This has nothing to do with Urban Meyer as a coach, that would be stupid. This has to do with where Notre Dame football is right now and what would be best for it.
It has to do with the last two years and most of the years between Holtz and Weis. It has to do with not wanting a do-over on rebuilding and not wanting to lose underclassmen who bolt because of a system change again. This time they might be pushed out by Urban instead of leaving of their own accord.
I want Notre Dame to be successful under every coach, I get sick and tired of losing. I get fed up with not being competitive with USC or Michigan and not being able to beat Michigan State. I want Charlie to succeed, I need Charlie to succeed. The last two years have to mean something to this program other than being a waste.
The turning of inexperience to dominance is what I want to see. This is the program's last chance with who is in place and I believe Swarbrick would have made the change last year if Charlie couldn't talk a good game. I need to see it in action rather than just hear about it.
The offense will probably be a pass-dominant issue again, whether it's because of Armando Allen and Robert Hughes not being able to carry the load or Michael Floyd, Golden Tate, and Kyle Rudolph (among others) just exploding for 150-yard games each consistently. This would seem to fit Weis' gameplan.
Notre Dame has to succeed next year because this is what we have been waiting for. As fans we are willing to look past the last two years (kind of) if this year means great success. As a fan who has seen the teams Notre Dame has lost to in person get worse and worse (from the Dowdell-led Spartans to Air Force during the 3-9 debacle to Syracuse last year), it has to be for something.
I have a belief in Notre Dame football that is insane because there is little reason to believe in Charlie. Sure, he's had some great recruiting classes and he turned a 6-7 team into back-to-back BCS teams...but there are questions about all of it.
This is the show-me year, Custer's last stand. We are looking at starting over again and the cupboard won't be bare. Instead, people will be looking for Urban immediately. His contract isn't up until 2013 so the next coach will have Urban watch even worse then Charlie does. Tommy Tubberville could probably withstand that and build a program, but could a less experienced coach like Brian Kelly? I don't know and the I don't know whether the future could be worse then the Charlie past/present. Here's to hoping Urban isn't necessary to fix the last 12 and that the answer is right beneath our noses.
Follow me on twitter @dascenzo and see my thoughts on sports that don't involve UND at my blog.