2015 MLB Draft Results: Team-by-Team List of Grades and Picks from Round 1

Justin Hussong@@HeatChecksHussContributor IIIJune 9, 2015

The Arizona Diamondbacks surprised few by going with Vanderbilt shortstop Dansby Swanson to open the 2015 MLB draft in Secaucus, NJ.
The Arizona Diamondbacks surprised few by going with Vanderbilt shortstop Dansby Swanson to open the 2015 MLB draft in Secaucus, NJ.Peter Aiken/Getty Images

The 2015 MLB draft kicked off Monday night in Secaucus, New Jersey, by welcoming the next crop of exciting young talent into professional baseball.

In this article, we will be tracking and grading all 36 picks made during the first round, as well as offering some analysis on the key talking points that resonated after the opening stanza.

A talent pool that is said to be relatively thin is still capable of providing huge talent for all 30 MLB clubs. The star power is minute, but there are plenty of high-potential guys to be found up and down this board.

Here is every selection of Round 1, with instant grades for each pick.

2015 MLB Draft
1Arizona DiamondbacksDansby Swanson, SS, VanderbiltA
2Houston AstrosAlex Bregman, SS, LSUB+
3Colorado RockiesBrendan Rodgers, SS, Lake Mary High School (FL)A-
4Texas RangersDillon Tate, RHP, UC Santa BarbaraA-
5Houston AstrosKyle Tucker, OF, Plant High School (FL)A
6Minnesota TwinsTyler Jay, LHP, IllinoisA
7Boston Red SoxAndrew Benintendi, OF, ArkansasB+
8Chicago White SoxCarson Fulmer, RHP, VanderbiltA
9Chicago CubsIan Happ, OF, CincinnatiB-
10Philadelphia PhilliesCornelius Randolph, SS, Griffin High School (GA)C-
11Cincinnati RedsTyler Stephenson, C, Kennesaw Mountain High School (GA)A
12Miami MarlinsJosh Naylor, 1B, St. Joan of Arc Catholic (Canada)C
13Tampa Bay RaysGarrett Whitley, OF, Niskayuna HS (NY)A
14Atlanta BravesKolby Allard, LHP, San Clemente High School (CA)A
15Milwaukee BrewersTrenton Clark, OF, Richland High School (TX)A-
16New York YankeesJames Kaprielian, RHP, UCLAB+
17Cleveland IndiansBrady Aiken, IMG Academy (FL)A+
18San Francisco GiantsPhil Bickford, RHP, College of Southern NevadaC+
19Pittsburgh PiratesKevin Newman, SS, ArizonaB
20Oakland AthleticsRichie Martin, SS, FloridaA
21Kansas City RoyalsAshe Russell, RHP, Cathedral High School (IN)A
22Detroit TigersBeau Burrows, RHP, Weatherford High School (TX)C+
23St. Louis CardinalsNick Plummer, OF, Brother Rice High School (MI)A
24Los Angeles DodgersWalker Buehler, RHP, VanderbiltA
25Baltimore OriolesDJ Stewart, OF, Florida StateA
26Los Angeles Angels of AnaheimTaylor Ward, C, Fresno StateC+
27Colorado RockiesMike Nikorak, RHP, Strousdburg High School (PA)A-
28Atlanta BravesMichael Soroka, RHP, Bishop Carroll High School (Canada)A-
29Toronto Blue JaysJon Harris, RHP, Missouri StateA+
30New York YankeesKyle Holder, SS, University of San DiegoA-
31San Francisco GiantsChris Shaw, OF, Boston CollegeA-
32Pittsburgh PiratesKe'Bryan Hayes, 3B, Concordia Lutheran High School (TX)B+
33Kansas City RoyalsNolan Watson, RHP, Lawrence North High School (IN)A-
34Detroit TigersChristin Stewart, OF, TennesseeA
35Los Angeles DodgersKyle Funkhouser, RHP, LouisvilleA+
36Baltimore OriolesRyan Mountcastle, SS, Hagerty High School (FL)A-

Three Shortstops Open the Draft for First Time Ever

There was plenty of speculation as to who would separate himself enough to earn the top pick in the draft, and it turned out to be Vanderbilt superstar shortstop Dansby Swanson.

Not to be outdone, Alex Bregman out of LSU and high school phenom Brendan Rodgers went quickly afterward, forming the first shortstop triumvirate to kick off an MLB draft in league history.

Swanson, the 2014 College World Series MVP, turned more than a few heads this year, including that of his own head coach, according to Nick Piecoro of AZCentral.com.

"The thing that is noticeable about Dansby and guys like him who play at that level, is that they rise to another level when things matter," Vanderbilt coach Tim Corbin said. "When something is on the line or there is a moment, he thrives in it. He's got an extra gear. … He has that ability in so many different ways."

The selections of Bregman and Rodgers, while hardly shocking, were still noteworthy.

The Houston Astros just called up 2012 No. 1 overall pick Carlos Correa, who is expected to lock down the shortstop position for them. Obviously, it is a ways away, but where does Bregman factor into the equation with Correa and All-Star second baseman Jose Altuve up the middle? Not a bad problem to have.

Rodgers provides exceptional upside at the No. 3 spot for the Colorado Rockies, but a healthy Troy Tulowitzki is still the best shortstop in the league. Colorado obviously saw Rodgers as a talent too good to pass up, but it still raises questions regarding Tulo's future.

Kicking off the draft with three shortstops could be a breath of fresh air at the position. The current state of shortstops around the league is extremely weak. This is certainly not the golden era of the late 1990s-early 2000s with Derek Jeter, Alex Rodriguez and Nomar Garciaparra bursting onto the scene. Maybe these three youngsters can dial back the clock.

Chicago Cubs and Philadelphia Phillies Provide Lone Top-10 Surprises

Things were going smoothly, as the first eight picks went about as most predicted, until the Cubs and Phillies decided to shake things up.

Chicago continued to add to its unfathomably large stable of incredible hitting prospects by going with Ian Happ. Jonathan Mayo of MLB.com had some high praise for the junior out of Cincinnati.

"Happ ranked as the top position prospect in the prestigious Cape Cod League in each of his two summers in college," he said. "A switch-hitter who's better from the left side of the plate, he has good balance and controls the strike zone well. Add in some deceptive strength, and he should hit for average and power."

Happ has drawn comparisons to Ben Zobrist and Jason Kipnis, and he features an incredibly advanced approach at the plate. Whether he settles in as an outfielder or infielder remains to be seen, but he displays some of the versatility that the Cubs regime loves.

Fellow stud prospects Javier Baez, Addison Russell and Arismendy Alcantara all performed at various positions for Chicago. It clearly goes for high-impact offensive talent and worries about where guys will fit in later. Great athletes should be able to play anywhere.

Happ may have been a slight reach at No. 9, but you cannot argue with his offensive upside. Cubs fans will enjoy him for a long time.

As for the No. 10 slot, Philly reached hard for Cornelius Randolph, the shortstop prospect out of Griffin High School in Georgia. Randolph was selected high strictly due to his bat. It is unlikely he will stick at shortstop in the majors.

Randolph was a risk at No. 10 with safer high school bats on the board. Tyler Stephenson, Trenton Clark and Daz Cameron were all still on the board.

Jeff Passan of Yahoo Sports is one person who is high on Randolph's hit tools.

The Phillies are desperate for high-ceiling talent due to their weak farm system. Randolph could be a stud, but he was certainly a surprise at No. 10. They ought to be commended for taking such a big swing.

The Los Angeles Dodgers Are Big Winners of the First Round

The rich get richer.

With pick No. 24, the Dodgers went with Vanderbilt pitcher Walker Buehler, who could have easily gone much higher. Buehler is seen as a low-floor prospect with tremendous polish and a deep repertoire. Baseball America had this to say about the athletic righty:

At his best, Buehler has four above-average offerings. He throws his fastball in the low to mid 90s, though it doesn't have a ton of life. His curveball and slider both show promise and he has a good feel for spinning the baseball, but they run together at times. He gets good fading action on his changeup. Scouts have more confidence that Buehler will be able to remain in the rotation thanks to his deep arsenal, athleticism and more polished delivery.

This selection was a home run for the Dodgers. Getting this kind of value late in the first round deserves high praise. The Dodgers are in firm "win-now" mode, and being able to add this kind of college arm could give them a devastating rotation in a few years.

But wait, there's more!

Kyle Funkhouser out of Louisville was once in play for the top overall pick, but a brief slump worried scouts. There were also questions about his signability due to being a Scott Boras client, but as Bill Plunkett of the Orange County Register pointed out, that has not deterred LA in the past.

Seeing Funkhouser slide down the draft board wasn't a huge surprise, but it was shocking to see him slip all the way to No. 35. The Dodgers got an absolute steal with each of their first-round selections and now have two new high-caliber right-handers to add to their stable of young talent.

Justin Hussong is a Featured Columnist/Breaking News Writer at Bleacher Report. You can follow him on Twitter @Hussington.


    Newest MLB Power Rankings 📊

    There's a new No. 1 with six weeks to go

    MLB logo

    Newest MLB Power Rankings 📊

    There's a new No. 1 with six weeks to go

    Joel Reuter
    via Bleacher Report

    Scherzer (Back) Expects to Return Thursday

    MLB logo

    Scherzer (Back) Expects to Return Thursday

    via ESPN.com

    MLB Lifers on State of Modern Baseball: 'Unwatchable'

    MLB logo

    MLB Lifers on State of Modern Baseball: 'Unwatchable'

    Bob Nightengale
    via USA TODAY

    Pete Alonso Sets NL Rookie HR Record

    MLB logo

    Pete Alonso Sets NL Rookie HR Record

    Scott Polacek
    via Bleacher Report