The funny part is, he's one of the most over-scrutinized, doubted players in the NFL, yet people actually have the nerve to call him over-rated?
By definition, that makes no sense whatsoever. Someone who is overrated is constantly praised despite not playing up to expectations.
You basically should judge a player in whether or not they are over or underrated based on the opinion from unbiased NFL fans. The consensus from that group seems to think Eli is not even a top 10 quarterback.
I'm here to prove them wrong.