Browsing the web, I've seen every possible draft grade for the Jaguars. Everything from A to D. It boils down to either understanding Gene Smith's drafting style, or wanting him thrown out of the building.
Smith is constantly knocked for taking small school players instead of those from more prominent schools. He tends to draft players who have entered the draft as juniors and seniors and players who were captains of their respective teams.
Although we'll have to wait another year or two to be determined the success of his two drafts, Smith selects the true best available players (BAP), no matter when he finds them.