Featured Video
Smith Sets B1G Yards Record 👑 (via @Fox)
Packers Patriots Football
New England Patriots quarterback Drake MayeAP Photo/Charles Krupa

Ranking Patriots QB Options to Replace Injured Drake Maye

Moe MotonNov 16, 2026

The New England Patriots lost starting quarterback Drake Maye on the first drive of their previous game in Munich, Germany, and potentially for the rest of the 2026 season. At 5-5, they still have a shot at the playoffs with a capable fill-in starter.

According to ESPN's Adam Schefter, the Patriots are concerned that Maye fractured his ankle, and he's out indefinitely.

NFL insider Jordan Schultz added that New England will "explore the QB market" while on its Week 11 bye.

While the Patriots mull over the quarterback market, we'll rank their potential options among their backups, free agents, and players they could sign off practice squads. 

These potential fill-in starters have played under Patriots offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels, have a solid history as a backup signal-caller, or offer upside under an experienced play-caller.

5. Nick Mullens

1 of 5
Buccaneers Jaguars Football
Jacksonville Jaguars quarterback Nick Mullens (14)

Nick Mullens is a career backup, though he's started in at least three games in three of his nine NFL seasons, with the San Francisco 49ers (2018 and 2020) and the Minnesota Vikings (2023). He didn't lead either team to the playoffs, but that doesn't mean the experienced signal-caller is incapable of doing so.

Mullens has thrown for 6,448 yards, 34 touchdowns and 31 interceptions with a 66 percent completion rate. If McDaniels can help him limit turnovers, he can be a decent starter in relief.

In his pro career, Mullens has played under respected play-callers, 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan, Vikings lead skipper Kevin O'Connell and currently Jacksonville Jaguars head coach Liam Coen.

Although Mullens wouldn't be a headline signing off the Jaguars' practice squad, he could be an alternative option if the Patriots favor experience.

4. Jake Browning

2 of 5
Chiefs Buccaneers Football
Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Jake Browning (5)

In 2023 and 2025, Jake Browning took over for an injured Joe Burrow. In the first of those two years, he threw for 1,936 yards, 12 touchdowns and seven interceptions with a league-leading 70.4 percent completion rate. The Cincinnati Bengals went 4-3 with him as their starter that year.

Last season, Browning didn't look as sharp filling in for Burrow, throwing for 771 yards, six touchdowns and eight interceptions with a 64.8 percent completion rate. After he made three starts, the Bengals replaced him with Joe Flacco, whom they acquired from the Cleveland Browns.

Still, Browning would bring quality experience, replacing a high-end starter for a team with playoff aspirations. He would be familiar with the pressure in that situation, with 10 career starts in Cincinnati.

New England could sign Browning off the Los Angeles Chargers' practice squad.

3. Will Levis

3 of 5
Bears Titans Football
New York Jets quarterback Will Levis

If the New England Patriots are open to adding a high-upside quarterback, Will Levis may be a top option on their target list.

The Tennessee Titans moved up to select Levis with the first pick in the second round of the 2023 draft. In his first two seasons with the Titans, he threw for 3,899 yards, 21 touchdowns and 16 interceptions with a 61 percent completion rate, but his turnover-prone play and inability to stay healthy cost him the starting job.

Levis is 27, and with only two years of starting experience, he can still develop into a decent starter.

The Patriots can look to Malik Willis and his development with the Green Bay Packers and Miami Dolphins over the last few years as an example of a player who capitalized on new opportunities after a rocky start to his career in Tennessee.

Levi's arm strength and mobility are appealing physical tools that could earn him a shot in New England. The Patriots can sign him off the New York Jets' practice squad.

2. Tommy DeVito

4 of 5
Raiders Patriots Football
New England Patriots quarterback Tommy DeVito (16)

NFL insider Jordan Schultz reported that even though the Patriots will explore quarterback options, backup Tommy DeVito is expected to start in place of Drake Maye, which makes the most sense because he's learned offensive coordinator Josh McDaniels' system over the last two seasons.

In August of 2025, New England claimed DeVito off waivers. He didn't play in any regular-season games until last Sunday in Munich, Germany. The fourth-year pro had a rough outing against the Detroit Lions, throwing for 81 yards, a touchdown and an interception.

However, DeVito should be more prepared following a bye week and a full week of practice with the first-team offense. 

In 2023, DeVito was a serviceable fill-in starter for the New York Giants in place of Daniel Jones, throwing for 1,101 yards, eight touchdowns, and three interceptions with a 64 percent completion rate.

In all likelihood, DeVito will get the first shot at starting at center in Maye's absence.

1. Jimmy Garoppolo

5 of 5
Cardinals Rams Football
Free agent quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo (11)

The Patriots could reunite McDaniels with Jimmy Garoppolo. They started their pro careers in New England and worked together through the 2023 season with the Las Vegas Raiders.

In 2016, Garoppolo showed promise in two starts with the Patriots, throwing for 502 yards and four touchdowns under McDaniels. New England won both games. Yet the club traded him to the San Francisco 49ers the following year, essentially choosing 40-year-old Tom Brady over his potential successor.

Garoppolo went on to have a solid career with the 49ers, throwing for 13,599 yards, 82 touchdowns and 42 interceptions with a 67.6 percent completion rate in six seasons. He also helped lead San Francisco to a Super Bowl appearance but struggled in the playoffs, throwing for four touchdowns and six interceptions with a 60.6 percent completion rate.

After the Raiders released Derek Carr in the 2023 offseason, they signed Garoppolo. At that time, McDaniels was Las Vegas' head coach, so the move made sense. Yet Garoppolo flopped as a starter with the Silver and Black, throwing for 1,205 yards, seven touchdowns and nine interceptions in seven games before the team benched him for Aidan O'Connell.

Nonetheless, if the Patriots want a stopgap quarterback with a wealth of big-game experience, Garoppolo fits the bill, and his familiarity with McDaniels could appeal to the coaching staff. The 35-year-old is an available free agent.

Maurice Moton covers the NFL for Bleacher Report. You can follow him on Twitter @MoeMoton.