First things first: I would like to congratulate the Madden team for a job well done.
Quite often there are a lot of players who the Madden staff simply get wrong. In fact, I'm looking right now at my copy of Madden '08, which had its cover player, quarterback Vince Young, rated at 87 overall with 90 speed.
That one made me laugh.
Anyway, in my humble opinion, the Madden team really stepped up their game. Even on teams that are "over-hyped" like the Cowboys and Colts, the Madden team has the vast majority of players right about where they belong.
With that said, however, the guys from Maitland, Florida, and I disagree on some things. Here are my 12 most overrated players in Madden '12.