Brandon Davies and BYU: What About the Past?

Fantasy GuidelineContributor IIIMarch 10, 2011

LAS VEGAS, NV - JANUARY 05:  Brandon Davies #0 of the Brigham Young University Cougars shoots against Derrick Jasper #5 of the UNLV Rebels during their game at the Thomas & Mack Center January 5, 2011 in Las Vegas, Nevada. BYU won 89-77.  (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)
Ethan Miller/Getty Images

As March Madness turns the corner and teams prepare to join the dance, there are a lot of new teams who find themselves among the top, and many surprising teams who have knocked down the powerhouses.

Leading the way among the new teams reaching the top are BYU and San Diego St, and in both head-to-head matchups with these two teams, BYU came out on top. One of the most surprising teams this year has been St John's, who knocked off the likes of Duke, Pittsburgh, Georgetown and Villanova while catching the attention of college basketball fans across the country.

While we've all heard of BYU and San Diego St.'s Cinderella seasons, on a player aspect we've really heard of the NCAA's scoring leader, Jimmer Fredette, who just so happens to play for BYU.

While Fredette has been BYU's lead man, he's also had another big time player beside him in Brandon Davies. Davies, a sophomore, averaged 11 points and six rebounds a game this season. Davies not only helped Fredette rise but has also been a main factor in helping BYU reach a top five spot in the rankings, before losing to New Mexico.

Davies, was dismissed from the team due to an honor code violation in which he had premarital sex with his girlfriend, which is against the Mormon faith. BYU, is a Mormon-based university. 

After the loss to New Mexico, in which Davies did not play, BYU fell to No. 8 in the rankings and lost hope of a No. 1 seed.

While all students and student-athletes do sign an honor code before attending BYU, religion and sports should never mix. BYU should run its program by university standards, but they should not affect a student-athlete's athletic career.

It is right to honor you school, but how strict should the code be? Davies has already been dismissed from the basketball team, yet he is still fighting to remain a student at BYU.

The honor code has effected not only Davies, but it has also hurt the BYU basketball program, and while blame is to be on Davies, is this honor code to much?

During the time in which BYU is recruiting a student-athlete, one must feel that the honor code is brought to the student's attention.  If it has been presented, is BYU at a disadvantage when scouting players?

Davies is not the first ever NCAA student-athlete to violate his school's honor code and he certainly should have been aware of the consequences that would lie ahead.

NFL player Tim Tebow, who is very strong in his faith, and NBA star Amar'e Stoudemire, who has taken time out of his life to learn about other faith practices, have both came out and said it best when defending Davies saying, "A young kid in that situation deserves a second chance."

While BYU heads to the dance, Davies heads to find about his future at BYU. Sports and religion should not be mixed, but a school still deserves to have an honor code, a certain line should be made.

BYU won their MWC championship, and BYU coach Dave Rose broke the school's ruling of Davies not be allowing to represent the team, when he allowed Davies to cut down the net after the Cougars' championship win.

As Rose gave hope to Davies coming back next season, BYU fans cheered, as they should. A young student-athlete who has violated an honor code, should be given a second chance, for his own honor.

Visit the site that made this article happen.

Related

    Payton Pritchard, No. 10 Oregon Upset No. 5 Michigan in 71-70 OT Win

    College Basketball logo
    College Basketball

    Payton Pritchard, No. 10 Oregon Upset No. 5 Michigan in 71-70 OT Win

    Tyler Conway
    via Bleacher Report

    USC Gets Notice of Allegations

    College Basketball logo
    College Basketball

    USC Gets Notice of Allegations

    Paul Kasabian
    via Bleacher Report

    Which Undefeated Team Falls Next?

    Do any of the five remaining unbeatens have a shot at perfection?

    College Basketball logo
    College Basketball

    Which Undefeated Team Falls Next?

    Kerry Miller
    via Bleacher Report

    5-Star SG's Unique Journey

    No. 11 prospect Josh Christopher's path to becoming the next great hooper from LA ➡️

    College Basketball logo
    College Basketball

    5-Star SG's Unique Journey

    Eric Yeboah
    via Bleacher Report