Alabama Football: 10 Best Players in Crimson Tide History
TUSCALOOSA, Ala. — The tricky part about trying to name the best players in University of Alabama football history is determining what standard to use.
You're talking about a program that dates back to 1892 and boasts of having 119 players who were named first-team All-American 153 times, and 239 players who landed all-conference honors 319 times.
Alabama has won so many trophies that a couple of years ago the Bryant Museum ran a humorous ad campaign about what the Crimson Tide use some of them for (paper weights, back scratcher, door jam, etc.).
But just how do you define "best"?
Do you base it on statistics? Would a player have had to been named an All-American or to a Hall of Fame to be considered? How do you compare players from different eras?
Would being the biggest icon count? If so, quarterback Joe Namath would have to be included, and probably Kenny Stabler as well, even though neither is in the College Football Hall of Fame.
Most awards? There would have to be a place for offensive lineman Barrett Jones.
Continual success? Quarterback AJ McCarron and linebacker Woodrow Lowe would be right there.
Consequently, if 100 different people did this list, there would be 100 different results. I encourage you to do your own and compare.
For this article, the standard is simple. It's the equivalent of being on a playground picking teams. These are the ones I'd want—the players who have to be considered among the best to ever play for the Crimson Tide.
10. Harry Gilmer
During World War II, Harry Gilmer headed up what was called "The War Babies," a group of players who, for the most part, couldn't serve in the military. He went on to have a prestigious career, and renowned sportswriter Grantland Rice called him, "the greatest college passer I’ve ever seen."
His sophomore year, he led the nation in passing touchdowns (13) and was second in total offense (1,457 yards). His junior year, Gilmer led the nation in punt returns with a 14.5 average on 37 returns.
The Washington Redskins drafted Gilmer, the 1946 Rose Bowl MVP, with the first overall pick in 1948.
Gilmer ended his career as Alabama's all-time leader in rushing (1,673), passing (2,894), punt returns (13.5 average), kickoff returns (28.7) and interceptions. He also passed for 26 touchdowns and ran for 24 more.
9. Don Hutson
Approximately 50 years before Jerry Rice changed the way the wide receiver position was played, Don Hutson revolutionized it first at both the collegiate and professional levels.
With deceptive speed, Hutson was considered the pioneer of modern pass patterns. He was the first to perfect the technique of catching a pass "in traffic" and made the end-around a potent weapon.
"For every pass I caught in a game, I caught a thousand in practice," Hutson once said.
Hutson played 11 years in the NFL with Green Bay, 1935-45, was All-Pro nine times, led the league in pass receptions eight times and in scoring five times, and was twice named MVP (1941-42). He finished his pro career with 488 pass receptions, more than 200 more than the next-best player.
His 99 career touchdown receptions stood as an NFL record for more than four decades, and his mark of 29 points in a game has yet to be broken.
8. Cornelius Bennett
In 1986, Cornelius Bennett notched what's simply known by Alabama fans as "The Sack" against Notre Dame, which remains one of the most famous plays in Crimson Tide history.
Bennett was a three-time All-Southeastern Conference selection and two-time All-American, and he was named Defensive Player of the Game at both the 1985 Aloha Bowl and the 1986 Sun Bowl. His senior year, he compiled 61 tackles, 10 sacks and six forced fumbles en route to unanimous All-America honors, in addition to finishing seventh in Heisman Trophy voting and receiving the Lombardi Award given to the nation's top lineman.
For his collegiate career, Bennett tallied 287 tackles, 21.5 sacks and three fumble recoveries.
He then went on to have an illustrious pro career playing in four consecutive Super Bowls with the Buffalo Bills (1990-93) and a fifth with the Atlanta Falcons (1998).
7. Amari Cooper
Nick Saban ran out of good things to say about Amari Cooper during his final season at Alabama (2014).
"Amari is not worthy of anyone comparing him to anybody else," the head coach said. "He is Amari Cooper. He has his own style. He's a very competitive guy who works really, really hard. Has really good speed getting in and out of breaks. Works hard in the game to get open. Does a good job of executing, has made a lot of really big plays for us this year.
"He's certainly been a dynamic player for our team and has made a great contribution to our season."
With 124 receptions for 1,727 yards and 16 touchdowns, Cooper set numerous single-season Crimson Tide records (many career marks as well) and put up most of his biggest numbers against some of the best pass defenses in college football.
At the end of the regular season, he had faced seven of the top 50, including two in the top 10 and three in the top 20. In those seven games, he caught 69 passes (9.9 per game) for 1,041 yards (148.7 yards) with 10 touchdowns. Cooper had three 200-yard performances.
Against the six opponents ranked in the Associated Press poll, he caught 58 passes for 756 yards and seven touchdowns, averaging 9.7 catches and 126 yards.
Consequently, he was the first Crimson Tide player, and just second in SEC history, to win the Biletnikoff Award as the nation's top receiver.
6. Mark Ingram Jr.
It was only 74 years in the making, but Mark Ingram Jr. won Alabama's first Heisman Trophy after helping the Crimson Tide finish the regular season undefeated en route to the national championship.
Ingram tallied 1,648 rushing yards to set the Alabama single-season record, and 1,992 all-purpose yards while scoring 20 touchdowns. He had nine 100-yard games, including a season-high and Bryant-Denny Stadium-record 246 yards against No. 22 South Carolina on October 17.
That game, when he handled the ball on every play during the Crimson Tide's game-clinching drive, and the screen pass against Florida proved to be his signature moments.
He also had only one career lost fumble and 1,002 yards after contact (53.7 percent). Moreover, he had 825 rushing yards and six touchdowns in Alabama's five games against Top 25 teams, averaging 165 yards per game against Virginia Tech, Mississippi, South Carolina, LSU and Florida.
In those same games, he averaged 201.1 all-purpose yards.
5. Lee Roy Jordan
While there have been numerous Crimson Tide players who have placed high in voting for the Heisman Trophy, one of the most impressive was Lee Roy Jordan's fourth-place showing in 1962 as a center and linebacker.
He was one of the leaders of Paul "Bear" Bryant's first national championship in 1961, when opponents combined to score just 25 points. For his senior season, 1962, he was a unanimous All-American selection. Alabama went 10-1 with a 17-0 victory over Oklahoma in the Orange Bowl, where Jordan made 30 tackles.
"He was one of the finest football players the world has ever seen," Bryant once said of Jordan. "If runners stayed between the sidelines, he tackled them. He never had a bad day; he was 100 percent every day in practice and in the games."
Jordan became a key part of the Doomsday Defense with the Dallas Cowboys. He played 14 seasons in the NFL, became the franchise's all-time leader in solo tackles with 743, helped lead the Cowboys to three Super Bowls and was twice named All-Pro.
4. Ozzie Newsome
Although some consider Ozzie Newsome the best tight end in NFL history, he first was a wide receiver at Alabama.
As a four-year starter from 1974-77, he set many of the Crimson Tide reception records. Overall, he caught 102 passes for 2,070 yards, with an average gain per pass of 20.3 yards, an SEC record.
In the NFL, "The Wizard of Oz" played in 198 consecutive games with the Cleveland Browns and caught a pass in 150 consecutive games, which was the second-longest streak when he retired as the league's all-time leading tight end in receiving with 662 receptions, 7,980 yards and 47 touchdowns.
Additionally, he won the NFL Players Association's Byron "Whizzer" White award for community service in 1990, four years after being presented the Ed Block Courage Award for continuing to play in spite of injuries.
Newsome is still in football as the general manager of the Baltimore Ravens.
3. John Hannah
Once dubbed the "Best Offensive Lineman of All Time" by Sports Illustrated, John Hannah could easily top this list, especially if his pro career were a contributing factor.
Hannah was an All-American in 1971 and a unanimous selection the following year when he also won the SEC's Jacobs Award as its best blocker, along with Lineman of the Year by the Birmingham Quarterback Club, Atlanta Touchdown Club and Miami Touchdown Club.
After being the fourth overall pick in the 1973 draft, Hannah played his entire professional career with the New England Patriots. He was named All-Pro 10 times (1976-85) and selected for nine Pro Bowls. Other honors included being one of the few players named to an NFL All-Decade Team twice, for the 1970s and 1980s. He was also the top guard listed on the NFL 75th Anniversary All-Time Team in 1994.
Bryant once said of Hannah, "In over 30 years with the game, he's the finest offensive lineman I've ever been around."
2. Derrick Henry
Derrick Henry's legendary stature will likely only grow with time because it's going to take a while for a lot of fans to grasp what he did in 2015.
In addition to taking home Alabama's second Heisman Trophy, Henry was the first to win all three major "player of the year" awards, the Maxwell and Walter Camp being the others. He also won the Doak Walker Award for best running back.
To put that into perspective, consider that Ingram had previously been the only Alabama player to win the Heisman, McCarron had been the lone Maxwell winner, and no one had ever won the Walter Camp. Trent Richardson had been the only Doak Walker winner.
The Southeastern Conference's first 2,000-yard rusher, Henry topped Bo Jackson's numbers and broke some of Herschel Walker's longstanding single-season records, including his mark of 1,891 rushing yards on 385 carries set in 1981.
With 2,219 rushing yards in 2015, he smashed Alabama's single-season rushing record by 540 yards—almost 25 percent of his total—and finished as the program's all-time leading rusher. Henry had 3,591 career yards to top Shaun Alexander's 3,565 (1996-99).
He had 10 100-yard performances in 2015 alone, to set another school record, and his 28 rushing touchdowns shattered the previous SEC record of 23 (Tim Tebow and Tre Mason).
The last time Henry failed to score a touchdown in a game was as a sophomore, against LSU in 2014.
1. Derrick Thomas
On Alabama's all-time sacks list, Derrick Thomas has more than twice as many as the player in second place (52 to Kindal Moorehead's 25 from 1998-2002), and he's first and second in single-season sacks with 27 in 1988 and 18 in 1987.
Sadly, he's not credited with either NCAA record because the NCAA did not start collecting official defensive statistics until 2000.
Alabama's first winner of the Butkus Award for best linebacker in the nation, Thomas was a unanimous All-American in 1988.
When the Kansas City Chiefs made him the fourth overall selection in the 1989 NFL draft, team president Carl Peterson called it a new "beginning" for the organization. Thomas recorded 10 sacks that initial season and was named the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year.
For an encore, he had 20 sacks in 1990, the fifth-best season in NFL history, and set a league single-game record with seven sacks against the Seattle Seahawks.
Even though he died at the young age of 33 after a car accident, he was named an All-Pro three times and to nine Pro Bowls. He established franchise career records for sacks (126.5), safeties (three), fumble recoveries (18) and forced fumbles (45).
The 126.5 sacks were the fourth-highest total ever by a linebacker at the time of his death.
Quotes were obtained firsthand unless otherwise noted.
Christopher Walsh is a lead SEC college football writer. He's also the author of "100 Things Crimson Tide Fans Should Know and Do Before They Die." Follow Christopher on Twitter @WritingWalsh.