36-27.  (Photo by Dilip Vishwanat/Getty Image
    Dilip Vishwanat/Getty Images

    This is another interesting kid.

    Smith is an extremely raw, but athletic pass rushing force that will make his living off the edge.

    He does not completely wow me though and a lot of his stock is heavily leaning towards potential rather than substance.

    Too many times do players of this type not completely work out and while I do think he will go in the first round the No. 17 prospect is a bit too high for me.

18. Tyron Smith: OT, USC

18 of 25

    LOS ANGELES, CA - SEPTEMBER 26:   Quarterback Matt Barkley #7 of the USC Trojans throws a pass as Tyron Smith #70 blocks Jesse Feagin #98 of  the Washington State Cougars during the second quarter of the college football game at the Los Angeles Memorial C
    Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images

    This is a very solid rank for Tyron Smith in my opinion.

    He has the potential to be the only elite offensive tackle in this class but still needs time. He put on weight from end of the season to the Combine and looks very good physically.

    Smith spent time on the right side of the line in college but will be tried as a left tackle almost immediately.

    I think he could get drafted higher than this but it is a very fair grade for him overall.

19. Jimmy Smith: CB, Colorado

19 of 25

    AUSTIN, TX - OCTOBER 10: Cornerback Jimmy Smith #3 of the Colorado Buffaloes picks up the loose ball which was knocked out of the hand of quarterback Colt McCoy of the Texas Longhorns as he rolled out in the second quarter on October 10, 2009 at Darrell K
    Brian Bahr/Getty Images

    Tons and tons of potential, rare size/speed combination, but far too many red flags for me to grade him in the first round.

    The talent is there but questions marks surrounding him off the field as well as work ethic on the field are troublesome.

    If a team is confident enough in its coaching staff and/or veteran leadership I have no problem with them taking a shot on him but I would not grade him in the first round.

20. Ryan Kerrigan: DE/OLB, Purdue

20 of 25

    WEST LAFAYETTE, IN - SEPTEMBER 20:  Quarterback Dan LeFevour #13 of the Central Michigan Chippewas is tackled by Ryan Kerrigan #94 of the Purdue Boilermakers at Ross-Ade Stadium on September 20, 2008 in West Lafayette, Indiana.  (Photo by Ronald Martinez/
    Ronald Martinez/Getty Images

    Kerrigan is a hard working, relentless pass rusher that surprised me with his overall athleticism in Indianapolis.

    Placing him at No. 20 grabs no argument from me because he will have to find a permanent position.

    He may be too light to anchor in a 4-3 but he should be able to make an impact regardless and whatever team takes him will be very happy.

21. Nate Solder: OT, Colorado

21 of 25

    BOULDER, CO - OCTOBER 04:  Brian Orakpo #98 of the Texas Longhorns rushes against Nate Solder #78 the Colorado Buffaloes at Folsom Field on October 4, 2008 in Boulder, Colorado. Texas defeated Colorado 38-14.  (Photo by Doug Pensinger/Getty Images)
    Doug Pensinger/Getty Images

    Nate Solder is such an intriguing prospect but he has as much bust potential as he does boom.

    He could develop into a franchise tackle or he could be moved around the line.

    He has an impressive frame and moves really well but he has not dominated the way I'd like and if I was to move Solder at all it would be down no lower than 25.

22. Anthony Castonzo: OT, Boston College

22 of 25

    CHESTNUT HILL, MA - OCTOBER 03:  Anthony Castonzo #74 of the Boston College Eagles congratulates teammate Montel Harris #2 after Harris scored a touchdown in the first quarter against the Florida State Seminoles on October 3, 2009 at Alumni Stadium in Che
    Elsa/Getty Images

    In contrast to Solder, Castonzo is a "what you see is what you get type guy."

    He's an extremely polished technician, has the versatility to shift around the line and has solid athleticism overall.

    Castonzo plays like a lineman and knows what he is doing at the position; he's the safest of the tackles in my book.

23. Gabe Carimi: OT, Wisconsin

23 of 25

    IOWA CITY, IA - OCTOBER 23: Offensive lineman Gabe Carimi #68 of the Wisconsin Badgers holds the Heartland Trophy with his teammates as they celebrate their victory of the University of Iowa Hawkeyes at Kinnick Stadium on October 23, 2010 in Iowa City, Io
    David Purdy/Getty Images

    Fantastic production out of big school, Carimi also showed me better athleticism than I expected in Indianapolis.

    He truly has the ability to play almost any position, was very consistent and although he may never be a franchise left tackle he will certainly be a very effective lineman for a long time.

    No. 23 is a fair ranking for a kid who can make the whole line better.

24. Adrian Clayborn: DE, Iowa

24 of 25

    TEMPE, AZ - DECEMBER 28:  Defensive end Adrian Clayborn #94 of the Iowa Hawkeyes in action during the Insight Bowl against the Missouri Tigers at Sun Devil Stadium on December 28, 2010 in Tempe, Arizona. The Hawkeyes defeated the Tigers 27-24.  (Photo by
    Christian Petersen/Getty Images

    Early season top 10 prospect that did not completely play up to potential in the beginning of the season.

    Clayborn will not fall too far, though, as his toughness, versatility, speed and disruptiveness are hard to come by.

    May not be a dynamic sack artist but he wears down lineman and keeps it coming all game long.

    Mel's got a good beat on him and No. 24 is a solid ranking.

25. Stephen Paea: DT, Oregon State

25 of 25

    PALO ALTO, CA - NOVEMBER 27:  Stephen Paea #54 of the Oregon State Beavers loses his helmet as he tackles Tyler Gaffney #25 of the Stanford Cardinal at Stanford Stadium on November 27, 2010 in Palo Alto, California.  (Photo by Ezra Shaw/Getty Images)
    Ezra Shaw/Getty Images

    The Combine's new bench press record holder is more than just a strong man, he can play football too.

    I am a fan of Stephen Paea and think he has the potential to make a solid impact in the NFL as a rock on the interior of someone's line.

    He plays with tremendous strength (obviously), uses his leverage to his advantage and is one of two run-stuffing tackles that could go in the first round.

    No. 25 is a bit high for me at the moment but there is sound argument for him being a first round player.


The latest in the sports world, emailed daily.