Giants Get Orlando Cabrera, Lose Thomas Neal
I don’t like this trade nearly as much as I liked the Carlos Beltran deal, or for that matter, the Jeff Keppinger trade. The Giants gave up too much for a player who doesn’t look like he has much left.
Giants’ GM Brian Sabean is thinking Orlando Cabrera is a proven winner (six previous trips to the post-season) and his crappy year in Cleveland is the result of playing in the superior American League.
I don’t agree. Cabrera was awful with the bat (.657 OPS) in Cincinnati, a much better place to hit than San Francisco, in 2010; and his .598 OPS so far this year in Cleveland suggests he’s a 36 year old with nothing left.
It smacks of a desparation move, with Mike Fontenot struggling, Brandon Crawford clearly over-matched in his first season in the Show, and Emmanuel Burriss playing so poorly he’s deservedly back at AAA Fresno. However, I just don’t see Cabrera giving them anything more than they’d get from Fontenot, on either side of the ball.
Part of my irritation is that I feel like the Giants are trading away Thomas Neal when his trade value is at a relative low. After three fine minor league seasons in a row (at least, if you take park factors into consideration), they’re sending him away in a year in which he’s been battling injuries.
Despite the injuries this year, Neal is still hitting .295 at AAA, and he doesn’t turn 24 until mid-August. He’s going to be a major league player, at least as good as Freddie Lewis and possibly better.
If Cabrera plays reasonably well for the Giants and helps them make the post-season and then some, the trade makes sense. I have a feeling, though, the Giants will make the post-season in spite of Cabrera rather than because of anything he adds.
What is the duplicate article?
Why is this article offensive?
Where is this article plagiarized from?
Why is this article poorly edited?