Newcastle United vs. Manchester City: Live Player Ratings for the Citizens

Alex Dimond@alexdimondUK Lead WriterJanuary 12, 2014

NEWCASTLE, UNITED KINGDOM - OCTOBER 30: Yohan Cabaye of Newcastle United (right) makes a challenge on David Silva of Manchester City during the Capital One Cup Fourth Round match between Newcastle United and Manchester City at St James' Park on October 30, 2013 in Newcastle upon Tyne, England (Photo by Ian Horrocks/Getty Images)
Ian Horrocks/Getty Images

Premier League, St James' Park

Sunday, January 12, 2014


Goals: Dzeko (8'), Negredo (90'+5)

Goals from Edin Dzeko and Alvaro Negredo sent Manchester City back to the top of the Premier League table on Sunday, although it was a far tougher game against Newcastle than the final scoreline may suggest.

City went ahead after just eight minutes after Dzeko expertly turned home Aleksandr Kolarov's low cross, but from that point onwards it was perhaps the home side that edged matters. And there was huge controversy shortly before half-time, when Cheick Tiote's brilliant strike was ruled out, seemingly erroneously, for offside.

City continued to ride their luck at times in the second half, before eventually securing the points deep into injury time as Negredo completed a quick counter-attack.

Here's how Manchester City's starting XI performed during the game.

Manchester City Player Ratings
PlayerHT RatingFT Rating
Joe Hart68
Pablo Zabaleta66
Vincent Kompany77
Martin Demichelis66
Aleksandr Kolarov77
Samir Nasri56
Yaya Toure66
David Silva77
Alvaro Negredo67
Edin Dzeko77

First half comments

Joe Hart: Made a couple of reasonable saves but was only prevented from conceding by the officials.

Pablo Zabaleta: Was occasionally caught out by the likes of Sissoko and Gouffran, but offered his usual valuable outlet going forward.

Vincent Kompany: Made a number of important defensive clearances.

Martin Demichelis: Not as influential as Kompany, but made some key challenges when needed.

Aleksandr Kolarov: Delivered a great ball for Dzeko's opener, and nearly replicated it moments later.

Samir Nasri: One lax pass to Cabaye nearly gifted Newcastle a great opportunity. Not as attentive as he has been in recent times.

Fernandinho: Relatively quiet by his recent high standards.

Yaya Toure: Physically the most dominant player on the pitch.

David Silva: Throughball for Kolarov set the stage for the opener, and he nearly had a goal of his own from a volley shortly before half-time.

Alvaro Negredo: A constant point of concern for Newcastle's defence, although it was his strike partner that actually got the goal.

Edin Dzeko: Made a classic striker's run to poke home the opener.

NEWCASTLE UPON TYNE, ENGLAND - JANUARY 12:  Manchester City striker Alvaro Negredo rounds Tim Krul before tapping into an empty net to score the second goal during the Barclays Premier League match between Newcastle United and Manchestre City at St James'
Stu Forster/Getty Images

Second half comments

Joe Hart: Forced into a few crucial saves in the second half—particularly from Remy and Cabaye—that kept his side ahead. Impressive.

Pablo Zabaleta: Not the Argentine's best performance, with a number of poor fouls underlining an uncharacteristically uncertain display.

Vincent Kompany: Continued to dominate defensively in the air and on the deck, and was a key component of the eventual clean sheet.

Martin Demichelis: Continued to provide good support for Kompany.

Aleksandr Kolarov: Continued to provide chances with some good left-foot crosses, and was defensively sound more often than not.

Samir Nasri: The big concern from this match for Pellegrini—the Frenchman seemed to be seriously injured after a horrible tackle from Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa

Fernandinho: Grew in stature as the game went on, especially important after Yaya Toure limped off early in the second half.

Yaya Toure: Forced off early in the second half for Javi Garcia, who did not replicate the Ivorian's impact.

David Silva: Continued to be the cleverest, most deft player on the park—just unfortunate that none of the many chances he created were turned into goals.

Alvaro Negredo: His late strike masked an otherwise sub-standard performance, although he knitted together some of City's counter-attacks expertly.

Edin Dzeko: Withdrawn almost immediately for Jesus Navas, who provided City with extra width.


    Bob Marley’s Love of Football Made the Game Beautiful

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Bob Marley’s Love of Football Made the Game Beautiful

    Edd Norval
    via These Football Times

    Man City Wouldn't Sell Jadon Sancho to Liverpool

    Manchester City logo
    Manchester City

    Man City Wouldn't Sell Jadon Sancho to Liverpool

    via liverpoolecho

    Chiellini: Sergio Ramos Is World's Best Defender

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Chiellini: Sergio Ramos Is World's Best Defender

    Matt Jones
    via Bleacher Report

    Harry Kane Could Return vs. Burnley

    World Football logo
    World Football

    Harry Kane Could Return vs. Burnley

    Evening Standard
    via Evening Standard