Featured Video
Zay Flowers' Fumble in Clutch ๐Ÿ˜ฌ
Monday Night RAW
WWE/WWE via Getty Images

Ranking WWE and AEW's Most Underrated Stars of 2026

Chris MuellerNov 17, 2026

We're closing in on the end of the year, and that means people are going to start looking back at 2026 in different ways.

This past year was an interesting time for pro wrestling. While WWE has been in the news for a lot of reasons, both good and bad, AEW spent most of the year trying to highlight a lot of newer faces in the company.

With so many men and women employed between the two companies, it's never going to be possible for every single person who deserves a push to get one, and that often leads to a lot of people not getting the proper attention.

Whether they are underrated by the fans, management, or in some other way, a lot of people across both companies have been very valuable and deserve more attention in 2027.

This list will be ranked by how underrated someone is in relation to their booking, not against each other.

10. Ricochet

1 of 10

Ricochet came into AEW, quickly turned heel, formed a faction with Bishop Kaun and Toa Liona, and he has been a regular fixture ever since.

Whether Tony Khan needs to have someone win a title, put someone else over, play a villain, or just go out and have a fantastic match, Ricochet is the man for the job.

He has been nothing short of incredible in the ring against a variety of AEW stars, and his heel run has been so entertaining that it makes you wonder why WWE never allowed him to give it a shot.

The only thing holding Ricochet back is available space at the top of the card. He is part of one of the most stacked rosters with a lot of people who have been there longer, so he just needs to be patient and his time will come.

9. Roxanne Perez

2 of 10
SmackDown

Roxanne Perez is nicknamed The Prodigy for a reason. She is way ahead of the curve on in-ring ability, and that has been the case since she got to WWE.

Unfortunately, she has spent most of her time on the main roster playing backup for Liv Morgan in Judgment Day, which means she hasn't had the level of success she deserves yet.

Being the person WWE can rely on to go out and have a good match with anyone while simultaneously being booked to lose constantly is never an ideal situation for a Superstar.

Roxy is good enough to already be in the world title picture, and hopefully, WWE realizes that and acts accordingly next year.

8. LA Knight

3 of 10
WWE: Money In The Bank

LA Knight always seems like he is on the cusp of breaking into the main event scene, but for some reason, WWE has yet to commit.

Whenever WWE needs someone for anything, Knight is a good option. He can work heel or babyface, he is good in the ring, even better on the mic, and the crowd loves him.

When Knight was ranting about how he had been kept down in WWE during his feud with Roman Reigns, there was a seed of truth in those words.

The Megastar could easily be elevated at any time, and hopefully, management decides to do it in 2027. He is 44 years old, so he doesn't have forever to work at this level.

7. Mark Davis

4 of 10

Seeing Mark Davis on this list might surprise some people, but if you look at the year he has had, you will understand why.

Dunkzilla is one of those guys who is so good at everything that it often goes unnoticed because we are so used to it.

When AEW booked him to beat Will Ospreay clean, nobody batted an eye at it because it was believable. When he got paired with Jake Doyle, he instantly became one-half of a physically dominant tag team that squashed The Young Bucks in a match.

Davis had a brief national title run, but he deserves so much more success. He is a unique talent with tons of skill and a unique look. There is no reason why he and Doyle should not be holding the tag titles soon.

6. Chelsea Green

5 of 10
SmackDown

You might be thinking to yourself, "Chelsea Green was just a WWE champion. How can she possibly be underrated?"

The answer is simple if you look at how she got to that point. During an episode of WWE Unreal, Michael Hayes made comments about Green's booking that upset a lot of her fans because it made it sound like she is only good for putting other women, like Tiffany Stratton, over.

And what just happened? She had a three-month reign with the belt that came to an end at Crown Jewel, thanks to none other than Tiffy.

Green is one of the most versatile women in WWE. She's a hard worker, puts everything she has into even the smallest segments, and is more than willing to look foolish if it helps the story. And on top of all that, she's incredibly entertaining.

5. Daniel Garcia

6 of 10

The Death Riders are one of a handful of stables in AEW right now, but they are arguably the top faction in the company.

Jon Moxley has had great success, and so have other members of the group, but one guy who often feels like he is only used to give another team a win is Daniel Garcia.

During Anarchy in the Arena at Full Gear, we got to see just how much the crowd loves this guy when he is having fun. As soon as the crowd started hearing DMX and saw Garcia dancing, everyone erupted in cheers.

He's a technical wizard, he's young with a long career ahead of him, and he can be both funny and intimidating. Danny Boy needs a significant push in 2027 to remind everyone how good he is.

4. Skye Blue

7 of 10

Skye Blue is in a very similar situation to Perez in WWE. She is a talented performer who is popular with fans, but she often ends up being sacrificed so someone else can get over.

Blue has become especially known for her willingness to compete in hardcore matches that usually leave her a bloody mess, and she will sometimes wear white gear just to make sure it stands out more.

The good news is at just 27 years old, she still has a ton of time left to find success. By this time next year, she could easily be the TBS champion and nobody would bat an eye because we all know she would be great at it.

Her team with Thekla and Julia Hart is a lot of fun, but if she needs to go off on her own to get what she deserves, then that is what should happen.

3. Chad Gable

8 of 10
Monday Night RAW

Chad Gable is very well regarded for his in-ring ability, and he had a pretty decent 2026 with his first reign as the intercontinental champion, but it took WWE way too long to get here.

Every single match Gable has had for the belt has stolen the show, and his match with El Grande Americano at TripleMania might end up being the best WWE match of the year when it's all wrapped up.

His ability to be comedic while also being a beast in the ring reminds a lot of people of Kurt Angle, and the fact that both men competed in the Olympics on the U.S. wrestling team draws even more comparisons.

If WWE wanted to, it could elevate Gable to the main event scene and nobody would question it. He would make an incredible underdog world champion if given the opportunity.

2. Athena

9 of 10

Athena is still breaking records as the longest-reigning champion in modern pro wrestling, but she is still massively underrated and underused.

The main issue is that this epic reign has taken place in Ring of Honor. AEW rarely uses her on Dynamite or Collision, but when it does, she always knocks it out of the park.

The Fallen Goddess has done an incredible job with this role. There is no denying that at a time when ROH barely feels relevant, she is the one shining light that keeps a lot of fans tuning in every week.

She deserves a bigger stage, bigger opportunities, and more exposure. She is doing the best work of her career, and so few people get to see it because it's behind a paywall.

1. Carmelo Hayes

10 of 10
Monday Night RAW

For a large portion of 2026, Carmela Hayes was having the best matches in WWE every single week on SmackDown against a variety of opponents, but he did not seem to get as many spots on PLEs as one would hope.

He is currently seeing a renewed push after joining up with Royce Keys in 946, and hopefully this feud against The Bloodline elevates everyone in the group.

Melo is one of those performers who just has that extra layer of shine to him. He's so accurate and so precise that it sometimes feels like his reflexes are on a superhuman level.

Hayes has the ability to steal the show at the drop of a hat, and he often does, so let's hope WWE uses him to his fullest potential in 2027.


The 10 men and women on this list are all talented performers who often feel underrated and underused. Who else do you think deserves better booking in WWE and AEW?