Alshon Jeffery was the subject of great debate during the 2012 NFL draft season. His weight, his speed, his dramatically different levels of production in 2010 and 2011, and his non-participation at the combine inspired many to take strong stances for and against Jeffery as a draft prospect.

The dual nature of the opinions in the draft community carries over to an inspection of his film and subsequent projection to what he'll do with the Chicago Bears, who took Jeffery in the second round. Even taken in the most positive light, Jeffery looks like a player that will inspire agony and ecstasy from Bears fans, often in the same game.

For this exercise, I watched cut-ups of his games from 2010, his best year. No excuses of poor quarterback play can be made for Jeffery.

The first thing that stands out is that Jeffery is not fast or sudden. He's not going to create great separation or make much happen after the catch. On the other hand, Jeffery displays a terrific knack for getting behind the defensive back in the red zone, creating touchdowns at :10, 3:13, and 3:45. 

Read More »4

When a team has three of the first 37 picks of the draft, you expect them to rely on their rookies more heavily than any other team. The surprising result of an analysis of which rookies the Cleveland Browns could include in their starting 22 against the Eagles in Week 1 is that injuries and poor recent drafting could force them to start as many six first-year players.

Let's start with the obvious choices. The No. 3 overall pick Trent Richardson will be the Browns' starting running back. Fellow first-rounder quarterback Brandon Weeden will start barring a preseason meltdown no matter what general manager Tom Heckert and team president Mike Holmgren say about an open competition at his position. Second-round right tackle Mitchell Schwartz will be better than Oniel Cousins even while he adjusts to the speed and power of the NFL game on the fly.

All three took first-team snaps at this week's OTA practice open to the media according to Mary Kay Cabot of the Cleveland Plain Dealer, and they will almost certainly do the same in September. Teams in the midst of rebuilding like the Browns often put their top rookies in from day one, and the Cincinnati Bengals proved last year that rookie-led teams can even make the playoffs.

Having two first-round picks and an early second-round pick starting shouldn't raise any eyebrows. Trotting out a third-rounder and two fourth-rounders, on the other hand, can never be a good sign for a team's fortunes.

Read More »15

The Seahawks have been one of the most unpredictable teams in the draft since head coach Pete Carroll and general manager John Schneider took over in 2010. Their bold moves always give us plenty talk about when analyzing their rookie class.

Which rookie storylines are the most fascinating going into next week's OTA and the team minicamp from June 12-14?

Can first-round pick Bruce Irvin take advantage of defensive end Chris Clemons' absence at OTAs to earn a larger immediate role?

Chris Clemons has been very productive for the Seahawks since coming over from Philadelphia, but he is in the last year of his contract and Brock Huard of ESPN 710 thinks it's because he wants a new contract. While he's away, Clemons could actually lose leverage if Irvin impresses in his stead and shows signs that he can suitably replace Clemons next year.

Read More »5

No NFL team experienced a more dramatic changing of the guard in the last year than the Oakland Raiders. After the passing of Al Davis, quite possibly the most hands-on owner in the league, the Raiders let Hue Jackson have the reins just long enough to trade away their 2012 first-round pick and 2013 second-round pick for Carson Palmer. The team had already used their second, third, and fourth-round picks in trades and the 2011 supplemental draft. New general manager Reggie McKenzie only had a knife at the gunfight that was the 2012 NFL Draft, but he wasn't going to shy away from the task at hand. What can we conclude about his and the Raiders' new philosophy in light of the picks and moves they made?

The Raiders are no longer going to be obsessed with speed.

McKenzie hinted at this before the draft, saying "We're not looking for guys that just run fast." He doesn't need to focus on speed because Al Davis's fixation on 40 times has the team stocked with speed all over the field.

The moving on from the need for speed was best shown by the choice of Criner, a big wide receiver who fell to the fifth round because he runs in the 4.6s. McKenzie said Criner is quick for a big guy, which meant the lack of speed wasn't a "red flag".

Read More »8

When Ryan Broyles suffered a torn ACL in November, it seemed certain that his draft stock would take a huge hit and he would be unlikely to make a big impact in his rookie year. The Detroit Lions still took Broyles in the second round, and according to CBS Sports' Rob Rang, they believe he can be back on the field full-time for training camp. What should we expect to see when Broyles does get on the field?

Broyles shared in his post-draft conference call that he actually got an email of encouragement from New England Patriots wide receiver Wes Welker, who similarly shocked observers by coming back from an ACL tear before anyone expected it. Broyles insisted that he shouldn't be pigeonholed as a Welker-type slot receiver, saying that he can play inside and outside and that they rotated him for "basically (his) whole career" at Oklahoma.

Does Broyles' tape reflect his statement?

Not quite. The following cut-ups of three of his 2010 games shows that Broyles does most of his damage either in the slot or lined up off the line of scrimmage. He catches a lot of passes near the line of scrimmage on the Oklahoma version of a wide receiver screen.

Read More »4

Becoming the NCAA all-time leader in kickoff return and all-purpose yardage in only three years should be enough to get a player drafted. However, when that player is suspended for their entire senior season and withdraws from school during that beleaguered year, the only chance they'll have to make it in the NFL is by impressing as an undrafted free agent.

That's exactly what Damaris Johnson has been doing during his first month with the Philadelphia Eagles. The 5'8", 170-pound mighty mite signed on with a team that is somewhat unsettled at wide receiver beyond the top three of Jeremy Maclin, DeSean Jackson and Jason Avant.

Now, according to many reports, he's standing out enough to possibly make the team.

Tommy Lawlor of the Eagles' official website wrote that Johnson was a "hot name" and "everyone was impressed with his quickness and elusiveness" during the Eagles' rookie minicamp. Meanwhile, Ed Kracz of Phillyburbs.com writes that Johnson has had a "steady" three weeks of practice, catching everything thrown his way. Kracz speculates that Johnson could push Chad Hall for a roster spot.  

Read More »5

Pittsburgh Steelers fans have been calling for the team to fix the offensive line via the draft for years, and in April, they finally got their wish. The team's first- and second-round picks were used to upgrade the offensive line, and both could start the season opener vs. the Denver Broncos.

The Steelers were elated to land offensive guard David DeCastro at the 24th pick. Jason La Canfora of CBS Sports even reported that the team had a deal in place to move up to No. 16 for DeCastro.

The Stanford product, who gave up only one sack in his college career while protecting Andrew Luck, has been projected as a plug-and-play starter from day one, and the team's enthusiasm to add him would indicate that they plan to start him.

There is one complicating factor, and it involves second-round offensive tackle Mike Adams' chances to start. If the Steelers leave Willie Colon at right tackle and Marcus Gilbert at left tackle, Adams is unlikely to break the starting lineup. Instead, he would be the team's swing tackle, and DeCastro would only need to beat out end-of-the-roster fodder Trai Essex to start. 

Read More »7

The San Francisco 49ers were this close to the Super Bowl last year.

The team devoted most of their draft to upgrading the offensive line and playmakers. As we watch for dispatches from their OTAs, what are the best rookie storylines to follow in the upcoming OTAs from June 4-7 and team minicamp from June 12-14?

Will Randy Moss delay first-round pick A.J. Jenkins arrival in the first-team pass offense?

With free-agent signing Randy Moss looking like the Moss of old, according to tight end Vernon Davis, will there be a place for A.J. Jenkins? The team also signed Mario Manningham, presumably to start, and they also often run two-tight end sets with Davis and Delanie Walker.

Read More »8