Notre Dame Football: The Brian Kelly Era, a 2010 Retrospective

IsmailAnalyst IJanuary 27, 2011

The first coat of paint was put on in 2010.
The first coat of paint was put on in 2010.

The first year of the Brian Kelly era at Notre Dame certainly didn’t lack for drama, that’s for sure.

There was a lot of drama surrounding the 2009 team and the future of Charlie Weis, but that team limped to the finish in depressing fashion and didn’t have to deal with the same roller coaster ride of emotions that this past year’s team did.

In a lot of ways, I think this past year mirrored Michael Floyd’s season.

In the preseason there were heightened expectations for Floyd as he had assaulted the record books during his first two seasons and dominated whenever he was healthy enough to stay in the lineup.

There was some concern about the change in offensive systems, but everyone knew the ball was going to be thrown a lot and that Floyd would be target No. 1.

With a coach like Brian Kelly taking over and a fair amount of high-level talent awaiting development, it was kind of the same feeling with the team as a whole.

That led me to write articles during the summer such as, “Why Can’t Notre Dame Win Ten Games?” and “Don’t Expect the Underachieving to Continue.”

Heck, even noted Irish antagonist Mark May predicted a 10-win season.

Then the games got under way and things did not go as expected.

The Irish started out to with a 1-3 record and Michael Floyd got off to a slow start and didn’t seem to be targeted as much as previous seasons.

Things improved slightly with a two-game winning streak, but Floyd missed the entire Navy game and watched from the sidelines as the Irish were defeated by the Midshipmen. The next week he tried to break up an under-thrown ball but the interception sealed a loss against Tulsa.

But then the four-game winning streak at season's end turned the team’s fortunes around. Floyd played his best football of the season during that stretch and asserted key leadership on the squad.

Even though Notre Dame didn’t win 10 games and Floyd wasn’t an All-American, there were still a lot of positives to take away from the season.

Floyd didn’t blow anyone away with his numbers, but he still had one of the best seasons for a receiver in school history.

And while there were some soul-crushing losses, the team’s eight wins were the most since 2006.

All in all, not too shabby for the team and Michael Floyd. And with Floyd returning for his senior year, the best part is that things should get better next season.

Retrospective Topic No. 1: These Schedules are Crazy

The 2010 schedule was not supposed to be that difficult (for Notre Dame’s high standards), but it ended up being one of the hardest in the country.

Notre Dame’s opponents had a combined 106-61 recordgood for a rather shocking .634 winning percentage. A tough slate indeed.

I know Brian Kelly mentioned before the season that he wants to play the best teams in the country, but I’m not sure he was fully prepared for the type of schedule that Notre Dame plays, nor do I think any coach really is until they’ve experienced it.

I’ve mentioned numerous times that the biggest challenges are the tough games every single Septemberand usually right off the bat with the first game. There is also a lack of truly bad teams to pad the stats and gain confidence from.

This past season Notre Dame played one team (Purdue 4-8) that had a losing record, and played seven teams that won at least eight games. The Irish even played an absurd 11 teams that won at least seven games.

Coach Kelly better get used to it because the schedules appear even stronger in the coming years.

Retrospective Topic No. 2: Ranking the Losses

In order, starting with the most painful: Navy, Tulsa, Michigan, Michigan State and Stanford.

If you go back and watch the Stanford game, you might be surprised how well the defense played in that contest. The Cardinal eventually asserted their dominance and there wasn’t anything in that game that approached good for Notre Dame, but the Irish simply ran into a better team that day.

The fake field goal hurt tremendously against Michigan State, but Notre Dame played well on the road on both sides of the ball. Sure there were moments of inconsistency, but we saw glimpses of what was to come later in the season in this game against the Spartans.

The loss to Michigan will always hurt, but without quarterback Dayne Crist for nearly an entire half, it’s not as bad as it could have been. Plus, Denard Robinson had to put together a performance for the ages to get the victory.

That is the same for the Tulsa loss as well, where we could grind our teeth over the interception at the end, but things would have been much different if Crist stayed healthy. That is not to mention there were about five freak ocurrences in the game that went against the Irish.

I don’t think there’s any doubt that the loss to Navy was the worst of the season. For all the other losses, there were reasons and circumstances you could point to explaining the loss.

With Navy, there was a complete and utter collapse on both sides of the ball that is really hard to explain, even today.

Retrospective Topic No. 3: Oh, But the Wins!

We can continue to fret over the losses from the 2010 season and claim that Notre Dame should have won at least two more games, and that’s fine to argue about if you want.

But in my opinion the victories to end the season were much more important for the long-term health of the Fighting Irish program.

Before the season, I asked if really bad losses are worse than lacking any big wins. Most people think the horrendous losses are, which makes plenty of sense.

Yet 2010 kind of validated my argument that the Irish desperately needed a big win or two, even at the expense of some terrible losses.

Of course that the wins came to finish the year and were strung together always helps, but Notre Dame truly needed to beat a ranked team (Utah), end the embarrassing losing streak (USC), and finish strong with another upset (Miami).

This is all the more true when you consider that the players and coaches actually learned from their defeats and were able to come through the fire a lot stronger.

I don’t think we can ever overestimate how important it is for a team to learn how to win and to have that rush of winning a big game flowing through their veins.

Like the teams in years past, the 2010 squad lost a few games that they probably shouldn’t have, but unlike those previous teams, they turned it around and won a couple games they weren’t supposed to.

This is huge for the program's psyche moving forward.

Retrospective Topic No. 4: More Stats on the Defense, Please!

The major aspect of learning from the losses was the complete turnaround the defense showed late in the season.

Aside from the Navy game, the defense was playing more fundamentally sound than in the past, but the late-season dominance really shocked some people.

If you want to know why some are extremely excited for the future of this defense, just read some of these stats.

Notre Dame moved up 40 spots nationally in scoring defense (23rd overall) and 38 spots in rush defense (51st overall).

They improved 23 spots in pass defense (53rd overall) and 35 spots in total defense (51st overall).

The Irish moved up 40 spots on third-down defense (28th overall) and 29 spots in total sacks (55th nationally).

There’s still obviously a lot of work to be doneafter all we can’t get too excited over some of those rankings in the 50s, but what we wanted most out of this defense was improvement, and they achieved that goal big time in 2010.

Retrospective Topic No. 5: Not a Great Year for the Offense

I should probably hang my head in shame that I thought this could be one of the best offenses in school history, but I am telling you, we will see crazy explosiveness soon with Brian Kelly as coach and the weapons he has to work with.

This offense never had the opportunity to get off the ground with the eventual injuries to Crist, RB Armando Allen and TE Kyle Rudolph, so it isn’t that astonishing that the numbers dropped significantly from 2009.

Scoring offense dropped 34 spots nationally (66th overall) while rushing offense took a modest eight-spot drop (92nd overall).

Passing offense fell 29 spots (still a respectable 34th overall) and the total offense took a huge plunge falling 53 spots to 61st nationally.

Third-down conversions fell 18 spots (72nd overall), but a bright spot was that sacks given up improved 31 spots to finish the season 34th overall.

Like I said, this drop-off is to be expected with the injuries that occurred, and with Brian Kelly’s past, there shouldn’t be a whole lot of reason to worry about the future of the offense.

Once the quarterback situation settles down things should start to blossom.

But there needs to be a significant improvement in all aspects of the running game and better efficiency through the air as well.

Both areas are a huge priority for 2011.

Retrospective Topic No. 6: Yankee Stadium & Neutral Sites

I was one of the fans who were excited right from the beginning with the announcement of a game at Yankee Stadium.

I know there were a lot of fans who didn’t think it was a big deal and weren’t excited about playing Army, but the event came off very well, and that was from just watching on TV.

I think the best we can hope for is a great neutral-venue game every other year, and it is looking like this is how it'll shape up in the near future.

The game in San Antonio was pretty lackluster and next year's game at FedEx Field could potentially be along those same linesunless Maryland is really good or Notre Dame comes in undefeated or something.

But 2012 will feature two great neutral games with the rumble in Dublin against Navy and the meeting against Miami at Solider Field. Both of those contests should be high-level entertainment.

And don’t forget about the game against Arizona State at Cowboys Stadium in a few years either. That will be a great venue, and if the Sun Devils are in the hunt for the Pac-12 title by then it could be a tremendous neutral-site game.

2010 Opponent Awards Presented by One Foot Down

The Top Player Performance Award:

Gold Medal: Denard Robinson (QB, Michigan)

Robinson was the run-away winner for 2010 and might be the champion of this award for the entire decade.

We don’t have to relive the agony again, but you don’t see 502 total yards and 200 rushing and passing yards from a quarterback all that often.

This one is well deserved.

Silver Medal: Alexander Teich (FB, Navy)

For the second straight season, a Navy fullback embarrassed the Notre Dame defense. Teich rumbled for 210 yards on the ground and also added a 31-yard receiving touchdown on a screen pass.

Are there any questions on which position the Irish have to take out next year when they play Navy?

Bronze Medal: Damaris Johnson (WR, Tulsa)

Johnson is one of the best athletes in the country and he quietly terrorized the Irish in South Bend in 2010. He scored the game’s first touchdown on a nine-yard reception, made plays all day long on the ground, and scored a critical 59-yard punt return touchdown late in the third quarter.

His 208 all-purpose yards isn’t mind-blowing, but Johnson was super effective against Notre Dame in 2010.

The Top Venue AwardSpartan Stadium (East Lansing, Michigan)

The Coliseum and Yankee Stadium all deserve credit and could make a case for this award, but I don’t think any of those venues were rocking quite like Spartan Stadium this past year.

There’s always a quality amount of bad-blood between Michigan State and Notre Dame, it was a night game on primetime, and the way the game went back and forth and ended ultimately sealed this for East Lansing.

The Top of the Revenge List AwardThe United States Naval Academy

The matchup in 2011 is going to be a big “show me” game for defensive coordinator Bob Diaco and the Irish defense. They made adjustments against Army and shut down that triple option attack, but the Navy offense is a different beast all together.

Notre Dame has lost three out of four to Navy, this game will be at home and Navy is losing some key players, so this is a must-win game for the Irish.

The Middies are a good team, but if Notre Dame wants to get back to the top it has to start beating Navy and revenging last year’s debacle is a high priority in 2011.

Runners-up: Michigan Wolverines

The entire Notre Dame fan base is itching to play Michigan again after losing to the Wolverines for the second straight year, particularly after losing in the last seconds in both 2009 and 2010.

Notre Dame seems to be gaining an upper-hand in talent and coaching, but the time is coming where they will have to prove it on the field.

The Irish will certainly be looking for revenge under the lights in the Big House this September.

The “Thank God He’s Leaving School” AwardRicky Dobbs (QB, Navy)

Dobbs didn’t see any action as a freshman in 2007, but he’s been part of a Navy program that has won three out of four against Notre Dame, with Dobbs under center for the last two victories.

In those last two wins, Dobbs was been masterful at running the triple option and making precise decisions with the ball.

He combined for 192 yards rushing with four touchdowns to go along with 127 passing yards on four of five attempts, two touchdowns and no interceptions.

No Irish fan is sad to see him move on to his bright future as an American leader.

Runner-up: Greg Jones (LB, Michigan State)

Jones was an All-American for the Spartans and a huge reason why Notre Dame had so many problems running the ball consistently against Michigan State for the past three years.

He is one of the best defenders in Michigan State history and will leave a huge hole in their defense.

Over the past three seasons Jones compiled 27 tackles against Notre Dameand that is with the Irish trying to avoid his presence at all costs. His absence may make life a little easier for the Notre Dame offense in the future.

Very Important Honorable Mention: Jim Harbaugh (Coach, Stanford)

In terms of long-term impact, Harbaugh’s departure from Stanford is No. 1 on this list. But since he’s not a player, he is given an honorable mention.

Stanford caught a break with the announcement that quarterback Andrew Luck is going to return his senior season, and the current recruiting class has still held up well and looks very strongbut without Harbaugh the dream is over.

The Cardinal may very well be a great team for the next year or two, but without the presence of Harbaugh, the program is going to suffer and fall back in the coming years.

The Coach of the Year AwardMark Dantonio (Michigan State)

Jim Harbaugh would have won this award but I disqualified him because he is already mentioned above.

Dantonio did a wonderful job this year at Michigan State sharing the Big Ten title, and he has been doing very well in his short tenure in East Lansing.

A beat down by Alabama in their bowl game put a damper on things, but an 11-2 record isn’t a joke.

Plus, Little Giants followed by a heart attack…come on, this coach deserved it!

Runner-up: Todd Graham (Tulsa)

Graham had a very successful season leading Tulsa to a 10-3 record with a bowl win over Hawaii (and of course the upset in Notre Dame Stadium against the Irish).

He has been awarded for his success and is now the head coach at Pittsburgh,  where he will be seeing a lot more of Notre Dame in the future.

Most Overrated Team AwardMiami Hurricanes

Miami had some competition, but their performance to end the season and in the Sun Bowl against the Irish sealed the deal.

There’s no doubting that the Hurricanes have talent, but they did not prove it on the field in 2010 except for a couple of games in which they looked very strong.

Miami lost to Ohio State and Notre Dame and ended the year a very disappointing 7-6 after being ranked in the preseason.

Runners-up: Utah Utes

A 10-3 record isn’t bad at all, but Utah is the runner-up in this category because they were viewed as possibly the most dangerous and talented team on the Notre Dame schedule and didn’t deliver.

Utah beat Pittsburgh and ended the regular season with quality wins against San Diego State and BYU, but the Utes were embarrassed and looked awful in losses to TCU, Notre Dame and Boise State.

Since their ceiling was so high they end up being overrated.

Most Underrated TeamTulsa Golden Hurricane

Notre Dame had the unfortunate pleasure of giving Tulsa their first victory over a BCS caliber team in ages, but that shouldn’t hide the fact that the Hurricane were a really solid team this year and underrated in many ways.

It will take the fan base awhile to really get over this loss, but I don’t think it should be considered the worst loss in school history as some have suggested, especially because Tulsa was an underrated and talented team in 2010…offensively at least.

Top Uniform AwardUSC Trojans

I’m not a big fan of USC’s uniforms and I think they are among the most overrated in college football, but I can respect that they bring a nice traditional look.

Michigan would have won this but their away uniforms have ruined their traditional look.

Worst Uniform AwardMichigan State Spartans

This was mentioned in the preseason when these uniforms were unveiled, but Nike completely failed in this makeover attempt.

At first glance they don’t seem that bad, but once you realize all of the changes that were made to liven up an already great uniform, you’ll see a ton of mistakes.

Six more days until National Signing Day…the 2011 season awaits!

From the FanTake blog: One Foot Down

Follow on Twitter: @OneFootDown


    Buckeyes Flip 4-Star QB Dwan Mathis

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Buckeyes Flip 4-Star QB Dwan Mathis

    Tyler Conway
    via Bleacher Report

    Do the Fighting Irish 'Choke' in Primetime?

    Notre Dame Football logo
    Notre Dame Football

    Do the Fighting Irish 'Choke' in Primetime?

    One Foot Down
    via One Foot Down

    Five Freshmen Who Could Make an Instant Impact

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Five Freshmen Who Could Make an Instant Impact

    Auburn Lands 2019 4-Star ATH Jashawn Sheffield

    College Football logo
    College Football

    Auburn Lands 2019 4-Star ATH Jashawn Sheffield

    SDS Staff
    via Saturday Down South