Featured Video
Zay Flowers' Costly Fumble ๐Ÿ˜ฌ

SEC to ESPN: “You're smothering me.”

Fadeproof
Sep 6, 2009

ย by Fadeproof

I, like many college football fans, shuddered at the announcement of the ESPNโ€“SEC television deal. ESPNโ€™s coverage of the SEC has in recent years been fairly over the top, and that was without (I hope) direct financial incentive.
Now the self-proclaimed โ€œWorldwide Leader in Sportsโ€ has a financial interest in making the brand that is the SEC as marketable as possible.

Colour me horrified.

As background, let me explain what I see as the two most prevalent issues with recent SEC media coverage:

SEC Phenomenon One: Any favorable attribute or event associated with any individual team in the SEC is automatically attributed to the fact that that team is in the SEC conference. The most ubiquitous example of this phenomenon is the constant reminders that each SEC team has an โ€œSEC defense.โ€

Here is a typical scenario involving SEC Phenomenon One: An โ€œanalystโ€ states that โ€œTeam A may have a tough time moving the ball against Team Bโ€™s SEC defense.โ€
Note that Team Bโ€™s predicted success in containing Team A is not supported with defensive statistics, or the fact that Team B itself has had success containing offenses similar to Team Aโ€™s; it is enough to say that Team B has an SEC defense. Query: is that the same kind of defense Utah played against in the Sugar Bowl last year?

SEC Phenomenon Two: Anything negative that befalls an SEC team is either (one) ignored (see Alabama vs. Utah) or (two) attributed to a brilliant characteristic of some other SEC team. Thus, if Auburn is shut-out by LSU, itโ€™s not a sign of Auburnโ€™s offensive weakness; nay, itโ€™s just the obvious consequence of playing an SEC defense. โ€œNo worries, Auburn, LSU would have shut itself out too if only it could play itself.โ€
This is why if Auburn and LSU play to a 3-0 finish it is nothing less than a wizardly display of defensive genius, a feat to be marvelled. If, however, Wisconsin and Purdue play to a 3-0 finish, it is a pathetic display of offensive ineptitude, proof positive that the Big Ten is finished.

My fear is now that ESPN and SEC are business partners, the hyperbole might get worse (something I never imagined possible). Exhibit A is Thursdayโ€™s coverage of the NC State โ€“ South Carolina game. Jesse Palmer made the game virtually unwatchable with his SEC homerism.
As an example, here is a paraphrased, but accurately represented, conversation between Craig James and Jesse Palmer during Thursdayโ€™s broadcast, which represents a case of SEC Phenomenon One:

James (perplexed): "Iโ€™m really surprised at how bad NC Stateโ€™s offense looks. They just donโ€™t look as crisp or as sharp as they did late last year."
Palmer (all coy, with mock sincerity):"But might that not be because tonight theyโ€™re playing an SEC defense (as opposed to the lowly ACC defenses they played last year)?"

James (now reading off of the teleprompter): "Ahhhhhโ€ฆ.thatโ€™s a good point."

What! How is that a good point? When James said โ€œthatโ€™s a good pointโ€, what he was actually saying was this: โ€œOh shitโ€ฆ.first game of the year and I forgot that South Carolina is in the SEC conference (and thus has an SEC defense), but now that young Palmer has reminded me, itโ€™s quite clear to me why NC Stateโ€™s offense looks so shitty tonight.โ€
Absurd. Why couldnโ€™t Palmer have simply said, โ€œWell, Craig, we should give South Carolina credit because their defense is playing well tonight, which might explain some of NC Stateโ€™s offensive strugglesโ€ (though I think NC State would have looked awful against any defense on Thursday) instead of โ€œWell of course NC Stateโ€™s offense is having trouble, theyโ€™re playing an SEC defenseโ€?

How does the fact that South Carolina is in the SEC conference automatically mean that it has a good defense, especially in the very first game of the season before theyโ€™ve proven anything on the field?

What about South Carolinaโ€™s offense, or NC Stateโ€™s defense? South Carolinaโ€™s offense was obviously, ahem, โ€œrustyโ€ (read: god-awful), but that didnโ€™t fit the script. Did good defense from NC State contribute at least in part to South Carolinaโ€™s offensive woes? Of course it did, to some extent. What say you, Mr. Palmer? Sorry, NC State, no props for you.

In fact, despite South Carolinaโ€™s offensive suckiness (pardon my technical phraseology), Palmer referred to them as a โ€œspecial bunch.โ€ Naturally, I threw up in my mouth when he said that, though I think by that point my ears were already bleeding. Anyway, letโ€™s see if anyone will refer to South Carolina as a โ€œspecial bunchโ€ by yearโ€™s end (unless โ€œspecialโ€ is announcer-speak for โ€œmediocreโ€).

This example represents a case of SEC Phenomenon Two: South Carolinaโ€™s offense was horrid, but that fact was ignored by Palmer. Make no mistake, if NC State was an SEC team, we would have seen the other variety of SEC Phenomenon Two: South Carolinaโ€™s offense struggled, but that was only because it was playing a mythical โ€œSEC defense.โ€

Who cares, you ask? Ok. Jesse Palmer is a monumental d-bag, but he is entitled to his blowhard opinions. I get it. But what gives me nightmares is the thought that his incessant use of the three letters โ€œS-E-Cโ€ was prompted by a pre-game reminder from the powers that be that ESPN and SEC are now, officially, in bed with one another (i.e., โ€œhumpingโ€).

In other words, Palmer was responding (in a WAY over-the-top fashion) to the corporate memo issued to on-air โ€œtalentโ€ addressing the effective marketing of the SEC brand. More nightmarish is the possibility that he got an โ€œatta boyโ€ after the game (where he clearly should have received a dirty look or something).

Maybe Iโ€™m over-sensitive, but I think this is something to watch in the coming weeks. Listen closely for examples of unnecessary SEC attribution. Count how many times you hear the phrase โ€œSEC defenseโ€ in a non-conference match-up (Hey! Drinking game!) and compare that to the number of times you hear it in an all-SEC battle.
Iโ€™ve always despised you eSECpn, for oh so many reasons, but now my contempt has risen to a new level. Please donโ€™t ruin college football for me.