Alexander Ovechkin or Sidney Crosby: Who Is a More Valuable Asset?

I've debated or have at least mentioned in some previous posts who I believe to really be the better of the two between Alex Ovechkin and Sidney Crosby, but in case people haven't read those previous articles, here it goes again—Alex Ovechkin is the more superior player between the two.  Here is why:

First thing, If I asked you who the better player was between Alex Ovechkin and Evgeni Malkin, the majority of people will say Ovechkin.  But if I asked you who is better between Ovechkin and Sidney Crosby, then there would be a debate. But as of right now, and since mid-season last year, Malkin is the superior player to Crosby.

I was glad to finally see someone in the NHL say something over the hype surrounding Sidney Crosby.  Now some people could argue that they're jealous—but believe me, in no way is Alexander Semin jealous of Sidney Crosby.

Don't get me wrong. It's great what the NHL has done is promoting Sidney Crosby and broadening the NHL. Yet the NHL has so many stars to offer other than just Sidney Crosby. He is simply over-hyped and granted, I'm sure he does not want all this exposure.  What 21-year old would? He has taken it all in great stride, promoting the NHL and spend all his free time being the ambassador for hockey.

What was lost in translation on what Semin said of Crosby is more that the NHL is promoting one man as the best in the world, when he does not stand far above the other franchise players. Crosby is no Gretzky, or Lemieux for that matter. Not even in this era of the NHL.

Crosby has accomplished a lot in his brief career in the NHL, He was the youngest player in all of sports to win a leading-scorer award and league MVP. But while everyone stated Crosby would run away with the Calder Memorial Trophy, his rookie year he was ousted by Alex Ovechkin.

In the first two years Crosby has had the beneficiary of playing with better players than Ovechkin—especially in their rookie season. Sidney Crosby has had Sergei Gonchar and Ryan Whitney to move the puck out of the defense zone, while Ovechkin had to wait til last season for Mike Green to emerge as a puck-moving superstar.

In Crosby's second season he had the benefit of having both Evgeni Malkin and Jordan Staal joining the fold as well as two other top-five draft picks. Crosby was surrounded by a better cast of players, but the Caps have caught up with the emergence of Alexander Semin, Mike Green, Nicklas Backstrom, and free agent pickups Sergei Fedorov, Viktor Kozlov, Jose Theodore, Tom Poti, Michael Nylander and Brian Pothier—although Pothier has been on the Injured Reserved list for some time.

Now that both teams have consistent depth, the rivalry is getting bigger and Ovechkin is emerging as the better player.

Ovechkin has won more hardware than Crosby has.  Both have won the triple crown of the Art Ross, Lester B. Pearson, and the Hart Memorial, yet Ovechkin has also won the Maurice Rocket Richard as well as beaten Crosby for the Calder Memorial for rookie of the year. I wouldn't be surprised to see Ovechkin evolve his game even further, and one day win Frank J Selke trophy for best defensive forward, as he does have one of the best as a mentor in Fedorov.

You're currently logged into Facebook

Do you want to share your Bleacher Report activity on Facebook?