Should Adrian Mutu Pay Chelsea €17m?
Last week's decision by the Court of Arbitration for Sport (CAS)ย could haveย ramifications for football as big as the Bosman ruling in 1995ย and the Webster ruling in 2006. The notable difference being that where the previous legal rulings significantly increased player power inย the football market, this newest ruling is almost definitely a triumph for the clubs.
Having tested positive for cocaine in September 2004 his employer, Chelsea FC, decided to sack Mutu in October. After spending almost โฌ30m purchasing Mutu from Parma in the summer of 2003, barely a year and a half later, Mutu was out on his earย with his reputationย in tatters.
The CAS have ordered Mutu to repay over half of the investment Chelsea made in him. The final figure of โฌ17m (which was originally โฌ9m as deemed by FIFA) is a hammerblow...even by a footballer's standards.
Of course, one would be pushed to ask, whyย did Chelsea push for such drastic action in the first place with Mutu? Surely a โฌ30m write-off on a player was too much back in 2004?
Maybe for most, but probably not for Roman Abramovich.
Even then,ย the most naive of football fans will still tell you that there is a more than fair chance the young, rich, and famous playboys of the Premier Leagueย will often experiment with recreational drugs anyway.
Don't clubs deal with this sort of thing in-house?
And that's where Mutu can be rightly aggrieved. The decision to make Mutu's (admittedly disgraceful) actions public and sack him on that basisย wasย more thanย likely, a politically motivated decision within the club.ย
Adrian Mutu, I can assure you, is not the first footballer in history to have been caughtย snorting cocaine by his club, so why treat him as such?
Various cynics have suggested his quite public spat with Mourinho at the time may have been a decisive factor in the events leading up to Mutu's dismissal...was Mutu faking injury? We'll never know for sure.
Butย the sackingย was also to prove a double blow for Mutu, because along with losingย his lucrative contractย at a clearly successful club, Mutu was banned from football for seven months and was fined ยฃ20,000 by the FA.
Mutu did eventually return to football however; moving to Italy, signing with Juventus (who were themselves to dragย moral standardsย in football to a new low, ironically).ย So byย January 2005, Juventus had come to aquire for free what Chelsea had paidย over the oddsย for.
Another obvious question, and one proposed by Mutu's legal team then arises, can Juventus be held liable for part of the compensation? Common sense would dictate this would certainly be a bit of a stretch, especially considering Juventus were simply dealing with a free agent at the time of his signing and nothing more.
The CAS agreed.
Today, Mutu has established a reputation forย himself as a reformed man at Fiorentina, remarrying and living a far cleaner lifestyle off the pitchโaway from the world of porn stars and the devil's dandruff.
Butย theย past has come back to haunt Mutu. Even the salary increase Mutu received from Fiorentina with his last contract will not be enough to compensate for the incredible sum staring Mutu right in the face.
Two options remain for Mutu: To take the case further into the court system and appealย at the EUย level or to simply retire from the game and avoid having to pay the compensation altogetherโremember, the decision was a ruling by the CAS, not a civil court and therefore is not applicable outside sport.
Time is ticking.
Chelsea would be foolish to expect the money back in one lump sum this summer and while Mutu's teammates at Fiorentinaย admirably have come together in a fund-raising effort for their teammate, it isย entirely possible now that Mutu may soon become bankrupt should he decide to play on.
As the dust clears, the implications for the wider world of football are enormous. A precedent has been set whereby clubs can demand compensation from players for breach of contract but at a more fundamental level, it seems FIFA has finally decided where to draw the line with players.


.jpg?w=2560)




.jpg?w=2560)

.jpg?w=2560)
