Debate: Who Truly Deserves to Win the 2011 Heisman?

Debate

Debate: Who Truly Deserves to Win the 2011 Heisman?

7,918 reads

95

107531432_crop_650x440

By the process of elimination, I will uncover the winner on my imaginary ballot. Robert Griffin III is an intriguing...Full Comment»

We are proud to bring you B/R's new Reader Debates. Jump into the Debate and have your say.  Agree with someone's comment? Vote for it to make the Debate Highlights section. Disagree with a comment? Reply and voice your opinion. Happy Debating!

Jump into the debate
and have your say.

Agree with someone's comment? Vote for it to make the Debate Highlights section. Disagree with a comment? Reply and voice your opinion. Happy Debating!

Add Comment
I still say Andrew Luck. His stock has fallen off of late but if we are still looking at the best player overall in college football, I still g... Full comment »
Top Comment
23 votes
Tim Coughlin Rory Brown matthew lowe Matt  Smith
6+
1
By the process of elimination, I will uncover the winner on my imaginary ballot. Robert Griffin III is an intriguing c...
23 votes
Bryan Goldberg Tracey Robertson
6+
2
When using offensive numbers to determine how good a player on offense is, one has to consider the worth of the defenses...
14 votes
Dave Morrison Jonathan McDanal
6+
3
The Heisman is a three pronged award. At least in the past, the award was based on a "body of work" accumulated over sev...
12 votes
Dave Morrison
6+
4
Interesting choices this year all-around. In any other year, the top three (Luck, RG III, and Richardson IMHO) would hav...
11 votes
Matt  Smith
6+
5
If you look at what Montee Ball has accomplished this season in a conference known for stout run defenses, it's pretty a...
11 votes
Stix Symmonds matthew lowe Mary Boda
6+
6
Montee Ball. When the Big Ten has a Heisman candidate, it usually means that player is actually the best in the country ...

Debate Zone

Debate Closed

87 Comments

There are no comments yet. Get the conversation started by leaving the first comment
Big
Loading comments...
just now posted just now
  • Loading...
  • Nobody has liked this comment yet
Cancel

This comment and all replies have been deleted This comment has been deleted Undo delete

Follow B/R on Facebook

Fans of

Icon_subscribe
Icon_youtube
Icon_google
College Football

Subscribe Now

We will never share your email address

Thanks for signing up.

We're Scouting Top Writers

BCS Chances for Every Top 50 Team Hint: you can use arrow keys to navigate through this channel.