
We've been reeling all season long from the number of superstar NHL players who have asked to be traded. Going back to the offseason with Connor Hellebuyck and Dylan Larkin and now into the season with Nikita Kucherov, it's staggering to see so many elite players express displeasure with where they are and wanting out.
All while we're witnessing this change of philosophy by players and stars seeking to take control of their situations, we're left wondering... Who's next to ask for a trade?
Now that we're about 20 games into the season and we're starting to see the haves and have-nots starting to establish themselves, we're keeping our eyes fixed on the teams that are falling far back of the packs in their conferences to scout for possibilities.
Some of our choices are based on recent history while others are tied into where their contracts are and when they're expiring. We're kicking ideas around here and wondering aloud if maybe these stars might take inspiration from current trends.
6. Auston Matthews, Toronto Maple Leafs
1 of 6
Let's theorize what a situation where Auston Matthews asked for a trade out of Toronto could look like and what it would mean.
Matthews is captain of the Maple Leafs and their best player and unfortunately, the Leafs are struggling to stay close to their rivals in the Atlantic Division and Eastern Conference yet again. After being part of some great teams that couldn't get over the hump for more than a few seasons in Toronto, the Leafs are looking at potentially being out of the mix for the playoffs again.
Toronto missing the playoffs would normally mean looking ahead to the draft lottery, something that allowed them to luck out and land Gavin McKenna in the 2026 Draft with the No. 1 pick. But the Leafs won't have their own first-round pick in 2027 or 2028 thanks to previous trades. Matthews has one more year left on his contract after this season before potentially becoming an unrestricted free agent and you can see why this situation could get gnarly.
If Matthews wanted a trade, he'd have full control over where he could go thanks to a no-move clause. Aside from the major psychic damage that would come from such a situation for the Leafs, Toronto could look at this as a way to majorly recoup futures (first-round picks, top prospects) and still have a potentially elite player in McKenna to replace Matthews on hand already.
If things keep sliding away for Toronto, you have to wonder if Matthews would want to ride it out or not. Heck, you could make the same argument for William Nylander with the big difference being that his contract goes until 2032.
5. Artemi Panarin, Los Angeles Kings
2 of 6
We've already seen Artemi Panarin get traded a year ago when the New York Rangers sent him to the Los Angeles Kings. While Panarin enjoyed the move enough to sign a two-year extension to stay with L.A., we're guessing he wasn't expecting to see the Kings wind up near the bottom of the Western Conference when he did so.
Panarin is 35 years old and his two-year, $22 million extension isn't exactly cheap. But given his history of offensive production and his continued solid production this season (19 points in 17 games), if the Breadman wanted to get out of Los Angeles to join a more competitive team, who could blame him?
The Kings are in a bit of an awkward transition following Anže Kopitar's retirement and with Drew Doughty at 36 years old in a contract year. They're also a very veteran team and for the handful of top younger players they have (Quinton Byfield, Brandt Clarke), they need more. If Panarin were to ask out, trading him could help make that happen.
4. Elias Pettersson, Vancouver Canucks
3 of 6
We know it feels like Elias Pettersson's name has been in trade rumors for a long time and while that's cooled off since J.T. Miller was traded to the Rangers in February 2025, it has to be tough for Pettersson to see the Canucks be among the league's worst teams yet again this season.
If Pettersson were to want out of Vancouver with five more years left on his contract with an $11.6 million cap hit, it would be equally deflating and sad to see as it would be fascinating to see how that trade would get put together.
This season, Pettersson has had a bit of a return to glory putting up a point per game (23 points in 23 games) after producing at 0.7 points per game the previous two seasons combined. Seeing his production pick up again despite the team's struggles is notable, especially given how much he struggled previously and how foreboding that seemed. A Pettersson resurgence would no doubt help get more teams to the table even with his bulky contract.
3. Jake DeBrusk, Vancouver Canucks
4 of 6
We don't mean to pick on the Canucks, but when a team has struggled as much as they have the past few seasons and with the amount of rumors that swirled, it's inevitable. One of those guys who's been in rumors is Jake DeBrusk and if the power forward wanted to escape Vancouver, there's no doubt the market for him would be busy.
DeBrusk carries a $5.5 million cap hit and a contract that has four more years beyond this one which makes him more than affordable, especially with the cap skyrocketing in coming years. He's scored 20-plus goals in four of the past five seasons and while he's got just 12 points in 21 games this season, his rugged style of play would make him a favorite anywhere in the league.
Given that DeBrusk is 30 years old, that comes with the usual "buyer beware" caveats, especially with him being signed through 2031, his style of play and ability to get to the net would make him plenty attractive. His no-move clause this season would also allow him to pick where he wanted to go...if he wanted to leave.
2. Erik Karlsson, Pittsburgh Penguins
5 of 6
There are a lot of reasons to be bummed out about seeing the Pittsburgh Penguins struggling. Watching superstar veteran players struggle is hard to see and the possibility of those players missing out on the postseason instead of getting one more crack at a Stanley Cup is sad. While we doubt any of Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin or Kris Letang would ask for a trade to go for a shot at one more Stanley Cup, we can't say the same for Erik Karlsson who's still looking for his first.
Karlsson is in the final year of his contract and even though his cap hit is still juicy at $10 million and he has a full no-move clause, he can still play well, move the puck and produce offense from the blue line. He leads the Penguins with 19 points this season (in 20 games) with eight of those points coming on the power play.
Contending teams would love to add a player like Karlsson to make them deeper and it's possible (likely?) that he wouldn't even need to ask for a trade to be moved this season. GM Kyle Dubas has done well with trades the past few seasons and if a contender calls for Karlsson, the only thing that would get in the way of him getting his asking price would be Karlsson nixing the move.
1. Zach Werenski, Columbus Blue Jackets
6 of 6
You have to wonder what's going through Zach Werenski's mind these days.
After an awkward offseason in which he initially asked to be traded and then walked it back after speaking with Blue Jackets management, the 2026 Norris Trophy winner is playing well on a Columbus team that's sunk to the bottom of the Eastern Conference and fighting for air.
Werenski has one more year left on his contract with the Jackets before he can become an unrestricted free agency and with the way Columbus is struggling, you wouldn't be able to blame Werenski if he was already reassessing his desire to stay there.
An elite No. 1 defenseman hitting the trade market would create a frenzy, but Werenski's no-move clause means he would be able to select his destination of choice. Curiously enough, PuckPedia.com shows that Werenski's no-move changes to a 10-team trade list next season. If Werenski pulls the trigger and says he wants out, it would create a potentially fascinating situation.
.jpg?w=2560)




.jpg?w=2560)





.jpg?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)
.jpg?w=2560)