Great article on J.J. Redick, I thought you demonstrated sympathy on a controversial issue, and yet didn't give Redick a free pass about how he said things. I'm impressed, added you to fav writers!
I'm a new guy to your writing, but I put your name to memory after reading your article on RGIII's reponse to criticism. I was hoping to learn something here, but you were so broadly damning of his critics that you lost me. Saying that you can't compare RGIII to Vick because it's unfair, but deciding you can compare RGIII to Cam because it speaks better for RGIII is pretty biased. I hope you're right, honestly, I think the old school pigskin guys have too much invested in making sure the new, more athletic QBs like RGIII fail. But that doesn't give you license to be a hypocrite. You've got bad habits of using just as many poor arguments as all the haters. Don't lower yourself to their level, I want to remember your name for a good reason...