Team-by-Team NFL Rookie Class Report Card Heading into Preseason Week 4

Preseason football has nearly run its course. Now, the regular season is just a stone's throw away.

This definitely seems like the perfect time to gauge the progress of the newest members of the NFL elite. Though we’re still rather early into the evaluation process, there’s still a lot to be learned from the first three weeks of NFL action.

Continue along as we find out which rookies are on the path to stardom and which ones have all the makings of a first-class bust.

In order to create this rookie power ranking, I painstakingly watched every single preseason game to date, focusing my attention exclusively on rookies and their performances. Furthermore, I used preseason statistics provided by Pro Football Focus (paid site) and NFL.com in order to aid in the ranking process.

For the “draft grade” column, I used my personal big board to help determine the draft value of each prospect relative to the round they were selected in. The “overall grade” was determined by averaging the “draft grade” and “preseason grade” together. I also factored in some key undrafted free agents (when applicable) who have stood out.

Buffalo Bills

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	EJ Manuel	QB	6'5"	237	A	A-
Round 2	Robert Woods	WR	6'0"	201	C+	B
Round 2	Kiko Alonso	LB	6'3"	238	C	B
Round 3	Marquise Goodman	WR	5'9"	183	B+	B
Round 4	Duke Williams	S	6'0"	190	D	B
Round 5	Jonathan Meeks	DB	6'1"	210	D	B+
Round 6	Dustin Hopkins	PK	6'2"	193	C	B+
Round 7	Chris Gragg	TE	6'3"	244	B-	B

Overachieving undrafted free agents: WR Brandon Kaufman (A), QB Jeff Tuel (A), CB Nickell Robey (B+).

First-rounder EJ Manuel flashed his vast potential through the first two preseason games, giving Bills fans new hope for the future in Buffalo.

This rookie class was projected to be a solid group right from the start, yet they’ve managed to excel expectations after three weeks of preseason action. 

Rookie quarterback Jeff Tuel has been turning heads all preseason long with his decision making and accuracy. He now looks to make the most of his opportunity as the injury bug continues to take its toll on Buffalo's QBs.

Overall Grade: B

Miami Dolphins

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Dion Jordan	DE	6'6"	248	B	C
Round 2	Jamar Taylor	CB	5'11"	192	A	C
Round 3	Dallas Thomas	OT	6'5"	300	D+	F
Round 3	Will Davis	CB	5'11"	186	C	D+
Round 4	Jelani Jenkins	LB	6'0"	243	C	C-
Round 4	Dion Sims	TE	6'5"	262	C	D
Round 5	Mike Gillislee	HB	5'11"	208	D-	D-
Round 5	Caleb Sturgis	PK	5'10"	188	C	B+
Round 7	Don Jones	S	5'11"	199	C	C+

Overachieving undrafted free agents: WR Chad Bumphis (A), DE Tristan Okpalaugo (B). 

The Dolphins appeared to have a distinct plan for this draft—get faster on the defensive side of the ball. Well, they certainly did that with the additions of Dion Jordan, Jamar Taylor, Will Davis and Jelani Jenkins.

The only question now is; did they actually get better?

Though their top-two draft selections have struggled early on this summer, look for each of these guys to become top contributors to a defensive unit that has undergone quite the makeover.

Dion Sims has not looked like the physically dominating blocker I watched at Michigan State. He will definitely need to adjust the speed of the NFL quickly after the disheartening season-ending injury to starting tight end Dustin Keller.

Their biggest concern should be the depth at the tackle position considering Jake Long moved on to St. Louis via free agency. Dallas Thomas has looked horrific throughout his first NFL preseason and second-year pro Jonathan Martin is still unproven at left tackle. If this position falters, it’s safe to assume the entire offense will suffer.

Overall Grade: C

New England Patriots

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 2	Jamie Collins	LB	6'3"	250	A+	D+
Round 2	Aaron Dobson	WR	6'3"	210	D	B-
Round 3	Logan Ryan	CB	5'11"	191	B-	B
Round 3	Duron Harmon	S	6'1"	200	D	F
Round 4	Josh Boyce	WR	5'11"	206	B+	D-
Round 7	Michael Buchanan	DE	6'5"	255	A	C+
Round 7	Steve Beauharnais	LB	6'1"	240	C	C-

Overachieving undrafted free agents: WR Kenbrell Thompkins (B+), TE Zach Sudfeld (A-), DT Joe Vellano (A).

It’s always hard to critique the team-building philosophy of Bill Belichick and the New England Patriots. They seem to make a habit of pulling off some of the oddest moves in the league each and every draft.

Third-round safety Duron Harmon is on early draft bust watch after failing to make tackles or cover his man this preseason.

I was personally a big fan of pass-rusher Michael Buchanan out of college and believe the Patriots got a seventh-round steal. He has shown promise so far but has still failed to live up to my exceedingly high expectations.

Receiver Josh Boyce has all the physical tools to succeed in the NFL, but so far he has appeared lost in games and cannot find his groove. This position happens to be a critical area of need for Tom Brady’s offense and would be greatly weakened should any rookie fail to meet expectations.

One way or another, rookie receivers will be producing for the Patriots.

Surprisingly, the first rookie to emerge in August has been undrafted free agent Kenbrell Thompkins. His play has been so impressive that he’s pressing both Aaron Dobson and Boyce for playing time in the season opener.

Linebacker Jamie Collins is one of my favorite players of the 2013 draft class. He has struggled a bit in pass coverage and whiffed on a few tackles, but don’t underestimate this kid’s enormous potential. He will eventually prove to be one of the most versatile and talented players on that defense.

Oddly enough, the most impressive rookies in New England so far this summer all went undrafted.

Overall Grade: C+

New York Jets

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Dee Milliner	CB	6'0"	201	A	D+
Round 1	Sheldon Richardson	DL	6'2"	294	A+	A
Round 2	Geno Smith	QB	6'2"	218	A+	D
Round 3	Brian Winters	OL	6'4"	320	C-	C-
Round 5	Oday Aboushi	OT	6'5"	308	D+	D
Round 6	William Campbell	OG	6'4"	311	C	C+
Round 7	Tommy Bohanon	FB	6'1"	246	B	C+

Overachieving undrafted free agents: WR Ryan Spadola (A+).

The New York Jets are hoping to turn their fortune around in 2013 with a much-improved offense. The only problem is they really didn’t address the offense in this draft other than grabbing quarterback Geno Smith in the second round along with a few offensive linemen. Their real need is at the skill positions.

Sheldon Richardson was one of the most dynamic defensive playmakers in the entire draft. So far his rare talents have translated well at the next level.

Geno Smith looks uncomfortable and raw out there, but he still may be the better option at QB over the disappointing and injured Mark Sanchez.

Expect top pick Dee Milliner to play solid football at the cornerback position despite hitting a rough patch in the Jacksonville game. His talents and NFL readiness will ultimately take over as he will be trusted to hold his own while Rex Ryan sends the house at opposing offenses.  

This draft class is much better than it’s playing at the moment.

Overall Grade: B-

Baltimore Ravens

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Matt Elam	S	5'10"	208	B-	A
Round 2	Arthur Brown	LB	6'0"	241	C	C-
Round 3	Brandon Williams	DT	6'1"	335	A-	A
Round 4	John Simon	LB/DE	6'1"	257	B+	C-
Round 4	Kyle Juszczyk	FB	6'1"	248	C	C-
Round 5	Ricky Wagner	OT	6'6"	308	B	B+
Round 6	Kapron Lewis-Moore	DL	6'4"	298	C	F
Round 7	Aaron Mellette	WR	6'2"	217	B+	B+
Round 7	Marc Anthony	CB	5'11"	196	A-	B+

Top pick Matt Elam is living up to his first-round billing as he brings a mean physicality to this new-look defense.

Arthur Brown was drafted to fill the role of Dannell Ellerbe at the Will linebacker position. His sideline-to-sideline ability is among the best of the 2013 rookie crop, however, he has struggled to take on blocks and needs to get both stronger and more physical at the point of attack. This has been my concern with him coming out of college and it seems to be haunting him early on.

Seventh-round receiver Aaron Mellette was one of the most productive collegiate players in this draft class. He may not have all the physical tools, but he does have good size and instincts which has been on full display with his impressive touchdown grabs.

Watch out for offensive tackle Ricky Wagner who I believe is highly underrated coming out of Wisconsin.

General Manager Ozzie Newsome has put together another fine draft from top to bottom as the Ravens quickly look to reload as they try to defend their crown as Super Bowl champions

Overall Grade: B-

Cincinnati Bengals

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Tyler Eifert	TE	6'6"	251	A+	B+
Round 2	Giovani Bernard	RB	5'8"	202	B-	A
Round 2	Margus Hunt	DE	6'8"	277	A-	D+
Round 3	Shawn Williams	S	6'0"	213	A	C
Round 4	Sean Porter	LB	6'1"	229	C+	D
Round 5	Tanner Hawkinson	OT	6'5"	298	C	D+
Round 6	Rex Burkhead	RB	5'10"	214	A-	B+
Round 6	Cobi Hamilton	WR	6'2"	212	B	C+
Round 7	Reid Fragel	OT	6'8"	308	A	C
Round 7	T.J. Johnson	C	6'4"	310	C	C-

For those of you who are not familiar with my work, you may not know that Tyler Eifert has quickly become my new favorite player. He will play a significant role in the Bengals’ offense this season.

This draft class is loaded with talent as Cincinnati continues to stockpile young, promising football players.

One way or another, the Bengals are going to have to part ways with some highly talented individuals as they continue to narrow the squad down to 53 men.

Overall Grade: B-

Cleveland Browns

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Barkevious Mingo	LB	6'4"	241	A	B-
Round 3	Leon McFadden	CB	5'10"	193	A	C-
Round 6	Jamoris Slaughter	S	6'0"	195	C	D+
Round 7	Armonty Bryant	DE	6'4"	263	D	B
Round 7	Garrett Gilkey	OT	6'6"	318	C-	D

Overachieving undrafted free agent: OT Martin Wallace (A).

The new era of Browns' football is officially upon us. Barkevious Mingo is the prize of the bunch as he showed impressive quickness off the edge in limited time this preseason before suffering a bruised lung, which landed him in the hospital.

Cornerback Leon McFadden has not lived up to expectations so far which may change once he gets a better feel for the game.

This draft class may be small but it should produce some solid contributors across the board.

Overall Grade: C+  

Pittsburgh Steelers

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Jarvis Jones	LB	6'2"	245	C-	C+
Round 2	Le'Veon Bell	RB	6'1"	230	B+	D
Round 3	Markus Wheaton	WR	5'11"	189	A	A-
Round 4	Shamarko Thomas	S	5'9"	213	A+	A
Round 4	Landry Jones	QB	6'4"	225	B	D+
Round 5	Terry Hawthorne	CB	6'0"	195	C-	C
Round 6	Justin Brown	WR	6'3"	209	C-	C
Round 6	Vince Williams	LB	6'0"	247	B-	A
Round 7	Nick Williams	DT	6'4"	309	C	D

Overachieving undrafted free agents: KR Reggie Dunn (A), DE Brian Arnfelt (A-).

The Steelers know how to build through the draft, which is exactly what they did with this impressive group of rookies.

Once Le'Veon Bell is finally healthy he should make a push for the starting running back position.

Two of the most impressive performers thus far have been linebacker Vince Williams and DB Shamarko Thomas. These two hard-hitting defenders could end up being a formidable tandem for years to come.

First-rounder Jarvis Jones is expected to break Steelers’ tradition and become a starter at some point during his rookie year. They need all the youth they can get on that defense.

Receiver Markus Wheaton was a third-round steal and may end up being one of the best of his class. He should see a ton of action this season.

Pittsburgh cannot afford to miss the playoffs for a second-straight year. This team needs to reload and replenish just as they’ve been able to do for so long. So far it appears they have done it with this talented group.

Overall Grade: B-

Houston Texans

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	DeAndre Hopkins	WR	6'1"	214	A-	B-
Round 2	D.J. Swearinger	S	5'10"	208	A	C-
Round 3	Brennan Williams	OT	6'6"	318	D	F
Round 3	Sam Montgomery	DE	6'3"	263	B	C
Round 4	Trevardo Williams	LB	6'1"	241	A	B+
Round 6	David Quessenberry	OL	6'5"	302	A	A-
Round 6	Alan Bonner	WR	5'10"	193	D	F
Round 6	Chris Jones	DT	6'2"	302	D	C
Round 6	Ryan Griffin	TE	6'6"	247	C+	A+

Overachieving undrafted free agents: RB Cierre Wood (B+).

The Texans addressed immediate needs in this draft by bringing in some rookies I was very high on coming out.

As you can see in the chart above, there are four rookies I gave an “A” draft value to. One mid-round sleeper who could end up becoming a starter for years is versatile offensive lineman David Quessenberry from San Jose State. This kid has all the tools to be great someday.

One of the biggest preseason surprises thus far has been tight end Ryan Griffin. He has excelled as a blocker, pass catcher and in special teams. Anytime you can find a multi-faceted contributor in the sixth round you're doing something right.

Hopkins flashed his potential early on this preseason and he should be a top candidate for Rookie of the Year.

Overall Grade: C+

Indianapolis Colts

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Bjoern Werner	LB	6'3"	266	C	D-
Round 3	Hugh Thorton	OG	6'3"	320	C-	C
Round 4	Khaled Holmes	C	6'3"	302	C-	F
Round 5	Montori Hughes	DT	6'4"	329	D-	C+
Round 6	John Boyett	S	5'10"	204	C	F
Round 7	Kerwynn Williams	RB	5'8"	195	C-	B-
Round 7	Justice Cunningham	TE	6'3"	258	C	D

Overachieving undrafted free agents: LB Caesar Rayford (A).

Going into the season I was not a big fan of the Colts’ draft. Bjoern Werner lacked the hustle and athleticism to justify a first-round pick and none of the players they brought in afterwards really impressed me.

They may be able to squeeze out a few contributors but don’t expect any star power to arise from this collection of mediocrity.

This is definitely one of the least impressive rookie classes in the entire league. Their most promising new addition could be undrafted outside linebacker Caesar Rayford. He leads the league in sacks with five.

Overall Grade: C-

Jacksonville Jaguars

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Luke Joeckel	OT	6'6"	306	B+	C+
Round 2	Johnathan Cyprien	S	6'0"	217	A+	F
Round 3	Dwayne Gratz	CB	5'11"	201	A	A
Round 4	Ace Sanders	WR/KR	5'7"	173	C	C
Round 5	Denard Robinson	OW	5'10"	199	A	C
Round 6	Josh Evans	S	6'1"	207	C	B
Round 7	Jeremy Harris	CB	6'2"	181	C-	F
Round 7	Demetrius McCray	CB	6'1"	187	C	C

Overachieving undrafted free agents: TE Ryan Otten (B).

Jacksonville is making a strong effort to ascend from the NFL’s basement. They may have a long way to go before serious contention but at least they should be able to keep games competitive.

Luke Joeckel was the best offensive tackle in the draft despite being passed up by Eric Fisher for the top-overall pick. He shores up the right side with an immediate upgrade.

Safety Johnathan Cyprien started out hot in OTA’s and mini-camps but now seems to be struggling. Don’t be too alarmed by his “F” performance. There’s no doubt this kid will be a very good football player for years to come.

Denard Robinson has shown some of his playmaking potential but he still needs to get comfortable in his new role.

The star so far has been cornerback Dwayne Gratz. He was one of the more physically gifted corners coming out this year, which pairs nicely with a highly productive college career.

The Jags could end up with three or four starters from this rookie class—which by all standards is considered a successful draft.

Overall Grade: C+

Tennessee Titans

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Chance Warmack	OG	6'2"	317	B	C-
Round 2	Justin Hunter	WR	6'4"	196	C+	C-
Round 3	Blidi Wreh-Wilson	CB	6'1"	195	C+	F
Round 3	Zaviar Gooden	LB	6'1"	234	B	F
Round 4	Brian Schwenke	C	6'3"	314	B	C-
Round 5	Lavar Edwards	DE	6'4"	277	C+	D
Round 6	Khalid Wooten	CB	5'11"	210	C-	F
Round 7	Daimion Stafford	S	6'0"	221	C-	D-

I currently had this group of rookies rated fairly high heading into the season. So far they have failed to yield much in terms of production this preseason. Perhaps the Titans will be able to harvest the full fruits of this draft class once the season starts because nobody has really stood out yet.

Chance Warmack was widely considered the safest prospect heading into last April’s draft. So far he has failed to live up to his elite status as a human bulldozer. But I wouldn’t worry too much about it this early. He has still played decent and should only get better once he stops thinking too much.

Blidi Wreh-Wilson has been absolutely atrocious in nearly all phases of the game. At this point it would be a miracle if he somehow develops into a solid starter in this league. His deficiencies seem far too great to overcome.

This group does have some talent; they just haven’t realized it yet.

Overall Grade: C-

Denver Broncos

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Sylvester Williams	DT	6'3"	313	B	F
Round 2	Montee Ball	RB	5'10"	214	B	D+
Round 3	Kayvon Webster	CB	5'10"	195	B	A+
Round 5	Quanterus Smith	DE	6'5"	250	A+	C+
Round 5	Tavarres King	WR	6'0"	189	A	C
Round 6	Vinston Painter	OL	6'4"	306	C-	C-
Round 7	Zac Dysert	QB	6'3"	231	A+	C

Overachieving undrafted free agent: RB C.J. Anderson (B).

I absolutely love what the Broncos did in the first five rounds of this draft. Sylvester Williams isn’t fully healthy yet and it shows in his play, but look for him to be among the league’s best interior linemen before his career is over.

Kayvon Webster is also going to be a top-tier cornerback and was a steal in the third round. He’s having one of the best summers in the NFL so far.

Quanterus Smith happens to be the pass rusher who impressed me the most in college. This guy has the most impressive array of moves I’ve seen all year. He is recovering from major knee surgery and will take some time to get back to full strength.

Don’t sleep on RB C.J. Anderson either. This kid could end up working his way into the rotation at running back after his impressive debut performance against the 49ers’ defense. His development has since been placed on hold as he recovers from a chipped bone in his knee.

Overall Grade: B-

Kansas City Chiefs

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Eric Fisher	OT	6'7"	306	B-	D-
Round 3	Travis Kelce	TE	6'5"	255	B	C-
Round 3	Knile Davis	RB	5'10"	227	C	C-
Round 4	Nico Johnson	LB	6'2"	248	D-	B-
Round 5	Sanders Commings	CB	6'0"	216	A-	F
Round 6	Eric Kush	C	6'4"	305	C	D+
Round 6	Braden Wilson	FB	6'3"	251	C	C
Round 7	Mike Catapano	DE	6'3"	271	D+	D+

Overachieving undrafted free agent: S Bradley McDougald (B+).

The Chiefs had the dubious honor of drafting first overall in this year’s draft. They decided to grab the very athletic tackle out of Central Michigan, Eric Fisher. So far he has failed to play like the best offensive tackle drafted, let alone the best player.

Alabama’s inside linebacker Nico Johnson has been the biggest surprise so far along with undrafted safety Bradley McDougald.

Running Back Knile Davis could turn into a nice weapon for Andy Reid and Co. if he can hold onto the ball.

Sometimes it just takes a little patience when waiting for rookies to hit their stride.

Overall Grade: C-

Oakland Raiders

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	D.J. Hayden	CB	5'11"	191	B-	D
Round 2	Menelik Watson	OT	6'5"	310	D-	F
Round 3	Sio Moore	LB	6'1"	245	B	A-
Round 4	Tyler Wilson	QB	6'2"	215	B+	D+
Round 6	Nick Kasa	TE	6'6"	269	C	B
Round 6	Latavius Murray	RB	6'2"	223	C	C-
Round 6	Mychal Rivera	TE	6'3"	242	C	D
Round 6	Stacy McGee	DT	6'3"	308	D	C
Round 7	Brice Butler	WR	6'3"	205	C	A+
Round 7	David Bass	DE	6'4"	262	D	C+

Overachieving undrafted free agents: DE Ryan Robinson (B). 

When you’re strapped by the salary cap and have no money to spend, you try to build through the draft as much as possible. This is the fate of the Oakland Raiders, a team looking to completely purge the roster and start anew.

Receiver Brice Butler has looked fantastic so far and could be competing for the WR3 position. If he continues to make spectacular catches each week, he may actually end up in the starting lineup before the season is out—not bad for a guy taken in the seventh round.

Sio Moore is another young guy who has established himself as a starter on this defense. He’s a player who I was very impressed with coming out of college yet has continued to exceed my expectations.

Overall Grade: C

San Diego Chargers

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	D.J. Fluker	OT	6'5"	339	B	B-
Round 2	Manti Te'o	LB	6'1"	241	A	D+
Round 3	Keenan Allen	WR	6'2"	206	A-	B-
Round 5	Steve Williams	CB	5'9"	181	B+	C
Round 6	Tourek Williams	DE	6'3"	260	C	D
Round 7	Brad Sorenson	QB	6'4"	229	C	A-

Overachieving undrafted free agent: DT Kwame Geathers (B).

This was a solid draft class for the Chargers and their new regime. Keenan Allen is a highly talented receiver who expects to see a lot of run with numerous injuries at the position.

Media magnet Manti Te’o looked good throughout mini-camps but has been sidelined with a foot injury. He is expected to be an early starter for this defense but needs to get more reps if he hopes to succeed in the regular season.

Seventh-round quarterback Brad Sorenson has become a hot commodity after lighting up defenses this preseason. He should have a firm grasp on the backup QB job.

Overall Grade: B-

Dallas Cowboys

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Travis Frederick	C	6'4"	312	D	F
Round 2	Gavin Escobar	TE	6'6"	254	C+	F
Round 3	Terrance Williams	WR	6'2"	208	B	D
Round 3	J.J Wilcox	S	6'0"	213	D	D+
Round 4	B.W. Webb	CB	5'10"	184	C+	C
Round 5	Joseph Randle	RB	6'0"	204	B-	B+
Round 6	DeVonte Holloman	LB	6'1"	243	B	A+

Overachieving undrafted free agents: LB Brandon Magee (A-), LB Taylor Reed (B).

This has got to be the league’s worst collection of drafted rookies this year. Center Travis Frederick cannot seem to get comfortable in the offense despite a nice start in the preseason opener. Since then he has been showing his inexperience through this difficult adjustment period. 

The Cowboys top-four draft picks have each played poorly up to this point in the preseason.

A few positives that can be taken from this rookie class all happen to come from the latter part of the draft and beyond, particularly with linebacker DeVonte Holloman. This kid has been an absolute stud in all phases of the game, including some huge pass breakups and a couple of interceptions in pass coverage.

They also have two undrafted rookies at linebacker who have been making it extremely difficult for the Cowboys to cut them.

It could be time for Jerry Jones the general manager to hang it up and give the job to someone more qualified.  

Overall Grade: C

New York Giants

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Justin Pugh	OL	6'4"	307	D-	C-
Round 2	Johnathan Hankins	DT	6'3"	320	C-	C+
Round 3	Damontre Moore	DE	6'4"	250	A-	A-
Round 4	Ryan Nassib	QB	6'2"	227	B	D
Round 5	Cooper Taylor	S	6'4"	228	D	F
Round 7	Eric Herman	OG	6'4"	320	C-	D
Round 7	Michael Cox	RB	6'1"	214	D	C

When the Giants decided to draft offensive lineman Justin Pugh in the first round I was blown away.

Watching Pugh throughout college, it was hard to see the ability that would suggest he'd be an elite-level blocker in the NFL. Teams should never waste a first-round pick on a player who has little to no chance to be one of the best at his position. This is exactly what the Giants did when they valued Pugh’s versatility over his actual ability to block at a high level.  

In terms of steals, they may have landed one of the biggest steals of the year with the selection of DE Damontre Moore in the third round. Moore’s athleticism and consistency has been a huge bright spot for this crop of rookies. His success may just overshadow their first-round failure.    

Overall Grade: C-

Philadelphia Eagles

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Lane Johnson	OT	6'6"	303	B	C-
Round 2	Zach Ertz	TE	6'5"	249	C-	C-
Round 3	Bennie Logan	DT	6'2"	309	C-	A
Round 4	Matt Barkley	QB	6'2"	227	A-	C
Round 5	Earl Wolff	S	5'11"	209	C	C+
Round 7	Joe Kruger	DE	6'6"	269	C+	F
Round 7	Jordan Poyer	CB	6'0"	191	A+	C+
Round 7	David King	DE	6'5"	286	D+	D-

Overachieving undrafted free agents: RB Matthew Tucker (B+), OT Matt Tobin (A).

One of the more interesting storylines of last April’s draft was trying to figure out what type of offense new head coach Chip Kelly was going to implement. We knew it would be fast paced, but we had no idea if he was going to replicate what he had in Oregon.

Drafting Matt Barkley in the fourth round sent a strong message throughout the league that coach Kelly was going to adapt his offense to the talent he has around him.

Cornerback Jordan Poyer could be a real steal in the seventh round. Keep an eye on his impressive ability to take the ball away.

Overall Grade: C+

 

Washington Redskins

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 2	David Amerson	CB	6'1"	205	A	C+
Round 3	Jordan Reed	TE	6'2"	236	C-	C
Round 4	Phillip Thomas	S	6'0"	208	B+	D+
Round 5	Chris Thompson	RB	5'7"	192	D	D-
Round 5	Brandon Jenkins	LB	6'2"	251	D-	C-
Round 6	Bacarri Rambo	S	6'0"	211	A	B-
Round 7	Jawan Jamison	RB	5'7"	203	C	C-

The Redskins’ rookies have not looked as impressive as some of the other teams so far but David Amerson and Bacarri Rambo have each flashed enormous potential.

Rambo has to get better with his pursuit angles as to not give up the big play. Amerson has been looking solid and displayed a surprising willingness to be physical against the run.

Washington fared pretty well for a team without a first-round selection.

Overall Grade: C

Chicago Bears

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Kyle Long	OG	6'6"	313	D-	A+
Round 2	Jonathan Bostic	LB	6'1"	245	C	B
Round 4	Khaseem Greene	LB	6'1"	241	A	C-
Round 5	Jordan Mills	OT	6'5"	316	D	B-
Round 6	Cornelius Washington	OLB	6'4"	265	B	A-
Round 7	Marquess Wilson	WR	6'3"	194	C+	B

Overachieving undrafted free agents: RB Michael Ford (B-).

Clearly I was not high on Kyle Long as a draft prospect. So when the Chicago Bears drafted him in the first round I was extremely surprised. Apparently they saw something in this guy I was unable to see. Long has been the Bears' most impressive offensive lineman throughout this entire preseason.

In the second round the Bears decided to address replacing Brian Urlacher by drafting the very athletic linebacker Jonathan Bostic out of Florida. Bostic seemed to lack instincts while at Florida as he struggled to find the ball or make plays with any regularity. Yet here he is on the big stage racking up impressive highlights throughout the preseason.

The biggest sleeper of this entire group could be the receiver Marquess Wilson, whose stock fell after being kicked off the team while at Washington State.

Cornelius Washington is another guy who could end up vastly outperforming his draft position. His big issue seems to be an inability to finish the play.

As a whole the Bears have done great job adding rookie talent this year.

Overall Grade: B- 

Detroit Lions

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Ziggy Ansah	DE	6'5"	271	D-	C
Round 2	Darius Slay	CB	6'0"	192	D+	D+
Round 3	Larry Warford	OG	6'3"	332	C-	B
Round 4	Devin Taylor	DE	6'7"	266	A	B-
Round 5	Sam Martin	P	6'1"	205	C	B-
Round 6	Corey Fuller	WR	6'2"	204	D-	C-
Round 6	Theo Riddick	RB	5'10"	201	D	B-
Round 7	Michael Williams	TE	6'5"	278	D-	D+
Round 7	Brandon Hepburn	LB	6'2"	240	C	B-

Overachieving undrafted free agents: TE Joseph Fauria (A).

The Detroit Lions were able to bring in a solid group of guys who should be able to contribute in some fashion this season. I don’t see any future stars in this rookie crop which is why I believe they reached big-time for Ziggy Ansah.

Devin Taylor could emerge as the better DE when all is said and done. His measurables and athleticism are arguably more impressive than Ansah's, and he has significantly more football experience.

One of the bright spots on the team has been the play of undrafted tight end Joseph Fauria out of UCLA. This kid has been doing everything right so far in his brief NFL career.

One of the major concerns with Fauria coming out of college was that he was too soft and wouldn’t be able to block in the NFL. So far he appears to have turned his weakness into a real strength. Fauria has been outstanding as a blocker and could become a deadly weapon in the red-zone for quarterback Matthew Stafford.  

Overall Grade: C

Green Bay Packers

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Datone Jones	DE	6'4"	283	A	D+
Round 2	Eddie Lacy	RB	5'11"	231	B	B-
Round 4	David Bakhtiari	OT	6'4"	299	C	C
Round 4	J.C. Tretter	OT	6'4"	307	C+	F
Round 4	Johnathan Franklin	RB	5'10"	205	A+	D-
Round 5	Micah Hyde	CB	6'0"	197	C-	A-
Round 5	Josh Boyd	DE	6'3"	310	B+	A-
Round 6	Nate Palmer	LB	6'3"	240	C	B-
Round 7	Charles Johnson	WR	6'2"	215	D	C-
Round 7	Kevin Dorsey	WR	6'3"	210	D	C-
Round 7	Sam Barrington	LB	6'1"	246	D+	C

Overachieving undrafted free agent: S Chris Banjo (B).

Could this be the year Aaron Rodgers finally has a viable running game?

The Packers did a nice job in last April’s draft strengthening both sides of the ball. We can already expect their first three picks to start in Week 1.

Josh Boyd has looked even better than advertised this summer by making plays consistently on the front line. He could end up playing his way into a steady rotation if he continues to impress with each opportunity.

There were high hopes for Johnathan Franklin heading into the season as I had him rated much higher than the fourth round. He has looked completely unprepared for the speed of the NFL, lacking the strength, vision and quickness to hit the holes before they collapse. However, it is still very early in the evaluation process and Franklin is not one we should give up on just yet.

Overall Grade: C

Minnesota Vikings

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Shariff Floyd	DT	6'3"	297	B	B+
Round 1	Xavier Rhodes	CB	6'1"	210	C-	A-
Round 1	Cordarrelle Patterson	WR	6'2"	216	B-	A
Round 4	Gerald Hodges	LB	6'1"	243	B-	C-
Round 5	Jeff Locke	P	6'0"	209	C	D+
Round 6	Jeff Baca	OG	6'3"	302	A	D
Round 7	Michael Mauti	LB	6'2"	243	C	C-
Round 7	Travis Bond	OG	6'6"	329	C	D
Round 7	Everett Dawkins	DT	6'2"	292	D+	D+

Overachieving undrafted free agents: FB Zach Line (B+).

Anytime you get the luxury of having three first-round draft picks in a single draft you have a distinct advantage over the competition. So far each of the Vikings top-three picks have been impressive.

It’s somewhat surprising to see offensive guard Jeff Baca struggle this much. I considered him one of the better guards in this draft.

The strength of this draft class appears to be in Minnesota’s first-round additions. Following the draft I considered each of those players to have high bust potential. If they keep playing like they have so far, those concerns will soon be a distant memory.    

Overall Grade: C+

Atlanta Falcons

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Desmond Trufant	CB	6'0"	190	A	D-
Round 2	Robert Alford	CB	5'10"	188	B-	A-
Round 4	Malliciah Goodman	DE	6'4"	276	A	B-
Round 4	Levine Toilolo	TE	6'8"	260	D	D
Round 5	Stansly Maponga	DE	6'2"	256	C	D
Round 7	Kemal Ishmael	DB	5'11"	206	D	D+
Round 7	Zeke Motta	S	6'2"	213	C+	B
Round 7	Sean Renfree	QB	6'3"	219	C-	C

Overachieving undrafted free agents: LB Paul Worrilow (A).

Many people believed cornerback Desmond Trufant was overrated; I was not one of those people. As it turns out, it appears I was wrong. But one of the benefits of “double dipping” in an area of need is that you increase your chances of finding the right guy. So far that guy appears to be Robert Alford.

Malliciah Goodman is a nice pickup in the fourth round who should be able to add some much-needed depth on the DL. His upside makes him a great value pick while also filling a big-time need for the Falcons.

Keep an eye on undrafted free agent LB Paul Warrilow. This guy has been a tackling machine.

Overall Grade: C+

Carolina Panthers

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Star Lotulelei	DT	6'2"	311	A	C+
Round 2	Kawann Short	DT	6'3"	299	C+	A-
Round 4	Edmund Kugbila	OG	6'4"	317	D	F
Round 5	A.J. Klein	LB	6'1"	250	C	D-
Round 6	Kenjon Barner	RB	5'9"	196	A+	C-

The Panthers are looking extremely stout in the middle with rookies Star Lotulelei and Kawann Short plugging things up. Each of these players seems to have Pro Bowl potential and should make for a highly frustrating duo for years to come against opposing offenses.

Rookie RB Kenjon Barner was supposed to be a big-time steal in the seventh-round, but so far he’s played the part of underachiever.

The Panthers still need help at the receiver position but at least they have some young pieces on defense to build upon.

Overall Grade: C

New Orleans Saints

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Kenny Vaccaro	S	6'0"	214	A	A-
Round 3	Terron Armstead	OT	6'5"	306	B-	A
Round 3	John Jenkins	DT	6'4"	346	B-	C+
Round 5	Kenny Stills	WR	6'0"	194	C	A+
Round 6	Rufus Johnson	DE/LB	6'4"	266	C-	B-

Overachieving undrafted free agents: RB Khiry Robinson (B+), DE Glenn Foster (A).

Last year the Saints had the worst defense in the NFL. So it only makes sense that their first priority in the draft would come on the defensive side of the ball.

Kenny Vaccaro reminds me a lot of a Troy Polamalu-type at safety. He recklessly throws his body around and loves getting in the mix of a scrum. So far he has lived up to expectations and he will need to play a pivotal role for the Saints defense in 2013.

Receiver Kenny Stills has emerged this preseason as one of the best young wideouts in the game.

It’s saying something when there’s not a single grade below a “C” throughout the entire class of rookies.

Overall Grade: B

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 2	Johnthan Banks	CB	6'2"	185	A+	A
Round 3	Mike Glennon	QB	6'7"	225	C-	B
Round 4	Akeem Spence	DT	6'1"	307	D	B-
Round 4	William Gholston	DE	6'6"	281	B-	A
Round 5	Steven Means	DE	6'3"	260	C+	D
Round 6	Mike James	RB	5'10"	223	D+	A

One of my favorite players from this draft is cornerback Johnthan Banks. Long, lean and equipped with the quickness to close the gap fast. He's also one of the most impressive playmakers entering the NFL this year.

Mike Glennon was drafted to put heat on Josh Freeman at quarterback, but it doesn’t seem like he’s anywhere near ready to start an NFL game.

The Bucs may not have had a first-round draft pick, but they did get a first-round talent in Banks.

Overall Grade: B-

Arizona Cardinals

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Jonathan Cooper	OG	6'2"	311	A-	B
Round 2	Kevin Minter	LB	6'0"	246	B+	C+
Round 3	Tyrann Mathieu	DB	5'9"	186	A-	A
Round 4	Alex Okafor	LB	6'4"	264	A	C
Round 4	Earl Watford	OG	6'3"	300	D	C+
Round 5	Stepfan Taylor	RB	5'9"	214	B	B-
Round 6	Ryan Swope	WR	6'0"	205	B+	F
Round 6	Andre Ellington	RB	5'9"	199	A-	C-
Round 7	D.C. Jefferson	TE	6'6"	255	C+	D

Overachieving undrafted free agents: WR Charles Hawkins (A+), S Tony Jefferson (A).

The Cardinals may have arguably the best draft class of 2013.

Unfortunately they will be without their first-round draft pick Jonathan Cooper for the remainder of the season. He was having a great summer before breaking his leg in last week’s exhibition game.

This crop of rookies could eventually yield five or six starters, including two talented former LSU Tigers, Kevin Minter and Tyrann Mathieu. These guys provide an instant upgrade and attitude to the defense.

Receiver Ryan Swope was forced to retire before his career even began after suffering yet another concussion. He has a history of concussions dating back to his time at Texas A&M.

This crop of rookies is sure to make the Cardinals a much more competitive team in the years to come.

Overall Grade: B-

St. Louis Rams

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Tavon Austin	WR	5'8"	174	A	C-
Round 1	Alec Ogletree	LB	6'2"	242	C-	C-
Round 3	T.J. McDonald	S	6'2"	219	A	C+
Round 3	Stedman Bailey	WR	5'10"	193	A	C
Round 4	Barrett Jones	OG	6'4"	306	C+	C-
Round 5	Brandon McGee	CB	5'11"	193	C-	C-
Round 5	Zac Stacy	RB	5'8"	216	A+	D

Overachieving undrafted free agents: LB Ray-Ray Armstrong (A), S Rashard Hall (A-).

The Rams brought in a promising draft class in 2013; adding talent and speed to both sides of the ball. It’s clear they coveted linebackers who can cover and wanted to surround Sam Bradford with dangerous weapons on offense.

Tavon Austin should be an exciting addition as he is joined by his college teammate Stedman Bailey. These two receivers know how to make people miss and pose a deadly threat to defenses each time they touch the ball.

Fifth-round running back Zac Stacy has struggled early which has taken him out of the hunt for the starting running back job. However, this kid is built in the same mold as Tampa Bay’s phenomenal running back Doug Martin. Expect Stacy to have a productive career once he becomes familiar with the pace of the NFL game.

Overall Grade: B-

San Francisco 49ers

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 1	Eric Reid	S	6'1"	213	C	B+
Round 2	Cornellius Carradine	DE	6'4"	276	C-	F
Round 2	Vance McDonald	TE	6'4"	267	A	A
Round 3	Corey Lemonier	LB	6'3"	255	A+	A
Round 4	Quinton Patton	WR	6'0"	204	A	C+
Round 4	Marcus Lattimore	RB	5'11"	221	A	F
Round 5	Quinton Dial	DE	6'5"	318	C-	F
Round 6	Nick Moody	LB	6'1"	236	C-	C+
Round 7	B.J. Daniels	QB	6'0"	217	C+	A
Round 7	Carter Bykowski	OT	6'6"	306	D	D
Round 7	Marcus Cooper	DB	6'2"	192	C+	B

Overachieving undrafted free agent: DL Mike Purcell (B).

San Francisco knew they could address their future in the 2013 draft which is exactly what they did when they picked up Tank Carradine and Marcus Lattimore.

Eric Reid was their top prize when they traded up in the first round to snag him. He should step in as the immediate starter at free safety, filling the void left by the departure of All-Pro Dashon Goldson.

Receiver Quinton Patton looked impressive in his Week 3 performance against the Vikings. He could end up playing a major role in this offense due to several key injuries at the position.

Tight end Vance McDonald is a tough, hard-nosed guy that Jim Harbaugh loves to have on his team. He should help keep defenses from overloading their coverage on Vernon Davis.

Corey Lemonier is a dynamic pass-rusher who has first-round talent. He has shown an incredible burst off the edge this summer and should be able to provide some added help in passing situations.

The core of this 49ers’ draft class is promising on both sides of the ball.  

Overall Grade: C+

Seattle Seahawks

Draft Round	Player	Position	Height	Weight	Draft Grade	Preseason Grade
Round 2	Christine Michael	RB	5'10"	220	A	A+
Round 3	Jordan Hill	DT	6'1"	303	C+	B
Round 4	Chris Harper	WR	6'1"	229	C+	C
Round 5	Jesse Williams	DT	6'3"	323	D+	C-
Round 5	Tharold Simon	CB	6'2"	202	C	F
Round 5	Luke Wilson	TE	6'5"	251	C	B+
Round 6	Spencer Ware	RB	5'10"	228	C	B+
Round 7	Ryan Seymour	OG	6'5"	300	C	D+
Round 7	Ty Powell	DE/LB	6'2"	249	D+	C+
Round 7	Jared Smith	DT	6'3"	302	C	F
Round 7	Michael Bowie	OT	6'5"	330	C	C-

Overachieving undrafted free agent: OLB/DE Benson Mayowa (A).

One of the most physically gifted athletes in the NFL has been added to an already stellar unit of running backs. Christine Michael is as fun to watch as he is hard to tackle. He should eventually replace Marshawn Lynch as the featured back in a few years down the line.

The Seattle Seahawks are loaded with talent and only continue to get better with each passing year. It’s hard to tell which of these gifted rookies will contribute the most in Year 1 given the depth at each position. Unfortunately, they seem to be underperforming at the one position group where they could use the most help: wide receiver.

Chris Harper is big, fast and loaded with potential, but he needs to step it up if he’s going to receive playing time in the regular season.   

Pete Carroll may have found some mid-round gems in tight end Luke Wilson and running back Spencer Ware. So far each of these players has made a strong case for a spot on the final roster. 

The stage is now set for this team to make the final push for dominance in the NFC West.

Overall Grade: C

Follow @Ryan_Riddle