NFL Draft Grades 2013: Full Evaluations for Every Organization
The future of a franchise is at stake during the NFL draft.
It's a fascinating investment risk as well, because teams are expecting immediate dividends on players with obviously zero professional experience. Sure the Senior Bowl, East-West Shrine Game, combine and pro days provide a small sense of the NFL atmosphere, but the big stage will unveil full transparency.
This is also why we have seen plenty of top-talented athletes fail to live up to pro football's expectations. On the contrary, it's not surprising when a late-round selection or undrafted free agent makes a quick impact.
That's simply the enigma of the draft process, which is also why every selection matters. So, just because a team landed a key prospect in Round 1 doesn't mean it received an A-grade. How each fared throughout all of late April is below, along with a few highlighted teams that impressed.
Team | Grade |
| New York Giants | B |
| Dallas Cowboys | D- |
| Philadelphia Eagles | B+ |
| Washington Redskins | C |
| Pittsburgh Steelers | A |
| Baltimore Ravens | A- |
| Cleveland Browns | C- |
| Cincinnati Bengals | B+ |
| Green Bay Packers | B+ |
| Detroit Lions | B- |
| Minnesota Vikings | A- |
| Chicago Bears | C |
| Houston Texans | B+ |
| Indianapolis Colts | D+ |
| Tennessee Titans | B |
| Jacksonville Jaguars | B+ |
| Atalanta Falcons | A- |
| New Orleans Saints | B- |
| Tampa Bay Buccaneers | B |
| Carolina Panthers | C |
| Denver Broncos | B |
| Kansas City Chiefs | A |
| Oakland Raiders | C |
| San Diego Chargers | A |
| Arizona Cardinals | B+ |
| Seattle Seahawks | B- |
| San Francisco 49ers | B- |
| St. Louis Rams | A- |
| New England Patriots | C |
| Buffalo Bills | C+ |
| Miami Dolphins | B |
| New York Jets | C+ |
Baltimore Ravens
Given all of Baltimore's offseason departures, the Ravens really helped themselves during the draft.
Florida safety Matt Elam was a huge get at the end of Round 1. As a true playmaker with a nose for the ball, Elam defended 18 passes the previous two seasons and collected 22 tackles for loss.
Baltimore immediately complemented him with Arthur Brown from Kansas State. Brown is just as reliable when it comes to locating the ball, as evidenced by his 201 tackles and nine defended passes between 2011 and 2012.
Thereafter, the Ravens made other strong selections in Wisconsin tackle Ricky Wagner, Notre Dame defensive end Kapron Lewis-Moore (six sacks, two forced fumbles in 2012) and California corner Marc Anthony (26 career defended passes).
Baltimore is still in a brief replenishing period, though. Not only will it be difficult relying on multiple rookies, but the Ravens will also get every opponent's A-game after winning Super Bowl XLVII. Nevertheless, expect coach John Harbaugh's team to enter 2013 as the AFC North favorites.
Atlanta Falcons
The Falcons had to address the defensive side of the ball to remain Super Bowl contenders.
Fortunately for Atlanta, adding cornerbacks Desmond Trufant and Robert Alford brings top-talented depth to its secondary. The Dirty Birds also helped the spruced-up pass defense with sound pass-rushers in Clemson's Malliciah Goodman and TCU's Stansly Maponga.
Improved coverage in the secondary will allow these guys more time to apply pressure, which obviously increases their production.
In college, each produced well. Goodman forced eight fumbles and racked up 17 tackles for loss from 2010 through 2012. As for Maponga, he too created eight fumbles and accounted for 23 tackles for loss in three seasons.
The Falcons later snagged a gem in Central Florida safety Kemal Ishmael. During his tenure for the Knights, Ishmael recorded 368 tackles, defended 19 passes and forced six fumbles. Ultimately, Atlanta is building a more aggressive defense to control the line and generate turnovers.
Seattle Seahawks
Even though the Seahawks didn't have a Round 1 selection, Seattle made some impressive draft picks.
Two underrated selections occurred along the defensive line. In Round 3, Seattle grabbed Penn State's Jordan Hill and then Alabama's Jesse Williams in Round 5. Hill amassed 16.5 tackles for loss and eight sacks in two seasons, whereas Williams recorded 61 tackles.
Obviously Hill is the better statistical defender here, which will be a competitive advantage on third down and inside the red zone. Williams, on the other hand, is a force at eating blocks and flushing the quarterback out of the pocket.
Each will contribute to the rotation and offer great depth to Seattle's front wall.
Other solid selections include running back Christine Michael (change of pace), receiver Chris Harper (capable deep threat) and corner Tharold Simon (nickel/dime back playmaker).
Round 1
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 1. | Chiefs | Eric Fisher | OT | Cent. Michigan |
| 2. | Jaguars | Luke Joeckel | OT | Texas A&M |
| 3. | Dolphins* | Dion Jordan | DE | Oregon |
| 4. | Eagles | Lane Johnson | OT | Oklahoma |
| 5. | Lions | Ezekiel Ansah | DE | BYU |
| 6. | Browns | Barkevious Mingo | DE | LSU |
| 7. | Cardinals | Jonathan Cooper | OG | UNC |
| 8. | Rams* | Tavon Austin | WR | West Virginia |
| 9. | Jets | Dee Milliner | CB | Alabama |
| 10. | Titans | Chance Warmack | OG | Alabama |
| 11. | Chargers | D.J. Fluker | OT | Alabama |
| 12. | Raiders* | D.J. Hayden | CB | Houston |
| 13. | Jets* | Sheldon Richardson | DT | Missouri |
| 14. | Panthers | Star Lotulelei | DT | Utah |
| 15. | Saints | Kenny Vaccaro | S | Texas |
| 16. | Bills* | EJ Manuel | QB | Florida State |
| 17. | Steelers | Jarvis Jones | OLB | Georgia |
| 18. | 49ers* | Eric Reid | S | LSU |
| 19. | Giants | Justin Pugh | OG | Syracuse |
| 20. | Bears | Kyle Long | OG | Oregon |
| 21. | Bengals | Tyler Eifert | TE | Notre Dame |
| 22. | Falcons* | Desmond Trufant | CB | Washington |
| 23. | Vikings | Sharrif Floyd | DT | Florida |
| 24. | Colts | Bjoern Werner | DE | Florida State |
| 25. | Vikings* | Xavier Rhodes | CB | Florida State |
| 26. | Packers | Datone Jones | DE | UCLA |
| 27. | Texans | DeAndre Hopkins | WR | Clemson |
| 28. | Broncos | Sylvester Williams | DT | UNC |
| 29. | Vikings* | Cordarrelle Patterson | WR | Tennessee |
| 30. | Rams* | Alec Ogletree | OLB | Georgia |
| 31. | Cowboys* | Travis Frederick | C | Wisconsin |
| 32. | Ravens | Matt Elam | S | Florida |
Round 2
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 33. | Jaguars | Johnathan Cyprien | S | FIU |
| 34. | Titans* | Justin Hunter | WR | Tennessee |
| 35. | Eagles | Zach Ertz | TE | Stanford |
| 36. | Lions | Darius Slay | CB | Mississippi St. |
| 37. | Bengals* | Giovani Bernard | RB | North Carolina |
| 38. | Chargers* | Manti Te'o | ILB | Notre Dame |
| 39. | Jets | Geno Smith | QB | West Virginia |
| 40. | 49ers* | Cornellius Carradine | DE | Florida State |
| 41. | Bills | Robert Woods | WR | USC |
| 42. | Raiders* | Menelik Watson | OT | Florida State |
| 43. | Buccaneers | Johnthan Banks | CB | Mississippi St. |
| 44. | Panthers | Kawann Short | DT | Purdue |
| 45. | Cardinals* | Kevin Minter | ILB | LSU |
| 46. | Bills* | Kiko Alonso | ILB | Oregon |
| 47. | Cowboys | Gavin Escobar | TE | San Diego St. |
| 48. | Steelers | Le'Veon Bell | RB | Michigan St. |
| 49. | Giants | Johnathan Hankins | DT | Ohio State |
| 50. | Bears | Jon Bostic | ILB | Florida |
| 51. | Redskins | David Amerson | CB | NC State |
| 52. | Patriots* | Jamie Collins | OLB | Southern Miss |
| 53. | Bengals | Margus Hunt | DE | SMU |
| 54. | Dolphins* | Jamar Taylor | CB | Boise State |
| 55. | 49ers* | Vance McDonald | TE | Rice |
| 56. | Ravens* | Arthur Brown | OLB | Kansas State |
| 57. | Texans | D.J. Swearinger | S | South Carolina |
| 58. | Broncos | Montee Ball | RB | Wisconsin |
| 59. | Patriots | Aaron Dobson | WR | Marshall |
| 60. | Falcons | Robert Alford | CB | SE Louisiana |
| 61. | Packers* | Eddie Lacy | RB | Alabama |
| 62. | Seahawks* | Christine Michael | RB | Texas A&M |
Round 3
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 63. | Chiefs | Travis Kelce | TE | Cincinnati |
| 64. | Jaguars | Dwayne Gratz | CB | Connecticut |
| 65. | Lions | Larry Worford | OG | Kentucky |
| 66. | Raiders | Sio Moore | OLB | Connecticut |
| 67. | Eagles | Bennie Logan | DT | LSU |
| 68. | Browns | Leon McFadden | CB | San Diego St. |
| 69. | Cardinals | Tyrann Mathieu | CB | LSU |
| 70. | Titans | Blidi Wreh-Wilson | CB | Connecticut |
| 71. | Rams* | T.J. McDonald | S | USC |
| 72. | Jets | Brian Winters | OG | Kent State |
| 73. | Buccaneers | Mike Glennon | QB | NC State |
| 74. | Cowboys* | Terrance Williams | WR | Baylor |
| 75. | Saints | Terron Armstead | OT | Arkansas-Pine Bluff |
| 76. | Chargers | Keenan Allen | WR | California |
| 77. | Dolphins | Dallas Thomas | OG | Tennessee |
| 78. | Bills* | Marquise Goodwin | WR | Texas |
| 79. | Steelers | Markus Wheaton | WR | Oregon State |
| 80. | Cowboys | J.J. Wilcox | S | Georgia Southern |
| 81. | Giants | Damontre Moore | DE | Texas A&M |
| 82. | Saints* | John Jenkins | DT | Georiga |
| 83. | Patriots* | Logan Ryan | CB | Rutgers |
| 84. | Bengals | Shawn Williams | S | Georgia |
| 85. | Redskins | Jordan Reed | TE | Florida |
| 86. | Colts | Hugh Thornton | OG | Illinois |
| 87. | Seahawks | Jordan Hill | DT | Penn State |
| 88. | 49ers* | Corey Lemonier | DE | Auburn |
| 89. | Texans | Brennan Williams | OT | North Carolina |
| 90. | Broncos | Kayvon Webster | CB | South Florida |
| 91. | Patriots | Duron Harmon | S | Rutgers |
| 92. | Rams* | Stedman Bailey | WR | West Virginia |
| 93. | Dolphins* | Will Davis | CB | Utah State |
| 94. | Ravens | Brandon Williams | DT | Missouri Southern St. |
| 95. | Texans | Sam Montgomery | DE | LSU |
| 96. | Chiefs | Knile Davis | RB | Arkansas |
| 97. | Titans | Zaviar Gooden | OLB | Missouri |
Round 4
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 98. | Eagles* | Matt Barkley | QB | USC |
| 99. | Chiefs | Nico Johnson | ILB | Alabama |
| 100. | Buccaneers* | Akeem Spence | DT | Illinois |
| 101. | Jaguars* | Ace Sanders | WR | South Carolina |
| 102. | Patriots* | Josh Boyce | WR | TCU |
| 103. | Cardinals | Alex Okafor | DE | Texas |
| 104. | Dolphins* | Jelani Jenkins | OLB | Florida |
| 105. | Bills | Duke Williams | S | Nevada |
| 106. | Dolphins* | Dion Sims | TE | Michigan State |
| 107. | Titans | Brian Schwenke | C | California |
| 108. | Panthers | Edmund Kugbila | OG | Valdosta State |
| 109. | Packers* | David Bakhtiari | OT | Colorado |
| 110. | Giants* | Ryan Nassib | QB | Syracuse |
| 111. | Steelers* | Shamarko Thomas | S | Syracuse |
| 112. | Raiders* | Tyler Wilson | QB | Arkansas |
| 113. | Rams | Barrett Jones | C | Alabama |
| 114. | Cowboys | B.W. Webb | CB | William & Mary |
| 115. | Steelers | Landry Jones | QB | Oklahoma |
| 116. | Cardinals* | Earl Watford | OG | James Madison |
| 117. | Bears | Khaseem Greene | OLB | Rutgers |
| 118. | Bengals | Sean Porter | OLB | Texas A&M |
| 119. | Redskins | Phillip Thomas | S | Fresno State |
| 120. | Vikings | Gerald Hodges | OLB | Penn State |
| 121. | Colts | Khaled Holmes | C | USC |
| 122. | Packers | J.C. Tretter | OG | Cornell |
| 123. | Seahawks | Chris Harper | WR | Kansas State |
| 124. | Texans | Trevardo Williams | DE | Connecticut |
| 125. | Packers* | Johnathan Franklin | RB | UCLA |
| 126. | Buccaneers* | William Gholston | DE | Michigan State |
| 127. | Falcons | Malliciah Goodman | DE | Clemson |
| 128. | 49ers | Quinton Patton | WR | Louisiana Tech |
| 129. | Ravens | John Simon | DE | Ohio State |
| 130. | Ravens | Kyle Juszczyk | FB | Harvard |
| 131. | 49ers | Marcus Lattimore | RB | South Carolina |
| 132. | Lions | Devin Taylor | DE | South Carolina |
| 133. | Falcons | Levine Toilolo | TE | Stanford |
Round 5
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 134. | Chiefs | Sanders Commings | CB | Georgia |
| 135. | Jaguars | Denard Robinson | WR | Michigan |
| 136, | Eagles | Earl Wolff | S | NC State |
| 137. | Seahawks* | Jesse Williams | DT | Alabama |
| 138. | Seahawks* | Tharold Simon | CB | LSU |
| 139. | Colts* | Montori Hughes | DT | Tenn-Martin |
| 140. | Cardinals | Stepfan Taylor | RB | Stanford |
| 141. | Jets | Oday Aboushi | OG | Virginia |
| 142. | Titans | Lavar Edwards | DE | LSU |
| 143. | Bills | Jonathan Meeks | S | Clemson |
| 144. | Saints | Kenny Stills | WR | Oklahoma |
| 145. | Chargers | Steve Williams | CB | California |
| 146. | Broncos* | Quanterus Smith | DE | Western Kentucky |
| 147. | Buccaneers | Steven Means | OLB | Buffalo |
| 148. | Panthers | A.J. Klein | ILB | Iowa State |
| 149. | Rams | Brandon McGee | CB | Miami (FL) |
| 150. | Steelers | Terry Hawthorne | CB | Illinois |
| 151. | Cowboys | Joseph Randle | RB | Oklahoma State |
| 152. | Giants | Cooper Taylor | S | Richmond |
| 153. | Falcons* | Stansly Maponga | DE | TCU |
| 154. | Redskins | Chris Thompson | RB | Florida State |
| 155. | Vikings | Jeff Locke | P | UCLA |
| 156. | Bengals | Tanner Hawkinson | OT | Kansas |
| 157. | 49ers* | Quinton Dial | DE | Alabama |
| 158. | Seahawks | Luke Wilson | TE | Rice |
| 159. | Packers | Micah Hyde | CB | Iowa |
| 160. | Rams* | Zac Stacy | RB | Vanderbilt |
| 161. | Broncos | Tavarres King | WR | Georgia |
| 162. | Redskins* | Brandon Jenkins | OLB | Florida State |
| 163. | Bears* | Jordan Mills | OT | Louisiana Tech |
| 164. | Dolphins* | Mike Gillislee | RB | Florida |
| 165. | Lions* | Sam Martin | P | Appalachian St. |
| 166. | Dolphins | Caleb Sturgis | K | Florida |
| 167. | Packers | Josh Boyd | DT | Mississippi St. |
| 168. | Ravens | Ricky Wagner | OT | Wisconsin |
Round 6
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 169, | Jaguars | Josh Evans | S | Florida |
| 170. | Chiefs | Eric Kush | C | California (PA) |
| 171. | Lions | Corey Fuller | WR | Virginia Tech |
| 172. | Raiders | Nick Kasa | TE | Colorado |
| 173. | Broncos* | Vinston Painter | OT | Virginia Tech |
| 174. | Cardinals | Ryan Swope | WR | Texas A&M |
| 175. | Browns | Jamoris Slaughter | S | Notre Dame |
| 176. | Texans* | David Quessenberry | OT | San Jose State |
| 177. | Bills | Dustin Hopkins | K | Florida State |
| 178. | Jets | William Campbell | DT | Michigan |
| 179. | Chargers | Tourek Williams | DE | FIU |
| 180. | 49ers* | Nick Moody | OLB | Florida State |
| 181. | Raiders* | Latavius Murray | RB | Central Florida |
| 182. | Panthers | Kenjon Barner | RB | Oregon |
| 183. | Saints | Rufus Johnson | DE | Tarleton State |
| 184. | Raiders* | Mychal Rivera | TE | Tennessee |
| 185. | Cowboys | DeVonte Holloman | OLB | South Carolina |
| 186. | Steelers | Justin Brown | WR | Oklahoma |
| 187. | Cardinals* | Andre Ellington | RB | Clemson |
| 188. | Bears | Cornelius Washington | DE | Georgia |
| 189. | Buccaneers* | Mike James | RB | Miami (FL) |
| 190. | Bengals | Rex Burkhead | RB | Nebraska |
| 191. | Redskins | Bacarri Rambo | S | Georgia |
| 192. | Colts | John Boyett | S | Oregon |
| 193. | Packers | Nate Palmer | OLB | Illinois State |
| 194. | Seahawks | Spencer Ware | RB | LSU |
| 195. | Texans | Alan Bonner | WR | Jacksonville St. |
| 196. | Vikings* | Jeff Baca | OG | UCLA |
| 197. | Bengals* | Cobi Hamilton | WR | Arkansas |
| 198. | Texans* | Chris Jones | DT | Bowling Green |
| 199. | Lions* | Theo Riddick | RB | Notre Dame |
| 200. | Ravens | Kapron Lewis-Moore | DE | Notre Dame |
| 201. | Texans | Ryan Griffin | TE | Connecticut |
| 202. | Titans | Khalid Wooten | CB | Nevada |
| 203. | Ravens | Ryan Jensen | OG | Colorado St.-Pueblo |
| 204. | Chiefs | Braden Wilson | FB | Kansas State |
| 205. | Raiders | Stacy McGee | DT | Oklahoma |
| 206. | Steelers | Vince Williams | ILB | Florida State |
Round 7
| Pick | Team | Player | Position | School |
| 207. | Chiefs | Mike Catapano | DE | Princeton |
| 208. | Jaguars | Jeremy Harris | CB | New Mexico St. |
| 209. | Raiders | Brice Butler | WR | San Diego State |
| 210. | Jaguars* | Demetrius McCray | CB | Appalachian St. |
| 211. | Lions | Michael Williams | TE | Alabama |
| 212. | Eagles* | Joe Kruger | DE | Utah |
| 213. | Vikings* | Michael Mauti | ILB | Penn State |
| 214. | Vikings* | Travis Bond | OG | North Carolina |
| 215. | Jets | Tommy Bohanon | FB | Wake Forest |
| 216. | Packers* | Charles Johnson | WR | Grand Valley St. |
| 217. | Browns* | Armonty Bryant | DE | E. Central Oklahoma |
| 218. | Eagles* | Jodran Poyer | CB | Oregon State |
| 219. | Cardinals* | D.C. Jefferson | TE | Rutgers |
| 220. | Seahawks* | Ryan Seymour | OG | Vanderbilt |
| 221. | Chargers | Brad Sorensen | QB | Southern Utah |
| 222. | Bills* | Chris Gragg | TE | Arkansas |
| 223. | Steelers | Nick Williams | DT | Samford |
| 224. | Packers* | Kevin Dorsey | WR | Maryland |
| 225. | Giants | Eric Herman | OG | Ohio |
| 226. | Patriots* | Michael Buchanan | DE | Illinois |
| 227. | Browns* | Garrett Gilkey | OG | Chadron State |
| 228. | Redskins | Jawan Jamison | RB | Rutgers |
| 229. | Vikings* | Everett Dawkins | DT | Florida State |
| 230. | Colts | Kerwynn Williams | RB | Utah State |
| 231. | Seahawks | Ty Powell | OLB | Harding |
| 232. | Packers | Sam Barrington | OLB | South Florida |
| 233. | Raiders* | David Bass | DE | Missouri Western |
| 234. | Broncos | Zac Dysert | QB | Miami (Ohio) |
| 235. | Patriots | Steve Beauharnais | ILB | Rutgers |
| 236. | Bears* | Marquess Wilson | WR | Washington State |
| 237. | 49ers | B.J. Daniels | QB | South Florida |
| 238. | Ravens | Aaron Mellette | WR | Elon |
| 239. | Eagles | David King | DE | Oklahoma |
| 240. | Bengals | Reid Fragel | OT | Ohio State |
| 241. | Seahawks | Jared Smith | DT | New Hampshire |
| 242. | Seahawks | Michael Bowie | OT | NE Oklahoma State |
| 243. | Falcons | Kemal Ishmael | CB | Central Florida |
| 244. | Falcons | Zeke Motta | S | Notre Dame |
| 245. | Lions | Brandon Hepburn | ILB | Florida A&M |
| 246. | 49ers | Carter Bykowski | OT | Iowa State |
| 247. | Ravens | Marc Anthony | CB | California |
| 248. | Titans | Daimion Stafford | S | Nebraska |
| 249. | Falcons | Sean Renfree | QB | Duke |
| 250. | Dolphins | Don Jones | S | Arkansas State |
| 251. | Bengals | T.J. Johnson | C | South Carolina |
| 252. | 49ers | Marcus Cooper | CB | Rutgers |
| 253. | Giants | Michael Cox | RB | Massachusetts |
| 254. | Colts | Justice Cunningham | TE | South Carolina |
Note: An asterisk (*) indicates that a trade was made for the pick
.png)
.jpg)








