2015 NFL Draft Order: Analyzing Tiebreakers and Scenarios for 1st Round

Joseph Zucker@@JosephZuckerFeatured ColumnistDecember 29, 2014

Oregon quarterback Marcus Mariota (8) celebrates after scoring a touchdown during an NCAA college football game against Oregon State in Corvallis, Or., Saturday, Nov. 15, 2014. Oregon beat Oregon State 47-19. (AP Photo/Troy Wayrynen)
TROY WAYRYNEN/Associated Press

With the 2014 regular season finally completed, the road map for the 2015 NFL draft is largely settled. Over half of the first round is set in stone, with the last 12 picks still up in the air and dependent on how the playoffs unfold.

Now fans and draft experts alike can really start putting together those mock drafts. It hasn't stopped anybody yet, but with the first 20 selections locked in, it's much easier to begin going about identifying which players will be available for certain teams and which needs each team will be able to address.

Here's a quick look at how the draft order shook out.

First-Round Picks No. 1-20

1Tampa Bay Buccaneers2-14.486
2Tennessee Titans2-14.506
3Jacksonville Jaguars3-13.514
4Oakland Raiders3-13.570
5Washington Redskins4-12.496
6New York Jets4-12.543
7Chicago Bears5-11.529
8Atlanta Falcons6-10.482
9New York Giants6-10.512
10St. Louis Rams6-10.531
11Minnesota Vikings7-9.475
12Cleveland Browns7-9.479
13New Orleans Saints7-9.486
14Miami Dolphins8-8.512
15San Francisco 49ers8-8.527
16Houston Texans9-7.447
17San Diego Chargers9-7.512
18Kansas City Chiefs9-7.512
19Cleveland Browns (via Buffalo Bills)7-9.479
20Philadelphia Eagles10-6.490

The only trade so far involving a first-round pick was between the Cleveland Browns and Buffalo Bills. The Browns will take Buffalo's first-rounder, thus owning both the 12th and 19th overall picks.

After that, it's pretty straightforward, with the teams lining up in ascending order by wins.

The tiebreaker when teams finish with identical records is strength of schedule. The team with the lower SOS will earn the lower pick. Although it doesn't apply this year, in the event that the teams are still tied, a coin flip at the NFL Scouting Combine would determine which team would receive the lower pick.

That scenario happened in 2012, when the Carolina Panthers and Miami Dolphins both had a claim on the eighth pick, while the Kansas City Chiefs and Seattle Seahawks fought over the 11th pick.

The tiebreaker played a big role this year since the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and Tennessee Titans tied for the worst record in the league. Getting the first pick means having the option of Marcus Mariota or Jameis Winston, the widely assumed top two selections in this year's draft.

Tampa can go either way, and Tennessee will get what is left. Matt Baker of the Tampa Bay Times said that the early exit polling is split among the two quarterbacks:

Bleacher Report's Luke Easterling isn't particularly adamant either way, just hopeful the Buccaneers address their abysmal quarterback situation:

Strength of schedule was also needed to separate the Jacksonville Jaguars and Oakland Raiders. Depending on how the first two picks shake out, the Jags could potentially have either Nebraska's Randy Gregory or USC's Leonard Williams fall right into their lap.

Some were surprised when Jacksonville passed on Khalil Mack and selected Blake Bortles last year. Next spring, the team might have a chance to correct that perceived wrong by targeting Williams or Gregory. CBSSports.com's Rob Rang praised both players after watching them in the Holiday Bowl on Saturday night:

The 6-foot-5, 290 pound Williams is big enough to slide inside to defensive tackle. His quickness and an effective swim move there make him virtually impossible for interior linemen at the collegiate level to handle him one-on-one. The Daytona Beach, Fla. native has been a dominant performer for the Trojans throughout his career, earning the Pac-12 Defensive Player of the Year in 2012 and improving his production the past two seasons. Williams has been my top-rated NFL prospect since October.

Gregory, too, could see action at multiple positions in the NFL but it could be at defensive end and outside linebacker. The 6-foot-6, 240 pound JUCO transfer (Arizona Western Community College) sports a chiseled upper body but his thin legs leave him reliant on his agility when defending the run. Gregory has a terrific first-step, changes directions fluidly and has the balance and coordination to recognize and defeat cut blocks. While not nearly as powerful as Williams, Gregory has an aggressive initial pop to disengage from blockers and shows plenty of strength to pull ball-carriers to the ground.

Of course, making any sort of draft predictions this far out is always folly to a certain extent. The whole process is so long and drawn out, with so much subterfuge as anonymous scouts and coaches attempt to tank a player's draft stock.

The likes of Bortles, Greg Robinson, Aaron Donald and Khalil Mack shot up draft boards in the weeks and months leading up to the draft, while Teddy Bridgewater and Derek Carr were among the higher-profile stars whose respective stocks dropped somewhat precipitously.

This year will be no different.

Playoff Picks

21Baltimore Ravens10-6.474
22Cincinnati Bengals10-5-1.483
23Detroit Lions11-5.471
24Arizona Cardinals11-5.523
25Carolina Panthers7-8-1.490
26Indianapolis Colts11-5.478
27Pittsburgh Steelers11-5.451
28Dallas Cowboys12-4.422
29Green Bay Packers12-4.482
30Denver Broncos12-4.521
31New England Patriots12-4.516
32Seattle Seahawks12-4.525
Current order is based on Playoff Seeding and Overall Records

The math is pretty simple for the 12 playoff teams: The earlier you're knocked out, the earlier you'll pick in the first round. Here's a brief breakdown for how the draft picks correlate to the different rounds:

  • Wild Card Round: Nos. 21-24
  • Divisional Round: Nos. 25-28
  • Conference Championship Round: Nos. 29 and 30
  • Super Bowl runner-up: No. 31
  • Super Bowl champion: No. 32

Overall records will determine the order for each of the different levels. When teams are tied with the same record, strength of schedule will once again come into play, per CBSSports.com.

It doesn't offer much consolation to the fanbase, but at least a quick postseason exit is somewhat cushioned by having a higher pick.

Note: Draft order is courtesy of CBSSports.com.


    Gordon Predicts Rivers to Indy

    Melvin Gordon thinks Colts are best fit for Philip Rivers: ‘They run the same playbook, so it’d be easy’

    NFL logo

    Gordon Predicts Rivers to Indy

    Rob Goldberg
    via Bleacher Report

    Report: Dolphins Might Pass on Tua 👀

    Miami doesn’t see Tua as ‘slam dunk’ near top of draft; view of Justin Herbert is ‘increasingly positive’

    NFL logo

    Report: Dolphins Might Pass on Tua 👀

    Tyler Conway
    via Bleacher Report

    Ideal FA Target for Every Team 🎯

    Tap to see your team's perfect match

    NFL logo

    Ideal FA Target for Every Team 🎯

    Brent Sobleski
    via Bleacher Report

    Buying or Selling the Latest Draft Buzz 🤔

    The biggest rumors circulating around the NFL

    NFL logo

    Buying or Selling the Latest Draft Buzz 🤔

    Chris Roling
    via Bleacher Report