Featured Video
Skubal Market Moving Fast ๐Ÿ’จ
Baltimore Orioles v Detroit Tigers
Duane Burleson/Getty Images

MLB Winners and Losers of Tarik Skubal, New York Mets Agreeing to $450M Contract

Kerry MillerNov 22, 2026

The biggest domino of the 2026-27 Major League Baseball offseason has officially fallen, with two-time Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal signing a doubly record-setting nine-year, $450 million deal with the New York Mets.

The news was first broken by New York Post's Jon Heyman, with ESPN's Jeff Passan coming through two minutes later with the contract figures.

There was a report on Friday evening that the Mets had already offered Skubal a nine-year, $400M contract earlier in the offseason. And if that was leaked for the sole purpose of driving Steve Cohen and the Mets to increase their offer, mission accomplished.

Starting out with the blatantly obvious biggest winner, who stand out as the winners and losers of this monumental signing?

We're glad you asked.

Winner: New York Mets

1 of 8
Minnesota Twins v New York Mets

The team that signed Tarik Skubal is one of the winners of Tarik Skubal's signing?

Well, thank goodness you're here, Captain Obvious. We couldn't have solved that one without you.

Perhaps more than anything, though, mediocre starting pitching is what has doomed this team over the past two seasons.

You would think that for the sheer amount of money they spend on their roster, the Mets would have someone other than Nolan McLean in their starting rotation worth building around.

But while a Yankees-Dodgers World Series rematch would hypothetically feature a Game 4 duel between Carlos Rodรณn and Tyler Glasnow, the Mets were (prior to signing Skubal) looking at either Christian Scott or Zac Thornton as their Game 2 starter, with possibly both Kodai Senga and Sean Manaea rounding out the rotation.

They simply had to do something drastic, which is why seemingly everyone in the tea-leaf-reading business reached an unspoken agreement a few weeks ago that the Mets were the clear favorite to sign Skubal.

Even talk of the Blue Jays, Padres and "mystery teams" as interested parties felt like red herrings, meant to drive up the price that New York was inevitably going to pay.

Now, let's see if it works out better for them than that time they gave both Max Scherzer and Justin Verlander a $43.3M salary in advance of a fire sale for the ages.

Loser: Future of the Mets, If a Salary Cap Is Coming

2 of 8
New York Mets v Washington Nationals

Rob Manfred and Major League Baseball keep saying that the owners are united and steadfast in their demand for a salary cap in these CBA negotiations.

But does anyone honestly believe that the Dodgers and the Mets want that to happen? After all the future spending they've already done over the past half-decade?

Maybe the biggest question of this whole ordeal has been: How do they handle these gargantuan contracts, when guys like Shohei Ohtani, Juan Soto, Aaron Judge and now Tarik Skubal are single-handedly due more than 15 percent of the proposed salary cap?

Can't void contracts already signed, and can't imagine other owners are going to be on board with just sort of grandfathering in a few superstar contracts to help out the traditional big spenders.

So, with the addition of Skubal's $50M salary, the 2028 Mets have a tax payroll in which Skubal, Bo Bichette, Francisco Lindor, Marcus Semien and Devin Williams are at a combined sum of $216.1M in 2028. If they have to somehow fit that under a $258.2M ceiling, that leaves them $42.1M to fill out the rest of the roster?

Sure, OK. That sounds fun.

Whatever the future picture looks like, though, Steve Cohen and Co. went into these talks with Skubal, knowing full well that a salary cap was the league's goal, and they still saw fit to squeeze one more blockbuster in under the wire.

It makes them one of the top teams to beat in 2027. But if MLB gets its way this winter, the Mets could be in a really tough spot from there.

Winner: The Next Crop of Elite Free Agent Pitchers

3 of 8
St. Louis Cardinals v Pittsburgh Pirates

Next winter's class of free agent starting pitchers is looking underwhelming, at least in the "young enough to sign a massive contract" division. Joe Ryan (in advance of his age-32 season) and Logan Gilbert (in advance of his age-31 season) will certainly generate a lot of interest, but nothing compared to Skubal's market.

Similar story the following offseason, where George Kirby, Hunter Brown and Reid Detmers are looking like the biggest draws under the age of 33.

Three years from now, though, is when Paul Skenes will hit the open market for the first time, assuming he doesn't sign a long-term extension before then.

And while Skubal is already 30, Skenes won't turn 28 until two months into the first season of his new contractโ€”quite the byproduct of making his MLB debut 10 months after getting drafted.

Two years after that is when the 2026 Cy Young winners, Cam Schlittler and Jacob Misiorowski are scheduled to hit free agency.

We shall see what happens between now and their respective times to cash in. Skenes already had a much less impressive season in 2026 than he did in 2024-25, and the ongoing CBA negotiations could result in a new cap-driven world in which $40M+ salaries simply don't exist.

But it does feel like one of those three is likely to be the next "got to have him" pitcher up for grabs, and Skubal resetting the bar with this mammoth contract ought to pay dividends for the superstar arm that follows him.

Loser: Previous Record Holders

4 of 8
National League Championship Series: Los Angeles Dodgers v Milwaukee Brewers - Game Two

Excluding Shohei Ohtani, the previous largest contract ever signed with a pitcher was Yoshinobu Yamamoto's 12-year, $325M deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers.

Moreover, excluding Ohtani again, the largest AAV on a pitcher's contract was the $43.3M marks that both Justin Verlander and Max Scherzer received from the Mets earlier this decade.

Both of those records now belong to Skubal at $450M and $50M, respectively.

Thanks to inflation, those records are, of course, made to be broken. Yamamoto broke Gerrit Cole's record, who broke Stephen Strasburg's record, who broke David Price's record and so on and so forth. (Remember when Barry Zito getting a seven-year, $126M deal was an historic investment?)

But could you imagine if Yamamoto had signed something like a three-year, $84M deal instead and was also a free agent right now, two years younger than Skubal and only slightly less dominant over the past three seasons?

Could he have signed basically the same contract that Skubal did?

Perhaps even a slightly more lucrative one?

Yamamoto does have the ability to opt out after 2029โ€”which could make for a wild winter with both him and Paul Skenes (and Elly De La Cruz) availableโ€”but it feels like he is being woefully underpaid at this point, with an AAV roughly 60 percent of Skubal's.

It was a nice three-year run with the crown of highest-paid pitcher, though. He certainly backed it up with his postseason prowess, especially in 2025.

Winner: Teams with Controllable Starting Pitchers to Trade

5 of 8
Seattle Mariners v Los Angeles Angels

Now that the biggest ace is off the board, it's time for the Dodgers, Blue Jays, Padres and others to start more earnestly calling the teams who might be willing to trade them an arm to help fill that void instead.

Seattle already parted with Bryce Miller and Logan Evans and surely won't be unloading Logan Gilbert or George Kirby at this point.

Dreams of getting Joe Ryan away from the Twins also vanished in the instant that they signed Sonny Gray to a two-year deal, announcing their intention to contend in 2027.

There are still plenty of options, though.

Reid Detmers has two years of arbitration eligibility remaining, with the Angels presumably at least willing to listen to offers in their current state.

Drew Rasmussen is owed $20M in 2027, but the Rays could be willing to unload that salary for the right package. In San Diego, in particular, he could be the Opening Day starter for less than half the cost of one year of Skubal.

The Yankees have an excess of starting pitchers and ought to be willing to move at least one of Ryan Weathers, Will Warren or Luis Gil.

Or in the "buy low candidate with multiple years of control left" department, Pittsburgh's Mitch Keller, Atlanta's Spencer Strider and Cincinnati's Andrew Abbott could all be prime targets.

Even though we're talking about teams that theoretically had room in their budget to sign Skubal, trading for 1-3 years of any of those pitchers may well be preferable to going to five years at $20M+ apiece in a bidding war for Trevor Rogers or Freddy Peralta.

Time to let those proposals fly.

Loser: Remaining Free Agency Buzz

6 of 8
Baltimore Orioles v New York Yankees

On the free agency front, it has been 'Skubal this' and 'Skubal that' since the offseason began.

That's partially because he is such an incredible talent, but perhaps more so because of the lack of other must-have players in this free agency cycle.

When the Mets whiffed on Kyle Tucker last year, they quickly pivoted to Bo Bichette, also making him one of the nine players who received a nine-figure contract. It was the fifth consecutive offseason in which teams invested a combined sum of at least $2.9 billion in free agents.

This winter, though, Skubal plausibly could be the only player who signs for at least $100M.

There are several candidates to join him in that clubโ€”namely Randy Arozarena, Seiya Suzuki, Teruaki Sato, Freddy Peralta and Trevor Rogersโ€”but there's no guarantee any of them will get nine figures.

Also, when the Mets pivoted from Tucker to Bichette, that was like settling for a grape snow cone after finding out the concession stand was out of cherry syrup. Converselyโ€”and with all due respect to Rogers and Peraltaโ€”pivoting from Skubal to whomever you deem to be the next-best pitcher on the market is like planning on a cherry snow cone and coming away with a small, not even fresh popcorn.

Of course, with the lockout at our doorstep, free agency buzz was about to completely disappear, anyway. But it's just weird that it's not even December and the one big fish in the pond has already been caught.

Winner: Scott Boras, Per Usual

7 of 8
MLB: JUL 17 Tigers at Angels

Shortly after Skubal was dealt to the Dodgers at the trade deadline, Tigers president of baseball operations Scott Harris said they previously tried to get him to sign an extension, only to be informed that Skubal was committed to reaching free agency.

Skubal's agent, Scott Boras, subsequently said that the offer was $75M for four years, and that it came before the first of his back-to-back Cy Young seasons.

Who knows if there were other offers along the way or for precisely what amounts, but the long and short of it is that Skubal (with Boras' guidance) bet on himself, and he has now cashed in to an exponential degree.

Pre-arbitration long-term extensions have become all the rage lately, with guys like Kevin McGonigle, Konnor Griffin and JJ Wetherholt agreeing to eight-year or nine-year deals for north of $100M seemingly an hour after making their MLB debuts.

But Boras typically doesn't let his clients play that game, with the exception of Cooper Pratt this past spring.

It doesn't always pan outโ€”see: Zac Gallenโ€”but Boras strongly encourages his guys to keep their eyes on the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow; to play out their pre-arbitration and arbitration years before really cashing in as soon as they're able to do so.

And now Skubal is one of 45 active players (20 of them represented by Boras) who is making at least $25M per year on a contract of at least five years.

Loser: Los Angeles Dodgers

8 of 8
National League Championship Series: Los Angeles Dodgers v Milwaukee Brewers - Game One

First of all, the best free agent on the market didn't sign with the Los Angeles Dodgers, even though they were trying to sign him.

Did you know that was allowed to happen in today's era of Major League Baseball?

What, they couldn't figure out a way to pay him and his descendants $700M in $3.5M annual installments for the next two centuries, or something comparably enraging to the vast majority of fans?

But the thing that really makes the Dodgers a loser in this bidding war is that they didn't just fail to sign a star player.

They lost him from their roster.

Sure, he was great for those two-plus months in Dodger Blue. He made 10 regular season starts with a 2.61 ERA, as well as two postseason starts with a 2.45 ERA.

[He did take the L in Game 1 of the NLCS, but that was mostly the product of the Dodgers not recording one extra-base hit in that game. Allowing two runs in five innings of work against one of the most potent offenses in the sport is a pretty decent outing.]

They didn't win a ring, though. And considering they were already 10 games up in the NL West when they traded for him, it's not like he was the missing link that got them into the postseason.

Basically, they gave up an upper echelon prospect (Zyhir Hope) and a pair of pitchers (River Ryan and Brady Smith) for nothing. It didn't even give them a leg up in the bidding war.